Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-18T04:31:46.509Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘My Head Belongs to the King’: On the Political and Ritual Significance of Decapitation in Pre-Colonial Dahomey

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Robin Law
Robin Law
Affiliation:
University of Stirling
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The kings of Dahomey in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries claimed to ‘own’ the heads of all their subjects. Contemporary European observers of the pre-colonial period understood this claim in terms of the king's exclusive (and arbitrary) right to inflict capital punishment, decapitation being the normal Dahomian method of execution. More recent Dahomian tradition, however, suggests a ritual aspect to the claim, connecting it with stories that the early king Wegbaja (the second or third ruler of Dahomey, but conventionally regarded as its true founder and the creator of many of its political and judicial institutions) prohibited the decapitation of corpses before burial, supposedly in order to prevent the misappropriation of the heads for use in the manufacture of ‘amulets’, or for ritual abuse by enemies of the deceased. The article argues, drawing upon contemporary European accounts of the pre-colonial period and ethnographic material from the neighbouring and related society of Porto-Novo as well as Dahomian traditions, that unlike many of the supposed innovations traditionally attributed to Wegbaja this prohibition of the decapitation of corpses is probably a genuine Dahomian innovation, even if its attribution specifically to Wegbaja is doubtful, but that its significance and purpose is misrepresented in Dahomian tradition. The decapitation of corpses in earlier times was probably related to the practice of separate burial and subsequent veneration of the deceased''s head as part of the ancestor cult of his own lineage. The suppression of this practice by the kings of Dahomey can be understood in terms of their desire (for which there is other evidence) to downgrade the ancestor cults of the component lineages of Dahomey, in order to emphasize the special status of the public cult of the royal ancestors, and more generally to concentrate or monopolize ritual as well as political and judicial power in the hands of the monarchy.

Type
Death, Ritual and Power in West Africa
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 30 , Issue 3 , November 1989 , pp. 399 - 415
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1989

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Cf. Law, Robin, ‘Dahomey and the slave trade: reflections on the historiography of the rise of Dahomey’, J. Afr. Hist., xxvii, ii (1986), 237–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

2 Akinjogbin, I. A., Dahomey and its Neighbours 1708–1818 (Cambridge, 1967).Google Scholar

3 For an extreme instance of this secularization, see the attempt to interpret the essentially religious ‘Annual Customs’ of Dahomey as a deliberative assembly analogous to a European parliament, by Yoder, John C., ‘Fly and elephant parties: political polarization in Dahomey, 1840–1870’, J. Afr. Hist., xv, iii (1974), 417–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

4 For an exceptional attempt to examine the religious character and policy of the Dahomian state, see Fuglestad, Finn, ‘Quelques réflexions sur l'histoire et les institutions de l'ancien royaume du Dahomey et de ses voisins’, Bull. de l'I.F.A.N., sér. B, xxxix, iii (1977), 493–517.Google Scholar

5 Law, Robin, ‘Ideologies of royal power: the dissolution and reconstruction of political authority on the “Slave Coast”, 1680–1750’, Africa, lvii, iii (1987), 321–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, ‘History and legitimacy: aspects of the use of the past in pre-colonial Dahomey’, History in Africa, xv (1988), 431–56.

6 For discussion, and arguments for the accuracy of the earlier version, cf. Law, ‘History and legitimacy’, 438–9.

7 Le Hérissé, A., L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey (Paris, 1911), 289–91Google Scholar; cf. 24–5, 54, 73–4, 84–6.

8 Dunglas, Edouard, ‘Contribution à l'Histoire du Moyen-Dahomey’, t. i, Etudes Dahoméennes, xix (1957), 90.Google Scholar

9 SirBurton, Richard, A Mission to Gelele, King of Dahome (ed. Newbury, C. W., London, 1966), 309.Google Scholar

10 Dalzel, Archibald, The History of Dahomy (London, 1793; reprinted 1967), 211, 219.Google Scholar

11 Cf. Law, ‘History and legitimacy’, 445–7.

12 Bulfinch Lamb, Abomey, 27 Nov. 1724, in Smith, William, A New Voyage to Guinea (London, 1744; reprinted 1967), 186.Google Scholar

13 Snelgrave, William, A New Account of Some Parts of Guinea (London, 1734; reprinted 1971), 31–2.Google Scholar

14 Another account estimates the total of those killed in the Dahomian conquest of Whydah at over 5,000: Francisco Pereyra Mendes, Ajuda [Whydah], 4 April 1727, in Verger, Pierre, Flux et reflux de la Traite des nègres entre le Golfe de Bénin et Bahia de Todos os Santos du XVIIe au XIXe siècle (Paris, 1968), 145.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

