Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7czq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-24T09:02:48.936Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Public Opinion” and Political Power: Qingyi in Late Nineteenth Century China

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 March 2011

Mary Backus Rankin
Get access

Abstract

The author reinterprets the phenomenon of qingyi (represented by members of the Qingliu and Emperor's party) as passing through five phases from 1875 to 1898, in the course of which it enlarged its scope of demands by lower- and middle-grade metropolitan officials for a broader distribution of political power and contributed to the formation of public opinion. This evolution was attended by the rise of analogous demands for political restructuring by men in two other environments: extrabureaucratic managerial and scholarly circles and the treaty ports. Militant patriotism mobilized and eventually united different groups, stimulating nationally conscious opinion that was alienated from the political leadership. The failure of government leaders to accommodate new political initiatives redirected qingyi into provincial movements and set the stage for the competition between centralizing bureaucratic and societally based programs for change that led to the 1911 revolution.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Asian Studies , Volume 41 , Issue 3 , May 1982 , pp. 453 - 484
Copyright
Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1982

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

List of References

Weijun, An. 1914. Wangyun shan fang wenji [Literary collection from the house at Wangyun Mountain].Google Scholar
Ayers, William. 1971. Chang Chih-tung and Educational Reform in China. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aying, . 1958. Jiawu Zhong Ri zhanzheng wenxue ji [A collection of writings on the Sino-Japanese War, 1894–1895]. Shanghai: Zhonghua.Google Scholar
Bastid, Marianne. 1974. “The Party of the Emperor and Chinese Nationalism before the Sino-Japanese War.” Paper given at Association for Asian Studies meeting (Boston).Google Scholar
Bland, J.O.P., and Backhouse, E. 1910. China under the Empress Dowager. London: William Heinemann.Google Scholar
Boorman, Howard, ed. 1967. Biographical Dictionary of Republican China. 4 vols. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Baochen, Chen. 1969. Cangqu lou zouyi shiji [Collection of memorials and poetry from the Cangqu Studio]. 2 vols. Rpt. Taipei: Wenhai.Google Scholar
Mi, Chen. 1934. Chen Jieshi xiansheng nianpu [Chronological biography of Chen Fuchen].Google Scholar
Mi, Chen. 1935. “Qingdai Ruian xian juren biao” [Table of juren degree-holders from Ruian in the Qing dynasty]. Oufeng zazhi huikan [Collections from the Oufeng Miscellany] 2, 3:la–17a.Google Scholar
Qiu, Chen. 1935. “Baoguo lu xu” [A preface to a record to requite the country]. Oufeng zazhi huikan 2, 3: 9b–10b.Google Scholar
I-fan, Ch'eng. 1976. “Kung as Ethos in Late Nineteenth Century China: The Case of Wang Hsien-ch'ien [1842–1918].” in Cohen, and Schrecker, , eds., pp. 170–80.Google Scholar
Kenkyūkai, Chūgoku [China research society]. 1918. Shimmatsu Minsho Chūgoku kanshin jimmeiroku [Who's who of officials and gentry of late Qing and early Republican China]. Tokyo.Google Scholar
Cohen, Paul. 1974. Between Tradition and Modernity: Wang T'ao in Late Ch'ing China. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Cohen, Paul, and Schrecker, John, eds. 1976. Reform in Nineteenth Century China. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Chengxiu, Deng. 1974. Yubing ge zouyi [Memorials from the Yubing Pavillion]. Rpt., Taipei: Wenhai.Google Scholar
DHL. Guangxu zhao donghua lu [The Donghua records of the Guangxu reign period]. 1958. Shoupeng, Chu, ed. Rpt., Shanghai: Zhonghua.Google Scholar
Eastman, Lloyd. 1965. “Ch'ing-i and Chinese Policy Formation during the Nineteenth Century.” Journal of Asian Studies 24, 4:595–611.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eastman, Lloyd. 1967. Throne and Mandarins: China's Search for a Policy during the Sino-French Controversy, 1880–1885. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Eastman, Lloyd. 1968. “Political Reformers in China Before the Sino-Japanese War.” Journal of Asian Studies 27, 4:695–710.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tingyi, Guo. 1963. Jindai Zhongguo shishi rizhi [Chronology of modern Chinese history]. 2 vols. Taipei: Zhengzhong.Google Scholar
