Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-04T20:29:09.402Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Are you a Billy, or a Dan, or an old tin can?’: street violence and relations between Catholics, Jews and Protestants in the Gorbals during the inter-war years

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 January 2013

AVRAM TAYLOR
AVRAM TAYLOR*
Affiliation:
School of Arts and Social Sciences, Lipman Building, Northumbria University, Sandyford Road, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE1 8ST, UK
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

This article makes use of memoirs, autobiographies and oral interviews in order to consider the relations between the Catholic, Jewish and Protestant communities in the Gorbals. While there was considerable variation in individual experience, there were also particular occasions where inter-ethnic relations were all too predictable, almost following a ‘calendar of conflict’. The article shows that, while there was a degree of anti-Semitism in the area, integration between the Jewish and non-Jewish residents of the district was facilitated by a number of factors. Ultimately, anti-Semitism was mediated through the sectarian rivalry, which was the dominant religious conflict in the city.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 41 , Issue 1 , February 2014 , pp. 124 - 140
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 McArthur, A. and Kingsley Long, H., No Mean City (London, 1957)Google Scholar. The longevity of the image of Glasgow portrayed in No Mean City can be seen in the continued use of the phrase in depictions of the city: see e.g. the 1988 Glasgow Centre for Housing Research report, Maclennan, Duncan, Glasgow No Mean City to Miles Better (Glasgow, 1988)Google Scholar.

2 Abrams, N., Caledonian Jews: A Study of Seven Small Communities in Scotland (Jefferson, NC, 2009), 1–2Google Scholar. Kenneth Collins has done much to lay the foundations of work in this field. See for example Collins, K. (ed.), Aspects of Scottish Jewry (Glasgow, 1987)Google Scholar, and idem, Scotland's Jews: A Guide to the History and Community of the Jews in Scotland (Glasgow, 1999).

3 Collins’, Kenneth pioneering work includes Second City Jewry (Glasgow, 1990)Google Scholar and Be Well! Jewish Health and Welfare in Glasgow, 1860–1914 (East Linton, 2001). Other scholars have subsequently built on his work. See also Maitles, H., ‘Jewish trade unionists in Glasgow’, Immigrants and Minorities, 10 (1991), 46–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Braber, B., Jews in Glasgow 1879–1939: Immigration and Integration (Edgware, 2007)Google Scholar.

4 Kenefick, W., ‘Comparing the Jewish and Irish communities in twentieth-century Scotland’, in Cesarani, D., Kushner, T. and Shain, M. (eds.), Place and Displacement in Jewish History and Memory Zakor v’ Makor (London and Portland, OR, 2009), 55Google Scholar. See also Kenefick, W., ‘Jewish and Catholic Irish relations: the Glasgow waterfront c.1880–1914’, in Cesarani, D. and Romain, G. (eds.), Jews and Port Cities 1590–1900: Commerce, Community and Cosmopolitanism (London and Portland, OR, 2006), 215–35Google Scholar.

5 For a description of the autobiographies in question, see Taylor, A., ‘“Remembering spring through Gorbals voices”: autobiography and the memory of a community’, Immigrants and Minorities, 28 (2010), 1–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar. On oral history, see: Summerfield, P., ‘Culture and composure: creating narratives of the gendered self in oral history interviews’, Cultural and Social History, 1 (2004), 65Google Scholar; Perks, R. and Thomson, A. (eds.), The Oral History Reader (London and New York, 1998)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Thomson, A., ‘Unreliable memories? The use and abuse of oral history,’ in Lamont, W. (ed.), Historical Controversies and Historians (London, 1998), 28Google Scholar.

7 Cesarani, D., ‘Port Jews, concepts, cases and questions’, in Cesarani, D. (ed.), Port Jews in Cosmopolitan Maritime Trading Centres, 1550–1950 (London and Portland, OR, 2002), 8Google Scholar.

