Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-18T09:49:10.012Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Primordialism for Scholars Who Ought to Know Better: Anthony D. Smith’s Critique of Modernization Theory

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 March 2020

Alexander Maxwell Open the ORCID record for Alexander Maxwell [Opens in a new window]
Alexander Maxwell*
Affiliation:
Victoria University of Wellington, Wellington, New Zealand
*
*Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

A theory of nationalism should explain the evidence provided by the historical record, but also provide unexpected insight. The modernist theory of nationalism, espoused among others by Benedict Anderson and Eric Hobsbawm, provides a surprising chronology of nationalism’s modernity. The modernization theory of nationalism has attracted extensive criticism from Anthony Smith, who proposed instead a theory he called “ethnosymbolism.” This article considers Smith’s critique of Anderson and then his critique of Hobsbawm, finding that Smith’s objections to modernist theorists rest on mischaracterizations, fallacies, and contradictions. Smith’s approach caters to the primordialism rampant in public opinion, providing scholarly respectability to popular misconceptions. Scholars of nationalism should look instead to Rogers Brubaker for guidance.

Keywords

ethnosymbolismAnthony D. SmithBenedict AndersonEric Hobsbawm
Type
Article
Information
Nationalities Papers , Volume 48 , Issue 5 , September 2020 , pp. 826 - 842
Check for updates
Copyright
© Association for the Study of Nationalities 2020

