Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7fkt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-01T02:31:30.989Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Military nuclear relations between the United States and Great Britain under the terms of the McMahon Act, 1946–1958

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

S. J. Ball
S. J. Ball
Affiliation:
University of Glasgow
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article takes a fresh look at Anglo-American nuclear relations between 1946 and 1958. It concentrates on the relationship between the military establishments of the two countries in general and the ties between the United States air force and the Royal Air Force in particular. The article argues that an understanding of military relations is essential for an understanding of the high politics of the nuclear relationship. It is shown that senior officers in the armed services were the main ‘functional elite’ dealing with nuclear delivery systems and the planning for their use. Relations between these groups were personally and institutionally close and on the whole cordial. In Britain the link sustained optimism about the possibility of close nuclear co-operation in the 1940s and early 1950s and suppressed fears about the loss of nuclear independence in the late 1950s. In the United States it was recognized that military relations were an important channel through which to influence British nuclear policy. The article offers accounts, based on new archival research, of the nuclear aspect of the October 1947 Pentagon talks on the Middle East, Churchill's visit to the United States in January 1952 and the first Anglo-American joint nuclear targeting agreement – the Wilson/Alexander agreement of 12 March 1954. It reveals for the first time details of Plans E and X which equipped the RAF with American atomic and thermonuclear weapons between 1955 and 1958. The article concludes that the British nuclear force was becoming subordinated to the United States even before negotiations about Thor, Skybolt and Polaris missiles became central to the relationship.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 38 , Issue 2 , June 1995 , pp. 439 - 454
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Margaret, Gowing, Independence and deterrence: Britain and atomic energy, 1945–52 (2 vols., London, 1974), I, 1–13.Google Scholar

2 Richard, Hewlett and Oscar, Anderson, The new world: a history of the United States Atomic Energy Commission (Pennsylvania, 1962), I, 320–528Google Scholar; Gowing, , Independence and deterrence, pp. 63–130Google Scholar; John, Simpson, The independent nuclear state: the United States, Britain and the military atom (London, 1983), pp. 27–40.Google Scholar

3 Chief of the air staff to assistant chief of the air staff (policy), 3 Aug. 1944, Kew, Public Record Office (P.R.O.), AIR20/3749; Converse, Elliot V., ‘United States plans for a postwar overseas military base system, 1944–47’ (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Princeton University, 1984), p. 73.Google Scholar

4 Converse, ‘Plans for a postwar overseas military base system’, p. 131 and pp. 182–3.Google Scholar

5 Converse, ‘Plans for a postwar overseas military base system’, pp. 216–17Google Scholar; Simon, Duke, US defence bases in the UK (Basingstoke, 1987), pp. 19–21.Google Scholar

6 Converse, ‘Plans for a postwar overseas military base system’, p. 217Google Scholar; Duke, , US defence bases, p. 21.Google Scholar

7 Duke, , US defence bases, p. 31.Google Scholar

8 Gregg, Herken, The winning weapon: the atomic bomb in the cold war, 1945–1950 (New York, 1981), p. 251.Google Scholar

9 P.R.O., AIR2/14027, Frank Roberts (Bevin's private secretary) to R. F. Wood (ministry of defence), 26 Jun. 1948.

10 P.R.O., AIR2/14027, Bevin to Douglas, 27 Jun. 1948.

11 Alan, Bullock, Ernest Bevin: Foreign Secretary (Oxford, 1985 edn), p. 577.Google Scholar

12 P.R.O., AIR2/14027, Roberts to Wood, 26 Jun. 1948.

13 Duke, , US defence bases, p. 24.Google Scholar

14 Chief of the air staff to vice-chief of the air staff, 13 Aug. 1952, London, ministry of defence (MoD), Slessor papers, file XLIIIH. (Since this article was written the papers of Sir John Slessor have been transferred to the Public Record Office, Kew.)

15 Herken, , Winning weapon, pp. 239–41.Google Scholar

16 For the British account of the military aspects of the talks see: P.R.O., AIR20/2461, Price to General Leslie Hollis (chief staff officer to the minister of defence and principal British military representative at the talks), 19 Sept. 1947; assistant chief of the air staff (policy) minute on JP(47)130(Final), 29 Sept. 1947; COS(47)122nd meeting, 1 Oct. 1947; COS(47)209(o)(Revise), 2 Oct. 1947; and P.R.O., AIR20/2463, secretary, chiefs of staff committee to secretary, commanders-in-chief committee, Middle East, 12 Dec. 1947.

