Hostname: page-component-6bf8c574d5-9nwgx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-02-23T20:34:16.980Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Human rights without human supremacism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2020

Will Kymlicka
Will Kymlicka*
Affiliation:
Philosophy Department, Queen's University, Kingston, Canada
*
E-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Early defenders of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights invoked species hierarchy: human beings are owed rights because of our discontinuity with and superiority to animals. Subsequent defenders avoided species supremacism, appealing instead to conditions of embodied subjectivity and corporeal vulnerability we share with animals. In the past decade, however, supremacism has returned in work of the new ‘dignitarians’ who argue that human rights are grounded in dignity, and that human dignity requires according humans a higher status than animals. Against the dignitarians, I argue that defending human rights on the backs of animals is philosophically suspect and politically self-defeating.

Keywords

Human rightsanimal rightshuman dignityspeciesism
Type
Articles
Information
Canadian Journal of Philosophy , Volume 48 , Issue 6 , December 2018 , pp. 763 - 792
Copyright
Copyright © Canadian Journal of Philosophy 2017

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

Presented as the CJP Distinguished Lecture at the annual meeting of the Canadian Philosophical Association in May 2017. This paper draws extensively on ideas developed in collaborative work with Sue Donaldson, as part of our ongoing work in elaborating a political theory of animal rights. Earlier versions were presented at the Donia Human Rights Center at the University of Michigan, and the Groupe de recherche en éthique environnementale et animale (GREEA) in Montreal. Thanks to the audiences for their questions, and to Kiyoteru Tsutsui and Sophia Rousseau-Mermans for the invitations. Thanks also to Maneesha Deckha, Sue Donaldson, Jess Eisen, Raffael Fasel, Kyle Johannsen, Andrew Lister, Alistair Macleod, Josh Milburn, Christine Straehle and Saskia Stucki for helpful written comments.

References

Amiot, Catherine, and Bastian, Brock. 2017. “Solidarity with Animals: Assessing a Relevant Dimension of Social Identification with Animals.” Plos One 12(1): e0168184. 10.1371/journal.pone.0168184CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Anderson, Elizabeth. 2014. “Human Dignity as a Concept for the Economy.” In The Cambridge Handbook of Human Dignity, edited by Duwell, Marcus, Braarvig, Jens, Brownsword, Roger, and Mieth, Dietmar, 492–497. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 10.1017/CBO9780511979033CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Appiah, Kwame Anthony. 2010. “What will Future Generations Condemn Us for?” Washington Post, September 26.Google Scholar
Arneil, Barbara. 2002. “Becoming Versus Being: A Critical Analysis of the Child in Liberal Theory.” In The Moral and Political Status of Children, edited by Archard, David and Macleod, Colin, 70–96. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bagaric, M., and Allan, J.. 2006. “The Vacuous Concept of Dignity.” Journal of Human Rights 5(2): 257–270. 10.1080/14754830600653603CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bastian, Brock, Jetten, Jolanda, and Haslam, Nick. 2014. “An Interpersonal Perspective on Dehumanization.” In Humanness and Dehumanization, edited by Bain, Paul, Vaes, Jeroen, and Leyens, Jacques-Philippe, 205–224. Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
Bastian, Brock, Costello, Kimberly, Loughnan, Steve, and Hodson, Gordon. 2012. “When Closing the Human–Animal Divide Expands Moral Concern.” Social Psychological and Personality Science 3(4): 421–429. 10.1177/1948550611425106CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bekoff, Marc, and Pierce, Jessica. 2009. Wild Justice: The Moral Lives of Animals. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 10.7208/chicago/9780226041667.001.0001CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bennett, Gaymon. 2016. Technicians of Human Dignity. New York: Fordham University Press. 10.26530/OAPEN_605861Google Scholar
Benton, Ted. 1988. “Humanism= Speciesism? Marx on Humans and Animals.” Radical Philosophy 50: 4–18.Google Scholar
Bilchitz, David. 2009. “Moving Beyond Arbitrariness: The Legal Personhood and Dignity of Non-Human Animals.” South African Journal on Human Rights 25(1): 38–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bolliger, Gieri. 2016. “Legal Protection of Animal Dignity in Switzerland.” Animal Law 22: 311.Google Scholar
