No CrossRef data available.
We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 February 2023
The image of French music from the late 18th century to the present day in its European context is less clear in most people's minds, even most French people's minds, than one could reasonably expect. Yet it has a decisive bearing on what one makes of contemporary developments. There are too few names involved, for one thing, and the lines of influence drawn do not always point in the right direction. In particular, historical ascendancy is blurred, not least because too many musicologists who ought to know better base their work on that shakiest of grounds, ‘accepted repertoire’. Manuals repeat uncritically the opinions of Grimm and Rousseau on the shortcomings of le style français without bothering to uncover the influence of Rameau and Armand-Louis Couperin on Schobert – and through him on the young Mozart. Beethoven's ‘heroic’ manner is most often thought to be the outcome of an instinctively ‘romantic temperament’ exploding Viennese classicism from inside, when in fact it was largely prompted by French composers of the revolutionary period such as Méhul and Gossec (something altogether natural in a composer born in the Rhine–Palatinate). The beginning of a new contrapuntal spirit in French music is often credited to Gounod and his discovery of Bach, to detriment of Böely both as composer and performer.
1 It was the harpsichordist Jane Clarke who first pointe d this out to me.
2 On the other side of the balance one should remember that some otherwise respectable German musicologists will insist that Webern took absolutely nothing from Debussy and that the ‘impressionist’ details in his orchestration can all of it be traced to Gustav Mahler. What Mahler himself may have learned from the scores of Debussy seems not to come into the equation.
3 A delightful exception is the neo-baroque musette in ‘Les bergers’ from La nativité du Seigneur.
4 ‘Villiers’ avowedly mythical novel on the life of Edison, La nonvelle Eve, is the best instance of this.
* Notes to CD 2e2m 1006. A discography will be provided in Part 2 of this article. (Ed.)
4 In fact the reference is to the early death of his talented daughter Nathalie, whose paintings are reproduced on the covers of Mefano's recordings listed in the Discography.
* Notes to CD Adda 581272. (Ed.)
5 Our own David James was the first soloist – as he himself puts it, a far cry from his cathedral duties at the time.