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Aguilar, Filomeno. 2017. “Towards Community Formation in Southeast Asia? History Education, ASEAN and the Nation-State.” Journal of Social Issues in Southeast Asia 32 (1): 137–169.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Anderson, Benedict. 1991. Imagined Communities. Rev. ed. London: Verso.Google Scholar
Anderson, Benedict. 2001. “Western Nationalism and Eastern Nationalism: Is there a Difference that Matters?” New Left Review 9: 31–42.Google Scholar
Breuilly, John, et al. 2016. “Benedict Anderson’s Imagined Communities: A Symposium.” Nations and Nationalism 22 (4): 625–659.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brubaker, Rogers. 2000. “Beyond Identity.” Theory and Society 29: 1–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brubaker, Rogers. 2004. Ethnicity without Groups. Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Connor, Walker. 1994. Ethnonationalism: The Quest for Understanding. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Connor, Walker. 2006. “Mapping the Field: Nationalism and the Ethnosymbolic Approach.” In Nationalism and Ethnosymbolism: History, Culture and Ethnicity in the Formation of Nations, edited by Leoussi, Athena, 15–50. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.Google Scholar
Culic, Irina. 2005. “Re-Writing the History of Romania after the Fall of Communism.” History Compass 3 (1): 1–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Díaz-Andreu, Margarita. 1996. “Islamic Archeology and the Origin of the Spanish Nation.” In Nationalism and Archeology in Europe, edited by Margarita Díaz-Andreu and Timothy Champion, 68–89. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Fragner, Bert. 2001. “‘Soviet Nationalism:’ An Ideological Legacy to the Independent Republics of Central Asia.” In Identity Politics in Central Asia and the Muslim World, edited by Willem van Schendel, 13–34. London: I.B. Tauris.Google Scholar
Gellner, Ernst. 1983. Nations and Nationalism. Cornell, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Gellner, Ernst. 1997. Nationalism. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Gopčević, Spiridion. 1889. Makedonian und Alt-Serbien. Vienna: Seidel and Sohn.Google Scholar
Guibernau, Monteserrat. 2004. “Anthony D. Smith on Nations and National Identity: A Critical Assessment.” Nations and Nationalism 10 (1/2): 125–141.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, John. 2016. “An Intellectual Journey: Anthony D. Smith interviewed by John A. Hall.” Nations and Nationalism 22 (1): 6–19.Google Scholar
Han, Kirsten. 2013. One Singapore?: Nationalism and Identity in Singapore’s Mainstream and Alternative Media. Cardiff, UK: Cardiff University Press.Google Scholar
Hill, Michael, and Lian, Kwen Fee. 2013. The Politics of Nation-Building and Citizenship in Singapore. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hobswawm, Eric. 1992. Nations and Nationalism since 1780: Programme, Myth, Reality. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hobsbawm, Eric. 1983. “Introduction.” In The Invention of Tradition, edited by Hobsbawm, Eric and Ranger, Terrance, 1–14. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Horowitz, Donald. 1985. Ethnic Groups in Conflict. Berkeley: University of California.Google Scholar
Hoskin, John. 1993. The Supernatural in Thai Life. Bangkok: Tamarind.Google Scholar
Hutchinson, John. 2005. Nations as Zones of Conflict . London: Sage.Google Scholar
Hroch, Miroslav. 1985. Social Preconditions of National Revival in Europe. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Ichijo, Atsuko, and Uzelac, Gordana. 2005. When is the Nation? Towards an Understanding of Theories of Nationalism. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Kamusella, Tomasz. 2010. “School History Atlases as Instruments of Nation-State Making and Maintenance: A Remark on the Invisibility of Ideology in Popular Education.” Journal of Educational Media, Memory, and Society 2 (1): 113–138.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kedourie, Elie. 1960. Nationalism. London: Hutchinson.Google Scholar
Kutzer, Daphne. 2002. Empire’s Children: Empire and Imperialism in Classic British Children’s Books. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kuzio, Taras. 2007. Theoretical and Comparative Perspectives on Nationalism. Stuttgart: Ibidem.Google Scholar
Lau, Albert. 2015. “Nationalism” in the Decolonization of Singapore.” In The Transformation of Southeast Asia, edited by Frey, Marc and Pruessen, Ronald, 194–210. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Lawrence, Paul. 2005. Nationalism: History and Theory. New York: Pearson Education.Google Scholar
Magnusson, Magnus. 2003. Scotland: Story of a Nation. New York: Grove.Google Scholar
Muro, Diego. 2015. “Ethnicity, Nationalism, and Social Movements.” In The Oxford Handbook of Social Movements, edited by Porta, Donatella Della and Diani, Mario, 189–199. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Murray, Elisabeth Hope. 2015. Disrupting Pathways to Genocide: The Process of Ideological Radicalization. London: Palgrave.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nikonova, Olga. 2010. “Soviet patriotism in a Comparative Perspective: A Passion for Oxymora.” Studies in East European Thought 62 (3–4): 353–376.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nimni, Ephraim. 2010. “Nationalism, Ethnicity and Self-Determination: A Paradigm Shift.” In After the Nation?: Critical Reflections on Nationalism and Postnationalism, edited by Breen, Keith and O’Neill, Shane, 21–37. London: Palgrave.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oakeshott, Michael. 1962. “On Being Conservative.” In Rationalism in Politics, and other Essays, 168–196. London: Methuen.Google Scholar
Özkırımlı, Umut. 2003. “The Nation as an Artichoke? A Critique of Ethnosymbolist Interpretations of Nationalism.” Nations and Nationalism 9 (3): 339–355.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pop, Ioan Aurel. 1999. Romanians and Romania: A Brief History. Boulder, CO: East European Monographs.Google Scholar
Payaslian, Simon. 2008. The History of Armenia: From the Origins to the Present. London: Palgrave.Google Scholar
, Shnirelman. 2009. “Stigmatized by History or by Historians? The Peoples of Russia in School History Textbooks.” History and Memory 21 (2): 110–149.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 1983. Theories of Nationalism. London: Duckworth.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 1986. The Ethnic Origins of Nations. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 1991. National Identity. Reno: University of Nevada.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 1994. “Ethnic Nationalism and the Plight of Minorities,” Journal of Refugee Studies 7: 186–198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 1995. Nations and Nationalism in a Global Era. Cambridge, UK: Polity.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 1996. The Nation: Real or Imagined? The Warwick Debates on Nationalism. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 1998. Nationalism and Modernism: A Critical Survey of recent Theories of Nations and Nationalism . London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 2000. The Nation in History: Historiographical Debates about Ethnicity and Nationalism. Hanover, NH: Brandeis University Press.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 2001. Nationalism . Cambridge, UK: Polity.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 2002. “When is a Nation?” Geopolitics 7 (2): 5–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 2004. The Antiquity of Nations. Cambridge: Polity.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 2008. The Cultural Foundations of Nations: Hierarchy, Covenant, and Republic. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 2009. Ethno-Symbolism and Nationalism: A Cultural Approach. New York: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, Anthony. 2010. Nationalism: Theory, Ideology, History . London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Spencer, Philip and Wollman, Howard. 2002. Nationalism: A Critical Introduction . London: Sage.Google Scholar
Šulíková, Jana. 2016. “Unintended Revelations in History Textbooks: The Precarious Authenticity and Historical Continuity of the Slovak Nation.” Journal of Social Science Education 15 (3): 26–69.Google Scholar
Suny, Ronald Grigor. 2001. “Constructing Primordialism: Old Histories for New Nations.” Journal of Modern History 73 (4): 862–896.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sutherland, Claire. 2012. Nationalism in the Twenty-First Century: Challenges and Responses. London: Palgrave.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
, Thompson. 2014. Imperial Britain: The Empire in British Politics, c. 1880–1932. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Tilley, Virginia. 1997. “The Terms of the Debate: Untangling Language about Ethnicity and Ethnic Movements.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 20 (3): 497–523.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tromly, Benjamin. 2009. “Soviet Patriotism and its Discontents among Higher Education Students in Khrushchev-Era Russia and Ukraine.” Nationalities Papers 37 (3): 299–326.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Uberoi, Varun. 2007. “Social Unity in Britain.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 33 (1): 141–157.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vickers, Edward. 2009. “Education, Identity and Politics in Asia.” In: Education as a Political Tool in Asia, edited by Lall, Marie and Vickers, Edward, 10–32. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Wellings, Ben. 2002. “Empire-nation: National and Imperial Discourses in England.” Nations and Nationalism 8 (1): 95–109.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Young, Crawford. 1993. “The Dialectics of Cultural Pluralism.” In The Rising Tide of Cultural Pluralism: The Nation-State at Bay?, edited by Young, Crawford, 3–35. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar