Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gvvz8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T08:10:26.496Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Garamantes and Trans-Saharan Enterprise in Classical Times

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

R. C. C. Law
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The sources for pre-Arab trans-Saharan contacts are poor, but at least for the central Sahara a picture can be made out. The alignment of rock paintings and engravings of chariots along two trans-Saharari routes has been supposed to prove regular traffic across the desert. The inference is unjustified, but literary and archaeological sources indicate that the conclusion is correct. Herodotus attests the use of a route running west from Egypt to the Fezzan, then apparently south-west via Tassili and Hoggar to the Niger. This corresponds with the central Saharan ‘chariot-route’.

There was also a route to the Garamantes of the Fezzan from the Punic settlements on the coast of Tripolitania. Carthage imported from the Garamantes the precious stones known as ‘carbuncles’, which were apparently brought to the Fezzan from the south-west. Other possible imports are slaves and gold. Carthage imported gold from West Africa by sea, and it seems likely that her explorations down the coast were inspired by an overland trade in gold. But there is no direct evidence for such a trade.

In the second century B.C. Rome replaced Carthage in control of the coast of Tripolitania. Between 20 B.C. and A.D. 86 she fought a series of wars with the Garamantes. Later friendly relations were established, but further trouble led to the organization of the ‘limes Tripolitanus’ after A.D. 201. Trade is attested by imported Roman material in tombs of the Fezzan dating from the late first to the fourth centuries. There is evidence that the Romans imported ivory from the Garamantes, and slaves are now attested directly.

The commodities exported north by the Garamantes came not from the Fezzan, but from farther south. Literary sources refer to hunting expeditions and raids to the south, and finds of Roman material have been made along the ‘chariot-route’ south-west of the Fezzan as far as Ti-m-Missao.

Trade ended with the collapse of Roman rule in North Africa. It was revived with the Byzantine reconquest after A.D. 533, and Christianity penetrated to the Fezzan. In 666 the Arabs overran the Fezzan.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 8 , Issue 2 , July 1967 , pp. 181 - 200
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1967

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Mauny, R., ‘Tableau géographique de l'ouest africain au moyen âge’, Mém. I.F.A.N., no. 61 (Dakar, 1961), 283.Google Scholar

2 The last reference to Libyan war-chariots is of 307 B.C. (Diodorus Siculus, XX. 64, 3); first to Libyan cavalry is of z6i B.C. (Polybius, 1. 19, 2–4).Google Scholar

3 Mauny, R., ‘Une route préhistorique à travers le Sahara occidental’, Bull. I.F.A.N. (1947), 341–57.Google Scholar

4 Lhote, H., ‘Le cheval et le chameau dans les gravures et les peintures rupestres du Sahara’, Bull. I.F.A.N. (1953), 1138–228,Google Scholar and ‘The Search for the Tassili Frescoes’, trans. Broderick, A. H. (London, 1959), 124–8.Google Scholar

5 Garamantes: Herodotus, IV. 183, 4; Pharusii: Strabo, XVII. 3, 7.Google Scholar

6 Especially his belief that the line of oases runs from Thebes. There was a route to Siwa from Thebes (via Kharga: cf. Herod. iii. 26), but it would take about twenty, not ten, days, and it would not follow the ‘ridge’: these data are applicable only to a route from the Nile Delta. (Pliny, NH, V. 50, gives twelve days for the journey from Memphis to Siwa.)Google Scholar

7 See, for the earlier part of Herodotus's route, Rhys Carpenter, ‘A trans-Saharan Caravan-route in Herodotus’, Am. J. Archaeol. (1956), 231–42.Google Scholar

8 For reference see Rawlinson, C., The History of Herodotus, II (London, 1875), 162, n. 9.Google Scholar

9 Ghnema, Djebel ben: Lhote, H. (1953), loc. cit. Latouma: P. Huard, ‘Gravures rupestres des confins nigéro-tchadiens’, Bull. I.F.A.N. (1953), 1573.Google Scholar