8 Ibid., 8.

9 Allport, G.W., The Nature of Prejudice (Reading, MA, 1954), 14–15Google Scholar.

10 Ibid., 14.

11 Cesarani, D., ‘The transformation of communal authority in Anglo-Jewry 1914–1940’, in Cesarani, D. (ed.), The Making of Modern Anglo-Jewry (Oxford, 1990), 118Google Scholar.

12 Bermant, C., Troubled Eden: An Anatomy of British Jewry (London, 1969), 55Google Scholar.

13 For an account of the position of Jews in the Tsarist empire and their responses to their deteriorating situation see: Polonsky, A.The Jews in Poland and Russia, vol. II: 1881 to 1914 (Oxford and Portland, OR, 2010), 3–39Google Scholar.

14 Endelman, T.M., The Jews of Britain, 1656 to 2000 (Berkeley and Los Angeles, 2002), 127CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 Ibid., 129–30.

16 Collins, Second City, 46–7. Cf. Leese, P., Piatek, B. and Curyllo-Klag, I. (eds.), The British Migrant Experience, 1700–2000: An Anthology (Basingstoke, 2002), 285–6Google Scholar.

17 Lipman, V.D., A History of the Jews in Britain since 1858 (Leicester and London, 1990), 56Google Scholar.

18 Bermant, C., Coming Home (London, 1976), 52–3Google Scholar.

19 Kaplan, H.L., The Gorbals Jewish Community in 1901 (Glasgow, 2006), 9Google Scholar.

20 The Mitchell Library G1296 0941435 GLA Glasgow Jewish Year Book 1937–1938 (Glasgow, 1938), 43

21 Braber, Jews, 99 and 162.

22 H.L. Kaplan, The Gorbals, 10–11.

23 Maitles, H, ‘Jewish trade unionists in Glasgow’, Immigrants and Minorities, 10 (1991), 51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Collins, Second City, 11.

25 Robb, J.G., ‘Suburb and slum in the Gorbals: social and residential change 1800–1900’, in Gordon, G. and Dicks, B. (eds.), Scottish Urban History (Aberdeen, 1983), 130 and 135Google Scholar.

26 Ibid., 164.

27 Ibid.., 13–14 and 71.

28 Braber, Jews, 97 and 161–2. For a comprehensive list of Jewish organizations in Glasgow during the period see Glasgow Jewish Year Book 1937–1938.

29 Livingstone, H.M., ‘From Strength to Strength’: 100 Years of Service 1903–2003 Celebrating the Centenary of the Glasgow Jewish Lads’ Brigade (Glasgow, 2003), 20Google Scholar.

30 Endelman, Jews, 205.

31 Tape: Mrs Laski – 21.7.05 – 2210–20; Tape: Mrs Cohen – 26.4.02 – Side 2 – 1460–70. The Glasgow branch of the Maccabi goes back to the formation of the Bar Kochba in 1933, which was the first Jewish sports club in Glasgow, and was based in the Talmud Torah building on Turriff Street in the Gorbals. www.theglasgowstory.com/image.php accessed 7 Jul. 2011, 1.

32 Tape: Mr Levy – 21.7.05 – 1970; Tape: Mrs Cohen – 26.4.02 – Side 2 – 2135–45.

33 Withers, C., ‘The demographic history of the city, 1831–1911’, in Fraser, H.W and Maver, I. (eds.), Glasgow, vol. II: 1830 to 1912 (Manchester and New York, 1996), 150Google Scholar.

34 Edward, M., Who Belongs to Glasgow?: 200 Years of Migration (Glasgow, 1993), 34–6Google Scholar; Withers, ‘The demographic history of the city’, 151.

35 Withers, ‘The demographic history of the city’, 149–50.

36 Edward, Glasgow, 58.

37 MacRaild, D.M., Irish Migrants in Modern Britain, 1750–1922 (Basingstoke, 1999), 62CrossRefGoogle Scholar. In fact, there was considerable hostility leading, on occasion, to physical violence towards Irish migrants in Glasgow before the arrival of Famine victims in the city. Edward, Glasgow, 47–8 and 55.