15 Snelgrave, , New Account, 38, 43–9.Google Scholar

16 For the ‘Annual Customs’, see esp. Coquery-Vidrovitch, Catherine, ‘La Fête des coutumes au Dahomey: historique et essai d'interprétation’, Annates: E.S.C., xix (1964), 696–716.Google Scholar

17 Burton, Mission to Gelele, 201; Gléé, Maurice Ahanhanzo, Le Danxome: du pouvoir aja à la nation fon (Paris, 1974), 80Google Scholar

18 Snelgrave, , New Account, 7, 65, 120.Google Scholar

19 Archives Nationales, Paris [hereafter, AN]: C.6/25, Delisle, Dahomey, 13 Sept. 1728. For more recent Dahomian traditions of the defeat of Ayahase (or Yahase) of Weme, attributed to Agaja's predecessor Akaba, cf. Melville, J. and Herskovits, Frances S., Dahomean Narrative (Evanston, 1958), 368–72.Google Scholar

20 Norris, Robert, Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, King of Dahomy (London, 1789; reprinted 1968), 134.Google Scholar

21 Duncan, John, Travels in Western Africa (2 vols, London, 1847; reprinted 1968), 1, 230–1, 245–6Google Scholar; Forbes, Frederick E., Dahomey and the Dahomans (2 vols, London, 1851; reprinted 1966), 11, 23–4.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

22 Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 156.Google Scholar

23 This throne was first described in 1830: Conneau, Theophilus, A Slaver's Log Book, or 20 Years' Residence in Africa (ed. Smythe, Mabel M., London, 1976), 260Google Scholar; cf. also Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa, 11, 272.Google Scholar

24 Cf. Le Hérissé, L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 321.

25 Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa, 11, 274–5.Google Scholar

26 Bulfinch Lamb, in Smith, , New Voyage to Guinea, 173.Google Scholar

27 Snelgrave, , New Account, 38.Google Scholar

28 Norris, , Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, vii, 82, 93.Google Scholar

20 Ibid. 128.

30 Dalzel, , History of Dahomy, 190.Google Scholar

31 Freeman, Thomas Birch, Journal of Various Visits to the Kingdoms of Ashanti, Aku & Dahomi (London, 1844; reprinted 1968), 268Google Scholar; Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa, 1, 219.Google Scholar

32 Freeman, , Journal of Various Visits, 270Google Scholar; Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa, i, 253.Google Scholar

33 Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa, 11, 277.Google Scholar

34 Forbes, , Dahomey and the Dahomans, 1, 75Google Scholar; Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 174.Google Scholar

35 Norris, , Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, 18Google Scholar; Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 174 n. 30.Google Scholar

36 Le Hérissé, , L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 39–40.Google Scholar

37 For the contrast between the Whydahs as ‘merchants’ and the Dahomians who ‘voluntarily devote themselves only to war’, see, e.g. AN: C.6/25, Instruction pour Julien Dubellay, 27 June 1733; cf. also Norris, , Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, 137.Google Scholar

38 Le Hérissé, , L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 327–8.Google Scholar

39 Snelgrave, , New Account, 38.Google Scholar

40 Dalzel, , History of Dahomy, 166.Google Scholar

41 Forbes, , Dahomey and the Dahomans, 1, 17, 22.Google Scholar Duncan, presumably through misunderstanding his informants, speaks of the purchase of ‘scalps’ by the king: Travels in Western Africa, 1, 261.

42 Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 315–17.Google Scholar

43 Snelgrave, , New Account, 32–3.Google Scholar Soldiers were also permitted to attach to their guns a cowry shell for each slave or head taken: Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa. 1, 261.Google Scholar

44 Snelgrave, , New Account, 44.Google Scholar

45 Dapper, Olfert, Naukeurige Beschrijvinge der Afrikaensche Gewesten (Amsterdam, 1668), 493Google Scholar; Phillips, Thomas, ‘A Journal of a Voyage made in the Hannibal of London’, in Awnsham, & Churchill, John (eds), Collection of Voyages & Travels (6 vols, London, 1732), v, 220.Google Scholar

46 Phillips, , ‘Journal’, 220.Google Scholar

47 Snelgrave, New Account, 6. Cf. the story in Dahomian tradition that King Agaja, after defeating and capturing the king of Bozoume, derisively employed him to sweep the palace: Le Hérissé, ,L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 299.Google Scholar

48 Law, Robin, ‘A neglected account of the Dahomian conquest of Whydah (1727): the “Relation de la Guerre de Juda” of the Sieur Ringard of Nantes’, History in Africa, xv (1988), 327.Google Scholar

49 ‘Journal du Voiage de Guinée et Cayenne par le Chevalier des Marchais’ (unpublished MS, in Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris: Fonds Francçais, 24223), 59–59VGoogle Scholar; cf. Labat, Jean-Baptiste, Voyage du Chevalier des Marchais en Guinée, Isles Voisines et à Cayenne (2nd edn, 4 vols, Amsterdam, 1731), 11, 191.Google Scholar

50 De Chenevert and Abbé Bullet, ‘Réflexions sur Juda’ (unpublished MS, 1 June 1776, in Archives d'Outre-Mer, Aix-en-Provence [hereafter, AOM]: Dépôt des Fortifications des Colonies, Côtes d'Afrique, MS. iii), 51.

