Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T03:57:19.120Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Towards a ‘modern progressive society’: the National Coalition and social reform, 1973–7

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 February 2015

Ciara Meehan
Ciara Meehan*
Affiliation:
Quinn School of Business, University College Dublin
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The 1970s was a time of crisis internationally, when governments struggled to cope with rising inflation and public indebtedness in the aftermath of the first oil shock. It was also a period of social change, of demands for divorce and abortion, and second-wave feminism campaigned for greater rights for women. But as many of the contributors to The shock of the global have shown, amidst the political, social and economic turmoil, there was development and transformation. Ireland was not isolated from many of these trends that marked the 1970s. This article is concerned with the Fine Gael–Labour government of 1973 to 1977, in particular with the social reform agenda pursued by a coalition of one party (Fine Gael) that had advocated a ‘Just Society’ in the 1960s, and another (Labour) that had declared that the seventies would be socialist. They presented themselves at the 1973 general election as the socially progressive parties in the political system, attempting to outflank Fianna Fáil, which, in contrast, emphasised the Northern Ireland security question during the campaign. As the National Coalition grappled with fiscal expansion and the effects of stagflation, important changes occurred in the realm of social policy. Legislation affecting the status of women, recognising female heads of household and offering support to families of physically and mentally disabled children were all indicators of change.

Type
Research Article
Information
Irish Historical Studies , Volume 38 , Issue 151 , May 2013 , pp. 457 - 475
Copyright
Copyright © Irish Historical Studies Publications Ltd 2013

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Ferguson, Niall, Maier, Charles S., Manela, Erez and Sargent, Daniel J. (eds), The shock of the global: the 1970s in perspective (London, 2010).Google Scholar

2 Gallagher, Michael, The Irish Labour Party in transition, 1957–82 (Manchester, 1982), p. 55.Google Scholar

3 Quoted in Puirséil, Niamh, The Irish Labour Party, 1922–73 (Dublin, 2007), p. 239.Google Scholar

4 O’Connor, Tom and O’Halloran, Anthony, Politics in a changing Ireland, 1960–2007: a tribute to Seamus Pattison (Dublin, 2008), p. 76.Google Scholar

5 Puirséil, , Irish Labour Party, pp 264, 270.Google Scholar

6 Ibid., pp 264, 285.

7 Ministers Charles Haughey and Neil Blaney were sacked from the cabinet after allegedly attempting to import arms for use by the I.R.A. in Northern Ireland. Liam Cosgrave received a tip-off about the plot and approached taoiseach Jack Lynch who confirmed the allegations. Peter Berry was the civil servant who initially learnt of the plan to bring arms and ammunition into Dublin airport. His diaries reveal that Lynch, having been informed, had decided to bury the issue. He was only prompted to act after Cosgrave pressed him on the matter. See Collins, Stephen, The Cosgrave legacy (Dublin, 1996), pp 103–6.Google Scholar

8 Desmond, Barry, Finally and in conclusion: a political memoir (Dublin, 2000), p. 55.Google Scholar

9 Ibid., p. 56.

10 Fine Gael Digest, viii, no. 1 (Feb. 1958), p. 2.

11 Esmonde, John Grattan, ‘Should Fine Gael go it alone?’ in National Observer, ii, no. 5 (Nov. 1959), p. 5.Google Scholar

12 John A. Costello to James Dillon, 13 Jan. 1960 (University College Dublin Archives (U.C.D.A.), John A. Costello papers, P190/340).

13 Circular to Fine Gael parliamentary party, 27 Apr. 1964 (in possession of Costello family). Costello was first elected to the Dáil in 1951 at the age of twenty-five, initially representing the working-class constituency of Dublin North-West. There he witnessed the effects of relative poverty, unemployment and emigration, which were particularly acute in his constituency but were also in evidence across the country. These experiences drove his desire for reform.