10 Hanno, Periplus, 7.Google Scholar

11 Strabo, XVII. I, 2, etc.Google Scholar

12 Though Pliny evidently thought he was: cf. V. 45, echoing Herodotus.Google Scholar

13 The text of Herod. IV. 184, I actually has ‘Aτλavtεs, but this is impossible, as it duplicates the next people. The reading ‘Arápavtεs is quoted by Eustathius (ad. Dionys. 66) as from Rhianos; Nicolas Damascenus (F 140) has the foim ‘Aφápavtεs.Google Scholar

14 Carpenter, loc. cit.Google Scholar

15 There is, in fact, an Adrar massif in Tassili.Google Scholar

16 πρoς έπέρoυς τóπoυς (Prom. Vinct. 348–50).Google Scholar

17 Herodotus's statement that the natives called Atlas κíoνa πov ovρaνov (IV. 184, 3) is clearly an echo of Aeschylus (loc. cit.), who speaks of Atlas bearing on his shoulders κíoν ovpaνov πε κaì χωaνóς.Google Scholar

18 V. 44: ‘quidam solitudinibus interposuerunt Atlantes’.Google Scholar

19 As assumed by How, W. W. and Wells, J., A Commentary on Herodotus, I (Oxford, 1912), 363.Google Scholar

20 Salt-houses: Mauny (1961), 467; colours: e.g. Leo Africanus gives ‘candidi, rubei, cinericii colons’ (Rawlinson, II, 164, n. 7).Google Scholar

21 Mauny (1961), 332, who suggests, with reservations, Erebeb, north-west of Adrar des Iforas.Google Scholar

22 Herod. IV. 172, I, 182.Google Scholar

23 Mauny (1961), 205–6.Google Scholar

24 Cf. n. 7.Google Scholar

25 Herod. IV. 43, 5.Google Scholar

26 Mauny (1961), 453–4.Google Scholar

27 His source for the journey of the Nasamones was some Cyrenaians, who had heard it from the king of the Ammonioi (II. 32, I).Google Scholar

28 Notably religious: Amen was worshipped at Siwa (Herod. 11. 42) and Audjila (Procopius, Aed. VI. 2, 16–17);Google Scholar Bes and Osiris are apparently depicted in rock engravings in the Fezzan (McBurney, C. B. M., The Stone Age of Northern Africa (Penguin, 1960), 266);Google Scholar bird-headed goddesses in Egyptian style appear in the rock paintings of Tassili (Lhote, The Search for the Tassili Frescoes, p. 202).Google Scholar

29 The Lotophagoi are immediately east of the Machlyes (IV. 178), who are on the shores of ‘Lake Tritonis’ (Gulf of Gabes): the Island of Djerba, opposite Gigthis, was identified with the Island of the Lotophagoi by Eratosthenes (Pliny, V. 41).Google Scholar

30 I do not understand why Gsell, S., Histoire ancienne de l'Afrique du nord, IV (Paris, 1920), 138, assumes that the route in question is that via Bu Njem and Sokna.Google Scholar

31 ěθνoς μέλa ìσχυρως, Herod. IV. 283, I.Google Scholar

32 At least in Roman times: Tacitus, Ann. IV. 23; Pliny, VIII. 142; Ptolemy, I. 8, 4; Augustine, Lib. Qu. CXV. 23.Google Scholar

33 Greek pottery of the seventh century is reported from there (Boardman, J., The Greeks overseas (Penguin, 1964), 222).Google Scholar

34 Livy, XXXIV. 65, 3.Google Scholar

35 E.g. Bovill, E. W., The Golden Trade of the Moors (Oxford, 1958), 22,Google Scholar

36 Herod. IV. 189; cf. Polyb. III. 23, 2; Livy, XXIX. 25; XXXIV. 65.Google Scholar

37 His sources for the passage on carbuncles are Callistratos of Rhodes (fl ca. 155 B.C.) and Archelaos (King of Cappadocia 36 B.C. to A.D. 17).Google Scholar

38 Bovill (1958), 30, n. I.Google Scholar

39 Ptolemy's Γίργiρi, the source-mountain of the Kinyps (IV. 6, 3) must be Garian.Google Scholar

40 Several Negroid skulls have been found in Punic cemeteries (Gsell, IV, 174), presumably of slaves. Note also the Carthaginian nurse ‘corpore aquilo’ in Plautus, Poenulus, 1112–13.Google Scholar

41 There is, of course, no reason to suppose that he ‘crossed the desert’ in the sense of crossing into the Sudan.Google Scholar

42 Punica, III. 313–14 and passim.Google Scholar

43 E.g. Gsell, IV, 139.Google Scholar

44 ‘Cerné, I'île de Herné, et la question des navigations antiques sur la côte ouest - africaine’, Conférence internationale des africanistes de l'Ouest, IVe Conférence (Fernando Po, 1951), II, 73–80.Google Scholar

45 Pliny, II. 169.Google Scholar

46 Strabo, XVII. 3, 3.Google Scholar

47 The monument of Tin Hinan at Abalessa did produce several gold objects (for ref. cf. n. 94).Google Scholar

48 Mauny, ‘Monnaies anciennes trouvées en Afrique au sud du limes de l'empire romain’, C.I.A.O. no. IV (1951), vol. II, pp. 51–70.Google Scholar

49 The precise location of the Pharusii is uncertain: Strabo (XVII. 3, 3) says they are thirty days' journey from Lixus; Pliny (v. 43) has them separated by ‘deserta’ from the Gaetuli in the north, and by ‘vastae solitudines’ from the Garamantes in the cast.Google Scholar

50 Mauny (1961), 300.Google Scholar

51 Trimingham, J. S., A History of Islam in West Africa (Cambridge, 1962), 48.Google Scholar

52 Polybius, XXX. 2.Google Scholar

53 Sallust, lug. 77, 2.Google Scholar

54 See especially Desanges, P., ‘Le triomphe de Cornelius Balbus’, Revue africaine (1957), 5–43.Google Scholar

55 The nature of Rome's desert wars is well summarized by Orosius's account of the Gaetulian war of A.D. 6 (vi. 21, 18): ‘Gaetulos latius vagantes Cossus…artatis finibus coercuit atque a Romanis limitibus metu compulit’.Google Scholar

56 ‘L'expédition de Cornelius Balbus au Sahara en 19 av. J.-C. d'après le texte de Pline’, Rev. Afr. (1954) 45–83: answered by Desanges, bc. cit.Google Scholar

57 The variants are ‘Balsa’ and ‘Balla’: as the preceding name is ‘Galsa’, a corruption from ‘Balls’ to ‘Balsa’ is more likely.Google Scholar

58 An inscription from Cyrene (S.E.G. IX. 63) celebrates the end of a Maρμaρiκός πόλεпoς in A.D. 2: but this date raises difficulties for the chronology of Quirinius's career, and Syme, R. (The Roman Revolution (Oxford, 1939), 399, n. I) conjectures ca. 15 B.C.Google Scholar

59 Florus, II. 31.Google Scholar

60 Tac. Ann. III. 74.Google Scholar

61 Ibid. IV. 23.

62 Ibid. IV. 26.

63 Tac. Hist. IV. 50.Google Scholar

64 Pliny, V. 38.Google Scholar

65 Tac. Hist. IV. 50.Google Scholar

66 Pliny's main source was evidently the campaign of Balbus (cf. v. 36).Google Scholar

67 For example, Bovill (1958), 34.Google Scholar

68 Ptolemy also has a Φaμavίa somewhere in Africa (IV, 7, 10), but is completely vague about its location.Google Scholar

69 Pliny, V. 38.Google Scholar

70 Zonaras, XI. 19.Google Scholar

71 Victor, Caes. 20, 79; S.H.A. Severus, 18, 3.Google Scholar

72 Goodchild, R. G. and Perkins, J. B. Ward, ‘The “Limes Tripolitanus” in the light of recent discoveries’, Journal of Roman Studies (1949), 81–95.Google Scholar

73 Goodchild, ‘Oasis forts of Legio III Augusta on the routes to the Fezzan’, Papers of the British School at Rome 1954, 56–68.Google Scholar