Bradshaw, Gay. 2009. “Inside Looking Out: Neuroethological Compromise Effects in Elephants in Captivity.” In An Elephant in the Room: The Science and Well- Being of Elephants in Captivity, edited by Forthman, Debra, 54–68. Medford, MA: Center for Animals and Policy, Tufts University.Google Scholar
Bradshaw, Gay. 2011. “Why the Caged Bird Does Not Sing: Captivity and Complex PTSD in parrots and people.” Psychology Today (blog), October 16. https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/bear-in-mind/201110/why-the-caged-bird-does-not-sing.Google Scholar
Braitman, Laurel. 2014. Animal Madness. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
Brownlee, Kimberley. 2013. “A Human Right Against Social Deprivation.” The Philosophical Quarterly 63(251): 199–222. 10.1111/phiq.2013.63.issue-251CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Butler, Judith. 2006. Precarious Life. Brooklyn, NY: Verso.Google Scholar
Cataldi, Sue. 2002. “Animals and the Concept of Dignity.” Ethics & the Environment 7(2): 104–126. 10.2979/ete.2002.7.issue-2CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cavalieri, Paola. 2001. The Animal Question: Why Nonhuman Animals Deserve Human Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Cochrane, Alasdair. 2013. “From Human Rights to Sentient Rights.” Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 16(5): 655–675. 10.1080/13698230.2012.691235CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Costello, Kimberly, and Hodson, Gordon. 2010. “Exploring the Roots of Dehumanization: The Role of Human-Animal Similarity in Promoting Immigrant Humanization.” Group Processes & Intergroup Relations 13(1): 3–22. 10.1177/1368430209347725CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Costello, Kimberly, and Hodson, Gordon. 2014a. “Explaining Dehumanization Among Children: The Interspecies Model of Prejudice.” British Journal of Social Psychology 53(1): 175–197. 10.1111/bjso.12016CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Costello, Kimberly, and Hodson, Gordon. 2014b. “Lay Beliefs About the Causes of and Solutions to Dehumanization and Prejudice: Do Nonexperts Recognize the Role of Human–Animal Relations?” Journal of Applied Social Psychology 44(4): 278–288. 10.1111/jasp.2014.44.issue-4CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davies, Ben. 2017. “Utilitarianism and Animal Cruelty: Further Doubts.” De Ethica. A Journal of Philosophical, Theological and Applied Ethics 3(3): 5–19. 10.3384/de-ethica.2001-8819CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dayan, Colin. 2011. The Law Is a White Dog: How Legal Rituals Make and Unmake Persons. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. 10.1515/9781400838592Google Scholar
De Waal, Frans. 2016. Are We Smart Enough to Know How Smart Animals Are? New York: Norton.Google Scholar
Deckha, Maneesha. 2008. “Intersectionality and Posthumanist Visions of Equality.” Wis. JL Gender, & Society 23: 249.Google Scholar
Deckha, Maneesha. 2009. “Holding onto Humanity: Animals, Dignity, and Anxiety in Canada's Assisted Human Reproduction Act.” Unbound: Harvard Journal of the Legal Left 5: 21–55.Google Scholar
Deckha, Maneesha. 2010. “The Subhuman as a Cultural Agent of Violence.” Journal for Critical Animal Studies 3(3): 28–51.Google Scholar
Dhont, Kristof, Hodson, Gordon, and Leite, Ana. 2016. “Common Ideological Roots of Speciesism and Generalized Ethnic Prejudice: The Social Dominance Human-Animal Relations Model (SD-HARM).” European Journal of Personality 30(6): 507–522. 10.1002/per.v30.6CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dhont, Kristof, Hodson, Gordon, Costello, Kimberly, and MacInnis, Cara C.. 2014. “Social Dominance Orientation Connects Prejudicial Human–Human and Human–Animal Relations.” Personality and Individual Differences 61: 105–108. 10.1016/j.paid.2013.12.020CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Donaldson, Sue, and Kymlicka, Will. 2014. “Unruly Beasts: Animal Citizens and the Threat of Tyranny.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 47(1): 23–45. 10.1017/S0008423914000195CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Donaldson, Sue, and Kymlicka, Will. 2016. “Rethinking Membership and Participation in an Inclusive Democracy: Cognitive Disability, Children, Animals.” In Disability and Political Theory, edited by Arneil, Barbara and Hirschmann, Nancy, 168–197. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 10.1017/9781316694053CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Donaldson, Sue, and Kymlicka, Will. 2017. “Children and Animals.” In Routledge Handbook on the Philosophy of Childhood and Children, edited by Calder, Gideon, Wispelaere, Jurgen De, and Gheaus, Anca, 1–1. Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