14 Quoted in David McCullagh, The reluctant taoiseach: John A Costello (Dublin, 2010), p. 296.

15 Meeting of the Fine Gael parliamentary party, 26 May 1964 (Fine Gael minute books, in possession of Maurice Manning).

16 Interview with Donal Flynn of Dublin (21 June 2011).

17 Irish Independent, 20 May 1964.

18 Irish Times, 2 May 1964.

19 Towards a just society, 1965 (in possession of the Costello family).

20 Notes for National Council meeting, 4 May 1965, (U.C.D.A., Fine Gael election papers, P39/GE/125).

21 Meeting of the parliamentary party, 26 Feb. 1964 (Fine Gael minute books).

22 Gallagher, , Irish Labour Party, p. 55.Google Scholar

23 Brendan Halligan speaking on ‘What if Declan Costello had become leader of Fine Gael?’, What if…?, RTÉ Radio 1, first broadcast 17 Sept. 2006.

24 Irish Times, 29 Jan. 1970.

25 Brendan Halligan speaking on ‘What if Declan Costello had become leader of Fine Gael?’.

26 Quoted in Collins, The Cosgrave legacy, p. 205.

27 Correspondence with Liam Cosgrave of Dublin (19 Feb. 2010).

28 One-to-One interview conducted by David McCullagh, first broadcast 26 Oct. 2009, RTÉ 1.

29 Irish Independent, 26 Feb. 1973.

30 Statement of intent (Irish Labour History Museum and Archive (I.L.H.M.A.) Brendan Corish papers).

31 Gráda, Cormac Ó, A rocky road: the Irish economy since the 1920s (Manchester, 1997), p. 69.Google Scholar

32 Irish Times, 12 Mar. 1973.

33 Speech to Fine Gael Ard Fheis, Mansion House, Dublin, 19 May 1973 ( N.A.I., DT 2004/22/37).

34 Cherish News, Jan. 1974.

35 Eibhlin Ní Threunmhoir, secretary, Single Women’s Association, to Liam Cosgrave, 31 May 1973 (N.A.I., DT, 2004/21/54).

36 Connolly, Eileen, ‘The Republic of Ireland’s equality contract: women and public policy’, in Galligan, Yvonne, Ward, Eilís and Wilford, Rick (eds), Contesting politics: women in Ireland, north and south (Oxford, 1999), pp 74–89 at p. 85.Google Scholar

37 Power, Anne, Hovels to high rise: state housing in Europe since 1850 (London, 1993),p. 339.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

38 Cabinet minutes, 24 May 1973 (N.A.I., DT, 2004/20/1).

39 Irish Times, 13 July 1974.

40 Cedric Sandford and Oliver Morrissey, The Irish wealth tax: a case study in economics and politics, Economic and Social Research Institute paper 123 (Dublin, 1985),p. 21.

41 Sandford, … Morrissey, , Irish wealth tax, p. 5.Google Scholar

42 Note on contribution of an annual wealth tax and a gifts tax to curbing wealth concentration prepared for meeting of cabinet sub-committee, 20 Nov. 1973 (N.A.I., DF,2005/9/166).

43 Address by Richie Ryan to Junior Chamber Ireland luncheon, 28 Apr. 1974 (N.A.I.,DT, 2005/7/292).

44 Alexis Fitzgerald to Liam Cosgrave, 8 Mar. 1974 (N.A.I., DT, 2005/7/292).

45 Sandford … Morrissey, Irish wealth tax, p. 31.

46 Richard Bourke to Liam Cosgrave, 4 May 1974 (N.A.I., DT, 2005/7/293).

47 Anne Cassin to Liam Cosgrave, 1 May 1974 (N.A.I., DT, 2005/7/294).

48 Ned McGuire to Liam Cosgrave, 19 Mar. 1974 (N.A.I., DT, 2005/7/292).

49 G.P. Crookes to Liam Cosgrave, 20 June 1974 (N.A.I., DT, 2005/7/294).

50 Branch resolutions, 5 and 10 May 1974 (N.A.I., DT, 2005/7/293).

51 Quoted in Diarmaid Ferriter, ‘“The stupid propaganda of the calamity mongers?”: the middle class and Irish politics, 1945–97’ in Lane, Fintan (ed.), Politics, society and the middle class in modern Ireland (Basingstoke, 2010), pp 271–88 at p. 281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

