Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-fbnjt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-03T01:01:32.944Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Mandating Treatment for Pregnant Substance Abusers: A Compromise

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 May 2016

Deborah Mathieu
Deborah Mathieu*
Affiliation:
University of Arizona, USA
Get access

Abstract

This article considers one of the many ways in which the state might intervene in the life of a pregnant woman in order to prevent serious harm to the child she intends to bear: requiring a substance-abusing pregnant woman to live in a residential treatment center for the duration of her pregnancy. While the author agrees with those who argue that such state action is unjustifiable, she points out that the facts grounding this normative conclusion may change. Disagreeing with those who contend that, regardless of the circumstances, the state may never interfere with the activities of a pregnant woman in order to prevent harm to her future child, the author considers both the present situation and the most likely future scenario, and offers a compromise solution—civil commitment to an outpatient treatment facility.

Type
Pregnancy And Substance Abuse
Information
Politics and the Life Sciences , Volume 14 , Issue 2 , August 1995 , pp. 199 - 208
Copyright
Copyright © Association for Politics and the Life Sciences 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abel, E.L.(1984). Fetal Alcohol Syndrome and Fetal Alcohol Effects. New York: Plenum.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Abel, E.L. and Sokol, R.J.(1987). “Incidence of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome and Economic Impact of FAS-Related Anomalies.” Drug and Alcohol Dependence 19:51–70.Google Scholar
Addington v. Texas (1979). 441 U.S. 418.Google Scholar
Alroomi, L.G., Davidson, J., Evans, T.J., Galea, P., and Howat, R.(1988). “Maternal Narcotic Abuse and the Newborn.” Archives of Disease in Childhood 63:81–83.Google Scholar
American Medical Association Board of Trustees (1990). “Legal Interventions during Pregnancy.” Journal of the American Medical Association 264:2663–70.Google Scholar
American Medical Association Council on Scientific Affairs (1983). “Fetal Effects of Maternal Alcohol Use.” New England Journal of Medicine 249:2517–21.Google Scholar
Anglin, M.D., Brecht, M.L., and Maddahian, E.(1989). “Pre-Treatment Characteristics and Treatment Performance of Legally Coerced versus Voluntary Methadone Maintenance Admissions.” Criminology 27:537–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aronson, M. and Olegard, R.(1987). “Children of Alcoholic Mothers.” Pediatrician 14:57–61.Google Scholar
Arrigo, B.A.(1992-93). “Paternalism, Civil Commitment and Illness Politics.” Journal of Law and Health 7:131–68.Google Scholar
Barnard, C.P.(1984). “Alcoholism and Incest.” Focus on Family and Chemical Dependency 7:27–29.Google Scholar
Barry, E.M.(1989). “Pregnant Prisoners.” Harvard Women's Law Journal 12:189–205.Google Scholar
Becker, B.L.(1991). “Order in the Court.” Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly 19:235–59.Google Scholar
Behrman, R.E.(1987). “Premature Births among Black Women.” New England Journal of Medicine 312:763–65.Google Scholar
Blank, R.H.(1993). “Maternal-Fetal Relationship: The Courts and Social Policy.” Journal of Legal Medicine 14:73–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chan, L.S., Wingert, W.A., Wachsman, L., Schuetz, S., and Rogers, C.(1986). “Differences between Dropouts and Active Participants in a Pediatric Clinic for Substance Abuse Mothers.” American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 12:89–99.Google Scholar
Chasnoff, I.J.(1987). “Perinatal Effects of Cocaine.” Contemporary Obstetrics and Gynecology 29:163–79.Google Scholar
Chasnoff, I.J.(1989). “Drug Use and Women: Establishing a Standard of Care.” In Hutchings, D.E.(ed.), Prenatal Abuse of Licit and Illicit Drugs. New York: New York Academy of Medicine.Google Scholar