17 P.R.O., AIR20/2462, vice-chief of the air staff to secretary of state for air, 25 Oct. 1947; assistant chief of the air staff (policy) to vice-chief of the air staff, 31 Oct. 1947; and P.R.O., AIR20/2463, Sir Guy Garrod (senior RAF representative at the talks) to vice-chief of the air staff, 7 Nov. 1947.

18 Converse, ‘Plans for a postwar overseas military base system’, pp. 214–30.Google Scholar

19 P.R.O., AIR8/1606, chief of the air staff to air member for supply and organization, 24 Sept. 1948.

20 Converse, ‘Plans for a postwar overseas military base system’, p. 217.Google Scholar

21 Duke, , US defence bases, p. 51.Google Scholar

22 P.R.O., AIR8/1796, chief of the air staff to Sir Charles Medhurst (head of the air force staff of the British joint staff mission in Washington), 18 Nov. 1948.

23 P.R.O., AIR8/1796, DO(49)13, 15 Feb. 1949.

24 P.R.O., AIR8/1590, assistant chief of the air staff (policy) to chief of the air staff, 5 Jan. 1950.

25 MoD, Slessor papers, Lord Tedder to Sir John Slessor, 6 Apr. 1949, file XIVA.

26 Duke, , US defence bases, pp. 86–8.Google Scholar

27 P.R.O., AIR8/1796, Medhurst to chief of the air staff, 4 Jan. 1949.

28 MoD, Slessor papers, Sir John Slessor to the Hon. Sir Ralph Cochrane, 6 Jan. 1950, file XIVA.

29 MoD, Slessor papers, Sir John Slessor to Major-General Leon Johnson (headquarters, Third Air Division), 6 Jan. 1950, file XIVA.

30 MoD, Slessor papers, Slessor to Johnson, 7 Jan. 1950, file XIVA.

31 Timothy, Botti, The long wait: the forging of the Anglo-American nuclear alliance (New York, 1987), pp. 80–6, 90, 93, 101, 115, 204.Google Scholar

32 MoD, Slessor papers, Sir John Slessor to secretary, chiefs of staff committee, ‘Draft paper on defence policy and global strategy’, 20 Mar. 1950, file XIVA.

33 MoD, Slessor papers, Sir John Slessor to Sir Hugh Lloyd (commander-in-chief bomber command), 22 Jun. 1950, file XIVA.

34 Botti, , Long wait, pp. 81–6.Google Scholar

35 Duncan, Campbell, The unsuikable aircraft carrier: American military power in Britain (London, 1986 edn), pp. 127–8.Google Scholar

36 JCS 2208/3 Hoyt Vandenberg (chief of staff, USAF on behalf ofJCS) to secretary of defense, 20 Nov. 1951, Glasgow, Glasgow University Library (G.U.L.), microfilm of joint chiefs of staff records, 1946–53.

37 Kenneth, Strong, Intelligence at the top: recollections of an intelligence officer (London, 1968), pp. 224–7.Google Scholar

38 MoD, Slessor papers, Sir John Slessor to Sir William Elliot, 15 Jan. 1952, file XIVD.

39 MoD, Slessor papers, Slessor to Elliot, undated, file XIVD.

40 Botti, , Long wait, p. 107.Google Scholar

41 MoD, Slessor papers, Slessor to Churchill, 9 Jul. 1952, file XIVD.

42 Ian, Clark and Nicholas, Wheeler, The British origins of nuclear strategy, 1945–1955 (Oxford, 1989), p. 174.Google Scholar

