Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-fscjk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T08:51:18.919Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Canonisation of the Forty English Martyrs: An Ecumenical Dilemma

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 February 2015

Andrew Atherstone
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In October 1970, amidst jubilant celebrations at St Peter's in Rome, Pope Paul VI canonised forty English and Welsh martyrs as saints. Auberon Waugh called it ‘the biggest moment for English Catholicism since Catholic emancipation in 1829’. It marked the culmination of a long campaign which had begun in earnest in the mid-nineteenth century under Cardinals Wiseman and Manning, shortly after the restoration of the Catholic hierarchy. By 1935 nearly two hundred Reformation martyrs had been beatified, but only two of these had been canonised, John Fisher and Thomas More—the first Englishmen to be made saints since John of Bridlington in 1401. After the hiatus of the Second World War, the cause was revived in 1960 seeking the canonisation of another forty English martyrs. All were Roman Catholics executed under the Tudor and Stuart monarchs or the Puritan Commonwealth, ranging from Carthusian monks who fell foul in 1535 of Henry VIII's Act of Supremacy, to seminary priests who were caught up in the ‘Popish Plot’ against Charles II in 1679. All but six of the forty had been hung, drawn and quartered, many of them on the gallows at Tyburn.

Type
Research Article
Information
British Catholic History , Volume 30 , Issue 4 , October 2011 , pp. 573 - 587
Copyright
Copyright © Catholic Record Society 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

I am grateful to Dr. Alana Harris for her comments on a draft of this paper.

1 Waugh, Auberon, ‘For All the (English) Saints’, Spectator, 14 November 1970, p. 596.Google Scholar

2 For the history of the cause, see Molinari, Paolo, ‘The Forty Martyrs of England and Wales’, Clergy Review 55 (October 1970), pp. 759–70.Google Scholar

3 Memorandum from Philip Caraman, 15 January 1960; James Walsh to Paolo Molinari, 18 March 1960, Jesuit Archives, London.

4 Rockett, June, A Gentle Jesuit: Philip Caraman, SJ, 1911—1998 (Leominster: Gracewing, 2004), pp. 128–33.Google Scholar

5 ‘Martyrs’ Memorial’, Times, 24 December 1969, p. 7.

6 See especially, Purdy, William, The Search for Unity: Relations between the Anglican and Roman Catholic Churches from the 1950s to the 1970s (London: Geoffrey Chapman, 1996).Google Scholar

7 ‘Controversial Forty’, Month 1 ns (February 1970), p. 67.

8 Hebblethwaite, Peter, In the Vatican (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1987), pp. 114–15.Google Scholar

9 Hebblethwaite, Peter, ‘The Meanings of Canonisation’, Month 2 ns (October 1970), pp. 104–5.Google Scholar

10 Roger de Wever to John Heenan, 2 March 1970, quoted in Harris, Alana, Transformations in English Catholic Spirituality and Popular Religion 1945—1980 (Oxford University, DPhil thesis, 2008), p. 327,Google Scholar forthcoming as Faith in the Family (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2012).

11 Report by Walsh for the Hierarchy of England and Wales, Low Sunday 1966, Westminster Diocesan Archives [WDA] Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

12 Joseph, A. Munitiz, ‘The Symbolic Forty Martyrs’, New Christian, 19 February 1970, p. 6.Google Scholar

13 ‘The Forty Martyrs of England and Wales’, Westminster Cathedral Chronicle 59 (August 1965), pp. 136–7.

14 Catholic Herald, 30 July 1965, p. 5.

15 Tablet, 25 September 1965, p. 1068.

16 Tablet, 9 October 1965, p. 1132.

17 Walsh to Heenan, 1 November 1965, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

18 Tablet, 21 August 1965, p. 939.

19 Catholic Herald, 3 September 1965, p. 5.

20 Catholic Herald, 26 November 1965, p. 1.

21 Tablet, 4 September 1965, p. 985.

22 Tablet, 14 and 28 August 1965, pp. 915, 963.

23 ‘Proposed Letter from the Hierarchy of England and Wales for Martyrs’ Sunday 1966’ (drafted by Walsh), WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

24 Tablet, 21 March 1970, p. 289.

25 John Brady to Heenan, 15 December 1969, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

26 Tablet, 2 October 1965, p. 1098.

27 O'Dwyer, Michael, ‘Forty Martyrs – First Ecumenists’, Westminster Cathedral Chronicle 55 (August 1961), p. 196.Google Scholar

