Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-q99xh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T20:18:31.822Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Londoners and London Mendicants in the Late Middle Ages

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 May 2015

Jens Röhrkasten
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Much attention has been paid to the role and functions of the mendicant orders in their urban environment. Among the topics discussed have been the friars' importance for urban development, their coexistence with other religious institutions, their economic practices and their relations with the secular authorities. As far as their spiritual and social significance is concerned their spectacular success and rapid development in the thirteenth century are generally accepted. There were some setbacks, particularly in towns where the Dominicans or Franciscans became involved in the suppression of heresy, but these had little impact on the rapid expansion of the orders. Members from all social groups, academics as well as aristocrats, merchants and artisans as well as the poor, felt the attraction of their sermons and way of life, some to such an extent that they decided to join one of the orders. But while the attraction of the mendicant ideal in the decades following the friars' arrival is undisputed, the problem of their importance for the religious life of the late medieval urban population is far more difficult to discuss. While there are assertions that the friars remained particularly popular, the orders' decline and their need of reform were already obvious in the fourteenth century and the various efforts to bring about a reinvigoration confirm this impression. In the fifteenth century famous mendicant preachers from Vincent Ferrer and Bernardino of Siena to Girolamo Savonarola attracted large crowds in many parts of Europe, but was this indicative of the population's general attitude towards the orders? Were the mendicants still perceived by the people as responding to their spiritual needs? How did the public react to signs of decadence, to disputes among the brothers? A general answer to such questions needs to be based on a large number of local studies and this is still a task for the future.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 47 , Issue 3 , July 1996 , pp. 446 - 477
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1996

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 ‘Les Ordres mendiants et la ville en Italie centrale (v. 1220–v. 1350)’, Mélanges de l'École française de Rome lxxxix/2 (1977)Google Scholar; Papi, A. Benvenuti, ‘Ordini mendicanti e città: appunti per un indagine, il caso di Firenze’, in Maselli, D. (ed), Da Dante a Cosimo I, Pistoia 1976, 122–45Google Scholar; Degler-Spengler, B., Das Klarissenkloster Gnadental in Basel (1289–1529), Basle 1969 Google Scholar; Dobson, B., ‘Mendicant ideal and practice in late medieval York’, in Addyman, P. V. and Black, V. E. (eds) Archaeological papers from York presented to M. W. Barley, York 1984, 109–22Google Scholar; Fügedi, E., ‘La formation des villes et les ordres mendiants en Hongrie’, Annales ESC xxv (1970), 966–87Google Scholar; Guidoni, E., ‘Città e ordini mendicanti: il ruolo dei conventi nella crescità e nella progettazione urbana del XIII e XIV secolo’, Quaderni medievali iv (1977), 69–106 Google Scholar; Isenmann, E., Die deutsche Stadt im Spätmittelalter, Stuttgart 1988, 219–22Google Scholar; Goff, J. Le, ‘Ordres mendiants et urbanisation dans la France médiévale’, Annales ESC xxv (1970), 924–46Google Scholar; Little, A. G. and Easterling, R. C., The Franciscans and Dominicans of Exeter, Exeter 1927 Google Scholar; Martin, H., Les Ordres mendiants en Bretagne (1230–1530), Rennes 1975 Google Scholar; Moorman, J. R. H., The Grey Friars in Cambridge 1225–1538, Cambridge 1952 Google Scholar; Neidiger, B., Mendikanten zwischen Ordensideal und städtischer Realität. Untersuchungen zum wirtschaftlichen Verhalten der Bettelorden in Basel, Berlin 1981 Google Scholar; Schmitt, J.-C., ‘Où est l'enquête “ordres mendiants et urbanisation dans la France médiévale”?’, in Elm, K. (ed.) Stellung und Wirksamkeit der Bettelorden in der städtischen Gesellschaft, Berlin 1981, 13–18 Google Scholar; Simons, W., Stad en apostolaat: de vestiging van de bedelorden in het graafschap Vlaanderen (ca. 1225–1350), Brussels 1987 Google Scholar; Stüdeli, B. E. J., Minoritenniederlassungen und mittelalterliche Stadt, Werl 1969 Google Scholar.

2 Rosenthal, J. T., The purchase of paradise: gift and giving and the aristocracy, 1307–1485, London 1972, 101 Google Scholar.

3 Royal alms were still paid to them in May 1304: PRO, E 101/369/11, fos 7r–v, 33r; Dominicans, Franciscans, Carmelites, Austin Friars, Friars of the Cross, Minoresses: Reddan, M., ‘Religious houses’, in Page, W. (ed.), The Victoria History of London, London 1909, i. 171–206 Google Scholar; Kingsford, C. L., The Grey Friars of London, London 1915 Google Scholar, and ‘Additional material for the history of the Grey Friars, London’, in Kingsford, C. L. (ed.), Collectanea Franciscana II, Manchester 1922, 61–149 Google Scholar; Foran, E., ‘Historical notes on Austin Friars, London’, Irish Ecclesiastical Record 5th ser. viii (1916), 35–46 Google Scholar; ix (1917), 130–53; Anstruther, G., ‘The last days of the London Blackfriars’, Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum xlv (1975), 213–36Google Scholar; Hinnebusch, W. A., The Early English Friars Preachers, Rome 1951, 20–40 Google Scholar; Martin, W. and Toy, S., ‘The Black Friars of London: a chapter in national history’, Transactions of the London and Middlesex Archaeological Society ns v (1929), 353–79Google Scholar; Palmer, C. F. R., ‘The friar-preachers of Holborn, London’, Reliquary xvii (1876/1877), 33–8, 75–80Google Scholar; Roth, F., The English Austin Friars 1240–1538, New York 1966, i. 286–96Google Scholar; Fly, H., ‘Some account of an abbey of nuns formerly situated in the street now called the Minories’, Archaeologia xv (1806), 92–113 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Fratris Thomae vulgo dicti de Eccleston tractatus de adventu Fratrum Minorum in Angliam, ed. Little, A. G., Manchester 1951, 21–2Google Scholar.