Chasnoff, I.J., Burns, K.A., Burns, W.J., and Schnoll, S.H.(1986). “Prenatal Drug Exposure: Effects on Neonatal and Infant Growth and Development.” Neurobehavioral Toxicology and Teratology 8:357–62.Google Scholar
Chasnoff, I.J., Landress, H.J., and Barrett, M.E.(1990). “The Prevalence of Illicit-Drug or Alcohol Use During Pregnancy and Discrepancies in Mandatory Reporting in Pinellas County, Florida.” New England Journal of Medicine 322:1202–6.Google Scholar
Chavkin, D.F.(1992). “‘For Their Own Good’: Civil Commitment of Alcohol and Drug-Dependent Pregnant Women.” South Dakota Law Review 37:224–88.Google Scholar
Chavkin, W.(1990). “Drug Addiction and Pregnancy: Policy Cross-roads.” American Journal of Public Health 80:483–87.Google Scholar
Chavkin, W.(1991). “Mandatory Treatment for Drug Use during Pregnancy.” Journal of the American Medical Association 266:1556–61.Google Scholar
Cnattingius, S.(1992). “Smoking during Pregnancy.” International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 8:91–95.Google Scholar
Cole, C.D. et al.(1984). “Neonatal Ethanol Withdrawal.” Journal of Pediatrics 105:444–71.Google Scholar
Collins, J.J. and Allison, M.(1983). “Legal Coercion and Retention in Drug Abuse Treatment.” Hospital and Community Psychiatry 34:1145–49.Google Scholar
Daley, S.(1991). “Born on Crack and Coping with Kindergarten.” New York Times (February 7).Google Scholar
Daniels, C.R.(1993). At Women's Expense: State Power and the Politics of Fetal Rights. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Deren, S.(1986). “The Children of Substance Abusers: A Review of the Literature.” Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 3:77–94.Google Scholar
Doberczak, T.M., Shanzer, S., Senie, R.T., and Kandall, S.R.(1988). “Neonatal Neurologic and Electroencephalographic Effects of Intrauterine Cocaine Exposure.” Journal of Pediatrics 113:354–58.Google Scholar
Dorris, M.(1994). “The Tragedy of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome.” 1994 Medical and Health Annual. Chicago: Encyclopedia Britannica.Google Scholar
Edelin, K.C., Gurganious, L., Golar, K., Oellerich, D., Kyei-Aboagye, K., and Adel Hamid, M.(1988). “Methadone Maintenance in Pregnancy: Consequences to Care and Outcome.” Obstetrics and Gynecology 71:399–404.Google Scholar
Ehrenkranz, S.M. et al., eds. (1989). Clinical Social Work with Maltreated Children and Their Families. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Ershoff, D.H., Quinn, V.P., Mullen, P.D., and Lairson, D.R.(1990). “Pregnancy and Medical Cost Outcomes of a Self-Help Prenatal Smoking Cessation Program in a HMO.” Public Health Reports-Hyattsville 105:340–47.Google Scholar
Fangman, J.J., Mark, P.M., Pratt, L., Conway, K.K., and Healey, M.L.(1994). “Prematurity Prevention Programs.” American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 170:744–50.Google Scholar
Feldman, J.G., Minkoff, H.L., McCalla, S., and Salwen, M.(1992). “A Cohort Study of the Impact of Perinatal Drug-Use on Prematurity in an Inner-City Population.” American Journal of Public Health 82:726–28.Google Scholar
Field, M.(1989). “Controlling the Woman to Protect the Fetus.” Law, Medicine and Health Care 17:114–29.Google Scholar
Finnegan, L.P.(1982). “Outcome of Children Born to Women Dependent upon Narcotics.” Advances in Alcohol and Substance Abuse:55–101.Google Scholar
Fitzsimmons, J. et al.(1986). “Pregnancy in a Drug-Abusing Population.” American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 12:247–55.Google Scholar
Flandermeyer, A.A.(1987). “A Comparison of the Effects of Heroin and Cocaine Abuse upon the Neonate.” Neonatal Network:42–48.Google Scholar
Frank, D.A. et al.(1988). “Cocaine Use during Pregnancy: Prevalence and Correlates.” Pediatrics 82:888–95.Google Scholar
Garcia, S. and Keilitz, I.(1991). “Involuntary Civil Commitment of Drug-Dependent Persons with Special Reference to Pregnant Women.” Mental and Physical Disability Law Reporter 15:418–25.Google Scholar
