Understanding the mechanism of hydrodynamic cloud cavitation is crucial to reducing noise, vibration and wear. Recent studies have clarified the physics of two distinct formation mechanisms of cloud cavitation. Ganesh et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 802, 2016, pp. 37–78) identified the propagation of bubbly shockwaves as a cloud detachment mechanism. Pelz et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 817, 2017, pp. 439–454) explained the influence of Reynolds number and cavitation number on asymptotic growth of the cavity sheet and its periodic shedding caused by re-entrant flow. In this paper the two mechanisms are set in relation to each other. For this, we show firstly that the transition from re-entrant flow to shockwave-driven cloud cavitation is given by a kinematic condition, namely the asymptotic sheet length equates to the chord length,
$\hat {a}=L$. For
$\hat {a}>L$ shockwave-driven cloud cavitation dominates. For
$\hat {a}< L$ re-entrant flow-driven cloud cavitation dominates. As the cavitation number decreases, the closure region of the cavity sheet reaches the trailing edge of the hydrofoil, identifying the trailing edge as a trigger for condensation shockwaves, particularly as re-entrant flow-driven cavitation diminishes. Since the sheet length is an implicit function of the cavitation number, the kinematic condition
$\hat {a}/L=1$ results in a critical cavitation number
${\sigma _\mathrm {II,III}}$ that is calculated analytically and validated by experiments. Secondly, we derive the relationship between the Strouhal number and the asymptotic sheet length for re-entrant flow-driven cloud cavitation. The model presented here is thoroughly validated by experiments.