Donovan, Josephine, and Adams, Carol. 2007. The Feminist Care Tradition in Animal Ethics. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Dupré, Catherine. 2013. “Constructing the Meaning of Human Dignity.” In Understanding Human Dignity, edited by McCrudden, C., 113–122. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Dupré, Catherine. 2015. The Age of Dignity: Human Rights and Constitutionalism in Europe. Portland, OR: Hart.Google Scholar
Düwell, Marcus. 2014. “On the Border of Life and Death: Human Dignity and Bioethics.” In The Cambridge Handbook of Human Dignity, edited by Duwell, M., Braarvig, Jens, Brownsword, Roger, and Mieth, Dietmar, 526–534. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 10.1017/CBO9780511979033CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Etinson, Adam. forthcoming. What's So Special About Human Dignity. Accessed March 2017. https://www.academia.edu/14634091/Whats_So_Special_About_Human_Dignity_DRAFT_Google Scholar
Fasel, Raffael. 2017. The Old ‘New’ Dignitarianism. Accessed September 2017. SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3034748Google Scholar
Feinberg, Joel. 1974. “The Rights of Animals and Unborn Generations.” In Philosophy and Environmental Crisis, edited by Blackstone, William, 43–68. Athens, GA: U Georgia Press.Google Scholar
Fineman, Martha. 2008. “The Vulnerable Subject: Anchoring Equality in the Human Condition.” Yale JL & Feminism 20: 1.Google Scholar
Fineman, Martha, and Grear, Anna, eds. 2013. Vulnerability: Reflections on a New Ethical Foundation for Law and Politics. Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
Gillespie, K., and Lopez, P.. 2015. “Introducing Economies of Death.” In Economies of Death: Economic Logics of Killable Life and Grievable Death, edited by Lopez, P. and Gillespie, K., 1–13. Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
Graumann, Sigrid. 2014. “Human Dignity and People with Disabilities.” In The Cambridge Handbook of Human Dignity, edited by Duwell, Marcus, 484–491. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 10.1017/CBO9780511979033CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Griffin, James. 2008. On Human Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199238781.001.0001CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gruen, Lori. 2014. “Dignity, Captivity, and an Ethics of Sight.” In The Ethics of Captivity, edited by Gruen, Lori, 231–247. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199977994.001.0001CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Guenther, Lisa. 2012. “Beyond Dehumanization: A Post-humanist Critique of Solitary Confinement.” Journal for Critical Animal Studies 10(2): 47–68.Google Scholar
Habermas, Jürgen. 2010. “The Concept of Human Dignity and the Realistic Utopia of Human Rights.” Metaphilosophy 41(4): 464–480. 10.1111/meta.2010.41.issue-4CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hodson, Gordon, MacInnis, Cara, and Costello, Kimberly. 2014. “(Over)Valuing ‘Humanness’ as an Aggravator of Intergroup Prejudices and Discrimination.” In Humanness and Dehumanization, edited by Bain, Paul, Vaes, Jeroen, and Philippe Leyens, Jacques, 86–110. Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
Hodson, Gordon, and Costello, Kimberly. 2012. “The Human Cost of Devaluing Animals.” New Scientist 216(2895): 34–35. 10.1016/S0262-4079(12)63189-3CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Humphreys, Rebekah. 2016. “Dignity and Its Violation Examined Within the Context of Animal Ethics.” Ethics & the Environment 21(2): 143–162. 10.2979/ethicsenviro.21.2.06CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kateb, George. 2011. Human Dignity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kim, Claire Jean. 2011. “Moral Extensionism or Racist Exploitation? The Use of Holocaust and Slavery Analogies in the Animal Liberation Movement.” New Political Science 33(3): 311–333. 10.1080/07393148.2011.592021CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kymlicka, Will. 2017. “Social Membership: Animal Law beyond the Property/Personhood Impasse.” Dalhousie Law Journal 40: 123–155.Google Scholar