Yen-p'ing, Hao. 1962. “A Study of the Ch'ing-liu Tang: The ‘Disinterested’ Scholar-Official Group (1875–1884).” Papers on China (East Asian Research Center, Harvard University) 16:40–65.Google Scholar
Howard, Richard. 1969. Introduction to “The Chinese Reform Movement of the 1890s: A Symposium.” Journal of Asian Studies 29, 1:12–13.Google Scholar
Kung-chuan, Hsiao. 1957. “Weng T'ung-ho and the Reform Movement of 1898.” Tsing-hua Journal of Chinese Studies, n.s., 1, 2:111–245.Google Scholar
Hsu, Immanuel C. Y. 1960. China's Entry into the Family of Nations: The Diplomatic Phase, 1858–1880. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sijing, Hu. 1924. Xianlu quanji [Complete works of Hu Sijing]. Nanchang.Google Scholar
Hummel, Arthur W. 1934–1944. Eminent Chinese of the Ch'ing Period. 2 vols. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
Youwei, Kang. 1975. Kang Youwei zibian nianpu [Autobiography of Kang Youwei]. In Kang Nanhai xiansheng shi wenji [Collection of poetry and writings by Kang Youwei]. Rpt., Taipei: Wenhai.Google Scholar
Kuhn, Philip. 1970. Rebellion and Its Enemies in Late Imperial China. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Lujing, Lei. 1977. Li Hongzhang nianpu [Chronological biography of Li Hongzhang]. Taipei: Shangwu.Google Scholar
Shiyue, Li. 1962. Zhang Jian he lixian pai [Zhang Jian and the constitutionalist party]. Peking: Zhonghua.Google Scholar
Zongtang, Li and Fenghan, Liu. 1969. Li Hongzao xiansheng nianpu [Chronological biography of Li Hongzao]. 2 vols. Taipei: Shangwu.Google Scholar
Dingfen, Liang. 1962. Jiean xiansheng yigao [Posthumous manuscripts of Liang Dingfen]. Hong Kong.Google Scholar
Housheng, Liu. 1965. Zhang Jian zhuanji [Biography of Zhang Jian]. Hong Kong: Longmen.Google Scholar
Kwang-ching, Liu. 1976. “Politics, Intellectual Outlook, and Reform: The T'ung-wen kuan Controversy of 1867.” In Cohen, and Schrecker, , eds., pp. 87–100.Google Scholar
Shaokuan, Liu. 1934. “Zhouyuan biji” [Written records from the Zhou Garden]. Oufeng zazhi [Oufeng Miscellany] 10:19b–20a.Google Scholar
Tu-ki, Min. 1971. “Musul pyōnpōp undong ūi paegyong e taehayŏ t'ŭkhi ch'ŏngnyup'a wa yang mup'a rŭl chungsim ŭro” [A background study of the 1898 Reform Movement with special reference to the Qingliu clique and the Foreign Affairs clique]. Tongyang sahak yon'gu [Journal of Asian historical studies] 5:101–152.Google Scholar
NCH. The North China Herald and Supreme Court and Consular Gazette. Shanghai.Google Scholar
Oufeng zazhi [The Oufeng miscellany]. Ruian, Wenzhou.Google Scholar
Pingyang xianzhi [Pingyang district gazetteer]. 1925.Google Scholar
Polachek, James. 1975. “Gentry Hegemony: Soochow in the T'ung-chih Restoration.” In Conflict and Control in Late Imperial China, ed. Wakeman, Frederic Jr. and Grant, Carolyn. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Polachek, James. 1977a. “Literati Groups and Literati Politics in Early Nineteenth Century China.” Doctoral dissertation, University of California, Berkeley.Google Scholar
Polachek, James. 1977b. “The Institutional Background of Ch'ing-i Rhetoric in the Late Ch'ing.” Paper given at Association for Asian Studies Meeting (New York).Google Scholar
Longwei, Qi. 1963. “Didang yu Wuxu bianfa” [The Emperor's party and the 1898 Reform Movement]. Xin jianshe [New construction] 9:35–42.Google Scholar
Osun, Qian. 1969. Wen Yunge xiansheng nianpu [Chronological biography of Wen Tingshi]. In Wen Tingshi quanji (Complete works of Wen Tingshi). Rpt., Taipei: Daihua.Google Scholar
Rankin, Mary. 1976. “Local Reform Currents in Chekiang before 1900.” In Cohen, and Schrecker, , eds., pp. 221–30.Google Scholar
Rankin, Mary. 1978. “Gentry Leadership Networks in Chekiang.” Paper given at New England China Seminar (Cambridge, Mass.).Google Scholar
Rankin, Mary. 1979. “Prefectural and District Elite Leadership in the Late Ch'ing Reforms, 1895–1911” Paper given at Association for Asian Studies Meeting (Los Angeles).Google Scholar
