Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 January 2009
Recent accounts of the proto-history of Africa use data from physical anthropology, but also concepts of race which physical anthropologists in general have abandoned as unsatisfactory; the paper seeks to explain this phenomenon sociologically. Late nineteenth-century political and sociological trends helped to produce patterns of thought which can no longer be regarded as affording adequate explanations of social processes. These patterns combined idealism, or the method of contrasting ideal types, with pseudo-Darwinism, which sought the origins of political development in the interaction of differently endowed groups. In African ethnography of the early twentieth century such concepts led to the view that the continent was inhabited by two groups, Caucasoids and Negroids, and by mixtures of the two which remained mixtures, to be analysed as such. The Caucasoid and Negroid types were regarded as absolute and universal, represented equally in the biological, linguistic, cultural and political aspects of man.
2 Parsons, Talcott, The Structure of Social Action (Glencoe, Ill., 1949), 473–87.Google Scholar
3 Gumplowicz, L., The Outlines of Sociology (trans. Moore, , Philadelphia, 1899).Google Scholar
4 Arkell, A. J., A History of the Sudan from Earliest Times to 1821 (London, 2nd ed. 1961), 22–4.Google Scholar
5 Barbour, K. M., The Republic of the Sudan; a Regional Geography (London, 1961), 74Google Scholar; Sergi, G., The Mediterranean Race (London, 1901).Google Scholar
6 Sergi, , Antropologica della stirpe camitica (Turin, 1897), 10.Google Scholar
7 Ibid. 395.
8 Smith, G. Elliot, The Ancient Egyptians (London, 1923), 67–9.Google Scholar
9 Seligman, C. G., ‘Some aspects of the Hamitic problem in the Anglo-Egyptian Sudan’, J. R. Anthrop. Inst. XLIII (1913), 595;Google Scholar and ‘Psychology and racial differences’ in Hadfield, J. A. (ed), Psychology and Modern World Problems (New York, 1936), 55Google Scholar see also Coon, Carleton S., The Races of Europe (1939).Google Scholar
10 Lévi-Strauss, C., ‘La structure des mythes’, in Anthropologie structurale (Paris, 1958), 227–56.Google Scholar
11 Diop, C-A., ‘Histoire primitive de l'Humanité; évolution du monde noir’, Bull. IFAN, xxiv B (1962), 449–541;Google Scholar and ‘Réponses à quelques critiques’, ibid. 542–74.
12 Ibid. 461.
13 Ibid. 452.
14 Coon, Race of Europe, 96.Google Scholar
15 Reisner, G. A., Excavations at Kerma, Harvard African Studies, vi (1923), 557.Google Scholar
16 Arkell, History of the Sudan, 46.Google Scholar
17 Junker, H., ‘The first appearance of the negroes in history’, J. Egypt. Archaeol. vii (1921), 128n.Google Scholar
18 Batrawi, A., ‘The racial history of Egypt and Nubia’, J. R. Anthrop. Inst. LXXV (1945), 81–101; LXXVI (1946), 131–56.Google Scholar
19 Arkell, review of Kirwan, L. P., The Oxford University Excavations at Firka, Sudan Notes Rec. xxiii (1940), 360.Google Scholar
20 Arkell, History of the Sudan, 86.Google Scholar
21 Seligman, ‘Some aspects of the Hamitic problem…’, 617–25;Google Scholar see also MacMichael, H. A., A History of the Arabs in the Sudan, 1, ch. 2 (Cambridge, 1922).Google Scholar
22 Keane, A. H., ‘Ethnology of Egyptian Sudan’, J. R. Anthrop. Inst. XIV (1885), 103.Google Scholar
23 Kirwan, L. P., The Oxford University Excavations at Firka (Oxford, 1939), 36, 40.Google Scholar
24 Huntingford, G. W. B., ‘The peopling of East Africa by its modern inhabitants’, in Roland Oliver and Gervase Mathew, History of East Africa, I (Oxford, 1963), 58–93.Google Scholar
25 Seigman, Egypt and Negro Africa (London, 1934), 60.Google Scholar
26 Goody, J., ‘Feudalism in Africa?’, J. Afr. Hist. iv (1963), 15.Google Scholar
