Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-r5fsc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-02T23:32:15.608Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Orthodoxy, Enlightenment and Religious Revival

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

W. R. Ward
W. R. Ward*
Affiliation:
University of Durham
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Everyone has his favourite squibs to illuminate the animosity of the devotees of the Christian application of modern knowledge towards the partisans of religious revival. R. B. Aspland, the unitarian, summed them all up succinctly in the early nineteenth century in his case against Wesleyanism. ‘Wine’, he declared, ‘is the beverage of the gentleman, spirits of the herd. So with religion’. Something of this edge had been there from the beginning, long before attitudes had been struck and the French Revolution had become a divider of spirits everywhere. Much of the fascination of the Turretini correspondence is provided by the conscious sense of intellectual superiority of the Swiss fathers of rational orthodoxy. ‘We are here much occupied with the scandalous affairs of Toggenburg’, writes Jean Gaspard Escher with an almost audible turn of the nose. ‘These are mountain people rather like Vaudois, Miquelets or Camisards’, and their murderous politics were of the Ulster variety. Neither the Toggenburgers, nor the Vaudois or Camisards were part of the history of religious revival, but they were very like Protestant minorities from Central Europe who were; the Salzburgers, for example. ‘The majority of these men’, writes Escher of the latter, ‘can neither read nor write; their fundamental doctrine is that worship is due to God alone and that salvation is by Jesus Christ. This doctrine fills them with a horror of popery: . . . they are ill-instructed in the other articles of religion. They know by heart some fine passages of scripture and some Lutheran hymns to which they hold’. Pastorally, if not confessionally, the mountain men were a different cup of tea from the practitioners of polite learning; but as late as 1800 it was possible to turn American methodists and baptists out in droves to vote for the deist Jefferson, and it is the purpose of this paper to suggest that the fate of the revivalist and that of the men of enlightenment was more closely linked at an early stage than the text-book categories usually suggest.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 17: Religion and Humanism , 1981 , pp. 275 - 296
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1981

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Aspland, R. B., The rise and present influence of Wesley an Methodism (London 1831) p 20 Google Scholar.

2 Lettres [inédites addressées à J. A.] Ttirretini, ed Bude, E.de, 4 vols (Paris/Geneva 1887) 2 P23 Google Scholar.

3 Ibid 1 pp 376-7.

4 Ibid 1 p 157: 2 pp 92-3, 120.

5 Ibid 1 p 302.

6 Ibid 1 p 340.

7 Ibid 2 p 50.

8 Journal [of the Rev. John Wesley[, ed Curnock, Nehemiah, 8 vols (2 ed London 1938) 2 PP 20–57 Google Scholar.

9 Lettres Turretini 2 p ni. It is entertaining to see the catholic enlightenment coming back to this point after catholics had wrought havoc for generations in the name of a strict confessionalism. A report made to Joseph II in 1771 after a tour of the old protestant territories of Bohemia, Moravia and Silesia, declared that ‘there is a great lack of education in all your majesty’s hereditary lands and in the real Christian and moral virtues; the mob lives in the greatest ignornace, the townsmen and many who regard themselves as pious souls are held in a really tasteless and superstitious piety, which brings religion to breakup and scorn, through the ignorant clergy, overstocked in these towns, who give occasion to petty devotions partly from self-interest, partly from their own stupidity.’ Aus der Zeit Maria Theresias. Tagebuch des Fürsten Johann Josef Khevenhüller-Metsch, 1742-1776, ed KhevenhüUer- Metsch, Rudolf Graf and Schlitter, Hans, 7 vols (Vienna 1907-25 7 p 381 Google Scholar. Cited below as KhevenhüUer Tagebuch.

10 Reichert, Detlef, ‘Der Weg protestantischer Liturgik zwischen Orthodoxie und Aufklärung’, D Theol thesis, University of Münster (1975) pp 295–6, 347-8Google Scholar. Pietism itself could be active in liturgical reform, taking up into itself themes both of orthodoxy and enlightenment. In Thuringia, for ecample, the pietists got rid of public confession, introduced public confirmation, and greatly developed the musical side of public worship, Geschichte Thüringens, ed Patze, Hans and Schlesinger, Walter, 4 vols (Cologne/Vienna 1968-73 in progress) 4 pp 30–1 Google Scholar. The pietist court in Denmark abolished exorcism as a normal part of the baptismal liturgy in 1737, Acta Historico-Ecclesiastica (Weimar 1737-56) 4 p 93.

