Element contents
Conscientious Objection in Medicine
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 12 March 2024
Summary
The Element examines ethical and conceptual issues about conscientious objection in medicine. Concepts analyzed include conscientious objection, conscientious provision, conscience, moral complicity, and moral integrity. Several ongoing ethical controversies are identified and critically analyzed. One is a disagreement about whether conscientious objection is compatible with physicians' professional obligations. The Element argues that incompatibilists fail to offer a justifiable specification of professional obligations that supports their position. The Element also argues that a challenge for compatibilists who support a reason-giving requirement is to specify justifiable and unambiguous criteria for reviewing objectors' reasons. Arguments for and against requirements to inform and refer patients are critically analyzed, and an alternative, context-dependent requirement is offered. Another subject of controversy is about the justifiability of asymmetry between responses to conscientious objectors and conscientious providers. Typically, only the former receive accommodation. The Element critically examines arguments for asymmetry and maintains that none provides a convincing justification.
- Type
- Element
- Information
- Online ISBN: 9781009076081Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication: 11 April 2024
References
American Medical Association Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs [AMA CEJA]. Modification of Ethics Policy to Ensure Inclusion for Transgender Physicians, Medical Students, and Patients. Report of the Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs, CEJA Report 2-I-07, 2007. https://bit.ly/3Os5G56.Google Scholar
American Medical Association Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs Code of Medical Ethics. Chicago, IL: American Medical Association, 2017.Google Scholar
Annas, George J. Transferring the Ethical Hot Potato. Hastings Center Report 17 (1987): 20–21.Google ScholarPubMed
Arras, John D. A Method in Search of a Purpose: The Internal Morality of Medicine. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 26 (2001): 643–62.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Ashford, Elizabeth. Utilitarianism, Integrity, and Partiality. Journal of Philosophy 97 (2000): 421–39.Google Scholar
Bayles, Michael D. A Problem of Clean Hands: Refusal to Provide Professional Services. Social Theory and Practice 5 (1979): 165–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beauchamp, Tom L., and Childress, James F.. Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Eighth ed. New York: Oxford University Press, 2019.Google ScholarPubMed
Ben-Moshe, Nir. The Truth Behind Conscientious Objection in Medicine. Journal of Medical Ethics 45 (2019): 404–10.Google ScholarPubMed
Ben-Moshe, Nir Conscientious Objection in Medicine: Making It Public. HEC Forum 33 (2021): 269–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bigelow, John, and Pargettre, Robert. Integrity and Autonomy. American Philosophical Quarterly 44 (2007): 39–49.Google Scholar
Blustein, Jeffrey. Doing What the Patient Orders: Maintaining Integrity in the Doctor–Patient Relationship. Bioethics 7 (1993): 289–314.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Boorse, Christopher. Concepts of Health and Disease. In Handbook of the Philosophy of Science, edited by Gifford, Fred, 13–64. Oxford: Elsevier, 2011.Google Scholar
Brock, Dan. Conscientious Refusal by Physicians and Pharmacists: Who Is Obligated to Do What, and Why? Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 29 (2008): 187–200.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brownlee, Kimberley. Conscience and Conviction: The Case for Civil Disobedience. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brummett, Abram L. Should Positive Claims of Conscience Receive the Same Protection As Negative Claims of Conscience? Clarifying the Asymmetry Debate. Journal of Clinical Ethics 31 (2020): 136–42.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Buetow, Stephen, and Gauld, Natalie. Conscientious Objection and Person‑Centered Care. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 39 (2018): 143–55.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Butler, Joseph. Five Sermons Preached at the Rolls Chapel and a Dissertation upon the Nature of Virtue. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing Company, 1983.Google Scholar