27 Bull. IFAN, xxiv (1962), 554.Google Scholar
28 Livingstone, F. B., ‘Anthropological implications of sickle cell gene in West Africa’, Am. Anthrop. LX (1958), 533–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
29 Oliver, R. and Fage, J. D., A Short History of Africa (Harmondsworth, 1962), 44–52.Google Scholar
30 Arkell, A History of the Sudan, 177.Google Scholar
31 Arkell, , ‘More about Fung origins’, Sudan Notes Rec. xxvii (1946), 87–97;Google ScholarA History of the Sudan, 208;Google Scholar and Holt, P. M., ‘Funj origins: a critique and new evidence’, J. Afr. Hist. iv (1963), 39–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
32 Reisner, Excavations at Kerma, 557–8.Google Scholar
33 Fairservis, W. A. Jr, The Ancient Kingdoms of the Nile (New York, 1962), 115.Google Scholar
34 Birdsell, J. B., ‘The origin of human races’, review of C. S. Coon, The Origin of Races, Quart. Rev. Biol. xxxviii (1963), 185.Google Scholar
35 Arkell, , Early Khartoum (Oxford, 1963), 31–3Google Scholar, and A History of the Sudan, 24–8; Oliver and Fage, 20–1.Google Scholar
36 Coon, , The Origin of Races (New York, 1963), 650–1.Google ScholarPubMed
37 Cassirer, E. A., ‘Structuralism in modern linguistics’, Word, 1 (1945), 99–120.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
38 Dobzhansky, T. and Montagu, Ashley, ‘Two views of Coon's Origin of Races’, Current Anthrop. iv (1963), 365.Google Scholar
39 Birdsell, , ‘Some implications of the genetical concept of race in terms of spatial analysis’, Cold Spr. Harb. Symp. Quant. Biol. xv (1950), 259–314.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
40 Livingstone, , ‘On the non-existence of human races’, Current Anthrop. III (1962), 279–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
41 Huntingford, 58.Google Scholar
42 Lehmann, H., ‘Distribution of the sickle-cell gene. A new light on the origin of the East Africans’, Eugen. Rev. XLVI (1954), 101–31.Google Scholar
43 Huntingford, 64.Google Scholar
44 Lehmann, 128.Google Scholar
45 Barnicot, N. A., in ‘A survey of some genetical characters in Ethiopian tribes’, Am. J. Phys. Anthrop. xx (1962), 208A.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
46 Huntingford, 83.Google Scholar
47 Huntingford, 83, n.2.Google Scholar
48 Huntingford, 71.Google Scholar
49 Kennedy, R. A., ‘A necked and lugged axe from Nigeria’, Bull. IFAN, xxii B (1960), 209.Google Scholar
50 Greenberg, J. H., The Languages of Africa, pub. 25 of the Indiana University Research Center in Anthropology, Folklore and Linguistics (Bloomington, 1963).Google Scholar
51 Keane, 103.Google Scholar
52 Evans-Pritchard, E. E., ‘Ethnological observations in Dar Fung’, Sudan Notes Rec. XV (1932), 55.Google Scholar
53 E.g. Seligman, C. G. and Seligman, B. Z., Pagan Tribes of the Nilotic Sudan (London, 1932), 15;Google Scholar and Mair, Lucy, in Phillips, A. (ed.), Survey of African Marriage and Family Life (London, 1953), 115.Google Scholar
54 Wrigley, C., ‘Linguistic clues to African history’, J. Afr. Hist. III (1962), 272.Google Scholar
55 Greenberg, 85.Google Scholar
56 Huard, P. and Charpin, M., ‘Contributions à l'étude anthropologique des Teda du Tibesti’, IFAN, xxii B (1960), 180–7.Google Scholar
57 Arkell, A History of the Sudan.
58 Ibid. 49–53.
59 Huard and Charpin, ‘Contribution à l'étude…; and Huard, P. ‘Figurations d'animaux à disques frontaux’, IFAN, xxiii B (1961), 476–517.Google Scholar
60 Kirwan, ‘A survey of Nubian origins’.
61 Vycichi, W., ‘The present state of Meroitic studies’, Kush, v (1957), 74–81.Google Scholar
62 Ibid. 88.
63 MacGaffey, W., ‘The history of negro migrations in the northern Sudan’, SWest. J. Anthrop. xvii (1961), 178–97.Google Scholar