38 MacRaild, Irish Migrants, 62.

39 Hutchison, I.G.C., ‘Glasgow working-class politics’, in Cage, R.A. (ed.), The Working Class in Glasgow 1750–1914 (London, Sydney and Wolfeboro, NH, 1987), 129Google Scholar.

40 Marshall, W.S., The Billy Boys: A Concise History of Orangeism in Scotland (Edinburgh, 1996), 13Google Scholar.

41 Ibid., 51–2.

42 Murray, B., The Old Firm: Sectarianism, Sport and Society in Scotland (Edinburgh, 1984), 154–6Google Scholar.

43 Glasgow Herald, 8 Jul. 1935.

44 Tape: Mrs Abrahams – 19.7.05 – Side 2 – 0570.

45 Collins (ed.), Aspects of Scottish Jewry, 52. In his comprehensive study of anti-Semitism in British society, Colin Holmes only mentions Glasgow once, and that is in connection with some possible discrimination against Jews in the housing market during the 1930s. Holmes, C., Anti-Semitism in British Society 1876–1939 (London, 1979), 205Google Scholar.

46 Caplan, J., Memories of the Gorbals (Oxford, 1994), 83–4Google Scholar.

47 Tape: Mrs Adler – 24.7.05 – 2312; Tape: Mrs Berkowitz – 21.7.05 – 1658–60; Tape: Mr Danzig – 28.8.03 – Side 2 – 0577; Tape: Mrs Friedlander – 20.7.05 – 1374; Tape: Mrs Greenberg – 24.7.05 – 2050; Tape: Mrs Solomons – 21.7.05 – 1860.

48 Tape: Mrs Greenberg – 24.7.05 – 2335.

49 Tape: Mr Cowan – 21.7.05 – 0958–90.

50 Tape: Mr Sacks – 19.7.05 – 1695 – 1258 and 1530.

51 Tape: Mr Goldman – 25.8.03 – Side 2 – 0475–80.

52 Tape: Mr Goldman – 25.8.03 – Side 2 – 0587–605.

53 Tape: Mrs Rosenberg – 18.7.05 – 1530.

54 Tape: Mr Zuckerman – Side 2 – 24.8.03 – 0610–40.

55 Tape: Mr Zuckerman – Side 2 – 24.8.03 – 1829–900.

56 Tape: Mrs Adler – 24.7.05 – 0600, 2100 and 2314.

57 Thomson, ‘Unreliable memories?’, 28–33.

58 Kenefick, ‘Comparing the Jewish and Irish communities’, 55. For example, Kenefick quotes a Jewish respondent as saying, ‘So we grew up in a mixed group of Jews and non-Jews. We were all friendly and mixed very well’ – ibid., 56. The novelist Muriel Spark saw Jews and Catholics as having a shared experience of discrimination which, it could be argued, would serve to unite the two groups. Reilly, P., ‘Kicking with the left foot: being Catholic in Scotland’, in Devine, T.M. (ed.), Scotland's Shame? Bigotry and Sectarianism in Modern Scotland (Edinburgh and London, 2000), 32–3Google Scholar.

59 Shinwell, Manny, Lead with the Left: My First Ninety-Six Years (London, 1981), 18Google Scholar.

60 Tape: Mrs Berkowitz – 21.7.05 – 0520–50.

61 Tape: Mrs Solomons – 21.7.05 – 1450 and 1929.

62 Tape: Mrs Cohen – 26.4.02 – Side 2 – 2370–90; Tape: Mr Danzig – 28.8.03 – Side 2 – 1720.

63 Glasser, R., Growing up in the Gorbals (London, 1987), 22Google Scholar.

64 Kay, B., ‘From the Gorbals to Gweedore’, in Kay, B. (ed.), Odyssey: Voices from Scotland's Recent Past (Edinburgh, 1980), 6Google Scholar.