Byrnes, Jeffrey. The Problem of “Core Moral Beliefs” as the Ground of Conscientious Objection. HEC Forum 33 (2021): 291–305.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Calhoun, Cheshire. Standing for Something. Journal of Philosophy 92 (1995): 235–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Card, Robert F. Conscientious Objection and Emergency Contraception. American Journal of Bioethics 7 (2007): 8–14.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Card, Robert F. Conscientious Objection, Emergency Contraception, and Public Policy. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 36 (2011): 53–58.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Card, Robert F. Reasonability and Conscientious Objection in Medicine: A Reply to Marsh and an Elaboration of the Reason-Giving Requirement. Bioethics 28 (2014): 320–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Card, Robert F. In Defence of Medical Tribunals and the Reasonability Standard for Conscientious Objection in Medicine. Journal of Medical Ethics 42 (2016): 73–75.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Card, Robert F. Reasons, Reasonability and Establishing Conscientious Objector Status in Medicine. Journal of Medical Ethics 43 (2017a): 222–25.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Card, Robert F. The Inevitability of Assessing Reasons in Debates about Conscientious Objection in Medicine. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 26 (2017b): 82–96.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Card, Robert F. A New Theory of Conscientious Objection in Medicine: Justification and Reasonability. New York: Routledge, 2020.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chervenak, Frank A., and McCullough, Laurence B.. The Ethics of Direct and Indirect Referral for Termination of Pregnancy. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 199 (2008): 232e1–32e3.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Childress, James F. Civil Disobedience, Conscientious Objection, and Evasive Noncompliance: A Framework for the Analysis and Assessment of Illegal Actions in Health Care. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 10 (1985): 63–83.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Clarke, Steve. Some Difficulties Involved in Locating the Truth behind Conscientious Objection in Medicine. Journal of Medical Ethics 45 (2019): 679–80.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Committee on Doctrine of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care Services. 6th edition, 2018. https://bit.ly/42uz6VU.Google Scholar
Cowley, Christopher. Conscientious Objection and Healthcare in the UK: Why Tribunals Are Not the Answer. Journal of Medical Ethics 42 (2016a): 69–72.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Cowley, Christopher A Defence of Conscientious Objection in Medicine: A Reply to Schuklenk and Savulescu. Bioethics 30 (2016b): 358–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cowley, Christopher Conscientious Objection in Healthcare and the Duty to Refer. Journal of Medical Ethics 43 (2017): 207–12.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Cox, Damian, Caze, Marguerite La, and Levine, Michael. Integrity. In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta, 2013. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/integrity/.Google Scholar
Curlin, Farr, and Tollefsen, Christopher. The Way of Medicine: Ethics and the Healing Profession. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 2021.Google Scholar
Daniels, Norman. Just Health: Meeting Health Needs Fairly. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008.Google Scholar
Davis, Nancy. The Priority of Avoiding Harm. In Killing and Letting Die, edited by Steinbock, Bonnie, 172–214. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1980.Google Scholar
Dickens, Bernard M., and Cook, Rebecca J.. Conscientious Commitment to Women’s Health. International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics 113 (2011): 163–66.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Durland, Spencer L. The Case against Institutional Conscience. Notre Dame Law Review 86 (2011): 1655–86.Google Scholar
Feinberg, Joel. The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law: Harm to Others. Vol. 1. New York: Oxford University Press, 1984.Google Scholar
Fernandez Lynch, Holly. Conflicts of Conscience in Health Care: An Institutional Compromise. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 2008.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fernandez Lynch, Holly, and Stahl, Ronit Y.. Opinion, Protecting Conscientious Providers of Health Care. New York Times, January 26, 2018.Google Scholar
Forrow, Lachlan, Arnold, Robert M., and Parker, Lisa S.. Preventive Ethics: Expanding the Horizons of Clinical Ethics. Journal of Clinical Ethics 4 (1993): 287–94.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Freud, Sigmund. Civilization and Its Discontents. Translated by James Strachey. New York: W. W. Norton & Co., 1962.Google Scholar
Fritz, Kyle. Unjustified Asymmetry: Positive Claims of Conscience and Heartbeat Bills. American Journal of Bioethics 21 (2021): 46–59.Google ScholarPubMed
General Medical Council. Good Medical Practice, 2024. www.gmc-uk.org/-/media/documents/gmp-2024-final---english_pdf-102607294.pdf.Google Scholar
Giubilini, Alberto. The Paradox of Conscientious Objection and the Anemic Concept of “Conscience”: Downplaying the Role of Moral Integrity in Health Care. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 24 (2014): 159–85.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Giubilini, Alberto Objection to Conscience: An Argument against Conscience Exemptions in Healthcare. Bioethics 31 (2017): 400–08.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Giubilini, Alberto Conscientious Objection in Healthcare: Neither a Negative nor a Positive Right. Journal of Clinical Ethics 31 (2020): 146–53.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Glasber, A. L., Eriksson, S., and Norberg, A.. Burnout and “Stress of Conscience” among Healthcare Personnel. Journal of Advanced Nursing 57 (2007): 392–403.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gomez, , Javiera Perez. Mcleod’s Conscience in Reproductive Health Care: Fiduciary Duties beyond Reproductive Care, the Role of the Pharmacist, and the Harms and Wrongs of Conscientious Refusals. International Journal of Feminist Approaches to Bioethics 15 (2022): 137–43.Google Scholar