Kymlicka, Will, and Donaldson, Sue. 2014. “Animal Rights, Multiculturalism and the Left.” Journal of Social Philosophy 45(1): 116–135. 10.1111/josp.2014.45.issue-1CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kymlicka, Will, and Donaldson, Sue. 2015. “Animal Rights and Aboriginal Rights.” In Canadian Perspectives on Animals and the Law, edited by Sankoff, Peter, Black, Vaughan and Sykes, Katie, 159–186. Ontario: Irwin.Google Scholar
Loder, Reed Elizabeth. 2016. “Animal Dignity.” Animal Law 23(1): 1–64.Google Scholar
Macklin, Ruth. 2003. “Human Dignity is a Useless Concept: It Means no More than Respect for Persons or their Autonomy.” BMJ 327(7429): 1419–1420. 10.1136/bmj.327.7429.1419CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maritain, Jacques. (1944) 2012. Christianity and Democracy. San Francisco: Ignatius Press.Google Scholar
McCrudden, Christopher. 2008. “Human Dignity and Judicial Interpretation of Human Rights.” European Journal of International Law 19(4): 655–724. 10.1093/ejil/chn043CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McCrudden, Christopher. 2013. “In pursuit of human dignity: An introduction to current debates.” In Understanding Human Dignity, edited by McCrudden, C., 1–58. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 10.5871/bacad/9780197265642.001.0001CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meyer, Michael. 2001. “The Simple Dignity of Sentient Life: Speciesism and Human Dignity.” Journal of Social Philosophy 32(2): 115–126. 10.1111/0047-2786.00083CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Montford, Kelly. 2016. “Dehumanized Denizens, Displayed Animals: Prison Tourism and the Discourse of the Zoo.” philoSOPHIA 6(1): 73–91. 10.1353/phi.2016.0017CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morawa, Alexander. 2003. “Vulnerability as a Concept of International Human Rights Law.” Journal of International Relations and Development 6(2): 139–155.Google Scholar
Morin, Karen. 2015. “Wildspace: The Cage, the Supermax, and the Zoo.” In Critical Animal Geographies, edited by Gillespie, Kathryn and Collard, Rosemary-Claire, 73–91. Abingdon: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morin, Karen. 2016. “Carceral Space: Prisoners and Animals.” Antipode 48(5): 1317–1336. 10.1111/anti.v48.5CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moyn, Samuel. 2015. Christian Human Rights. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar
Murphy, Ann. 2011. “Corporeal Vulnerability and the New Humanism.” Hypatia 26(3): 575–590. 10.1111/hypa.2011.26.issue-3CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nickel, James. 1987. Making Sense of Human Rights. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Nickel, James. 2014. “Human Rights.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2014 edition). https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rights-human/.Google Scholar
Nussbaum, Martha. 2006. Frontiers of Justice: Disability, Nationality, Species Membership. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Nussbaum, Martha. 2007. “Human Rights and Human Capabilities.” Harvard Law School Human Rights Journal 20: 21.Google Scholar
Perlo, Katherine. 2009. Kinship and Killing: the Animal in World Religions. New York: Columbia University Press. 10.7312/perl14622CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Phillips, Anne. 2015. The Politics of the Human. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 10.1017/CBO9781316145555CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Preece, Rod. 2002. Awe for the Tiger, Love for the Lamb: A Chronicle of Sensibility to Animals. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
Quinn, Gerard, and Arstein-Kerslake, Anna. 2012. “Restoring the ‘Human’ in ‘Human Rights’: Personhood and Doctrinal Innovation in the UN Disability Convention.” In The Cambridge Companion to Human Rights Law, edited by Gearty, C. and Douzinas, C., 36–55. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 10.1017/CCO9781139060875Google Scholar
Regan, Tom. 1983. The Case for Animal Rights. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Robinson, Fiona. 2003. “Human Rights and the Global Politics of Resistance: Feminist Perspectives.” Review of International Studies 29: 161–180.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rosen, Michael. 2012. Dignity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. 10.4159/harvard.9780674065512CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rossello, Diego. 2016a. “All in the (Human) Family? Species Aristocratism in the Return of Human Dignity.” Political Theory: 0090591716668383.Google Scholar