28 Tablet, 25 September 1965, p. 1068.

29 Heenan to Walsh, 23 October 1965, Jesuit Archives.

30 Waugh, ‘For All the (English) Saints’, p. 596.

31 Quoted in Kay, Hugh, ‘40 Martyrs: Saints this Year?’, Catholic Herald, 11 May 1962, p. 1.Google Scholar

32 Tablet, 3 January 1970, p. 17.

33 Times, 16 December 1969, p. 6.

34 A rare exception is Leonard, Graham, ‘Why I Rejoice over the Canonisation: An Anglican View of the Forty Martyrs’, Catholic Herald, 19 June 1970, p. 3.Google Scholar

35 Universe, 12 January 1962, p.1; 26 January 1962, p.1.

36 Church Times, 23 October 1970, p. 10.

37 Geoffrey Fisher to Heenan, 3 December 1969, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

38 Caraman to Gerald P. O'Hara, 20 February 1963, Jesuit Archives.

39 Caraman and Walsh to the Hierarchy of England and Wales, 4 April 1963, WDA Godfrey Papers, GO2/147.

40 Bernard P. Wall to Heenan, 21 April 1963, WDA Godfrey Papers, GO2/147.

41 Walsh to Igino Cardinale, 4 July 1966, Jesuit Archives.

42 Report by Walsh for the Hierarchy of England and Wales, Low Sunday 1966, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

43 Walsh to Heenan, 31 March 1966, Jesuit Archives.

44 Ramsey, Michael, ‘The Proposed Canonisation of the English and Welsh Martyrs of the Reformation Period’, 8 November 1966, Lambeth Palace Library [LPL], Ramsey Papers vol. 107, fo. 24.Google Scholar

45 Ramsey to Walsh, 8 July 1966, LPL Ramsey Papers vol. 107, fo. 16.

46 Cardinale to Walsh, 11 August 1966, Jesuit Archives.

47 Peter Gumpel to Walsh, 24 July 1966, Jesuit Archives.

48 Walsh to Molinari, 21 July 1966, Jesuit Archives.

49 Walsh to Cardinale, 11 July 1966, Jesuit Archives.

50 Tablet, 29 November 1969, p. 1169.

51 Heenan to Johannes Willebrands, 22 December 1969, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

52 Heenan to Gordon Wheeler, 10 December 1969, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

53 Brian Foley to Walsh, 3 December 1969, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

54 Foley to Heenan, 7 December 1969, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

55 Waugh, Auberon, ‘Ali Baba and the Forty Martyrs’, Spectator, 27 December 1969, p. 892.Google Scholar

56 Foley, Brian, ‘Douai: Seed-Bed of English Martyrs’, Ampleforth Journal 74 (Spring 1969), p. 19.Google Scholar

57 Times, 23 December 1969, p. 7.

58 Times, 27 December 1969, p. 7.

59 Rupp, Gordon, ‘“Catholic” and “Protestant’’, Tablet, 31 January 1970, p. 119.Google Scholar

60 Voyage: Bulletin of the British Council of Churches no. 19 (January / February 1970), p. 7.

61 ‘On Martyrdom’, Ampleforth Journal 75 (Autumn 1970), p. 333.

62 Times, 23 December 1969, p. 7.

63 ‘Pope Paul VI and the Anglican Martyrs’ Shrine, Uganda’, One in Christ 5 (1969), pp. 443–7; Hebblethwaite, Peter, Paul VI: The First Modern Pope (London: Harper Collins, 1993), pp. 535–8.Google Scholar

64 Brown, Douglas, ‘Martyrs into Saints’, Sunday Telegraph, 21 December 1969, p. 12.Google Scholar

65 Memorandum of interview between Ramsey and Enrici, 17 December 1969, LPL Ramsey Papers vol. 168, fos 148–9. For another summary of this interview, see WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

66 Heenan to Tom Burns, 1 December 1969; Heenan to Molinari, 4 December 1969, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

