Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-18T14:09:50.788Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

On the Antiquity of Vedic Culture

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 March 2011

Abstract

Image of the first page of this content. For PDF version, please use the ‘Save PDF’ preceeding this image.'
Type
Miscellaneous Communications
Copyright
Copyright © The Royal Asiatic Society 1909

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

page 1100 note 2 JRAS., 1909, pp. 721–6.Google Scholar

page 1101 note 1 Cf. IA., xxiv, 100.Google Scholar

page 1101 note 2 Whitney, , PAOS., March, 1894;Google ScholarOldenberg, , ZDMG., xlviii–l;Google ScholarThibaut, , IA., xxiv, 85 seq.Google Scholar

page 1101 note 3 See SBE., xv, 289:Google ScholarWeber, , Indischz Sludien, ii, 396;Google ScholarBühler, , IA., xxiii, 245, n. 21Google Scholar; Jacobi, , ZDMG., xlix, 228, n. 2.Google Scholar

page 1101 note 4 Jacobi, , IA., xxiii, 157.Google Scholar

page 1102 note 1 See Thibaut's convincing refutation of Hindu accuracy, IA., xxiv, 99.Google Scholar

page 1102 note 2 Jacobi, , IA., xxiii, 157.Google Scholar His observations on this point at ZDMG., xlix, 228, do not seem convincing.Google Scholar

page 1102 note 3 IA., xxiv, 91.Google Scholar

page 1102 note 4 ZDMG., xlix, 475 seq.Google Scholar

page 1102 note 5 xix, 2, 3.

page 1103 note 1 It may be noted here that the date given by the Vedānga is absolutely uncertain owing to the vagueness of the evidence; see Thibaut, , IA., xxiv, 98.Google Scholar

page 1103 note 2 x, 85, 13. Büler even doubted this; see IA., xxiii, 244.Google Scholar Cf. Thibaut, , IA., xxiv, 95Google Scholar; Müller, Max, Ṛgveda, iv, p. lxvii.Google Scholar

page 1103 note 3 IA., xxiv, 96.Google Scholar Cf. Oldenberg, , ZDMG., xlix, 473.Google Scholar

page 1103 note 4 IA., xxiii, 246 seq.Google Scholar

page 1103 note 5 JRAS., 1909, p. 721, n. 1.Google Scholar

page 1104 note 1 ZDMG., xlix, 478–80.Google Scholar

page 1104 note 1 On this cf. Eggeling, , SBE., xii, p. xl.Google Scholar

page 1104 note 3 The argument would be much better if ilāni had appeared once before Mitra-Varuna as a compound. It should be noted that the words for these gods are followed by words of unknown meaning and language. The variant Uru-w-na tells against Aruna as the name of the god referred to, and a Vedic Aruna is not proved.

page 1105 note 1 ZDMG., xlix, 178.Google Scholar

page 1105 note 2 These can easily be exaggerated. The later Vedic life is really no more than a fulfilment of the earlier, as all recent research more and more strongly shows.

page 1106 note 1 It is hardly necessary to discuss the significance of the Sun-god Šuriaš, of the Kašši, referred to by Professor Jacobi (JRAS., 1909, p. 726, n. 1). No stress can be laid on so isolated a name.Google Scholar