Guttmacher Institute. An Overview of Abortion Laws, August 31, 2023. www.guttmacher.org/state-policy/explore/overview-abortion-laws.Google Scholar
Halfon, Mark S. Integrity: A Philosophical Inquiry. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press, 1989.Google Scholar
Harris, Lisa H. Recognizing Conscience in Abortion Provision. New England Journal of Medicine 367 (2012): 981–83.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hepler, Charles D. Balancing Pharmacists’ Conscientious Objections with Their Duty to Serve. Journal of the American Pharmacists Association 45 (2005): 434–36.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hill, Thomas E. Jr. Four Conceptions of Conscience. In Integrity and Conscience (Nomos Xl), edited by Shapiro, Ian and Adams, Robert, 13–52. New York: New York University Press, 1998.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hughes, Jonathan A. Conscientious Objection in Healthcare: Why Tribunals Might Be the Answer. Journal of Medical Ethics 43 (2017): 213–17.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Joffe, Carole E. Doctors of Conscience: The Struggle to Provide Abortion Before and After Roe v. Wade. Boston, MA: Beacon Press, 1995.Google Scholar
Kant, Immanuel. The Metaphysics of Morals. Translated by Mary Gregor. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kant, Immanuel Lectures on Ethics. Translated by Peter Heath. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kantymir, Lori, and McLeod, Carolyn. Justification for Conscience Exemptions in Health Care. Bioethics 28 (2014): 16–23.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kim, Eric J., and Ferguson, Kyle. Does Medicine Need to Accommodate Positive Conscientious Objections to Morally Self-Correct? American Journal of Bioethics 21 (2021): 74–76.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Langston, Douglas C. Conscience and Other Virtues. University Park, PA: The Pennsylvia State University Press, 2001.Google Scholar
Lawrence, Ryan E., and Curlin, Farr A.. Clash of Definitions: Controversies about Conscience in Medicine. American Journal of Bioethics 7 (2007): 10–14.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Little, Margaret, and Drapkin Lyerly, Anne. The Limits of Conscientious Refusal: A Duty to Ensure Access. American Medical Association Journal of Ethics 15 (2013): 257–62.Google ScholarPubMed
Magelssen, M. When Should Conscientious Objection Be Accepted? Journal of Medical Ethics 38 (2012): 18–21.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Malm, H. M. Between the Horns of the Negative–Positive Duty Debate. Philosophical Studies 61 (1991): 187–210.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marsh, Jason. Conscientious Refusals and Reason-Giving. Bioethics 28 (2014): 313–19.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
McConnell, Doug, and Card, Robert F.. Public Reason in Justifications of Conscientious Objection in Health Care. Bioethics 33 (2019): 625–32.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
McLeod, Carolyn. Self-Trust and Reproductive Autonomy. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2002.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McLeod, Carolyn Trust. In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman, 2020a. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/trust/.Google Scholar
McLeod, Carolyn Conscience in Reproductive Health Care: Prioritizing Patient Interests. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2020b.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McLeod, Carolyn Justified Asymmetries: Positive and Negative Claims to Conscience in Reproductive Health Care. American Journal of Bioethics 21 (2021): 60–62.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Meyers, Christopher, and Woods, Robert D. An Obligation to Provide Abortion Services: What Happens When Physicians Refuse? Journal of Medical Ethics 22 (1996): 115–20.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Meyers, Christopher, and Woods, Robert D Conscientious Objection? Yes, but Make Sure It Is Genuine. American Journal of Bioethics 7 (2007): 19–20.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Miller, Franklin G., and Brody, Howard. The Internal Morality of Medicine: An Evolutionary Perspective. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 26 (2001): 581–99.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Minerva, Francesca. Conscientious Objection in Italy. Journal of Medical Ethics 41 (2015): 170–73.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Narveson, Jan. Positive/Negative: Why Bother? Tulane Studies in Philosophy XXXIII (1985): 51–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nussbaum, Martha C. Liberty of Conscience: In Defense of America’s Tradition of Religious Equality. New York: Basic Books, 2008.Google Scholar
