Did I find this book interesting? Yes, but would I recommend it to everyone? No. In most respects it is a fascinating collection of individual viewpoints and opinion, many of which may be widely shared, but I am not quite sure what it really intends to be. On the one hand it seems to set out to be an introductory book on adult mental health, a primer perhaps, but the title suggests something more and the editors do say it is designed for the reader to ‘dip in and out of sections’, which rather implies a reference function.
I don't really think it works as an introductory text or reference. It is not really suitable for those new to mental health as there is much missing and the construction and order of the chapters appears rather haphazard. There is too much opinion for a reference work and some things are stated as fact with which I would take issue. The editors do point out that they have not been able to be comprehensive, but certain things are too obvious by their absence. For example, there is no mention anywhere of psychodynamics and, although there is a chapter on ‘medication management’ there is no proper explanation of the rationale behind the use of psychotropic drugs.
However, much of the book is interesting and thought-provoking, and one or two of the chapters (such as ‘Personal experiences of mental health and illness’) are utterly absorbing. The case studies and some of the good practice points are also a nice touch.
So, although I do not think it is essential reading for anyone, having a copy to hand to dip into from time to time might help stimulate thought and provoke debate.
Open access
eLetters
No eLetters have been published for this article.