52 Anne Ahearne to Liam Cosgrave, 20 Mar. 1974; Anne Ahearne to Percy Dockrell, 19 Mar. 1974; Peter Roper to Percy Dockrell, 21 Mar. 1974 (N.A.I., DT, 2005/7/292). The file contains various other letters expressing similar views.

53 FitzGerald, Garret, All in a life: an autobiography (Dublin, 1991), pp 298–302.Google Scholar

54 Draft report on progress of economic sub-committee of cabinet in relation to work on capital taxation, 2 Jan. 1974 (N.A.I., DF, 2005/9/166).

55 Richie Ryan to Garret FitzGerald, 7 Jan. 1974 (N.A.I., DF 2005/9/166).

56 Brief for meeting of cabinet sub-committee, 17 July 1973 (N.A.I., DF 2005/9/166).

57 Memorandum on alternative system of capital taxation, [Nov. 1973], (N.A.I., DF 2005/9/166).

58 Quoted in Sandford & Morrissey, Irish wealth tax, p. 13.

59 FitzGerald, , All in a life, p. 300.Google Scholar

60 Quoted in Sandford & Morrissey, Irish wealth tax, p. 37.

61 Connolly, ‘The Republic of Ireland’s equality contract’, p. 85.

62 Report of Article 119 Special Group meeting, 2&3 Apr. 1973 (N.A.I., DJ 2005/14/01).

63 Minutes of government meeting, 21 June 1973 (N.A.I., DT 2004/21/611).

64 Memorandum for government, 29 Nov. 1973 (N.A.I., DT 2004/21/611).

65 Minutes of government meeting, 20 Jan. 1976 (NAI, DT 2005/133/396).

66 Margaret Ayres, ‘Equal pay in the 1970s? Delays, dissent and disinterest’ (M.A. thesis, University College, Dublin, 2010), p. 35.

67 Irish Times, 13 Feb. 1973.

68 Collins, Stephen, Spring and the Labour story (Dublin, 1993), pp 45–6.Google ScholarPubMed

69 Ferriter, Diarmaid, Occasions of sin: sex and society in modern Ireland (London, 2009), p. 421.Google Scholar

70 Interview with Cosgrave by Philippe Heymann, Vision, 30 Jan. 1974 (N.A.I., DT 2004/22/36).

71 Irish Women United to Liam Cosgrave, 2 Dec. 1975 (N.A.I., DT 2006/133/215).

72 Banshee: Journal of Irish Women United, i, no. 1 (1975), p. 2.

73 Patrick Curran to Liam Cosgrave, 23 Nov. 1975, (N.A.I., DT 2006/133/215).

74 Address by Conor Cruise O’Brien to annual conference of the Irish Humanist Association, County Down, 27 Mar. 1976 (N.A.I., DT, 2006/133/215).

75 Dáil Éireann deb., cclxxxix, 899 (6 Apr. 1976).

76 Macnamara, Angela, Yours sincerely (Dublin, 2003), p. 71.Google Scholar

77 Desmond, , Finally and in conclusion, p. 232.Google Scholar

78 Transcript of Le Monde interview, 13 May 1977 (N.A.I., DT 2007/116/337).

79 Girvin, Brian, ‘Contraception, moral panic and social change in Ireland, 1969–79’, Irish Political Studies, 32, no. 4 (Dec. 2008), pp 555–76 at p. 555.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

80 Ibid., p. 557.

81 Brooks, Barbara, Abortion in England, 1900–1967 (London, 1988), p. 12.Google Scholar

82 Quoted in Girvin, ‘Contraception, moral panic and social change in Ireland, 1969–79’, p. 567.

83 Who killed junior? booklet issued by Catholic Family Life, n.d., (N.A.I., DT, 2010/53/241).

84 Marion Kennedy, Parents’ Committee, League of Decency, to Gerald Collins, minister for Justice, 3 Feb. 1978; Nial Darragh, chairman of Council of Social Concern, to Jack Lynch [1979?], (N.A.I., DT 2010/53/241).