65 Tape: Mrs Rosenberg – 18.7.05 – 1600.

66 Tape: Mrs Abrahams – 19.7.05 – 2038–90.

67 Tape: Mrs Abrahams – 19.7.05 – 2105–20.

68 Kaplan, The Gorbals, 23.

69 Tape: Mr Goldman – 25.8.03 – Side 2 – 1990.

70 Tape: Mrs Rosenberg – 18.7.05 – 1275–320.

71 Kenefick, ‘Comparing the Jewish and Irish communities’, 56.

72 Tape: Mr Danzig – 28.8.03 – Side 2 – 1670. Although the schools in the district were segregated along religious lines, a tiny minority of Catholic parents chose to send their children to Protestant schools, so there was some mixing in the school environment. Tape: Mrs Cohen – 26.4.02 – Side 2 – 1350.

73 Tape: Mr Danzig – 28.8.03 – Side 2 – 1712. Tape: Mrs Cohen – 26.4.02 – Side 2 – 1430–40. Tape: Mr Goldman – 25.8.03 – Side 2 – 0658 – 0662.

74 See, for example, Dudgeon, P., Our Glasgow Memories of Life in Disappearing Britain (London, 2009), 237–8Google Scholar.

75 Tape: Mrs Cohen – 26.4.02 – Side 2 – 2440–70.

76 Tape: Mrs Cohen – 26.4.02 – Side 2 – 2470–90.

77 Cowan, E., Spring Remembered: A Scottish Jewish Childhood (Edinburgh, 1974), 101–2Google Scholar.

78 Tape: Mr Zuckerman – Side 2 – 24.8.03 – 1829–900.

79 Tape: Mr Lipman – 19.7.05 – 1085–115. Tape: Mrs Laski – 21.7.05 – 2180–200. Tape: Mrs Laski – 21.7.05 – Side 2 – 0820–30.

80 Glasser, Growing Up, 2–3.

81 Caplan, Memories, 73.

82 Ibid., 77–8.

83 Tape: Mr Levy – 21.7.05 – 1195–2005.

84 Tape: Mr Levy – 21.7.05 – 1160–80.

85 Tape: Mr Levy – 21.7.05 – Side 2 – 1786.

86 See for example Murray, Old Firm.

87 Gathorne-Hardy, J., Doctors: The Lives and Work of GPs (London, 1984), 12Google Scholar.

88 Tape: Mr Danzig – 28.8.03 – Side 2 – 1580.

89 Tape: Mr Danzig – 28.8.03 – Side 2 – 1595.

90 Davies, A., ‘Football and sectarianism in Glasgow during the 1920s and 1930s’, Irish Historical Studies, 35 (2006), 202CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

91 Ibid., 211.

92 Dudgeon, Our Glasgow, 224; Sillitoe, P., Cloak without Dagger (London, 1955), 130Google Scholar.

93 Tape: Mrs Danzig – 28.8.03 – Side 2 – 1587. William Kenefick also quotes a Jewish respondent who cited St Patrick's Day as an occasion for sectarian conflict. Kenefick, ‘Comparing the Jewish and Irish communities’, 56. Andrew Davies points out that, ‘Like their adult counterparts, gangs of schoolboys followed the festive calendar, with gangs of Protestant boys seeking confrontations at the gates of Catholic schools on St Patrick's Day and Catholic boys seeking retribution on the Twelfth of July.’ Davies, ‘Football and sectarianism’, 207.

94 Tape: Mrs Abrahams – 19.7.05 – Side 2 – 0280.

95 Kenefick, ‘Comparing the Jewish and Irish communities’, 56.

96 Tape: Mr Levy – 21.7.05 – 1260–305.

97 Karner, C., Ethnicity and Everyday Life (London and New York, 2007), 29Google Scholar. For a full account of structuration theory see Giddens, A., The Constitution of Society (Cambridge, 1984)Google Scholar.

98 Karner, Ethnicity, 29.

99 Tape: Mr Levy – 21.7.05 – 1160–70.