11 Walch, [J.G.], [Historische und theologische Einleitung in der] Religionsstreitigkeiten [welche sonderlich[ ansser der Evangelisch-Lutherischen Kirche [entstanden 5 vols (3 ed Jena 1733-6: reprint Stuttgart/Bad Canstatt 1972) 1 p 508 Google Scholar. The Invariata was a text of the original Augsburg Confession drawn up for the Book of Concord in 1580, and, despite its name, is said to differ in more than 450 places from the text of 1530. The Reformed were willing to accept the Variata, Melancthon’s revision of 1540.

12 Walch, Religionstreitigkeiten ausser der Evangelisch-Lutherischen Kirche 1 p 54.

13 Zeller, Winfried, Theologie und Frömmigkeit (Marburg 1971) esp pp 85–116 Google Scholar. Compare Hausamman, Susi, ‘ “Leben aus Glauben” in Reformation, Reformorthodoxie und Pietismus’, T[heologische] Z[eitschrift[ 27 (Basel 1971) pp 263-89Google Scholar; also Wernle, [Paul[, [Der] schweizerische Protestantismus [im XVIII. Jahrhundert], 5 vols (Tübingen 1923-42) 1 pp 92–103 Google Scholar.

14 van Andel, Cornells Pieter, ‘Paul Gerhardt, ein Mystiker zur Zeit des Barocks’, Traditio-Krisis-Renovatio aus theologischer Sicht, ed Jaspert, Bernd and Mohr, Rudolf (Marburg 1976) p 183 Google Scholar.

15 John Wesley, Journal 5 p 117; Wesley, John, Letters, ed Telford, J., 8 vols (London 1931) 4 p 299 Google Scholar. Amongst the 33 German hymns translated by Wesley were several by Gerhardt, four of which are in current use.

16 Zeller, Theologie und Frömmigkeit pp 109-10.

17 The reality of these fears is in no way diminished by the fact that the catholics in the empire continually harrowed themselves (and kept their party together) by fears that the protestant party was about to capture the Imperial dignity itself. On this see Duchardt, Heinz, Protestantisches Kaisertum und altes Reich (Wiesbaden 1977)Google Scholar. For Habsburg use of an alleged plot to subvert the catholic estates of the empire, see Khevenhüiler Tagebuch 2 pp 382-3.

18 Rürup, Reinhard, Johann Jakob Moser, Pietismus und Reform (Wiesbaden 1965) pp 29-31Google Scholar.

19 Teutsches Staats-Recht 1 pp 123-4.

20 Ibid 1 pp 167-8.

21 Modern introductions like Schulte, Aloys, Der deutsche Staat. Verfassung, Macht und Grenzen, 919-1914 (Stuttgart 1933, repr Aalen 1968)Google Scholar while useful are no substitute.

22 Struve, Burcard Gotthelf, Ausführliche Historie des Religions-Beschwerden zwischen denen Römisch-Catholischen und Evangelischen im Teutschen Reich (Leipzig 1722)Google Scholar.

23 von Schauroth, E.C.W., Vollständige Sammlung aller Conclusorum, Schreiben, und anderer übrigen Verhandlungen des hochpreisslichen Corporis Evangelicorum...bis auf die gegenwärtigen Zeiten, 3 vols (Regensburg 1751-2)Google Scholar preface to vol 1 n.p. (Italics mine).

24 Moser,Teutsches Staats-Recht 1 p 171.

25 An interesting report on all this was subsequently prepared for Turretini, lettres Turretini 3 pp 375-82.

26 On the whole question see Karl, Borgmann, Der deutsche ReUgionsstre’U der Jahre 1711/20.Abhandlungen der mittleren und neuren Geschichte. Heft 80 (Berlin 1937)Google Scholar. Andreas Biederbick, ‘Der deutsche Reichstag zu Regensburg im Jahrzehnt nach dem Spanischen Erbfolgkrieg, 1714-24. Der Verlauf der Religionsstreitigkeiten und ihre Bedeutung für den Reichstag’, Diss, University of Bonn (1937).

27 Wolfgang, Michael, Englische Geschichte im achtzehnten Jahrhundert, 5 vols (Hamburg, Leipzig and Basel 1896-1955) 3 pp 410 Google Scholar seq.

28 Droysen, J. G., Geschichte der preussischen Politik, 4 vols (Leipzig 1874-86) 4er Theil, 4e Abtheilung, pp 416-33Google Scholar. Compare Acta Historko-Ecclesiastica 3 p 563: 6 pp 529-34.

29 Schlenke, Manfred, England und das friderizianische Preussen, 1740-63 (Freiburg/Munich 1963)Google Scholar.

30 Neveux, J. B., Vie spirituelle et vie sociale entre Rhin et Baltique au XVIIe siècle (Paris 1967) pp xxxiii–xxxiv Google Scholar.

31 On the general situation see Jaeckel, G., ‘Die Bedeutung der konfessionellen Frage für die Besitzergreifung Schlesiens durch Friedrich den Grossen’, Jahrbuch für schlesische Kirche und Kirchengeschkhte, NF 34 (Düsseldorf 1955) pp 78–121 Google Scholar.

32 On whom see Greschat, Martin, Zwischen Tradition und neuem Anfang. Valentin Frnst Löscher und der Ausgang der lutherischen Orthodoxie (Witten 1971)Google Scholar.

33 First published at Wittenberg 1701, and at Leipzig 1704-61.

34 Heinrich, G., ‘Amsträgerschaft und Geistlichkeit. Zur Problematik der sekundären Führungsschichten in Brandenburg-Preussen, 1450-1786’, Beamtentum und Pfarrerstand, 1400-1800, ed Franz, Günther (Limburg/Lahn 1972) pp 179–238 Google Scholar.

35 Baumgarten’s, S.J. Geschichte der Religionspartheyen was edited by Semler, (Halle 1766, repr Hildesheim 1966)Google Scholar from lectures given in 1754 and 1755.

36 Ibib pp 25-60.

37 In Baumgarten’s rational orthodoxy Hobbes was promoted to the rank of ‘indifferentist’, since he permitted the sovereign to require not merely conformity, but conscientious adherence, by his subjects, to the religion he prescribed, Ibid p 107.

38 Fritz, Mauthner, Der Atheismus und seine Geschichte im Abendland, 4 vols (Stuttgart/ Berlin 1920-23)Google Scholar.

39 Blaufuss, Dietrich, Reichstadt und Pietismus—Philipp Jacob Spener und Gottlieb Spizel aus Augsburg (Neustadt a. d. Aisch 1977) p 268 Google Scholar.

40 Blaufuss, Dietrich, ‘Korrespondenten von G. W. Leibniz. 3. Gottlieb Spizel aus Augsburg (1639-91). Ein Anhänger Phil. Jac. Speners, des Führers des lutherischen Pietismus’, Studia Leibnitiana 5 (Wiesbaden 1973) pp 116-44Google Scholar; Gottfried Wilhelm, Leibniz, Sämtliche Schriften und Briefe, Erste Reihe 9 (Berlin 1975) p 595 Google Scholar.

41 Hans, Leube, ‘Ideen und Taten im deutschen Protestantismus nach dem Dreissigjährigen Kriege’, Zeitschrift für deutsche Geisteswissenschaft 5 (1943) pp 97–120 Google Scholar, reprinted in Leube, Hans, Orthodoxie und Pietismus, Gesammelte Studien (Bielefeld 1975)Google Scholar p in.

42 On this whole question see Leube, Hans, ‘Die Bekampfung des Atheismus in der deutschen lutherischen Kirchen des 17. Jahrhunderts’, ZKG 42 (1924) pp 227-44Google Scholar, reprinted in Leube, Orthodoxie und Pietismus pp 75-88.

43 Redwood, John, Reason, Ridicule and Religion. The age of Enlightenment in England, 1660-1730 (London 1976)Google Scholar; Jacob, Margaret C., The Newtonians and the English Revolution, 1689-1720 (Hassocks 1976) p 15 Google Scholar; Stromberg, Roland N., Religious Liberalism in eighteenth-century England (London 1954)Google Scholar.

44 Leube, Orthodoxie und Pietismus p 77.

45 Unschuldige Nachrichten 1721 pp 493-7.

46 Ibid 1727 pp 432-9. Wake’s catechism was published at Frankfurt and Leipzig in 1725; a Basel edition contained a foreword by the ferocious Cyprian opposing union with the reformed and others among whom socianism was gaining ground as rapidly as in the church of England.