85 Irish Times, 18 Jan. 1978.

86 Letter from Damien Boyle, Rúnaí, Department of Foreign Affairs, to ambassadors, 12 May 1978 (N.A.I., DT 2009/111/49).

87 Interview by Smith, Kingsbury, Boston Herald American, 2 Sept. 1974 (N.A.I., DT 2004/22/36).Google Scholar

88 Gráda, Cormac Ó and O’Rourke, Kevin, ‘Irish economic growth, 1945–88’, in Crafts, Nicholas and Toniolo, Gianni (eds), Economic growth in Europe since 1945 (Cambridge, 1996), pp 388–425 at p. 402.Google Scholar

89 Statement issued 26 Sept. 1974 (N.A.I., GIS 2/ 92).

90 Speech to the annual dinner of the Dún Laoghaire Chamber of Commerce, 24 Jan. 1976 (N.A.I., DT 2004/22/59).

91 Department of Finance to Department of the Taoiseach, 14 Apr. 1977, (N.A.I., DT 2007/116/434).

92 Department of Finance memo, Apr. 1977, (N.A.I., DT 2007/116/434).

93 John Bruton to Liam Cosgrave, 19 Jan. 1977, (N.A.I., DT, 2007/116/434).

94 Ó Gráda, A rocky road, p. 30.

95 Dáil Éireann deb., cclxxxvii, 622, (28 Jan. 1976).

96 Statement of intent (I.L.H.M.A., Brendan Corish papers).

97 Ferriter, Diarmaid, Ambiguous republic: Ireland in the 1970s (London, 2012), p. 480.Google Scholar

98 Keogh, Dermot, ‘Ireland, 1972–84’, in Hill, J.R. (ed.), A new history of Ireland, vii: Ireland, 1921-84 (Oxford, 2003), pp 356–94 at p. 367.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

99 McCashin, Tony, ‘Social policy: 1957–82’ in Litton, Frank (ed.), Unequal achievement: the Irish experience, 1957–1982 (Dublin, 1982), p. 208.Google Scholar

100 Ibid. p. 209.

101 Dukelow, Fiona, ‘The path towards a more “employment friendly” liberal regime? Globalisation and the Irish social security system’ in Cantillon, Bean and Marx, Ive (eds), International co-operation in social security: how to cope with globalization? (Oxford, 2005), pp 125–56 at p. 136.Google Scholar

102 Collins, , Cosgrave legacy, p. 158.Google Scholar

103 McCashin, ‘Social policy: 1957–82’, p. 206.

104 Excerpt from Hall’s Pictorial Weekly (http://www.rte.ie/laweb/ll/ll_t10b.html) (15 Nov 2010).

105 Memorandum to the cabinet, 1975 (I.L.H.M.A., Brendan Corish papers).

106 Jones, Jack, In your opinion: political and social trends through the eyes of the electorate (Dublin, 2001), pp 15–16.Google Scholar

107 Gardiner, Frances, ‘Political interest and participation of Irish women, 1922–1992: the unfinished revolution’ in Canadian journal of Irish studies, 18, no. 1 (July 1992), pp 15–39 at p. 21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

108 Kennedy, Finola, Cottage to crèche: family change in Ireland (Dublin, 2001), p. 239.Google Scholar

109 Girvin, Brian, ‘Continuity, change and crisis in Ireland: an introduction and discussion’ in Irish political studies, 23, no. 4 (Dec. 2008), pp 457–74 at p. 458.CrossRefGoogle Scholar