5 Three groups of wills were used in this study. Those enrolled in the Husting between 1373 and 1483 and those proved in the Archdeaconry and Commissary Courts in the same period: GL, MSS 9051/1, 9171/1–6.

6 Chiffoleau, J., La comptabililé de l'au-delà: les hommes, la mort et la religion dans la région d'Avignon à la fin du moyen âge (c. 1320–c. 1480), Rome 1980 Google Scholar, and ‘Pratiques funéraires et images de la mort à Marseille, en Avignon et dans le comtat Venaissin (vers 1280–vers 1350)’, in La religion populaire en Languedoc du XIIIe siècle à la moitié du XIVe siècle (Cahiers de Fanjeaux xi, 1976), 271–303 at pp. 272–4Google Scholar; McFarlane, K. B., Lancastrian kings and Lollard knights, Oxford 1972, 206ffGoogle Scholar; Rapp, F., ‘La pietà del popolo cristiano’, in Manselli, R. (ed.), La religiosità popolare nel medio evo, Bologna 1983, 279–96Google Scholar; Murphy, M., ‘The high cost of dying; an analysis of pro anima bequests in medieval Dublin’, in Sheils, W. and Wood, D. (eds), The Church and wealth (Studies in Church History xxv, 1987), 111–22Google Scholar; Courtemanche, D., ‘Les testaments parisiens sous Charles vi: des écrits sur soi au service de la mémoire collective’, Moyen Age xcvii (1991), 367–87Google Scholar; McHardy, A., ‘Some late medieval Eton College wills’, this JOURNAL xxviii (1978), 387–95Google Scholar; Carpenter, C., ‘The religion of the gentry of fifteenth-century England’, in Williams, D. (ed.), England in the Fifteenth Century, Bury St Edmunds 1987, 53–74 at p. 53Google Scholar; Fleming, P. W., ‘Faith and the gentry of Kent 1422–1529’, in Pollard, T. (ed.), Property and politics: essays in later medieval English history, Gloucester 1984, 36–58 at p. 37Google Scholar; Vale, M. G. A., Piety, charity and literacy among the Yorkshire gentry, 1370–1480 (Borthwick Papers 1, 1976)Google Scholar; Heath, P., ‘Urban piety in the later middle ages: the evidence of Hull wills’, in Dobson, B. (ed.) The Church, politics and patronage in the fifteenth century, Gloucester 1984, 209–34Google Scholar; Dinn, R., ‘Baptism, spiritual kinship, and popular religion in late medieval Bury St Edmunds’, Bulletin of the John Rylands Library lxxii (1990), 93–106 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lorcin, M.-T., ‘Les clauses religieuses dans les testaments du plat pays lyonnais aux XIVe et XVe siècles’, Moyen Age lxxviii (1972), 287–323 Google Scholar; Epstein, S., Wills and wealth in medieval Genoa 1150–1250, Cambridge, Mass. 1984, 136ffGoogle Scholar; Cullum, P. H. and Goldberg, P., ‘Charitable provision in late medieval York: “To the praise of God and the use of the poor”’, Northern History xxix (1993), 24–39 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Calendar of wills proved and enrolled in the court of Husting (1258–1688), ed. Sharpe, R. R., London 1889, i. 603 Google Scholar.

8 For example, John Bakere, GL, MS 9171/1, fos 190v–iv.

9 For example, Elena, wife of Adam le Barbour, Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 8r.

10 Thomas Sutton, ibid. MS 9171/2, fos 390v–iv; Joan, widow of John Calworth, MS 9171/3, fos 161v–2r.

11 Henry Wodewey, ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 352r; Richard Elgaston, MS 9171/3, fos 271v–2v.

12 For example John Makeby, ibid MS 9171/3, fo. 450r.

13 John Carter, ibid. MS 9171/5, fos 260r–iv.

14 Burgess, C., ‘“By quick and by dead”: wills and pious provision in late medieval Bristol’, English Historical Review cii (1987), 837–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 GL, MS 9171/2, fos 33v–4v.

16 Since there is no systematic study of London wills no attention could be paid to possible double entries (the same will in different registers) or those cases in which individuals made more than one will.

17 The dates were chosen because the first wills from the oldest surviving Commissary Court Register (Courtney) survive from 1373 and because the impact of the Observant Friars made itself felt in and around London from the mid-1480s. Thus the last wills of Commissary Court Register Wilde which date from 1483 form a convenient limit.

18 Since the registers are structured chronologically by date of probate, while for the present purpose the year in which the will was drawn up is of interest, it seems best to look at the different registers as a whole instead of trying to present a year-by-year account, which would hardly be possible, since not all entries have proper dates.

19 GL, MS 9171/1.

20 Ibid. MS 9051/1.

21 Ibid. MS 9171/2.

22 Ibid. MS 9171/3.

23 Ibid. MS 9171/4.

24 Ibid. MS 9171/5.

25 Ibid. MS 9171/6.

26 Attention is drawn to the difference between the figures from this group of wills and those proved in the Prerogative Court of Canterbury for the years 1401–49, 1479–86, 1523–5 and 1529/30. Here more than a third of the wills sampled contained bequests to friars: Thomson, J. A. F., ‘Piety and charity in late medieval London’, this JOURNAL XV (1964), 178–95 at p. 189Google Scholar.

