Direct numerical simulations have been performed for turbulent thermal convection between horizontal no-slip, permeable walls with a distance
$H$ and a constant temperature difference
$\Delta T$ at the Rayleigh number
$Ra=3\times 10^3\text {--}10^{10}$. On the no-slip wall surfaces
$z=0$,
$H$, the wall-normal (vertical) transpiration velocity is assumed to be proportional to the local pressure fluctuation, i.e.
$w=-\beta p'/\rho$,
$+\beta p'/\rho$ (Jiménez et al., J. Fluid Mech., vol. 442, 2001, pp. 89–117). Here
$\rho$ is mass density, and the property of the permeable wall is given by the permeability parameter
$\beta U$ normalised with the buoyancy-induced terminal velocity
$U=(g\alpha \Delta TH)^{1/2}$, where
$g$ and
$\alpha$ are acceleration due to gravity and volumetric thermal expansivity, respectively. The critical transition of heat transfer in convective turbulence has been found between the two
$Ra$ regimes for fixed
$\beta U=3$ and fixed Prandtl number
$Pr=1$. In the subcritical regime at lower
$Ra$ the Nusselt number
$Nu$ scales with
$Ra$ as
$Nu\sim Ra^{1/3}$, as commonly observed in turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection. In the supercritical regime at higher
$Ra$, on the other hand, the ultimate scaling
$Nu\sim Ra^{1/2}$ is achieved, meaning that the wall-to-wall heat flux scales with
$U\Delta T$ independent of the thermal diffusivity, although the heat transfer on the wall is dominated by thermal conduction. In the supercritical permeable case, large-scale motion is induced by buoyancy even in the vicinity of the wall, leading to significant transpiration velocity of the order of
$U$. The ultimate heat transfer is attributed to this large-scale significant fluid motion rather than to transition to turbulence in boundary-layer flow. In such ‘wall-bounded’ convective turbulence, a thermal conduction layer still exists on the wall, but there is no near-wall layer of large change in the vertical velocity, suggesting that the effect of the viscosity is negligible even in the near-wall region. The balance between the dominant advection and buoyancy terms in the vertical Boussinesq equation gives us the velocity scale of
$O(U)$ in the whole region, so that the total energy budget equation implies the Taylor dissipation law
$\epsilon \sim U^3/H$ and the ultimate scaling
$Nu\sim Ra^{1/2}$.