47 Benthcm, Henrich Ludolfi, Nen-eroffneter Engla’ndischer Kirch- und Schulenstaat.. . nebst einer Vor-Rede Hern. Consislorial-Rat und Generai-Superint. Mentzers in Hannover (Leipzig 1732) preface paras 9–10 Google Scholar. An obituary of Bentham who died 9 July 1723 is given in Unschuldige Nachrichten 1723 pp 838-9.

48 Pfister, Rudolf, Kirchengeschichte der Schweiz, 2 vols (Zürich 1964-74) 2 pp 486-96Google Scholar; Geiger, [Max], ‘Die Unionsbestrebungen [der schweizerischen reformierten Theologie unter der Führung des helvetischen Triumvirates]’, TZ 9 (1953) p 128 Google Scholar. Compare Martin, Schmidt, ‘Ecumenical activity on the Continent of Europe in the 17th and 18th centuries’, A history of the ecumenical movement, 1517-1948, ed Rouse, R. and Neill, S.C. (2 ed London 1967) p 109 Google Scholar.

49 Bloesch, [E.], [Geschichte der schweizerisclwn-reformierten Kirchen], 2 vols (Bern 1899) 2 P 46 Google Scholar.

50 Guggisberg, [Kurt], [Bernische Kirchengeschiclue] (Bern, 1958) pp 370, 401, 471-2Google Scholar; Geiger, ‘Die Unionsbestrebungen’ p 125.

51 Lettres Turretini 2 p 398.

52 Bloesch, 2 pp 136-7.

53 Guggisberg p 378; Bloesch 2 p 104.

54 This matter and the whole question of Anglo-Swiss participation in the much-canvassed protestant front in the war of the Spanish Succession is discussed by Dr Eamon Duffy in a paper contributed to Professor C. W. Dugmore’s Festschrift and kindly made available before publication, ‘ “Correspondence Fraternelle” : the SPCK, the SPG and the churches of Switzerland in the War of the Spanish Succession’.

55 Schöffler, Herbert, Das literarische Zurich, 1700-1750 (Frauenfeld/Leipzig 1925) p 108 Google Scholar.

56 Wernle, Schweizerische Protestantismus i p 107.

57 Lichtenberg, Hans Otto, Unterhaltsame Bauernaujklärung. Ein Kapitel Volksbildungs-ıeschichte (Tübingen 1970) passim esp pp 112-17Google Scholar.

58 Hinrichs, Carl, Preussentum und Pietismus (Gõttingen 1971) pp 1–125 Google Scholar.

59 Winter, Eduard, Halle als Ausgangspunkt der deutschen Russlandkunde im 18. Jahrhundert ([East] Berlin 1953)Google Scholar.

60 Zehrer, Karl, ‘Die Beziehungen zwischen dem hallesischen Pietismus und dem frühen Methodismus’, Pietismus und Neuzeit 2 (Witten 1975) pp 43–56 Google Scholar.

61 Winter, Eduard, Die Pflage der West- und Süd-slavischen Sprachen im 18. Jahrhundert ([East] Berlin 1954)Google Scholar: Winter, Eduard, Die tschechische und slavische Emigration in Deutsch land im. 17. und 18. Jahrhundert ([East] Berlin 1955)Google Scholar.

62 Jaeckel (see n 31 above) has lately argued that the Silesian wars (to which this propaganda led) were indeed of religion; certainly Prussia spared no pains to make them appear so. Polish commentators, much less enamoured than those of the DDR in presenting the intercourse between Halle and Peter the Great as a progressive foreshadowing of the present eastern bloc, prefer to talk about class conflict and see the Poles (many of whom in Silesia were indeed protestant) as the vanguard of peasant resistance to the exploitation of a (largely German) nobility ( wicz, Stanislaw Michalkie, ‘Einige Episoden aus der Geschichte der schlesischen Bauernkämpfe im 17. und 18. Jahrhundert’, Beitrage zur Geschichte Schlesiens, ed Maleczynska, Eva ([East] Berlin 1953) pp 356–400 Google Scholar. Some recent West German scholarly work is of pre-war intellectual vintage: Geschichte Schlesiens, band 2, Die Habsburgerzeit, 1526-1740, ed Petry, Ludwig and Menzel, J.Joachim (Darmstadt 1973) pp 1–135 Google Scholar.