27 Isenmann, , Die deutsche Stadt im Spälmittelalter, 210–16Google Scholar.

28 Hinnebusch, , The early English Friars Preachers, 29 Google Scholar; Annals, of Burton, , Annales Monastici, ed. Luard, H. R. (Rolls Series, 1864–1869), i. 346–47Google Scholar; CPR 1247–58, 457.

29 Documents of the baronial movement of reform and rebellion 1258–1267, ed. Treharne, R. F. and Sanders, I. S., Oxford 1973, 101 Google Scholar; Treharne, R. F., The baronial plan of reform, 1258–1263, Manchester 1932, 223, 306Google Scholar.

30 At the time the Privy Council appears to have been in session there, so the attack may have been mainly directed against the counsellors but it can hardly have been without repercussions for the friars: McKisack, M., The fourteenth century, 1307–1399, Oxford 1959, 83–4Google Scholar; CPMR i. 46; The Anonimalle Chronicle 1307 to 1334, ed. Childs, W. R. and Taylor, J. (Yorkshire Archaeological Society, Record Series, cxlvii, 1991), 126–8Google Scholar.

31 Rotuli hundredorum, ed. Illingworth, W., London 1812, i. 404, 429Google Scholar.

32 PRO, SC 5 London/Tower/1 m 2, m 2d, m 3, m 18, m 21.

33 Calendar of Letter-Books of the City of London, Letter-Book E (1314–1337), ed. Sharpe, R. R., London 1903, 63, 66Google Scholar; London Assize of Nuisance 1301–1431, ed. Chew, H. M. and Kellaway, W. (London Record Society x, 1973), no. 85Google Scholar.

34 Ibid. nos 45, 80, 102.

35 Ibid. nos 211, 296.

36 Ibid. no. 111.

37 Ibid. nos 113, 133.

38 Ibid. no. 188.

39 Ibid. no. 293.

40 Ibid. no. 630.

41 CPMR 1413–37, 156.

42 PRO, C 81/532/7957.

43 CPMR 1381–1412, 239; London Assize of Nuisance, no. 569.

44 Ibid. no. 618.

45 CCR 1405–1409, 149.

46 CCR 1369–74, 242–4.

47 CPMR 1381–1412, 182.

48 4 Henry IV c. 17, Statutes of the Realm, ed. Luders, A. and others, London 1810–1828, ii. 38 Google Scholar.

49 A good example is Sir Richard Gobiun, who, when he discovered that his son had joined the Franciscans in Northampton, threatened to withdraw his support: Fratris Thomae tractalus, 23; cf. Moorman, , Grey Friars in Cambridge, 106 Google Scholar.

50 Austin Friars 1380, £20: CPR 1377–81, 429; Dominicans 1387, 20 marks: PRO, C 88/59 no. 54; CPR 1385–89, 295; Carmelites 1391: CPMR 1381–1412, 179; Franciscans 1437, £5. CPR 1436–41, 13; St Clare 1454, £5: CPR 1452–61, 196.

51 Röhrkasten, J., Die englischen Kronzeugen 1130–1330, Berlin 1990, 348–9Google Scholar.

52 PRO, C 81/1793/12.

53 CPR 1247–58, 405.

54 BL, MS Cotton Nero C VIII, fo. 201r, 205r.

55 Memorials of London and London life 1276–1419, ed. Riley, H. T., London 1868, 303–4Google Scholar; PRO, C 81/1794/13.

56 John Sharp: PRO, C 81/1794/14, C 81/1794/15; Thomas Man: C 81/1794/16; Richard Stapelford: C 81/1794/17.

57 CCR 1429–35, 150.

58 PRO, C 81/1792 m 18; CPR 1385–89, 169; PRO, C 81/1792 m 19; CPR 1385–89, 522.

59 PRO, C 81/1792 m 21.

60 CCR 1409–13, 16, 42.

61 PRO, C 81/1794/10; CPR 1385–89, 324, 386. For the involvement of Austin Friars in political intrigues in these years see Gwynn, A., The English Austin Friars in the time of Wyclif, Oxford 1940, 125 Google Scholar.

62 PRO, C 81/1794/8, 9, 11.

63 CCR 1396–99, 13; CPR 1396–99, 52; CPR 1399–1401, 311.

64 CPR 1391–96, 357.

65 Thomson, W. R., ‘The image of the mendicants in the chronicles of Matthew Paris’, Archivum Franciscanum Historicum lxx (1977), 3–34 at pp. 16–17Google Scholar.

66 Dufeil, M.-M., Guillaume de Saint-Amour et la polémique universitaire parisienne 1250–1259, Paris 1972, 83 Google Scholar; Williams, A., ‘Chaucer and the friars’, Speculum xxviii (1953), 499–513 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and ‘The “limitour” of Chaucer's time and his “limitacioun”’, Studies in Philology lvii (1960), 463–78Google Scholar.

67 Cambridge University Library, MS Gg iv. 32, fo. 133r; Moorman, , Grey Friars in Cambridge, 86–7Google Scholar.

68 Walsh, K., A fourteenth-century scholar and primate: Richard Fitzralph in Oxford, Avignon and Armagh, Oxford 1981, 409–21Google Scholar; Delaruelle, E., Labande, E. and Ourliac, P., L'église au temps du Grand Schisme et de la crise conciliaire (1378–1448), 1964, 947–51Google Scholar.

69 A good example is Richard Whittington: Kingsford, , Grey Friars of London, 170 Google Scholar; Barron, C., ‘Richard Whittington: the man behind the myth’, in Hollaender, A. E. J. and Kellaway, W. (eds), Studies in London history presented to Philip Edmund Jones, London 1969, 197–248 at p. 232Google Scholar.