Schrecker, John. 1976. “The Reform Movement of 1898 and the Ch'ing-i Reform as Opposition.” In Cohen, and Schrecker, , eds., pp. 289–305.Google Scholar
Schwartz, Benjamin. 1964. In Search of Wealth and Power: Yen Fu and the West. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shaoxing xianzhi ziliao, di yi zhu [Materials for a Shaoxing gazeteer, first collection]. 1937.Google Scholar
Shenbao. 1874–1884, 1887. Shanghai.Google Scholar
Shengyu, . 1910. Yi-yuan wenlue [Writings from Yi Garden]. Zongyi, Yang, ed.Google Scholar
SL-GX. Ta Qing Dezong jing (Guangxu) huangdi shilu [Veritable records of the Qing dynasty, Guangxu reign]. 8 vols. Rpt., Taipei: Huawen.Google Scholar
Heng, Song. 1929. Liu zhai beiyi [Humble proposals from Liuzhai]. In Jingxiang lou congshu [Collections from the Jingxiang studio], ed. Qun, Huang. Vol. 10, chap. 1.Google Scholar
Heng, Song. 1947. Song Pingzi wenchao [Literary collection of Song Heng]. Shanghai.Google Scholar
Fangbu, Sun. 1934. Sun Yirang nianpu [Chronological biography of Sun Yirang]. Shanghai.Google Scholar
Yiyan, Sun. 1864–1873. Sunxue zhai wenchao [Literary collection from the Studio of Humble Study).Google Scholar
Yiyan, Sun. ca. 1873. Sunxue zhai xu wenchao [Supplementary literary collection from the Studio of Humble Study].Google Scholar
Zhijun, Tang. 1961. Wuxu bianfa renwu zhuangao [Draft biographies of 1898 reformers]. 2 vols. Peking: Zhonghua.Google Scholar
Zhijun, Tang. 1973. Wuxu bianfa shi luncong [Collected essays on the 1898 Reform Movement]. Rpt., Hong Kong: Chongwen.Google Scholar
Tongxiang xianzhi [Tongxiang district gazetteer]. 1881.Google Scholar
Tsai, Jung-fang. 1981. “The Predicament of the Compradore Ideologists.” Modern China 7, 2:191–225.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Renshou, Tu. 1974. Tu Guanglu zoushu [Memorials of Tu Renshou]. Rpt., Taipei: Wenhai.Google Scholar
Quchang, Wang. 1977. Shen Mensou nianpu [Chronological biography of Shen Cenzai]. Rpt., Taipei: Shangwu.Google Scholar
Yiyong, Wang. 1973. Wang Wenminggong yiji [Posthumous collection of Wang Yiyong]. Rpt., Taipei: Wenhai.Google Scholar
Tingshi, Wen. 1969. Wen Tingshi quanji [Collected works of Wen Tingshi]. 10 vols. Taipei: Daihua.Google Scholar
Tonghe, Weng. 1970. Weng Tonghe ziji [Diary of Weng Tonghe]. 6 vols. Typeset, ed. Taipei: Chengwen.Google Scholar
Tianren, Wu. 1979. Liang Jiean xiansheng nianpu [Chronological biography of Liang Dingfen]. Taipei: Yiwen.Google Scholar
To, Wu. 1936. “Qin-Tong tielu zhengyi” [The Tianqin-Tongzhou Railway dispute]. Zhongguo jindai shi yanjiu jikan [Studies in the modern economic history of China] 4, 1:67–132.Google Scholar
Chenwu, Xia. 1969. Jiading Changbai er xiansheng zouyi [Memorials of Xu Zhixiang and Baoting]. Rpt., Taipei: Wenhai.Google Scholar
Ke, Xu. 1928. Qingpei leichao [Notes of clarification]. Shanghai: Shangwu.Google Scholar
Yiming, . 1967. Zhong Fa zhanzheng ziliao [Materials on the Sino-French War]. Rpt., Taipei: Wenhai.Google Scholar
Yue, Yu. 1971. “Zijiang lun” [On self-strengthening]. In Zhonghua Minguo kaiguo wushi nian wenxian [Documents on the fiftieth anniversary of the founding of the Republic of China] 1, 7:586–87. Taipei: Zhengzhong.Google Scholar
ZFZZ. 1957. Zhong Fa zhanzheng [The Sino-French War]. Xunzheng, Shao et al. , eds. 7 vols. Shanghai: Renmin.Google Scholar
Dechang, Zhang. 1970. Qingji yige jing guan de shenghuo [The life of a metropolitan official at the end of the Qing dynasty]. Hong Kong: Zhongwen.Google Scholar
Jian, Zhang. 1925. Seweng ziding nianpu [Autobiography of Zhang Jian]. Nantong.Google Scholar
Peilun, Zhang. 1967. Jianyu ji [Collected works of Zhang Peilun]. Rpt., Taipei: Wenhai.Google Scholar
Xiaoruo, Zhang. 1930. Nantong Zhang Jizhi xiansheng zhuanji [Biography of Zhang Jian]. Shanghai: Zhonghua.Google Scholar
Yufa, Zhang. 1971. Qingji de lixian tuanti [Constitutionalists of the Qing period]. Taipei: Zhongyang.Google Scholar
Zhidong, Zhang. 1963. Zhang Wenxianggong quanji [The complete works of Zhang Zhidong]. Shutong, Wang, ed. Rpt., Taipei: Wenhai.Google Scholar
Ersun, Zhao. 1927–1928. Qingshi gao [A draft history of the Qing dynasty]. Peking.Google Scholar
Zhejiang chao [Tides of Zhejiang]. 1903. Tokyo, 4:177–183.Google Scholar
ZRZZ. 1957. Zhong Ri zhanzheng [The Sino-Japanese War]. Xunzheng, Shao, ed. 7 vols. Shanghai: Renmin.Google Scholar