Golden, M.R.(1991). “When Pregnancy Discrimination Is Gender Discrimination: The Constitutionality of Excluding Pregnant Women from Drug Treatment Programs.” New York University Law Review 66:1832–80.Google Scholar
Hefemeister, T.L. and Amirshahi, A.J.(1992). “Civil Commitment for Drug Dependency: The Judicial Response.” Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review 26:39–70.Google Scholar
Howard, J.(1992). “Chronic Drug Users As Parents.” Hastings Law Journal 43:645–68.Google Scholar
“Innocent Victims” (1991). Time (May 13):56–63.Google Scholar
Institute for Health Policy, Brandeis University (1993). Substance Abuse: The Nation's Number One Health Problem. Princeton, NJ: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.Google Scholar
Institute of Medicine (1985). Preventing Low Birthweight. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.Google Scholar
Johnson, L.(1994). National Survey Results on Drug Use from the Monitoring the Future Study, 1975-1993. Rockville, MD: Department of Health and Human Services.Google Scholar
Johnson v. State of Florida (1991, 1992). 578 So.2d, 419 (1991), 602 So.2d 1288 (1992).Google Scholar
Kempe, C.H. and Helfer, R., eds. (1980). The Battered Child. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Kolder, V.E.B., Gallagher, J., and Parsons, M.T.(1987). “Court-Ordered Obstetrical Interventions.” New England Journal of Medicine 316:1192–96.Google Scholar
Koren, G., Graham, K., Shear, H., and Einarson, T.(1989). “Bias against the Null Hypothesis: The Reproductive Hazards of Cocaine.” Lancet 2:1440–42.Google Scholar
Kosten, T.R., Gawin, F.H., Rounsaville, B.J., and Kleber, H.D.(1986). “Cocaine Abuse among Opioid Addicts: Demographic and Diagnostic Factors in Treatment.” American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 12:1–16.Google Scholar
Krandall, S.R. and Chavkin, W.(1992). “Illicit Drugs in America.” Hastings Law Journal 43:615–43.Google Scholar
Lefkovitch, Y., Weiser, M., and Levy, A.(1993). “Involuntary Outpatient Commitment: Ethics and Problems.” Medicine and Law 12:213–20.Google Scholar
Leiber, M.J. and Anderson, S.(1993). “A Comparison of Pre-Reform and Post-Reform Civil Commitment Decisionmaking in Dade County, Wisconsin.” New England Journal on Criminal and Civil Confinement 20:1–25.Google Scholar
Little, B.B., Snell, L. M., Gilstrap, L. D. III, and Johnson, W.L.(1990). “Patterns of Multiple Substance Abuse during Pregnancy.” Southern Medical Journal 83:507–9.Google Scholar
MacGregnor, S.N., Keith, L.G., Chasnoff, I.J., Rosner, M.A., Chisum, G.M., Shaw, P., and Minogue, J.P.(1987). “Cocaine Use during Pregnancy: Adverse Perinatal Outcome.” American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 157:686–90.Google Scholar
Madden, J.D., Payne, T.F., and Miller, S.(1986). “Maternal Cocaine Abuse and Effect on the Newborn.” Pediatrics 77:209–11.Google Scholar
Manning, W.G., Keeler, E.B., Newhouse, J.P., Sloss, E.M., and Wasserman, J.(1989). “The Taxes of Sin: Do Smokers Pay Their Way?” Journal of the American Medical Association 261:1604–9.Google Scholar
Marcus, J., Hans, S., and Jeremy, R.J.(1984). “A Longitudinal Study of Offspring Born to Methadone-Maintained Women. III. Effects of Multiple Risk Factors on Development at 4, 8, and 12 Months.” American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 10:195–207.Google Scholar
Mark, F.(1988). “Does Coercion Work? The Role of Referral Source in Motivating Alcoholics in Treatment.” Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly 5:5–22.Google Scholar
Mathieu, D.(1985). “Respecting Liberty and Preventing Harm: Limits of State Intervention in Prenatal Choice.” Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 8:19–55.Google Scholar
Mathieu, D.(1991). Preventing Prenatal Harm. Boston: Kluwer Academic.Google Scholar
McCormick, M.C.(1985). “The Contribution of Low Birth Weight to Infant Mortality and Childhood Morbidity.” New England Journal of Medicine 312:82–90.Google Scholar
Merrick, J.C.(1993). “Maternal Substance Abuse during Pregnancy.” Journal of Legal Medicine 14:57–71.Google Scholar