70 Thomson, , ‘Piety and charity in late medieval London’, 189 Google Scholar; Barron, C., ‘The parish fraternities of medieval London’, in Barron, C. and Harper-Bill, C. (eds), The Church inpre-reformation society: essays in honour of F. R. H. Du Boulay, Woodbridge 1985, 13–37 Google Scholar; Brigden, S., ‘Religion and social obligation in early sixteenth-century London’, Past and Present ciii (1984), 67–112 at pp. 94–7, 99CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and London and the Reformation, Oxford 1989, 36–9Google Scholar; Coote, H. C., ‘The ordinances of some secular guilds of London, 1354 to 1496’, Transactions of the London and Middlesex Archaeological Society iv (1871), 1–58 Google Scholar.

71 Jacob, E. F., The fifteenth century 1399–1485, Oxford 1961, 27–9Google Scholar; Moorman, , Grey Friars in Cambridge, 116–17Google Scholar; Storey, R. L., ‘Clergy and common law in the reign of Henry iv’, in Hunnisett, R. F. and Post, J. B. (eds), Medieval legal records edited in memory of C. A. F. Meekings, London 1978, 341–408 at pp. 343, 353–61Google Scholar.

72 Chronicles of London, ed. Kingsford, C. L., Oxford 1905, 63 Google Scholar; cf. Chronicon Adae de Usk, ed. Thompson, E. M., 2nd edn, London 1904, 84 Google Scholar, where the number is given as eleven.

73 Moorman, , Grey Friars in Cambridge, 116 Google Scholar; Historia vitae et regni Ricardi Secundi, ed. Stow, G., Philadelphia 1977, 173 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Thomae Walsingham Historia Anglicana, ed. Riley, H. T. (Rolls Series, 1864), ii. 249 Google Scholar; Eulogium Historiarum, ed. Haydon, F. S. (Rolls Series, 1858), iii. 389ff.Google Scholar; Chronicon Adae de Usk, 84.

74 John Viannde and John del Pantre: GL, MS 9171/2, fos gr–v, 16v.

75 Boulay, F. R. H. Du, ‘The quarrel between the Carmelite Friars and the secular clergy of London’, this JOURNAL vi (1955), 156–74Google Scholar.

76 Beatrix Fish (1379): GL, MS 9171/1, fo. 66r; Thomas Leche (1409): MS 9171/2, fo. 156r; Richard Godard (1421): MS 9171/3, fo. 85r, Thomas Osbern (1458): MS 9171/5, fo. 264r.

77 William Whelere (1387): ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 170r–v; Hugh Gardyner (1418): MS 9171/3, fos iv–2r; Thomas Aylward (1476): MS 9171/6, fos 207v–8v.

78 Galfridus Numan (1388): ibid. MS 9171/1, fo 172v.

79 John Bysshop (1392): ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 254r–v.

80 Richard North (1389): ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 187v–8r; Juliana Passur (1394): MS 9171/1, fo. 326V.

81 Nicholas Gorge (1395): ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 337v.

82 Thomas Sheyl (1402); ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 53v.

83 William Pappe (1408): ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 136v.

84 Richard Hatton (1409): ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 154v; John Pymberd (1417): MS 9171/2, fo. 383v.

85 Ralph in the Hale: ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 208r; Richard Bradfeld (1443): MS 9171/4, fo. 111v; William Siger (1444): MS 9171/4, fo. 132r–v.

86 Walter Sanney (1412): ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 223r; John Schepard (1478): MS 9171/6, fos 225v–6r.

87 Reginald Dyer (1413): ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 258r (inserted leaf); Thomas Congreve 9171/5. fos 391v–2r.

88 Richard Aston (1418): ibid. MS 9171/3, fo. 17r–v; Christiana Forde (1439): MS 9171/4, fo. 37r; Richard Brok (1442): MS 9171/4, fo. 99r; Idonia, widow of John von Wesull (1459): MS 9171/5, fo. 274r.

89 Richard Godard: ibid. MS 9171/3, fo. 85r.

90 Henry Denby: ibid. MS 9171/5, fo. 329r.

91 Thomas Combes: ibid. MS 9171/6, fo. 10r.

92 Ibid. MS 9171/6, fos 30V, 123r–v, 261v.

93 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fo. 389v.

94 John Laylond: ibid. MS 9171/6, fos 340r–1r.

95 John Wodeham: ibid. MS 9171/2, fos 78v–9r.

96 John Quyk: ibid. MS 9171/6, fos 41r–2r.

97 The cartulary of the Augustinian Friars of Clare, ed. Harper-Bill, C. (Suffolk Records Society xi, 1991), no. 137Google Scholar.

98 For example, John Bysshop: GL, MS 9171/1 fo. 254r–v.

99 Ibid. MS 9171/2 fos 136v (William Pappe), 208r (Ralph in the Hale), 223r (Walter Sanney); MS 9171/5, fo. 329r (Henry Denby); MS 9171/6, fos 41r–2r (John Quyk), 340r–41r (John Laylond).

100 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 187v–8r (Richard North); MS 9171/3, fo. 85r (Nicholas Cherman); MS 9171/4, fos 111v, 132r–v (Richard Bradfeld, William Siger); MS 9171/6, fo. 26iv (Robert Wylkynson).

101 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 337v (Nicholas Gorge); Ms 9171/3, fo. 85r (Nicholas Cherman).

102 Ibid. MS 9171 /2, fo. 53v (Thomas Sheyl).

103 Four to the Franciscans, four to the Dominicans, two to the Carmelites and one to the Friars of the Cross.

104 Jenks, S., ‘Hansische Vermächtnisse in London’, Hansische Geschichtsblätter civ (1986), 35–111 at p. 51Google Scholar. For the Italians in London: Thrupp, S. L., ‘Aliens in and around London in the fifteenth century’, in Hollaender, and Kellaway, , Studies in London history, 251–72 at p. 164–5Google Scholar; Barron, C., ‘The later middle ages: 1270–1520’, in Lobel, M. D. (ed.), The City of London from prehistoric times to c. 1520 (The British Atlas of Historic Towns iii, 1989), 42–56 at p. 54Google Scholar; Bradley, H. L., ‘Italian merchants in London c. 1350–1450’, unpubl. PhD diss. London 1992, 16, 51, 296Google Scholar.

105 Roth, , English Austin Friars, i. 291/2Google Scholar.

106 Simons, , Stad en apostolaat, 228 Google Scholar; Martin, , Les ordres mendiants en Bretagne, 394, 397Google Scholar.

107 Only 3 among 63. These were Margareta van de Good: GL, MS 9051–1, fo. 282r; Katerine van Aken: MS 9051/1, fo. 296r–v; Margarete Deloe: MS 9171/1, fo. 459r.

108 Chiffoleau, Comptabilité de l'au-delà, 50: one-third of the total of wills left by women, two-thirds by men; Baur, P., Testament und Bürgerschaft. Alltagsleben und Sachkultur im spätmittelalterlichen Konstanz, Sigmaringen 1989, 57 Google Scholar: wills by men 67%–88.5%, wills by women 17.8–33%.

109 Grundmann, H., Religiöse Bewegungen im Mittelalter, Darmstadt 1977, 170ff.Google Scholar; McDonnell, E. W., The Beguines and Beghards in medieval culture with special emphasis on the Belgian scene, New Brunswick, NJ, 1954 Google Scholar; Schmitt, J.-C., ‘Apostolat mendiantet société: une confrérie dominicaine à la veille de la réforme’, Annales ESC xxvi (1971), 83–104 at p. 100Google Scholar; Kuhn-Rehfuss, M., ‘Zisterzienserinnen in Deutschland’, in Elm, K., Joerissen, P. and Roth, H. J. (eds), Die zisterzienser, Bonn 1980, 125–47Google Scholar; Degler-Spengler, B., ‘Zisterzienserorden und Frauenklöster. Anmerkungen zur Forschungsproblematik’, in Elm, K. and Joerissen, P. (eds), Die zisterzienser. Ergänzungsband, Cologne 1982, 213–20Google Scholar.

110 Trüdinger, K., Stadt und Kirche im spätmittelalterlichen Würzburg, Stuttgart 1978, 44 Google Scholar; Degler-Spengler, , Das Klarissenkloster Gnadenthal in Basel, 89 Google Scholar. For relations between friars and Beguines in Trier see Schmidt, H.-J., Bettelorden in Trier, Trier 1986, 84ff.Google Scholar

111 Henry de Causton stated in his will (1348) that ‘lego mulieribus vocatis sororibus in civitate London pro se caste viventibus’: Corporation of London Record Office, Husting Roll 78 no. 210. An anchoress moved into the precinct of the London Blackfriars still in the sixteenth century: Clay, R. M., The hermits and anchorites of England, London 1914, 96 Google Scholar; Warren, A. K., Anchorites and their patrons in medieval England, Berkeley, CA. 1985, 288–9Google Scholar.

112 There are many examples of wills by women but no statistics on this point in Baur, , Testament und Bürgerschaft, 131ff.Google Scholar; Chiffoleau, , Comptabilité de l'au-delà, 259ff.Google Scholar; Grübel, J., Bettelorden und Frauenfrömmigkeit im 13. Jahrhundert, Munich 1987, 34, 48Google Scholar.

113 Epstein, , Wills and wealth, 192 Google Scholar; Neidiger, , Mendikanten zwischen Ordensideal und städtischer Realität, 170–1Google Scholar; Wehrli-Johns, M., Geschichte des zürcher Predigerkonvents (1230–1524): Mendikanten zwischen Kirche, Adel und Stadt, Zurich 1980, 73 Google Scholar; Michaud, F., ‘Liaisons particulières? Franciscains et testatrices à Marseille (1248–1320)’, Annales du Midi civ (1992), 7–18 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

114 Paxton, C., ‘The nunneries of London and its environs in the later Middle Ages’, unpubl. PhD. diss. Oxford 1993, 95–110 Google Scholar.

115 GL, MS 9171/5, fos 146v–8r (Thomas Hawkyn).

116 Ibid. MS 9171/6, fos 205v–6r (William Power).

117 Ibid. MS 9171/6, fo. 282V (Henry Buchlyn).

118 Ibid. MS 9171/3, fo. 88v (Robert Cowper).

119 Ibid. MS 9171/3, fo. 215r (John Halman).

120 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fo. 140r–v (William Barefeld).

121 Attention is again drawn to the different result obtained by Thomson, , ‘Piety and charity’, 189–90Google Scholar. Bequests to the friars were made by a far greater proportion of testators whose wills were enrolled in the Prerogative Court of Canterbury. Also of great interest is the result of Wood, R. A., ‘Poor widows, c. 1292–1415’, in Barron, C. M. and Sutton, A. F. (eds), Medieval London widows 1300–1500, London 1994, 55–70 Google Scholar, who analysed the wills of 49 poor widows from the Archdeaconry Register. Only four of them made bequests to the friars. In contrast, more than 20% of testators who had their wills enrolled in the Husting Rolls made a reference to the friars.

122 Gougaud, L., Devotional and ascetic practices in the middle ages, London 1927, 135–6Google Scholar; ‘Si dives in patria quisquis infirmetur,/Illuc frater properans et currens monetur;/Et statim cum venerit infirmo loquetur,/Ut cadaver mortuum fratribus donetur …/Quod si pauper adiens fratres infirmetur,/Et petat ut inter hos sepulturae detur,/Gardianus absens est, statim respondetur,/Et sic satis breviter pauper excludetur’: Political poems and songs relating to English history, ed. Wright, T. (Rolls Series, 1859), i. 257 Google Scholar; Owst, G. R., Preaching in medieval England: an introduction to sermon manuscripts of the period c. 1350–1450, Cambridge 1926, 88–90 Google Scholar. It should also be noted that among the wills enrolled in the Husting the proportion of those with references to friars is higher, cf. Table 1.