Rossello, Diego. 2016b. ““To be Human, Nonetheless, Remains a Decision”: Humanism as Decisionism in Contemporary Critical Political Theory.” Contemporary Political Theory: 1–20.Google Scholar
Roylance, Christina, Abeyta, Andrew, and Routledge, Clay. 2016. “I am not an Animal but I am a Sexist: Human Distinctiveness, Sexist Attitudes Towards Women, and Perceptions of Meaning in Life.” Feminism & Psychology 26(3): 368–377. 10.1177/0959353516636906CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sangiovanni, Andrea. 2017. Humanity Without Dignity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. 10.4159/9780674977440CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Satz, Ani. 2009. “Animals as Vulnerable Subjects.” Animal Law 16: 65.Google Scholar
Schinkel, Anders. 2008. “Martha Nussbaum on Animal Rights.” Ethics & the Environment 13(1): 41–69. 10.2979/ETE.2008.13.1.41CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sen, Amartya. 2005. “Human Rights and Capabilities.” Journal of Human Development 6(2): 151–166. 10.1080/14649880500120491CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shue, Henry. 1980. Basic rights. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Singer, Peter. 2010. “Speciesism and Moral Status.” Metaphilosophy 40(3): 567–581.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Slobodchikoff, Con. 2012. Chasing Doctor Dolittle: Learning the Language of Animals. New York: St. Martin's Press.Google Scholar
Smith, Laura. 2014, June 20. “Zoos Drive Animals Crazy.” Slate. http://www.slate.com/blogs/wild_things/2014/06/20/animal_madness_zoochosis_stereotypic_behavior_and_problems_with_zoos.html.Google Scholar
Stanescu, James. 2012. “Species Trouble: Judith Butler, Mourning, and the Precarious Lives of Animals.” Hypatia 27(3): 567–582. 10.1111/hypa.2012.27.issue-3CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Suen, Alison. 2015. The Speaking Animal: Ethics, Language and the Human-Animal Divide. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
Taylor, Angus. 2010. “Review of Wesley J. Smith's “A Rat is a Pig is a Dog is a Boy”.” Between the Species 10: 223–236.Google Scholar
Taylor, Chloë. 2008. “The Precarious Lives of Animals.” Philosophy Today 52(1): 60–72. 10.5840/philtoday200852142CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Taylor, Kathy, and Singer, Susanne. 2015. “Diet, Authoritarianism, Social Dominance Orientation, and Predisposition to Prejudice.” British Food Journal 117(7): 1949–1960.Google Scholar
Taylor, Sunuara. 2017. Beasts of Burden: Animal and Disability Liberation. New York: New Press.Google Scholar
Thompson, Kelly, and Gullone, Eleonora. 2003. “Promotion of Empathy and Prosocial Behaviour in Children Through Humane Education.” Australian Psychologist 38(3): 175–182. 10.1080/00050060310001707187CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Turner, Bryan. 2006. Vulnerability and Human Rights. University Park, PA: Penn State Press.Google Scholar
Wacquant, Loïc. 2002. “The Curious Eclipse of Prison Ethnography in the Age of Mass Incarceration.” Ethnography 3(4): 371–397. 10.1177/1466138102003004012CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Waldron, Jeremy. 2010. “The Coxford Lecture Inhuman and Degrading Treatment: The Words Themselves.” The Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence 23(2): 269–286. 10.1017/S0841820900004938CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Waldron, Jeremy. 2012. Dignity, Rank and Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199915439.001.0001CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Werner, M. 2014. “Individual and Collective Dignity.” In The Cambridge Handbook of Human Dignity, edited by Duwell, Marcus, et al., 343–352. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 10.1017/CBO9780511979033CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Willett, Cynthia. 2014. Interspecies Ethics. New York: Columbia University Press. 10.7312/will16776CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williams, Thomas. 2005. Who is my Neighbor? Personalism and the Foundation of Human Rights. Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press.Google Scholar
Zuolo, Federico. 2016. “Dignity and Animals. Does it Make Sense to Apply the Concept of Dignity to all Sentient Beings?” Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 19(5): 1117–1130. 10.1007/s10677-016-9695-8Google Scholar