Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t8hqh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T21:34:45.914Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

NANA SAHIB IN BRITISH CULTURE AND MEMORY*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 May 2015

BRIAN WALLACE
BRIAN WALLACE*
Affiliation:
King's College London
*
Department of History, King's College London, Strand, London, wc2r 2ls[email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The Indian Rebellion leader Nana Sahib became Victorian Britain's most hated foreign enemy for his part in the 1857 Cawnpore massacres, in which British men, women, and children were killed after having been promised safe passage away from their besieged garrison. Facts were mixed with lurid fiction in reports which drew on villainous oriental stereotypes to depict Nana. The public appetite for vengeance was thwarted, however, by his escape to Nepal and subsequent reports of his death. These reports were widely disbelieved, and fears persisted for decades that Nana was plotting a new rebellion in the mountains. He came to be seen as both a literal and symbolic threat; the arrest of suspects across the years periodically revived the memories and the atavistic fury of the Mutiny, while his example as the Victorians' archetypal barbaric native ruler shaped broader colonial attitudes. At the same time, he influenced metropolitan perceptions of empire through the popular Mutiny fictions in which he was a larger-than-life villain. Tracing Nana's changing presence in the British collective memory over generations illustrates the tensions between metropolitan and colonial ideas of empire, and suggests the degree to which an iconic enemy figure could shape perceptions of other races.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 58 , Issue 2 , June 2015 , pp. 589 - 613
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2015 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

I am grateful to Dr David Todd for supervising the MA dissertation on which this article is based, and to both him and Dr Paul Readman for their comments on earlier drafts. I would also like to thank the three anonymous referees for their input. The article was prepared for publication with the help of a grant from the late Miss Isobel Thornley's Bequest to the University of London. I am obliged to the British Library, the Cambridge University Library, and the Mary Evans Picture Library for the use of images from their collections.

References

1 Bradford Observer, 12 Nov. 1857.

2 Manchester Guardian, 23 Oct. 1874.

3 See Landon, Perceval, Under the sun (London, 1906), pp. 287–8Google Scholar; Ward, Andrew, Our bones are scattered: the Cawnpore massacres and the Indian Mutiny of 1857 (London, 1996)Google Scholar, p. 530; David, Saul, The Indian Mutiny (London, 2002)Google Scholar, p. 373.

4 Brantlinger, Patrick, Rule of darkness: British literature and imperialism, 1830–1914 (New York, NY, 1988)Google Scholar; Chakravarty, Gautam, The Indian Mutiny and the British imagination (Cambridge, 2005)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Frith, Nicola, ‘Rebel or revolutionary?: representing Nana Sahib and the Bibighar massacre in English- and French-language texts and images’, Interventions, 12 (2010), pp. 368–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bhatti, Anil, ‘Retcliffe's Nena Sahib and the German discourse on India’, in Mazumdar, Shaswati, ed., Insurgent sepoys: Europe views the Revolt of 1857 (London, 2011), pp. 137–51Google Scholar; Wagner, Kim A., ‘“Vengeance against England!”: Hermann Goedsche and the Indian Uprising’, in Carter, Marina and Bates, Crispin, eds., Mutiny at the margins: new perspectives on the Indian Uprising of 1857 (4 vols., London, 2013), iii, pp. 150–69Google Scholar.

6 Gupta, Pratul Chandra, Nana Sahib and the rising at Cawnpore (Oxford, 1963)Google Scholar.

7 Hall, Catherine, Civilizing subjects: metropole and colony in the English imagination, 1830–1867 (Cambridge, 2002)Google Scholar; MacKenzie, John, ed., Imperialism and popular culture (Manchester, 1989)Google Scholar; Porter, Bernard, The absent-minded imperialists (Oxford, 2004)Google Scholar.

8 See Halbwachs, Maurice, On collective memory, ed. Lewis Coser (Chicago, IL, 1992)Google Scholar.

9 Bloch, Marc, Apologie pour I'histoire ou métier d'historien (The historian's craft) (Paris, 1949)Google Scholar, p. 52.

10 Examiner, 10 Oct. 1857; Leeds Mercury, 21 Nov. 1857; Morning Chronicle, 9 July 1858.

11 On despatches, see Streets, Heather, Martial races: the military, race and masculinity in British imperial culture, 1857–1914 (Manchester, 2004), pp. 54–5Google Scholar.