43 MoD, Slessor papers, Slessor to Elliot, 27 Oct., file XIVD.

44 MoD, Slessor papers, Slessor to Lord Trenchard, 16 Oct., file XIVD.

45 MoD, Slessor papers, Notes on meeting with General Vandenberg, undated [Nov. 1952], file XXVC.

46 P.R.O., DEFE4/103, COS(58)7th meeting confidential annex, 21 Jan. 1958.

47 Desmond, Ball and Jeffrey, Richelson (eds.), Strategic nuclear targeting (Ithaca, 1986), pp. 40–2Google Scholar. For further details on United States nuclear planning see: Rosenberg, David Alan, ‘“A smoking radiating ruin at the end of two hours”: documents on American plans for nuclear war with the Soviet Union’, International Security, VI (1981/1982), 3–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, ‘The origins of overkill: nuclear weapons and American strategy, 1945–1960’, International Security, VII (1983), 3–71Google Scholar; idem, ‘Reality and responsibility: power and process in the making of United States nuclear strategy’, Journal of Strategic Studies, IX (1986), 35–52Google Scholar; Aaron, Friedberg, ‘A history of US strategic “doctrine”, 1945–80’, Journal of Strategic Studies, III (1980), 37–71Google Scholar; Peter, Pringle and William, Arkin, SIOP: nuclear war from the inside (London, 1983), pp. 20–92.Google Scholar

48 Botti, , Long wait, p. 117.Google Scholar

49 For details of NSC 162 see Foreign relations of the United States 1952–54, II, 488–534, 545–6, 562–97.

50 NSC 162, 30 Oct. 1953, FRUS 1952–54, II, 585.

51 NSC 162, 30 Oct. 1953, FRUS, 1952–54, II, 593.

52 P.R.O., AIR8/1852, Brief for chief of the air staff on meeting with Admiral Radford, chairman US JCS 3 Nov. 1953.

53 P.R.O., PREM11/620, Sir Oliver Franks to foreign office, 14 Jan. 1952.

54 P.R.O., PREM11/620, Note by minister of supply, 18 Jun. 1952.

55 P.R.O., DEFE13/222, ‘Meeting with the British, 1700, December 13, Hotel Talleyrand’, 13 Dec. 1953.

56 P.R.O., DEFE13/222, Richard Powell to Lord Alexander, 17 Dec. 1953.

57 P.R.O., DEFE13/222, Lord Alexander to Charles Wilson, 17 Dec. 1953.

58 P.R.O., DEFE13/222, Charles Wilson to Lord Alexander, 17 Feb. 1954; Alexander to Wilson, 23 Feb. 1954.

59 Ball, S. J., ‘The Royal Air Force and British nuclear strategy, 1945–59’ (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Cambridge, 1991), pp. 144–63.Google Scholar

60 P.R.O., DEFE13/222, Wilson to Alexander, 12 Mar. 1954.

61 P.R.O., DEFE11/101 General Sir Nevil Brownjohn to General Sir John Whitely, 24 Jun. 1954.

62 P.R.O., DEFE13/222, Colonel Potter to Mr Wheeler, 16 Sept. 1955.

63 Cmd.9555 Agreement between the Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of the United States of America for co-operation regarding atomic information for mutual defence purposes. Washington. June 15, 1955.

64 Simpson, , Independent nuclear state, pp. 115–16.Google Scholar

65 G.U.L., JCS 2208/2 Report by the joint strategic survey committee to the joint chiefs of staff on amendment to the Atomic Energy Act, 25 Oct. 1951.

66 Owen, Thetford, Aircraft of the Royal Air Force since 1918 (London, 1988), p. 517.Google Scholar

67 P.R.O., PREM11/846, Minister of defence (Harold Macmillan) to prime minister (Anthony Eden), 12 Aug. 1955.

68 This process was extremely sensitive for both governments. Even in the 1990s very few written records have reached the public domain and retired officials are very reluctant to talk to a historian about this aspect of nuclear relations. Of necessity, therefore, the following reconstruction of Projects E and X is based on fragmentary evidence.

69 P.R.O., T225/645, Note for the record by R. T. Armstrong: Project E, 5 Dec. 1955.

70 P.R.O., T225/645, M. Lynch to R. T. Armstrong, 28 Mar. 1956.

71 P.R.O., T225/645, G. Leitch (ministry of supply) to J. Macpherson (treasury), 14 Mar. 1956.

72 P.R.O., T225/645, Serpell, D. R. to Macpherson, J., ‘Project E: discussion with RAF’, 5 Jun. 1956Google Scholar; J. Macpherson to D. R. Serpell, 4 Oct. 1956; R. Haynes (air ministry) to J. Macpherson, 24 Oct. 1956.

