Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T07:32:48.387Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Priam's Treasure”

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 December 2013

D. F. Easton
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In Antiquity 57 David Traill claims to have exposed Schliemann's discovery of “Priam's Treasure” as a fraud (Traill, 1983). By this he means that it was not a single find as Schliemann represents, but an artificial collection put together from several different sources. The collection was formed around a group of bronzes (not identified exactly, but presumably including some of the spearheads, daggers, and flat axes) which was genuinely found on the site of Troy near the end of the 1873 season, but whose precise findspot and date of discovery Schliemann falsified. To this were added more valuable items which Schliemann had been setting aside from his excavations for just such a purpose over a period of months “or even years”. This theory was first put forward in outline in a BBC Chronicle programme on 20th January, 1982 and at that time included the further suggestion that some items were not even excavated at Troy but were bought from dealers in Constantinople or Athens. It is not clear how far Traill still holds to this notion: he acknowledges that all the pieces contained in the Treasure are appropriate to the Early Bronze Age at Troy, but at the same time hints that the purchase-theory would be a legitimate speculation (Traill, 1983, 185).

Type
Research Article
Information
Anatolian Studies , Volume 34 , December 1984 , pp. 141 - 169
Copyright
Copyright © The British Institute at Ankara 1984

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Bass, G.F., (1970). “A hoard of Trojan and Sumerian jewellery”, AJA 74, 335–41.Google Scholar
Bernabo-Brea, L. (1964). Poliochni: Città Preistorica nell' Isola di Lemnos, vol. I, 1–2 (Rome).Google Scholar
Bernabo-Brea, L., (1976). Poliochni: Città Preistorica nell' Isola di Lemnos, vol. II, 1–2 (Rome).Google Scholar
Bittel, K., (1959). “Beitrag zur Kenntnis Anatolischer Metalgefässe der zweiten Hälfte des dritten Jahrtausends v. Chr.”, JDAI 74, 1–34.Google Scholar
Blegen, C.W. et al. , (1950). Troy, vol. I, 1–2: The First and Second Settlements, (Princeton); cited as Troy I.Google Scholar
Blegen, C.W. (1951). Troy, vol. II, 1–2: The Third, Fourth and Fifth Settlements, (Princeton); cited as Troy II.Google Scholar
Borlase, W., (1878). “A visit to Dr Schliemann's Troy”, Fraser's Magazine 17 (February), 228–39.Google Scholar
Branigan, K., (1974). Aegean Metalwork in the Early and Middle Bronze Ages (Oxford).Google Scholar
de Jesus, P.S., (1980). The Development of Prehistoric Mining and Metallurgy in Anatolia, BAR International Series 74, i–ii, (Oxford).Google Scholar
Dörpfeld, W., (1902). Troja and Ilion, 2 vols. (Athens).Google Scholar
Easton, D.F., (1981). “Schliemann's discovery of ‘Priam's Treasure’: two enigmas”, Antiquity 55, 179–83.Google Scholar
Easton, D.F., (1982). “The Schliemann Papers”, Annual of the British School of Archaeology at Athens 77, 93–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldman, H., (1956). Tarsus, vol. II (Princeton).Google Scholar
Kadish, B., (1969). “Excavations of Prehistoric Remains at Aphrodisias, 1967”, AJA 73, 49–65.Google Scholar
Lamb, W., (1936). Excavations at Thermi in Lesbos, (Cambridge).Google Scholar
Lamb, W., (1937). “Excavations at Kusura near Afyon Karahisar”, Archaeologia 86, 1–64.Google Scholar
Maxwell-Hyslop, R., (1971). Western Asiatic Jewellery, (London).Google Scholar
Mellink, M.J., (1969). “Excavations at Karataş-Semayük in Lycia, 1968” AJA 73, 319–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meyer, E., (1936). Briefe von Heinrich Schliemann, (Berlin, Leipzig).Google Scholar
Meyer, E., (1953). Heinrich Schliemann—Briefwechsel, 2 vols., (Berlin).Google Scholar
Meyer, E., (1962). “Schliemann's letters to Max Müller in Oxford”, JHS 82, 75–105.Google Scholar
Meyer, E., (1969). Heinrich Schliemann: Kaufmann und Forscher, (Göttingen).Google Scholar
Muscarella, O.W., (1974). Ancient Art—The Nobert Schimmel Collection, (Mainz).Google Scholar
Orthmann, W., (1964). Die Keramik der Frühen Bronzezeit aus Inneranatolien, Istanbuler Forschungen 24.Google Scholar
Petruso, K.M., (1977). “Trojan weight metrology”, Paper read at the IVth International Colloquium on Aegean Prehistory, Sheffield.Google Scholar
Podzuweit, C., (1979). Trojanische Gefässformen der Frühbronzezeit in Anatolien, der Ägäis und angrenzenden Gebieten, (Mainz).Google Scholar
Schliemann, H., (1872). Unpublished Troy excavation notebook for 1872.Google Scholar
Schliemann, H., (1873a). Unpublished Troy excavation notebook for 1873.Google Scholar
Schliemann, H., (1873b). “Ausgrabungen in Troja”, Allgemeine Zeitung (Augsburg), Beilage zu Nr. 164 (13th June), 2509–10; Beilage zu Nr. 165 (14th June), 2527–8.Google Scholar
Schliemann, H., (1873c). “Der Schatz des Priamos”, Allgemeine Zeitung, (Augsburg), Beilage zu Nr. 217 (5th August) 3309–10.Google Scholar
Schliemann, H., (1874a). Trojanische Alterthümer, (Leipzig).Google Scholar
Schliemann, H., (1874b). Atlas Trojanischer Alterthümer, (Leipzig); cited as Atlas.Google Scholar
Schliemann, H., (1874c). Troy and its Remains (London); cited as TR.Google Scholar
Schliemann, H., (1881). Ilios: the City and Country of the Trojans (London); cited as Ilios.Google Scholar
Schmidt, H., (1902). Heinrich Schliemann's Sammlung Trojanischer Alterthümer, (Berlin); cited as SS.Google Scholar
Spanos, P., (1977). “Zur absoluten Chronologie der zweiten Siedlung in Troja”, ZA 67, 85–107.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stronach, D., (1957). “The Development and Diffusion of Metal Types in Early Bronze Age Anatolia”, Anat. Stud. 7, 89–125.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Traill, D.A., (1978–1979). “Schliemann's mendacity: fire and fever in California”, The Classical Journal 74, 348–55.Google Scholar
Traill, D.A., (1981–1982). “Schliemann's american citizenship and divorce”, The Classical Journal, 77, 336–42.Google Scholar
Traill, D.A., (1983). Schliemann's “discovery“ of “Priam's Treasure”, Antiquity, 57, 181–6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar