Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T07:28:24.222Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Talk like an Egyptian? Epistemological problems with the synthesis of a vocal sound from the mummified remains of Nesyamun and racial designations in mummy studies

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 May 2021

Uroš Matić
Uroš Matić*
Affiliation:
Österreichisches Archäologisches Institut, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Vienna, Austria
*
Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The paper examines epistemological problems behind a recent study claiming to provide a synthesis of a vocal sound from the mummified remains of a man named Nesyamun and behind racial designations in Egyptian mummy studies more generally. So far, responses in the media and academia concentrated on the ethical problems of these studies, whereas their theoretical and methodological backgrounds have been rarely addressed or mentioned only in passing. It seems that the media reaction has targeted the synthesis of a sound rather than other, equally problematic, assumptions found in Egyptian mummy studies. By focusing on the epistemological problems, it will be demonstrated that the issues of greatest concern are endemic to a general state of a considerable part of the discipline of Egyptology and its unreflective engagement with the material remains of the past, especially human remains.

Keywords

NesyamunEgyptologymummiesscientific racismethicsepistemology
Type
Articles
Information
Archaeological Dialogues , Volume 28 , Issue 1 , June 2021 , pp. 37 - 49
Check for updates
Copyright
© The Author(s) 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Assmann, J., 2005: Death and salvation in ancient Egypt, Ithaca and London.Google Scholar
Aston, D., and Bietak, M., 2017: Nubians in the Nile delta. A propos Avaris and Peru-nefer, in Spencer, N. and Stevens, A. (eds), The New Kingdom in Nubia. Lived experience, pharaonic control and indigenous traditions, Leuven (British Museum Publications on Egypt and Sudan 3), 489–522.Google Scholar
Babić, S., 2018: Metaarheologija, Belgrade.Google Scholar
Bednarski, A., Dodson, A. and Ikram, S., 2020: A history of world Egyptology, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Beck, T., 2016: Perspektivenwechsel. Eine Reflexion archäologischen Arbeitens in Ägypten. Die lokalen Grabungsarbeiter des Asyut Project, Wiesbaden (The Asyut Project 8).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bennett, T., 2013: The birth of the museum. History, theory, politics, London and New York.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bennett, T., 2018: Museums, power, knowledge. Selected essays. London and New York.Google Scholar
Bhabha, H.K., 1990: Introduction. Narrating the nation, in Bhabha, H.K. (ed.), Nation and narration, London, 1–7.Google Scholar
Candelora, D., 2018: Entangled in orientalism. How the Hyksos became a race, Journal of Egyptian history 11(1–2), 45–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carruthers, W., 2014: Histories of Egyptology. Interdisciplinary measures, London and New York.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Challis, D., 2014: The archaeology of race. The eugenic ideas of Francis Galton and Flinders Petrie, London.Google Scholar
Clarke, D., 1973: Archaeology. The loss of innocence, Antiquity 47(185), 6–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Colla, E., 2007: Conflicted antiquities. Egyptology, egyptomania, Egyptian modernity, Durham, NC.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cox, S.L., 2015: A critical look at mummy CT scanning, Anatomical record (Hoboken) 298(6), 1099–1110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cuno, J., 2014: Culture war. The case against repatriating museum artifacts, Foreign affairs 93(6), 119–126.Google Scholar
Day, J., 2014: ‘Thinking makes it so’. Reflections on the ethic of displaying Egyptian mummies, Papers on anthropology 23(1), 29–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
David, A.R., 2008: The background of the Manchester Mummy Project, in David, R.A. (ed.), Egyptian mummies and modern science, Cambridge, 3–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
David, A.R., and Tapp, E. (eds), 1992: The mummy’s tale. The scientific and medical investigation of Natsef-Amun, priest in the temple at Karnak, London.Google Scholar
Díaz-Andreu, M., and Champion, T. (eds), 1996: Nationalism and archaeology in Europe, London and New York.Google Scholar
Evison, M.P., 2004: Review of Making faces – using forensic and archaeological evidence by John Prag and Richard Neave (2nd edition), Bulletin of the Royal College of Pathologists 126, 59.Google Scholar
Falk, J.H., Dierking, L.D. and Foutz, S. (eds.), 2007: In principle, in practice. Museums as learning institutions, Plymouth.Google Scholar
Foucault, M., 1995: Discipline & punish. The birth of the prison, New York.Google Scholar
Gertzen, T.L., 2017: Einführung in die Wissenschaftsgeschichte der Ägyptologie, Berlin.Google Scholar
Gertzen, T.L., 2020: Some remarks on the ‘de-colonization’ of Egyptology, Göttinger Miszellen 261, 189–203.Google Scholar
Glithero-West, L., 2019: The conjuror’s greatest show. Belzoni and the Egyptian Hall, Journal of history and cultures 10, 89–121.Google Scholar
Hakenbeck, S.E., 2019: Genetics, archaeology and the far right. An unholy trinity, World archaeology 51, 517–527.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hamilakis, Y., 2013: Archaeology and the senses. Human experience, memory, and affect, Cambridge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hodder, I., 1982: Theoretical archaeology. A reactionary view, in Hodder, I. (ed.), Symbolic and structural archaeology, Cambridge, 1–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hornung, E., Krauss, R. and Warburton, D.A. (eds), 2006: Ancient Egyptian chronology, Leiden and Boston (Handbook of Oriental Studies 83).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Howard, D.M., Schofield, J., Fletcher, J., Baxter, K., Iball, G.R. and Buckley, S.A., 2020: Synthesis of a vocal sound from the 3,000 year old mummy, Nesyamun ‘True of voice’, Nature. Scientific reports, 23 January 2020, at www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-56316-y.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ikram, S., 2011: Collecting and repatriating Egypt’s past. Toward a new nationalism, in Silverman, H. (ed.), Contested cultural heritage. Religion, nationalism, erasure, and exclusion in a global world, New York, 141–154.Google Scholar
Jeffreys, D. (ed.), 2007: Views of ancient Egypt since Napoleon Bonaparte. Imperialism, colonialism and modern appropriations, London and New York.Google Scholar
Jenkins, T., 2011: Contesting human remains in museum collections. The crisis of cultural authority, London and New York.Google Scholar
Johnson, M., 2020: Archaeological theory. An introduction, 3rd edn, Oxford.Google Scholar
Jones, S., 1997: The archaeology of ethnicity. Constructing identities in the past and present, London and New York.Google Scholar
Kilani, M., 2019: Vocalisation in group writing. A new proposal, Berlin, Hamburg and Vienna (Lingua Aegyptia Studia Monographica 20).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kohl, P.L., and Fawcett, C. (eds), 1995: Nationalism, politics, and the practice of archaeology, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Lakomy, K., 2016: ‘Der Löwe auf dem Schlachtfeld’. Das Grab KV 36 und die Bestattung des Maiherperi im Tal der Könige, Wiesbaden.Google Scholar
Langer, C., 2017: The informal colonialism of Egyptology. From the French expedition to the security state, in Woons, M. and Weier, S. (eds), Critical epistemologies of global politics, Bristol, 182–202.Google Scholar
Lupton, C., 2003: Mummymania for the masses. Is Egyptology cursed by the mummy’s curse?, in MacDonald, S. and Rice, M. (eds), Consuming ancient Egypt, Walnut Creek, 23–46.Google Scholar
MacDonald, S., and Rice, M. (eds), 2003: Consuming ancient Egypt, Walnut Creek.Google Scholar
Matić, U., 2014: ‘Nubian’ archers in Avaris. A study of culture-historical reasoning in archaeology of Egypt, Etnoantropološki problemi (Issues in ethnology and anthropology) 9(3), 697–721.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Matić, U., 2018a: De-colonizing historiography and archaeology of ancient Egypt and Nubia, part 1. Scientific racism, Journal of Egyptian history 11, 19–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Matić, U., 2018b: ‘Execration’ of Nubians in Avaris. A case of mistaken ethnic identity and hidden archaeological theory, Journal of Egyptian history 11(1–2), 87–112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Matić, U. , 2018c: They were like lions roaring upon the mountain-crests. Soundscapes of war in New Kingdom Egypt, in Incordino, I. et al. (eds), Current research in Egyptology 2017. Proceedings of the Eighteenth Annual Symposium, Oxford, 103–115.Google Scholar
Matić, U., 2020: Ethnic identities in the land of the pharaohs, Cambridge (Elements – Ancient Egypt in Context).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meskell, L. (ed.), 1998: Archaeology under fire. Nationalism, politics and heritage in the Eastern Mediterranean and the Middle East, London and New York.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meskell, L., 1999: Archaeologies of social life. Age, sex, class et cetera in Ancient Egypt, Oxford.Google Scholar
Moreno García, J.C., 2014: The cursed discipline? The peculiarities of Egyptology at the turn of the twenty-first century, in Carruthers, W. (ed.), Histories of Egyptology. Interdisciplinary measures, London, 50–63.Google Scholar