73 P.R.O., T225/645, J. Macpherson to D. R. Serpell, 1 Jun. 1956.

74 P.R.O., T225/645, G. Leitch to J. Macpherson, 22 Aug. 1956; J. Macpherson to D. R. Serpell, 4 Oct. 1956.

75 ‘The origins and development of the British nuclear deterrent forces, 1945–1960’, Proceedings of the Royal Air Force Historical Society, VII (1990), 40 and 13.Google Scholar

76 P.R.O., CAB130/122, GEN570/2nd meeting, 30 May 1957.

77 P.R.O., DEFE4/94, COS(57)3rd meeting confidential annex, 8 Jan. 1957.

78 P.R.O., DEFE4/107 COS(58)46th meeting confidential annex, 30 May 1958.

79 P.R.O., DEFE11/101, secretary of state for air to minister of defence, 23 Mar. 1955.

80 Parliamentary debates, Commons, vol. 600, col. 1419, 26 Feb. 1959.

81 P.R.O., DEFE4/111, COS(58)77th meeting, 3 Sept. 1958.

82 It has recently been suggested that the British did not test the H-bomb in May 1957. Norman, Dombey and Eric, Grove, ‘Britain's thermonuclear bluff’, London Review of Books, XIV, 20 (10. 1992).Google Scholar

83 P.R.O., T225/645, R.J. Penney (air ministry) to T.J. Bligh (treasury), 19 Jun. 1957.

84 P.R.O., PREM11/2554, Compare Sir Harold Caccia to foreign office, 14 Sept 1957 (before the launch) to Sir Harold Caccia to foreign office, 6 Oct. 1957 (after the launch).

85 Cmnd.537 Agreement between the Government of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of the United States of America for co-operation on the uses of atomic energy for mutual defence purposes. Washington, July 3, 1958.

86 Cmnd.859 Amendment to the Agreement between the Government of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of the United States of America for co-operation on the uses of atomic energy for mutual defence purposes. Washington, May 7, 1959.

87 Botti, , Long wait, p. 248.Google Scholar

88 Jan, Melissen, The struggle for nuclear partnership: Britain, the United States and the making of an ambiguous alliance, 1952–1959, (Groningen, 1993), pp. 51–2.Google Scholar

89 P.R.O., AIR19/942, private secretary to the secretary of state for air to head of air staff secretariat, 23 Jan. 1958; ACSC(58)2nd meeting, 20 Jan. 1958 and P.R.O., AIR8/2164, secretary, chiefs of staff committee to chief of the air staff, 27 Feb. 1958; chief of the air staff note, undated.

90 Britain did not acquire Genie because the defence of bomber bases in the United Kingdom by RAF fighter command was abandoned during Duncan Sandys' tenure of minister of defence between 1957 and 1959.

91 P.R.O., DEFE13/180, ‘Record of meetings held at the Pentagon and State Department, Washington, DC, September 22 to September 25 1958’, 14 Oct. 1958.

92 P.R.O., T225/645, J. E. Herbecq to T. J. Bligh, 11 Nov. 1958.

93 P.R.O., CAB131/18, D(57)14 ‘Fissile material for nuclear weapons’ note by secretary, 27 Jul. 1957.

94 G.U.L., JCS 2208/3 Hoyt Vandenberg (chief of staff, USAF on behalf of JCS) to secretary of defense, 20 Nov. 1951.

95 Recent UK defence developments – a review for Ambassador Whitney (chiefs of mission meeting, Paris, May 1957), London, King's College library (photocopy from National Archives, Washington).

96 Botti, , Long wait, pp. 203–4.Google Scholar

97 P.R.O., PREM11/2868, ‘Note of a talk between Admiral Sir Michael Denny [the representative of the chiefs of staff in the USA] and First Lord’, First Lord of the Admiralty to prime minister, undated [1959].

98 P.R.O., AIR19/942, AC(58)2nd, 23/24 Jan. 1958 and chief of the air staff to chiefs of staff committee, 28 Jan. 1958.

99 These issues are addressed in more detail in Ball, , ‘RAF and British nuclear strategy’, pp. 279–318.Google Scholar