12 Illustrated London News (ILN), 16 Sept. 1876.

13 ILN, 26 Sept. 1857.

14 Saturday Review, 12 May 1894.

15 Dodd, George, The history of the Indian Revolt (London, 1859)Google Scholar, p. 124.

16 Forbes-Mitchell, William, Reminiscences of the great Mutiny (London, 1893), pp. 158–9Google Scholar. Forbes-Mitchell ascribed the deception to an ILN artist, but was almost certainly mistaken: the portrait he describes is clearly that of the prince rather than the warrior.

17 Hampshire Advertiser, 26 Dec. 1857; Lloyd's Weekly Newspaper, 20 Dec. 1857.

18 Thomson, Mowbray, The story of Cawnpore (London, 1859)Google Scholar, p. 46.

19 Meisel, Martin, Realizations: narrative, pictorial and theatrical arts in nineteenth-century England (Princeton, NJ, 1983), pp. 33–4Google Scholar.

20 British Library, Add. MS 52968O, The sacrifice, or, love unto death. This title appears to have been abandoned after the script revisions. First performed: Surrey Theatre, 9 Nov. 1857.

21 Boucicault, Dion, Jessie Brown, or, The relief of Lucknow (New York, NY, 1858)Google Scholar. First performed: Wallack's Theatre, New York, 22 Feb. 1858.

22 The sacrifice (India in 1857), p. 4.

23 See Paxton, Nancy, ‘Mobilizing chivalry: rape in British novels about the Indian Uprising of 1857’, Victorian Studies, 36 (1992), pp. 5–30Google Scholar.

24 Boucicault, Jessie Brown, p. 13.

25 Ziter, Edward, The Orient on the Victorian stage (Cambridge, 2003)Google Scholar.

26 Padamsee, Alex, Representations of Indian Muslims in British colonial discourse (Basingstoke, 2005)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, p. 50.

27 The sacrifice (India in 1857), p. 119.

28 Era, 15 Nov. 1857.

29 Ibid., 29 Nov., 13 Dec. 1857.

30 Welsh, Townsend, The career of Dion Boucicault (New York, NY, 1915)Google Scholar, p. 55.

31 Boucicault, Jessie Brown, p. 31.

32 Musical World, 2 Jan. 1875; Outlook, 17 Dec. 1898.

33 Wilkinson, James, ‘A choice of fictions: historians, memory, and evidence’, PMLA, 111 (1996), pp. 80–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

34 Once a Week, 7 Jan. 1860.

35 National Library of Scotland, Crawford Collection EB.3608, unknown, ‘The massacre of five Catholic clergymen, by the sepoys at Cawnpore’ (Belfast, 1859).

36 Notes & Queries, 25 Jan. 1862.

37 Morning Chronicle, 6 Nov. 1857.

38 Penny Illustrated Paper, 9 Nov. 1878.

39 Times, 19 Sept. 1857 (quoting Calcutta Englishman, 8 Aug. 1857).

40 Nora, Pierre, Realms of memory: rethinking the French past (3 vols., Columbia, NY, 1996)Google Scholar, i, p. xvii.

41 Spectator, 29 Dec. 1860.

42 Manchester Guardian, 17 Nov. 1874.

43 Examiner, 4 Jan. 1862.

44 Morning Post, 6 Jan. 1862.

45 Times, 15 Feb. 1862.

46 Daily News, 28 July 1862.

47 Times, 1 Aug. 1863.

48 London Reader, 5 Sept. 1863.

49 Quoted in Times, 28 Sept. 1863.

50 Reynolds's Newspaper, 11 Oct. 1863.

51 Times, 22 Oct. 1874; York Herald, 6 Nov. 1874; Dundee Courier & Argus, 2 Nov. 1874.

52 Graphic, 5 Dec. 1874.

53 Spectator, 31 Oct. 1874.

54 Reynolds's Newspaper, 17 Jan. 1875.

55 Manchester Guardian, 1 Dec. 1874.

56 Times of India, 30 Oct. 1874.

57 Quoted in Gupta, Nana Sahib, p. 193.

58 Pall Mall Gazette, 15 Mar. 1878; Standard, 26 Aug. 1880.

59 Arnold, Edwin, Education in India (London, 1860)Google Scholar, p. 8.

60 Trevelyan, Sir George, Cawnpore (London, 1865)Google Scholar, p. 51.

61 Idem, ‘Letters from a Competition-Wallah: letter XI’, Macmillan's Magazine, Nov. 1863 – Apr. 1864, p. 290.

62 Emily Richings, ‘Cities of the Mutiny’, Belgravia, Sept. 1897, p. 17.

63 Llewellyn-Jones, Rosie, The great uprising in India, 1857–1858 (Woodbridge, 2007), pp. 184–5Google Scholar.

64 Monthly Packet, 1 Oct. 1884.

65 Ward, Our bones, p. 551.

66 Murray's handbook for travellers in India, Burma and Ceylon (London, 1911)Google Scholar, p. 305.

67 Trevelyan, Cawnpore, p. 191.

68 Keene, H. G., A hand-book for visitors to Allahabad, Cawnpore and Lucknow (Calcutta, 1875)Google Scholar, p. 40.

69 ‘An Old Indian’ [Wyman, Frederick], From Calcutta to the snowy range (London, 1866), pp. 108, 114Google Scholar.