123 GL, MS 9171/1, fo. 117r,v.

124 Ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 142r.

125 Ibid. MS 9171/3, fo. 151v.

126 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 32r.

127 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 125r–6r.

128 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 340r–v.

129 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 150r–v (John Eystone).

130 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo. 88r: ‘ubi executores mei ordinare voluerint sit in ecclesia aut in cimiterio’.

131 A part of BL, MS Harley 544, fos 50r–74v – a copy made by John Stow – is the burial register of the Franciscan house.

132 GL, MS 9051/1, fo. 147v.

133 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fos 195v–6r (Richard Scot), 296r–v (Katerine van Aken).

134 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo. 38r–v (Jacobus Francisse Monaldi); MS 9171/5, fo. 292r (Thomas Machon).

135 John Mapylton: ibid MS 9051/1, fo. 179r–v: ‘videlicet ante ymaginem S. Cristofori depictatam super murum dicte ecclesie’ – the church of the Carmelites; MS 9051/1, fo. 244r: ‘coram ymagine beate Marie in parte australi dicte ecclesie’ – the church of the Franciscans (David Bardevyle); cf. also MS 9171/3, fos 102v (William Croft), (Albertus Alfkyn), 396v (Gamelin Gawyn), 465v (John Walton).

136 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo. 158v (William Asshe).

137 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo. 298r (Mariona Williamesdoughter).

138 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 53r (Elizabeth Dyere); MS 9171/2, fo. 289r (William Burstede).

139 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fo. 3r (Raphael Ponsola).

140 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fos 110r–v (Joan Neumarche); 166v (John Malberthorp).

141 Ibid. MS 9171/6, fo. 50v–1r (William Bowes).

142 Ibid. MS 9171/6, fo. 206r.

143 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo. 152v.

144 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo. 227r.

145 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fo. 331r.

146 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fo. 234r. For a closer analysis of the will see Sutton, A. F., ‘Alice Claver, silkwoman (d. 1489)’, in Barron, and Sutton, , Medieval London widows, 129–42 at pp. 130–1Google Scholar.

147 Nicholas de Hingstworth, pewterer, provides a good example: he wished to be buried in Ludgate, St Martin ‘ubi solebam sedere dum in ipsa ecclesia divina officia consuevi audire’: Corporation of London Record Office, Husting Rolls 93 no. 15Google Scholar.

148 GL, MS 9051/1, fo. 301v.

149 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo. 66r–v (John Hay), 212r (Richard Shrympling); MS 9171/2, fos 141r (William Muller), 367v (John Hall).

150 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo. 213r (John Clerk); MS 9171/6, fo. 79v (John White).

151 Ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 162r (John Wheston).

152 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fos 158v (William Asshe), 268r (Alicia de Northfolkke), 269r (William Ekynton); MS 9171/1, fos 211r–v (William Maynard), 360v (John Punchon); MS 9171/2, fos 107r (Simon Frenssh), 148r (John Paley), 279v (Joan Alfold); MS 9171/4, fo. 135v (Agnes Wynsley); MS 9171/5 fo. 233v (John Water); MS 9171/6, fos 206r (Thomas Dagworthe), 21 or (Joan Logeman).

153 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo 152v (Richard Barton); MS 9171/3, fo. 152v (John Basset); MS 9171/4, fos 115r–v (Henry Asshebourne), 200v (William Michell); MS 9171/5, fos 302r (Richard Walter), 339v–40r (Baldewin Payne), 351r (Thomas Thomas), 404r (Robert Wyllmote); MS 9171/6, fos 75r (John Englesse), 161r (Richard Waryn).

154 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 379r (William Kyngman); MS 9171/2, fo. 9r–v (John Viannde).

155 Ibid. MS 9171/3, fo. 281r (John Yong); MS 9171/5. fo. 349r–v (John Grene).

156 Ibid. MS 9171/4, fo. 220r (William Hoton).

157 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 43r (Edith Shark); MS 9171/2, fo. 227r–v (John Marty); MS 9171/5, fo. 230r–1r (William Benyngton); MS 9171–6, fo. 269r–v (William Benet).

158 Ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 166r–v (William Frost); MS 9171/4, fo. 255r (John Exton).

159 Ibid. MS 9171/3, fo. 396v (John Mone); MS 9171/5, fo. 6v (Andreas de Furnariis); MS 9171/6, fo. 143r (Jacobus de Ferrara).

160 Ibid. MS 9171/3, fos 491r–v (John Copsheth), 500r–v (Robert Donnesbury); MS 9171/5, fo. 220r (Katherin Gargade); MS 9051/1, fo. 301v (William Launde).

161 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 370v (Laurentius de Gerard); MS 9171/2, fos 242v (Joan Perseholt), 289r (William Burstede); MS 9171/6, fo. 50r,v (William Narburgh).

162 Harding, V., ‘“And one more may be laid there': the location of burials in early modern London’, London Journal xiv (1989), 112–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and ‘Burial choice and burial location in later medieval London’, in Basset, S. (ed.) Death in towns: urban responses to the dying and the dead, 100–1600, Leicester 1992, 119–35Google Scholar.

163 In the case of Nicholas Twyford also the presence of a friar at the death bed: GL, MS 9171/1, fos 223r–5r.

164 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 158r–v (Roger Lunt).

165 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 117r–v (Robert Denton).