74 Mauny, ‘Monnaies anciennes…’, loc. cit. There are also civilian gravestones at Ghadames, with inscriptions in both Latin and Libyan (J. M. Reynolds ‘Three inscriptions from Ghadames in Libya’, P.B.S.R. (1958), 135–6).Google Scholar

75 Procop. Aed. VI. 3, II.Google Scholar

76 Goodchild, , Roman Roads and Milestones in Tripolitania (Tripoli, 1948), 54–20, 29.Google Scholar

77 A find of ancient coins is reported at Waddan in the Oasis of Djofra (Mauny, ‘Monnaies anciennes…’, loc. cit.).Google Scholar

78 Pace, Sergi and Caputo, ‘Scavi Sahariani’, Monumenti Antichi 1951, coll. 151–552;Google ScholarSir Wheeler, M., Rome Beyond the Imperial Frontiers (London,1954), 97–107.Google Scholar

79 Loc. cit. 105–6.Google Scholar

80 Ibid. 178.

81 From information given by Miss O. Brogan.Google Scholar

82 Gsell, I (1913), p. 60, n. 8, suggests that the Seven also introduced the camel for desert travel in Tripolitania: camels were certainly known earlier, but they did not become numerous till the third century (for a different interpretation of the evidence, see O. Brogan, ‘The camel in Roman Tripolitania’, P.B.S.R. (1954) 126–31, and Bovill (1958), 39–43).Google Scholar

83 Monumenti Antichi 1951, coll. 313–14 (and figs. 106–7).Google Scholar

84 For which cf. Strabo, XVII. 3, 18 (Zouchis), Pliny IX. 127 (Djerba Is.).Google Scholar

85 Aurigemma, S., ‘L'elefante di Leptis Magna e il commercio dell'avorio e delle ‘Libycae ferae’ negli Emporia Tripolitani’, Africa Italiana (1940), 67–86.Google Scholar

86 An elephant was brought across the Sahara to Marrakech at the end of the sixteenth century (Bovill (1958), 184).Google Scholar

87 For references see Gsell, I, 302, n. 2.Google Scholar

88 Anthologia Latina (ed. Bücheler and Riese), no. 183.Google Scholar

89 The excrement of the Garamantes has come into our world, and the black slave rejoices in his pitch-coloured body. If the voice emitted from his lips did not prove him human, people would be frightened at the sight of this terrible ghost. May the Underworld, O Hadrumetum, carry off your monster for itself! Pluto's house should have him as its guardian.Google Scholar

90 For example, Bovill (1958), 40, identifies Ptolemy's Báρδητoν and Mέοχη with Bardai and Miski in Tibesti.Google Scholar

91 Mauny (1961), 265.Google Scholar

92 Ibid. 435.

93 Mauny, ‘Monnaies anciennes…’ loc. cit.Google Scholar

94 Reygasse, M., Monuments funéraires préislamiues de l'Afrique du nord (Paris, 1950), 88–117;Google ScholarWheeler (1954), 107–11.Google Scholar

95 Mauny, ‘Monnaies anciennes…’, loc. cit.Google Scholar

96 In the forest, a coin of Constantine has been found at Buea in Cameroun (Bovill (1958), 41, n.).Google Scholar

97 Unless they are credited with the introduction of iron-working into West Africa: cf. Mauny, ‘Essai sur l'histoire des métaux en Afrique occidentale’, B.I.F.A.N. (1952), 545–95, and against this Huard, ‘Contribution à l'étude du cheval, du fer, et du chameau au Sahara occidental. I. Le fer’, Bull. I.F.A.N. (1960), 134–78.Google Scholar

98 Procopius, Bell. Vand. I. 8, cf. II. 21.Google Scholar

99 Aed. VI. 2, 18–20.Google Scholar

100 Ibid. VI. 3, 9–10.

101 Trimingham (1962), 15, n. I.Google Scholar

102 Trimingham, ibid.; Bovill (1958), 51–2.Google Scholar

103 Especially in the cemetery of Tag'lit (Monumenti Antichi 1951, coll. 381–4).Google Scholar

104 Ibid.coll. 416–19.

105 Cf. n. 91.Google Scholar