70 Richings, ‘Cities of the Mutiny’, p. 23.

71 ‘Old Indian’, From Calcutta, p. 111.

72 Daly, John Bowles, Indian sketches and rambles (Calcutta, 1896), pp. 101–2Google Scholar.

73 Russell, William Howard, The prince of Wales' tour (London, 1877), pp. 357–8Google Scholar.

74 See Logan, William and Reeves, Keir, eds., Places of pain and shame (London, 2009)Google Scholar.

75 Monthly Packet, 1 Oct. 1884.

76 Ward, Our bones, p. 553.

77 Times, 18 Aug. 1896.

78 Hilda Gregg, ‘The Indian Mutiny in fiction’, Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine (Feb. 1897), pp. 226, 231.

79 Brantlinger, Rule of darkness, p. 204.

80 Money, Edward, The wife and the ward (London, 1859), pp. 403–4Google Scholar.

81 Gibbon, Frederick, The disputed V. C. (London, 1904), p. 328Google Scholar.

82 Fun, 6 Jan. 1886.

83 Bristol Mercury, 3 Jan. 1894; The Hull Packet, 27 Dec. 1861.

84 Fun, 8 May 1875.

85 ‘Harry's visit’, Bright Eyes (n.d., 1890s).

86 Observer, 5 Aug. 1883.

87 Charles Young, ‘The mystery of the mountain’, Boy's Own Paper, June–Sept. 1897.

88 Verne, Jules, The steam house (London, 1881)Google Scholar. Quotations are from The works of Jules Verne (15 vols., London, 1911)Google Scholar, xii.

89 Verne, The mysterious island (London, 1875), pp. 227–31Google Scholar.

90 See Swati Dasgupta, ‘Lost in translation: Jules Verne and the Indian Rebellion’, in Mazumdar, ed., Insurgent sepoys, pp. 221–36.

91 Verne, Works, p. 253.

92 Ibid., p. 385.

93 Ibid., p. 396.

94 Daily News, 3 June 1859; Punch, 5 July 1862 and 19 Sept. 1863; Times, 4 Jan. 1864; Pall Mall Gazette, 11 Mar. 1867; Standard, 23 Oct. 1867; Bowen, Governor G. F. (letter), Copies or extracts of correspondence between the Colonial Office and the governors of New Zealand (London, 8 July 1869)Google Scholar, p. 348; Contemporary Review, Oct. 1869; Manchester Guardian, 19 Aug. 1876; Pall Mall Gazette, 23 Feb. 1884; Glasgow Herald, 12 Aug. 1897; Derby Mercury, 19 Sept. 1900; Observer, 23 July 1901.

95 Graphic, 8 Dec. 1894.

96 Standard, 22 July 1882.

97 Freeman's Journal (Dublin), 24 July 1882.

98 Magnan, Charles (letter), Jamaica disturbances: papers laid before the royal commission of inquiry by Governor Eyre (London, June, 1866)Google Scholar, p. 153.

99 Blanc, Dr H. (letter), Papers connected with the Abyssinian expedition (London, 1867)Google Scholar, p. 576.

100 Fleming, Peter, The siege at Peking (Oxford, 1959)Google Scholar, p. 152.

101 Northern Echo, 17 July 1900.

102 Observer, 23 July 1901.

103 Quoted in Gupta, Nana Sahib, p. 201.

104 Times, 1 Sept. 1908.

105 Savarkar, V. D., The Indian War of Independence (orig. edn London, 1909; Calcutta, 1930), pp. 22–3Google Scholar.

106 Fortnightly Review, Feb. 1922, p. 194.

107 Leeds Mercury, 8 Sept. 1894.

108 Manchester Guardian, 24 Nov. 1925.

109 Licensed Victuallers' Mirror, 22 Sept. 1891.

110 Wilkinson, ‘Choice of fictions’, p. 28.

111 See Colley, Linda, ‘Britishness and otherness: an argument’, Journal of British Studies, 31 (1992), pp. 309–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

112 See Brantlinger, Rule of darkness, p. 203.

113 Observer, 25 Oct. 1874.