166 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fos 22v–3r (Thomas Chapman); MS 9171/6, fos 136v–v (Thomas Wellys).

167 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fos 260r–1v (John Carter, alias Bamme).

168 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fo. 331r.

169 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 239r–40r.

170 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 353r (John Muster), 389v–90r (William Palmer).

171 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fos 339v–40r (Baldewin Payne).

172 Ibid. MS 9171/2, fos 10r–11r (Sir Baldewin Radyngton).

173 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 459r (Margaret Deloe); MS 9171/3, fos 114v–15r (John Mycholl).

174 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 459r (Margaret Deloe).

175 Ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 324r (Walter Umfray).

176 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 196r.

177 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 344v–5v (Thoma s Erlond).

178 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 118r.

179 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 131r.

180 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fo. 326v.

181 Ibid. MS 9171/3, fo. 243v (Thomas Henyngham).

182 Ibid. MS 9171/3, fos 496v–7v: ‘die humationis mee’ (Richard Bamburgh).

183 Ibid. MS 9171/2, fos 171v–3r.

184 ‘Ad inde inveniendum unum lampadem ardentem coram summo altari ecclesie eiusdem domus et ad inveniendum panem vocatum Singyngbred pro omnibus fratribus capellanis illius domus sub conditione quod prefati prior et conventus et successores sui teneant anniversarium meum in ecclesia sua predicta modo honesto die quo me obire contigerit’: ibid. MS 9171/3, fos 393r–v.

185 Ibid. MS 9171/4, fo. 227v (Thomas Ely).

186 ‘quamdiu idem Prior secundum eius sanam conscientiam voluerit’: ibid. MS 9171/5, fos 193v–4r (John Queldryk).

187 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fos 5v–6r (Matilda, widow of William Penne).

188 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 256r–v (John Tettesworth).

189 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 125r–6r (John de Bisshopeston), 140r (John Gloos), 159r Roger Bobynton).

190 ‘Ut ipsi animam meam in orationibus suis cotidianis pie habeant recommendatam’: ibid. MS 9171/5, fo. 125r (Richard Dee).

191 Ibid. MS 9171/6, fos 70r–1v.

192 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fo. 148v (Thomas Murdag).

193 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo. 289r (William Bele).

194 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 227v–8r (John Fyfhyde); PRO, C 270/32/20; Catalogue of Ancient Deeds, London 1906, v. 126 Google Scholar.

195 GL, MS 9171/1, fos 150v–1r.

196 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 175r–v.

197 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 61r, 94v–5r.

198 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 141v, 145v.

199 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 170r–v.

200 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 51v–2r.

201 Bequest ‘inter fratres minores maxime indigentes’: MS 9171/3, fo. 93r (John Pellyng); ‘lego pauperi conventui Fratrum Carmelitarum’, MS 9171/5, fos 299v–300r (Richard Shergete). Little, A. G., ‘A royal inquiry into property held by the mendicant friars in England in 1349 and 1350’, in Edwards, J. G., Galbraith, V. H. and Jacob, E. F. (eds), Historical essays in honour of James Tail, Manchester 1933, 179–88 at p. 182Google Scholar. The inquiries may have been connected with anti-mendicant feeling but showed no irregularities: Raban, S., Mortmain legislation and the English Church 1279–1500, Cambridge 1982, 62 CrossRefGoogle Scholar. The special role of the poor in commemorating the dead is emphasised by Rexroth, F., ‘Armut und Memoria im spätmittelalterlichen London’, in Geuenich, D. and Oexle, O. G. (eds), Memoria in der Gesellschaft des Mittelalters, Göttingen 1994, 336–60 at pp. 341, 347–9Google Scholar.

202 ‘Pro suo proprio usu’: GL, MS 9171/1, fo. 403v (John Clapscheth).

203 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 263r–4v (John Pyncheon); MS 9171/3, fo. 167r–v (Agnes, widow of Richard Gyffard).

204 Ibid. MS 9171/2, fos 22v–3v (Bartholomeus Neve).

205 Ibid. MS 9171/3, fo. 93r.

206 Ibid. MS 9171/3, fos 285v–6r.

207 For example ibid. MS 9171/5, fos 327v–8r (Joan Gedeney).

208 ‘Cuilibet dotnui fratrum XII denarios ac etiam domui S. Crucis XII denarios’: ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 22r (Agnes, widow of Richard Fraunceys).

209 The reform-movement became active in England in the middle of the fifteenth century: Definities der Generate Kapittels van de orde van het H. Cruis 1410–1765, ed. van der Pasch, A., Brussels 1969, no. 45Google Scholar; GL, MS 9171/6, fos 49r (James Monthorpe), 50r–v (William Narburgh), 63r–4r (Dame Katherin Marrow), 90r (Robert Taillour); van den Bosch, P., ‘Die Kreuzherrenreform des 15. Jahrhunderts’, in Elm, K. (ed.) Reformbemühungen und Observanzbestrebungen im spätmittelalterlichen Ordenswesen, Berlin 1989, 71–82 Google Scholar.

210 For example, GL, MS 9051/1, fo. 111r–v (Elizabeth, widow of Robert Burlee).

211 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 111r (Randolf Bethlehem).

212 The total number of wills in this group, including those requesting burial, is 492.

213 GL, MS 9171/1, fos 26v–7r (John Berlyngham).

214 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo. 178v (Arnold Huet); MS 9171/1, fos 108v–9r (Sir John Corson), 252r (Adam in the Lance); MS 9171/2, fos 262v–3r (Baillardus Denbidam); MS 9171/4, fos 194v (John Cadolen), 233r (Sebet Tierlott); MS 9171/5, fos 13v (Arthur de Cursy), 170r (Robert Aleyn), 309v (Albert Grate); MS 9171/6, fos 138v (George Belton), 162v (Arnold Otte alias Fawkener), 311r (Robert de Prato).