51 Norris, , Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, 8.Google Scholar

52 Le Hérissé, , L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 161.Google Scholar

53 AN: C.6/25, Levet, Juda [Whydah], 21 Nov. 1733 (reporting the submission of the king-in-exile of the Whydahs): ‘…offrir leurs testes à Dada [the king of Dahomey] (ce sont les termes du pays)…’.

54 Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa, 1, 122–3Google Scholar; Garcia, Luc, Le Royaume du Dahomé face à la pénétration coloniale (1875–1894) (Paris, 1988), 266.Google Scholar Garcia identifies ‘head money’ with the levy also called amlonkoué (lit. ‘sleep money’), which was a ‘head tax [capitation]’ in the European sense of being levied at a flat rate per capita; Duncan, however, applies the name to a graduated tax levied ‘according to rank, reputation, and incom’.

55 Le Hérissé, , L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey 245.Google Scholar

56 Ibid. 243 n. 1.

57 Ibid. 244.

58 Ibid.; Herskovits, and Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 361Google Scholar; Glélé, Le Danxome, 112–13.

59 Herskovits, and Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 361.Google Scholar

60 Le Hérissé, , L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 55Google Scholar; cf. 243.

61 Herskovits, and Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 361.Google Scholar

62 Norris, , Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, 91Google Scholar; De Chenevert and Bullet, ‘Réflexions sur Juda’, 6–7; M'Leod, John, A Voyage to Africa (London, 1820; reprinted 1971), 40Google Scholar; Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 140.Google Scholar

63 Cf. Johnson, Samuel, The History of the Yorubas (London, 1921; reprinted 1966), 9, 95.Google Scholar

64 Le Hérissé, , L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 278, 281Google Scholar; Herskovits, and Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 366–7.Google Scholar

65 Cf. Fuglestad, , ‘Quelques réflexions’, 498–500.Google Scholar There did exist a sort of ‘contrapuntal paramountcy’ in Dahomey, since the Agassunon, or priest of Agassu, the legendary ancestor of the royal dynasty, enjoyed a degree of ritual precedence over the king, who had to prostrate in his presence: Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 206Google Scholar; Glélé, Le Danxome, 65–7. The Agassuno may perhaps be regarded as representing a displaced dynasty, since the title is said to have been conferred originally upon an elder brother of Dakodonu, the founder of Dahomey, who had been excluded from authority in favour of the latter: Glélé, , Le Danxome, 84.Google Scholar One account, indeed, suggests that it was the Agassunon from whom the king at his installation ‘purchased’ Dahomey: Dunglas, ‘Contribution à l'Histoire du Moyen-Dahomey’, 1, 90.

66 The question is discussed, inconclusively, by Law, ‘Ideologies of royal power’, 330–3.

67 Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 298Google Scholar; Herskovits, Melville J., Dahomey, an ancient West African kingdom (2 vols, New York, 1938), 11, 236.Google Scholar Cf. also the account in Maupoil, Bernard, La Géomancie à l'ancienne Côte des Esclaves (Paris: Institut d'Ethnologie, 1943; reprinted 1981), 387Google Scholar, which employs the term lido for the soul identified with the head, whereas Herskovits distinguishes the lido (or selido) from the semedo. (In Dahomian thought, a person had three or four separate souls.)

68 Norris, , Memoirs of the Reign of Bossa Ahadee, 85Google Scholar; De Chenevert and Bullet, ‘Réflexions sur Juda’, 7, 52.

69 Le Hérissé, , L'Ancien rpuaume du Dahomey, 54, 73.Google Scholar

70 De Chenevert and Bullet, ‘Réflexions sur Juda’, 51.

71 Robertson, G. A., Notes on Africa (London, 1819), 261.Google Scholar According to this account, even in ‘minor affairs’ appeal could be made from the decision of the local authorities to the ‘supreme court’ at Abomey: Ibid. 271–2.

72 Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa, 1, 259Google Scholar; cf. de Monleon, M., ‘Le Cap des Palmes, le Dahomey, Fernando-Pô et l'Ile du Prince en 1844’, Revue Coloniale, vi (1845), 68.Google Scholar

73 Le Hérissé, , L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 290.Google Scholar Though Avissu is presented in the traditions as a distinct person from Akpahe, who became dominant after the latter's death, the stories of the rivalry for leadership between him and Wegbaja look suspiciously like variants of those told of Akpahe.

