It has been quite some time since the charge that Schiller's Braut von Messina is a fate-tragedy à la Zacharias Werner was completely dismissed. We can also disregard the mixture of mythologies frowned upon by A. W. Schlegel, since in our day mythologies, like universes, threaten to become relative. The idea that the Braut is a pure imitation of the Greek tragedy, and that its dramatist was following Sophocles particularly, has fallen by implication, since attempts to point out the sources have gone down into ignoble failure.
On the other hand, we may today accept the brilliant critical statement of Wilhelm Dilthey, that the Braut is “das Mittelglied zwischen dem antiken Drama und der neuen Form des musikalischen Drama, die Wagner in den Nibelungen schuf.” This idea has been expanded by Josef Nadler, who does not fail to exclaim against the obstinate misinterpretation to which this drama, together with the Jungfrau von Orleans, has consistently been subjected. Nadler sees in the Braut the culmination of a tendency noticeable in the operatic tones of the Jungfrau, a tendency toward the creation of tragedy out of the spirit of music.