63 The role of protestant embassy-chaplains as smugglers of forbidden literature may explain the curious fact that though prospective clergy were as a class debarred from the scholarships endowed to support the new Regius Professors of Modern History of Oxford and Cambridge in 1724, three scholarships were reserved for ordinands willing to serve as embassy-chaplains. Sykes, N., Edmund Gibson, Bishop of London 1669-1748 (London 1926) p 96 Google Scholar.

64 Jenkins, Geraint H., Literature, Religion and Society in Wales, 1660-1730 (Cardiff 1978)Google Scholar.

65 On this whole subject see the seminal paper by Wittram, Reinhard, ‘Der lesende Landmann. Zur Rezeption aufklärerischer Bemühungen durch die bäuerliche Bevölker ung im 18. Jahrhundert’, Der Bauer Mittel- und Osteuropas im sozio-ökonomischen Wandel des l8. und 19. Jahrhunderts, ed Heinz, Ischreyt (Cologne/Vienna 1973) pp 142-96Google Scholar. Compare the situation among the French peasantry, Mandrou, Robert, De la culture populaire aux XVII’ et XVIIIe siècles. La Bibliothèque bleue de Troyes (Paris 1964)Google Scholar

66 The British Library has a collection of these sermons and cartoons at 1012. d. 30; see specially Löscher, V. E., Drey Predigten von Erkänntnis und der Ehre des Sohnes Cottes (Dresden 1733) p 26 Google Scholar. Compare Hillmger, J. G., Beytrag zur Kirchen-Historie des Erzbis-choftums Salzburg (Saalfeld 1732)Google Scholar.

67 John Wesley, Journal, 1 pp 475-6.

68 Schmidt, Martin, ‘Luthers Vorrede zum Römerbrief im Pietismus’, enlarged version in his Wiedergeburt und neuer Mensch. Gesammelte Studien zur Geschichte des Pietismus (Witten 1969) pp 299–330 Google Scholar.

69 Aufklärung, Absolutismus und Bürgertum in Deutschland, ed Kopitsch, F. (Munich 1976) p 21 Google Scholar.

70 This matter is explored in the unpublished doctoral dissertation of Agatha Kobuch, ‘Die Zensor in Kursachsen zur Zeit der Personalunion mit Polen (1692-1763). Beiträge zur Geschichte der Aufklärung’ (Humboldt university, East Berlin, 1965).

71 Carpzov, J.Gottlob, Religions-untersuchung der Böhmisch- und Mährischen Bruder von Anbeginn ihrer Gemeiner bis auf gegenwärtigen Zeiten (Leipzig 1742) p 406 Google Scholar.

72 Bucholtz, Arend, Die Geschichte der Familie Lessing, 2 vols (Berlin 1909) 1 pp 98, 109-10Google Scholar.

73 Sermon CXXXIV (1741). Works of John Wesley, 14 vols. (London, 1872: repr Grand Rapids nd) 7 p 454.

74 Sykes, N., William Wake, Archbishop of Canterbury, 1657-1737, 2 vols (Cambridge 1957) 2 pp 1–88 Google Scholar.

75 Tlie history of American Methodism, ed Bucke, E.S. 3 vols (New York/Nashville 1964) 1 pp 13–14 Google Scholar.

76 Schmalenberg, Gerhard, Pietismus-Schule-Religionsunterricht. Die christliche Unterweisung im Spiegel der von Pietismus bestimmten Schulordnung des 18. Jahrhunderts (Bern/ Frankfurt 1974)Google Scholar.

77 Ward, W. R., ‘The legacy of John Wesley’, Statesmen, Scholars and Merchants, ed Whiteman, A., Bromley, J.S. and Dickson, P.G.M. (Oxford 1973) pp 331-3Google Scholar. On Wesley’s relations with the Anglican equivalent of Orthodoxy, see Duffy, Eamon, ‘Primitive Christianity Revived: Religious renewal in Augustan England’, SCH 14 (1977) p 299 Google Scholar.

78 Beyreuther, Eric, ‘Halle und die Herrnhuter in den Rezensionen der Göttingischen Zeitungen von gelehrten Sachen auf dem Hintergrund niedersächsischer Religionspolitik zwischen 1739 und 1760’ Jahrbuch der Gesellschaft für niedersächsiche Kirchengeschichte 39 (Göttingen 1975) pp 109-34Google Scholar; Meinhardt, Günther, Die Universität Göttingen. Ihr Entwicklung und Geschichte von 1734-l974 (Göttingen 1977) esp pp 34–5 Google Scholar.