215 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fos 62v–3r (John Boteswayn), 76r (Margery, widow of William Vale).

216 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 443v–4v (Thomas Panton).

217 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fos 260r–1v (John Carter alias Bamme).

218 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 114r (John de War); MS 9171/2, fos 30v (Christina Rede), 69r–v (Ralph Freman).

219 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fo. 148v (Idonia, widow of Robert Salesbury and of Geoffrey Puppe).

220 Ibid. MS 9171/1, fos 156r (Richard Hale), 175r–v (John de Nevill, Lord Raby).

221 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fos 333v–4r (Robert Cristemasse).

222 Ibid. MS 9171/4, fo. 217r–v (William Pope).

223 Ibid. MS 9171/5, fo. 223v (Margaret Dolowe).

224 Ibid. MS 9171/6, fos 244v–5v (John Rogerson).

225 Ibid. MS 9051/1, fo. 287v (William Scut).

226 ‘Memorandum quod licet Ricardus Wodecok civis dum vixit et salter (…) filium suum legitimum et seniorem Willelmum nomine adtunc sub habitu regulari ordinis fratrum minorum degentem non processum [sic] ex quadam sua negligentia ut dixit in suo testamento predicto preterierit et omiserit nullam de eo in dicto suo testamento faciens mentionem (…) Postea tamen dicto testamento sic condito et confecto de prefato Willelmo filio suo reminiscens et recogitans consideransque quod idem Willelmus filius suus possit ante professionem suam dictum habitum religionis et ordinem dimittere et ad seculum et secularem vitam redire si voluerit. Et propterea ne in eventu quo idem Willelmus ante professionem suam dictum habitum et ordinem dimitteret et ad seculum rediret sua sustentatione esset desdtutus et sic forte daretur in occasio malignandi aut necessitas mendicandi prefatus Ricardus pater suus (…) ex paternali affectione quam erga filium suum Willelmum adtunc habuit motus et excitatus ad dictum testamentum suum aliqua inferius descripta pro sustentatione dicti Willelmi si ipsum ad seculum ut premittitur redire contigerit quasi per modum codicilli vive tamen vocis oraculo addidit.’ Ibid. MS 9171/2, fo. 315r.

227 Rosenthal, , Purchase of paradise, 101 Google Scholar.

228 Neidiger, , Mendikanten zwischen Ordensideal und städtischer Realität, 159 Google Scholar.

229 Kothe, W., Kirchliche zustände Strassburgs im 14. Jahrhundert, Freiburg/Br. 1903, 101 Google Scholar; Wehrli-Johns, M., ‘Stellungund Wirksamkeit der Bettelorden in Zürich’, in Elm, K. (ed.), Stellung und Wirksamkeit der Bettelorden in der städtischen Gesellschaft, Berlin 1981, 77–84 at p. 82Google Scholar; Neidiger, , Mendikanten zwischen Ordensideal und städtischer Realität, 160 Google Scholar; Lorcin, , ‘Les clauses religieuses’, 306 Google Scholar; Ingelfinger, F., Die religiös-kirchlichen Verhältnisse im heutigen Württemberg am Vorabend der Reformation, Stuttgart 1939, 75 Google Scholar.

230 Martin, , Ordres mendiants en Bretagne, 334 Google Scholar; Saul, N., ‘Religious sympathies of the gentry in Gloucestershire 1200–1500’, Transactions of the Bristol and Gloucestershire Archaeological Society xcviii (1980), 99–112 at p. 100Google Scholar; Tanner, N. P., The Church in late medieval Norwich, 1370–1532, Toronto 1984, 119 Google Scholar; Trüdinger, , Stadt und Kirche im spätmittelalterlichen Würzburg, 80–1Google Scholar; Wolter, H., ‘Die Bedeutung der geistlichen Orden für die Entwicklung der Stadt Frankfurt am Main’, Archiv für mittelrheinische Kirchengeschichte xxvi (1974), 25–43 at pp. 30–1Google Scholar.

231 Ibid. 35; Epstein, , Wills and wealth, 196 Google Scholar.

232 Guerrau, A., ‘Rentes des ordres mendiants à Mâcon au XIVe siècle’, Annales ESC xxv (1970), 956–65 at p. 960Google Scholar; Kothe, , Kirchliche zustände, 44, 90Google Scholar; Isenmann, , Die deulsche Stadt im Spätmittelalter, 212 Google Scholar.

233 Tanner, , Church in late medieval Norwich, 74 Google Scholar; Wolter, , ‘Bedeutung der geistlichen Orden’, 32 Google Scholar; Henderson, J. S., ‘Piety an d charity in late medieval Florence: religious confraternities from the middle of the thirteenth century to the late fifteenth century’, unpubl. PhD diss. London 1983, 24, 46Google Scholar; Papi, M. D., ‘Confraternite ed ordini mendicanti a Firenze: aspetti di una ricerca quantitativa’, Mélanges de l'École française de Rome lxxxix (1977), 723–32 at P. 731CrossRefGoogle Scholar; J. Chiffoleau, ‘Les confréries, la mort et la religion en comtat venaissin à la fin du moyen âge’, ibid. xci (1979), 785–819 at pp. 806ff; Simons, , Stad en apostolaat, 228–9Google Scholar; Ingelfinger, , Württemberg am Vorabend der Reformation, 172 Google Scholar.

234 Brigden, , London and the Reformation, 36, 37, 460Google Scholar, and ‘Religion and social obligation’, 97, 99; Barren, , ‘Parish fraternities’, 16, 17, 23, 27, 31Google Scholar; Coote, , Ordinances of some secular guilds, 34, 44, 52Google Scholar.