Since the Shī'ī response to constitutionalist notions
of government is potentially a very large subject,
for the purposes of this discussion Shī'ī will be
taken to mean the members of the orthodox
'ulamā, those most committed to
the sharī'a and learned in its
precepts. Whilst even within this group there is a
wide diversity of opinion, it is hoped that, by
looking at works written over a longer period, the
discussion will show that the response by a
particular ‘ālim to
constitutionalism is to some extent influenced by
the political conditions prevailing at the time of
writing. These form a factor together with the
restrictions imposed by the sharī'a
in shaping the views of particular writers. The
ideology under consideration is constitutionalism,
but it will be observed that for a large part the
subject matter treated consists of ideas such as
representation, consultation, legislation, freedom
and equality, which are allied to the
constitutionalist theory of government, rather than
the complete theory itself.