Mulvey, E.P., Geller, J.L., and Roth, L.H.(1987). “The Promise and Peril of Involuntary Outpatient Commitment.” American Psychologist 42:571–84.Google Scholar
Murray, J.L. and Bernfield, M.(1988). “The Differential Effect of Prenatal Care on the Incidence of Low Birth Weight among Blacks and Whites in a Prepaid Health Plan.” New England Journal of Medicine 319:1385–91.Google Scholar
Musto, D.F.(1991). “Opium, Cocaine and Marijuana in American History.” Scientific American.Google Scholar
Olegaard, R.(1992). “Alcohol and Narcotics: Epidemiology and Pregnancy Risks.” International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 8:101–5.Google Scholar
Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (1992). Health Policy Studies No. 1: U.S. Health Care at the Cross-Roads. Paris: OECD Publications.Google Scholar
Oro, A.S. and Dixon, S.D.(1987). “Perinatal Cocaine and Methamphetamine Exposure: Maternal and Neonatal Correlates.” Journal of Pediatrics 222:571–78.Google Scholar
Paltrow, L.M.(1990). “When Becoming Pregnant Is a Crime.” Criminal Justice Ethics 9:41–47.Google Scholar
Phibbs, C.S., Bateman, D.A., and Schwartz, R.M.(1991). “The Neonatal Costs of Maternal Cocaine Use.” Journal of the American Medical Association 266:1521–26.Google Scholar
Robins, L.N. and Mills, J.L., eds. (1993). “Effects of In Utero Exposure to Street Drugs.” American Journal of Public Health 83(Supp.):5–32.Google Scholar
Roberts, D.E.(1991). “Punishing Drug Addicts Who Have Babies.” Harvard Law Review 104:1419–82.Google Scholar
Rosenbaum, S., Hughes, D., Butler, E., and Howard, D.(1988). “Incantations in the Dark: Medicaid, Managed Care, and Maternity Care.” Milbank Quarterly 4:661–93.Google Scholar
Roth, R.(1993). “At Women's Expense: The Cost of Fetal Rights.” In Merrick, J.C. and Blank, R.H.(eds.), The Politics of Pregnancy. New York: Haworth Press.Google Scholar
Rubenstein, L.(1991). “Prosecuting Maternal Substance Abusers.” Yale Law and Policy Review 9:130–60.Google Scholar
Schachter, J.(1986). “Help Is Hard to Find for Addict Mothers: Drug Use ‘Epidemic’ Overwhelms Services.” Los Angeles Times (December 12):II-1.Google Scholar
Schiff, N.K.(1991). “Legislation Punishing Drug Use during Pregnancy.” Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly 19:197–234.Google Scholar
Sherman, R.(1989). “Keeping Babies Free of Drugs.” The National Law Journal 1:28–29.Google Scholar
Shiono, P.H., Klebanoff, M.A., and Rhoads, G.G.(1986). “Smoking and Drinking during Pregnancy.” Journal of the American Medical Association 255:82–84.Google Scholar
Spohr, H.L., Willms, J., and Steinhausen, H.C.(1993). “Prenatal Alcohol Exposure and Long-Term Developmental Consequences.” Lancet 341:907–10.Google Scholar
Steinbock, B.(1991). Life Before Birth. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Trost, C.(1989). “Born to Lose.” Wall Street Journal (July 18).Google Scholar
“Use of Alcohol Linked to Rise in Fetal Illness” (1995). New York Times (April 7):A13.Google Scholar
Westermeyer, J.(1989). “Nontreatment Factors Affecting Treatment Outcomes in Substance Abuse.” American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 15:13–29.Google Scholar
Wexler, D.(1994). “An Orientation to Therapeutic Justice.” New England Journal on Civil and Criminal Confinement 20:259–64.Google Scholar
Wilson, A.L., Munson, D.P., Schubot, D.B., Leonardson, G., and Stevens, D.C.(1992). “Does Prenatal Care Decrease the Incidence and Cost of Neonatal Intensive Care Admissions?” American Journal of Perinatology 9:281–84.Google Scholar
Wilson, G.S.(1989). “Clinical Studies of Infants and Children Exposed Prenatally to Heroin.” In Hutchings, D.E.(ed.), Prenatal Abuse of Licit and Illicit Drugs. New York: The New York Academy of Medicine.Google Scholar
Yawn, B.P. and Yawn, R.A.(1989). “Preterm Birth Prevention in a Rural Practice.” Journal of the American Medical Association 262:230–33.Google Scholar
Zuckerman, B. et al.(1989). “Effects of Maternal Marijuana and Cocaine Use on Fetal Growth.” New England Journal of Medicine 320:762–68.Google Scholar