67 Martin D'Arcy to Caraman, 10 December 1969, quoted in Rockett, Gentle Jesuit, p. 219.

68 Tablet, 10 and 31 January 1970, pp. 34, 110.

69 Daily Telegraph, 29 January 1970, p. 18.

70 Clement Tigar to Heenan, 26 January 1970, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

71 Daily Telegraph, 26 January 1970, p. 9.

72 Times, 26 January 1970, p. 10. See also Christian Guardian (edited by Brian Green), 24 and 31 January 1970.

73 English Churchman, 23 January 1970, p. 3.

74 Sir Cyril Black to Heenan, 27 January 1970, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

75 E. Taylor to Heenan, 9 January 1970; W. Corbishley to Heenan, 13 January 1970, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

76 E. McFarland to Heenan, 11 January 1970, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

77 Tablet, 10 January 1970, p. 34.

78 Church Times, 30 January 1970, p. 20.

79 Ramsey memorandum on Willebrands visit, 16 January 1970, LPL Ramsey Papers vol. 188, fo. 9.

80 Willebrands, Johannes, ‘Ecumenism and Martyrdom’, Tablet, 24 January 1970, p. 94.Google Scholar For the full text of the sermon, see LPL Ramsey Papers vol. 188, fos 26–33.

81 Ramsey memorandum on Willebrands visit, 16 January 1970, LPL Ramsey Papers vol. 188, fo. 9.

82 Michael Williams to John K. Drinkall, 6 May 1970, National Archives, Foreign and Common-wealth Office Papers, FCO 33/1248.

83 W.K.K. White to R.A. Burroughs, 12 May 1970, National Archives, FCO 33/1248.

84 Memorandum from W.K.K. White, 20 May 1970, National Archives, FCO 33/1248.

85 Memorandum from J.K. Drinkall, 13 May 1970; W.K.K. White to J.A. Snellgrove, 8 October 1970, National Archives, FCO 33/1248. Memoranda of discussion with John Hewitt (prime minister's appointments secretary), 27 and 28 May 1970, LPL Ramsey Papers vol. 188, fos 78, 81.

86 A.L. Kensit to Edward Heath, 16 October 1970; W.J. Cameron to Edward Heath, 20 November 1970, National Archives, FCO 33/1248.

87 For Smythe's statement, see Church Times, 23 October 1970, p. 1.

88 A.L. Kensit to Ramsey, 16 September 1970; Ramsey to John Moorman, 15 October 1970, LPL Ramsey Papers vol. 188, fos 119, 132.

89 Times, 28 October 1970, p. 4.

90 ‘A Meeting of the Ways in Oxford’, Tablet, 31 October 1970, pp. 1062–3.

91 ‘Cardinal Heenan's Address to Pope Paul’, in The Canonization of the Forty English and Welsh Martyrs: A Commemoration (London: Office of the Vice-Postulation, 1971), p. 69.Google Scholar

92 ‘Discourse of His Eminence Cardinal Heenan’, in Canonization of the Forty English and Welsh Martyrs, pp. 104–5.

93 Hebblethwaite, Peter, ‘St Peter's: A Day to Remember’, Tablet, 31 October 1970, p. 1047.Google Scholar

94 Tablet, 17 January 1970, p. 50.

95 John Dyson to Heenan, 27 December 1970; Heenan to Dyson, 15 January 1971, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

96 Hester Paton to Heenan, 21 September 1970, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

97 Geoffrey Houghton-Brown to Heenan, 18 September 1970, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

98 Times, 1 February 1975, p. 16.

99 ‘The Canonization Homily of Pope Paul VI’, in Canonization of the Forty English and Welsh Martyrs, pp. 58, 63.

100 ‘Canonization Homily, p. 64.

101 ‘The Holy Father's Address After the Ceremony’, in Canonization of the Forty English and Welsh Martyrs, p. 66.

102 Reflections by Heenan for Rome correspondent of the Catholic Herald, 25 October 1970, WDA Heenan Papers, HE1/E7.

103 Memorandum of conversation between Ramsey and Cardinal Suenens, 16 October 1970, LPL Ramsey Papers vol. 188, fo. 134; Williams to J.R. Satterthwaite, 10 June 1970; Satterthwaite to Williams, 15 June 1970, National Archives, FCO 33/1248.

104 Church Times, 30 October 1970, p. 10; ‘The Canonisation’, Ampleforth Journal 76 (Spring 1971), p. 94.

105 Anglican-Roman Catholic International Commission, The Final Report (London: SPCK /Catholic Truth Society, 1982), p. 91.