Naujoks, A-S., and Stelling, J., 2018: Einleitung, in Naujoks, A.-S. and Stelling, J. (eds), Von der Quelle zur Theorie. Über das Verhältnis zwischen Objektivität und Subjektivität in den historischen Wissenschaften, Leiden, 9–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nielsen, N., 2020: Egyptomaniacs. How we became obsessed with ancient Egypt, Yorkshire.Google Scholar
Osburn, W., 1828: An account of an Egyptian mummy, presented to the museum of the Leeds Philosophical and Literary Society, by the late John Blayds, Esq., Leeds.Google Scholar
Prag, J., and Neave, R., 1997: Making faces. Using forensic and archaeological evidence, London.Google Scholar
Price, C.R., 2020: Golden mummies of Egypt. Interpreting identities from the Graeco-Roman period, Manchester.Google Scholar
Quirke, S., 2010: Hidden hands. Egyptian workforces in Petrie excavation archives, 1880–1924, Bristol.Google Scholar
Redford, D.B., 1979: Egyptology and history, in Weeks, K. (ed.), Egyptology and the social sciences. Five studies, Cairo, 1–20.Google Scholar
Reid, D.M., 2003: Whose pharaohs? Archaeology, museums, and Egyptian national identity from Napoleon to World War I, Berkeley.Google Scholar
Riggs, C., 2014: Unwrapping ancient Egypt, London.Google Scholar
Riggs, C., 2016: Beautiful burials, beautiful skulls. The aesthetics of the Egyptian mummy, British journal of aesthetics 56 (3), 247–263.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Riggs, C., 2018: Loose bodies. Reserve collections, curatorial reservations, and the ancient Egyptian dead, in Brusius, M. and Singh, K. (eds), Museum storage and meaning. Tales from the crypt, London and New York, 253–262.Google Scholar
Riggs, C., 2020: We know it intimately. A review of A world beneath the sands: Adventurers and archaeologists in the golden age of Egyptology by Toby Wilkinson, Picador, 510 pp., £25, October, 978 1 5098 5870 5. London review of books 42(20), at www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v42/n20/christina-riggs/we-know-it-intimately.Google Scholar
Saini, A., 2019: Superior. The return of race science, London.Google Scholar
Schuenemann, V.J., Peltzer, A., Welte, B., van Pelt, W.P., Molak, M., Wang, C.C., Furtwängler, A., Urban, C., Reiter, E., Nieselt, K., Teßmann, B., Francken, M., Harvati, K., Haak, W., Schiffels, S. and Krause, J., 2017: Ancient Egyptian mummy genomes suggest an increase of sub-Saharan African ancestry in post-Roman periods, Nature communications 8, www.nature.com/articles/ncomms15694.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Sitch, B., 2015: Nesyamun or Natsef-amun, the Leeds mummy, in Cardin, M. (ed.), Mummies around the world. An encyclopedia of mummies in history, religion, and popular culture, Oxford, 327–329.Google Scholar
Sonbol, H., 2018: Identitätsbildung durch kulturelles Erbe. Zur Instrumentalisierung des pharaonischen Kulturerbes in ägyptischen Unterrichtsmaterialien, Zeitschrift für Außen- und Sicherheitspolitik 11, 289–304.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stantis, C., Kharobi, A., Maaranen, N., Nowell, G.M., Bietak, M., Prell, S. and Schutkowski, H., 2020: Who were the Hyksos? Challenging traditional narratives using strontium isotope (87Sr/86Sr) analysis of human remains from ancient Egypt, Plos one 15 (7), e0235414, at https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0235414.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Thompson, J., 2015: Wonderful things. A history of Egyptology 1. From antiquity to 1881, Cairo and New York.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tilley, C., 1989: Archaeology as socio-political action in the present, in Pinsky, V. and Wylie, A. (eds), Critical traditions in contemporary archaeology. Essays in the philosophy, history and socio-politics of archaeology, Cambridge, 104–116.Google Scholar
Tringham, R., 1991: Households with faces. The challenge of gender in prehistoric architectural remains, in Gero, J. and Conkey, M. (eds), Engendering archaeology. Women and prehistory, Oxford, 93–131.Google Scholar
Voss, S., 2012: The 1925 demand of the return of the Nefertiti bust. A German perspective, in Kampp-Seyfried, F. (ed.), In the light of Amarna. 100 years of the Nefertiti discovery, Berlin, 460–468.Google Scholar
Wassell, B., 2008: The Coffin of Nesyamun, the ‘Leeds mummy’ (LEEDM. D.1960.426), Leeds.Google Scholar
Wilkinson, T., 2020: A world beneath the sands. Adventurers and archaeologists in the golden age of Egyptology, London.Google Scholar
Williams, F.E., Belcher, R. L. and Armeelagos, G.J., 2005: Forensic misclassification of ancient Nubian crania. Implications for assumptions about human variation, Current anthropology 46(2), 340–346.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wood, M., 1998: The use of the pharaonic past in modern Egyptian nationalism, Journal of the American Research Center in Egypt 35, 179–196.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zakrzewski, S., Shortland, A. and Rowland, J., 2016: Science in the study of ancient Egypt, London and New York.Google Scholar