74 Barbot, Jean, ‘Description des Côtes d'Affriqu’ (unpublished Ms, 1688, in Public Record Office, London: ADM. 7/830), IIIe Partie, 136.Google Scholar

75 ‘Journal du Voiage…par le Chevalier des Marchais’, 30V; cf. Labat, , Vogage du Chevalier des Marchais, 11, 90.Google Scholar The treaty cited by des Marchais is actually dated 1704, but this was a renewal of one made originally in the previous year.

76 Le Hérissé, , L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 161.Google Scholar

77 Herskovits, , Dahomey, 1, 16Google Scholar; Herskovits, and Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 359–61.Google Scholar

78 The claim that the founders of Dahomey introduced cotton, to supplement bark-cloth, also appears, in a non-funerary context, in the traditions recorded by Le Hérissé, L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 279. This alleged introduction of cotton should probably, however, be interpreted not as a recollection of a real historical event, but merely as reflecting the assumption that one of the functions of kings was to distribute cloth (and other luxury goods) to their subjects. A traditional story hostile to the Dahomian royal dynasty asserts the reverse, that when Wegbaja arrived in the Dahomey area, he found that Gbaguidi (a local ruler who initially befriended him) ‘had large cloths’, while Wegbaja's people were ridiculed as being ‘without cloths’: Herskovits, and Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 365.Google Scholar

79 Herskovits, , Dahomey, 1, 16Google Scholar; Herskovits, and Herskovits, , Dahomean Narrative, 359.Google Scholar

80 Oké, Raymond, ‘Les siècles obscurs du royaume Aja du Danxome’, in de Medeiros, François (ed.), Peuples du Golfe de Bénin (Aja-Ewe) (Paris, 1984), 63–4Google Scholar; Argyle, W. J., The Fon of Dahomey (Oxford, 1966), 12.Google Scholar

81 The claim that Wegbaja, unlike the earlier rulers, made the land freely available to his subjects (for burial) seems also to reflect a traditional stereotype of his benevolence and generosity. Compare the story that he abolished tolls levied on the fetching of water from the spring at Dido, north of Abomey: Le Hérissé, L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 283.

82 ‘Relation du Royaume de Judas en Guinée’ (unpublished MS, AOM: Dépôt des Fortifications des Colonies, Côtes d'Afrique, MS 104), 37, 67, 68–9.

83 Herskovits, , Dahomey, 1, 183.Google Scholar

84 Akindélé, A. and Aguessy, C., Contribution à l'étude de l'histoire de l'ancien royaume de Porto-Novo (Dakar, 1953; reprinted Amsterdam, 1968), 99, 108–10Google Scholar; Kiti, Gabriel, ‘Rites funéraires des Goun (Dahomey)’, Anthropos, xxxii (1937), 426–30.Google Scholar

85 Palau-Marti, Montserrat, Le Roi-Dieu au Bénin (Paris, 1964), 108.Google Scholar

86 For the circumstances of the foundation of Porto-Novo, and its relationship to Allada, see esp. Person, Yves, ‘Chronologie du royaume gun de Hogbonu (Porto-Novo)’, Cah d'Et. Afr. xv, ii (1971), 217–38.Google Scholar

87 Lander, Richard, Records of Captain Clapperton's Last Expedition to Africa (2 vols, London, 1830; reprinted 1967), 11, 252–3.Google Scholar

88 Palau-Marti, , Le Roi-Dieu au Bénin, 97.Google Scholar

89 Cf. Law, ‘Ideologies of royal power’, 325–6.

90 For the annual processions to the Dangbe shrine in Whydah, see e.g. Bosman, William, A New & Accurate Description of the Coast of Guinea (London, 1705; reprinted 1967), 370–1Google Scholar; ‘Relation du royaume de Judas’, 61. The royal installation rituals also involved a similar procession: ‘Journal du Voiage…par le Chevalier des Marchais’, 45–45v; cf. Labat, , Voyage du Chevalier des Marchais, 11, 153–9.Google Scholar

91 Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa, 1, 258Google Scholar; 11, 305–6; cf. Burton, , Mission to Gelele, 234.Google Scholar

92 Bay, Edna G., Asen: Iron. Altars of the Fon People of Benin (Atlanta: Emory University Museum of Art and Archaeology, 1985), 41.Google Scholar

93 E.g. Duncan, , Travels in Western Africa, 1, 125.Google Scholar

94 Pires, Vicente Ferreira, Viagem de Africa em o Reino de Dahomé (ed. de Lessa, Clado Ribeiro, São Paulo, 1957), 76.Google Scholar

95 Cf. Le Hérissé, , L'Ancien royaume du Dahomey, 178–80.Google Scholar