Paris, Francesca. Bans on Transition Care for Young People Spread across U.S. New York Times, April 17, 2023.Google Scholar
Pellegrino, Edmund D. The Internal Morality of Clinical Medicine: A Paradigm for the Ethics of the Helping and Healing Professions. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 26 (2001): 559–79.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rentmeester, Christy A. Moral Damage to Health Care Professionals and Trainees: Legalism and Other Consequences for Patients and Colleagues. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 33 (2008): 27–43.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rhodes, Rosamond. The Ethical Standard of Care. American Journal of Bioethics 6 (2006): 76–78.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rhodes, Rosamond The Truted Doctor: Medical Ethics and Professionalism. New York: Oxford University Press, 2020.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Robinson, Michael. Voluntarily Chosen Roles and Conscientious Objection in Health Care. Journal of Medical Ethics 48 (2022): 718–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Saad, Toni C. Conscientious Objection: Unmasking the Impartial Spectator. Journal of Medical Ethics 45 (2019): 676–77.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Savulescu, Julian. Conscientious Objection in Medicine. British Medical Journal 332 (2006): 294–97.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Savulescu, Julian, and Schuklenk, Udo. Doctors Have No Right to Refuse Medical Assistance in Dying, Abortion, or Contraception. Bioethics 31 (2017): 162–70.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Schneider, Jason S., and Levin, Saul. Uneasy Partners: The Lesbian and Gay Health Care Community and the AMA. Journal of the American Medical Association 282 (1999): 1287–88.Google ScholarPubMed
Schuklenk, Udo, and Smalling, Ricardo. Why Medical Professionals Have No Moral Claim to Conscientious Objection Accommodation in Liberal Democracies. Journal of Medical Ethics 43 (2017): 234–40.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Sepper, Elizabeth. Taking Conscience Seriously. Virginia Law Review 98 (2012): 1501–75.Google Scholar
Sibley, Muford Q., and Jacob, Philip E.. Conscription of Conscience: The American State and the Conscientious Objector, 1940–1947. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1952.Google Scholar
Singer, Marcus G. Negative and Positive Duties. Philosophical Quarterly 15 (1965): 97–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Skorupski, John. Conscience. In The Routledge Companion to Ethics, edited by Skorupski, John, 550–61. London: Routledge, 2010.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smalling, Ricardo, and Schuklenk, Udo. Against the Accommodation of Subjective Healthcare Provider Beliefs in Medicine: Counteracting Supporters of Conscientious Objector Accommodation Arguments. Journal of Medical Ethics 43 (2017): 253–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stahl, Ronit Y., and Emanuel, Ezekiel J.. Physicians, Not Conscripts – Conscientious Objection in Health Care. New England Journal of Medicine 376 (2017): 1380–85.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Stein, Rob. Pharmacists’ Rights at Front of New Debate: Because of Beliefs, Some Refuse to Fill Birth Control Prescriptions. Washington Post, March 28, 2005, 1.Google Scholar
Sulmasy, Daniel P. What Is Conscience and Why Is Respect for It So Important? Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 29 (2008): 135–49.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Sulmasy, Daniel P. Conscience, Tolerance, and Pluralism in Health Care. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 40 (2019): 507–21.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Veatch, Robert M. The Impossibility of a Morality Internal to Medicine. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 26 (2001): 621–42.Google ScholarPubMed
Wear, Stephen, LaGaipa, Susan, and Logue, Gerald. Toleration of Moral Diversity and the Conscientious Refusal by Physicians to Withdraw Life-Sustaining Treatments. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 19 (1994): 147–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
White, Douglas B., and Brody, Baruch. Would Accommodating Some Conscientious Objections by Physicians Promote Quality in Medical Care? Journal of the American Medical Association 305 (2011): 1804–05.Google ScholarPubMed
Wicclair, Mark. Negative and Positive Claims of Conscience. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 18 (2009): 14–22.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wicclair, Mark Conscientious Objection in Health Care: An Ethical Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011a.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wicclair, Mark Conscientious Refusals by Hospitals and Emergency Contraception. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 20 (2011b): 130–38.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wicclair, Mark Conscience. In International Encyclopedia of Ethics, edited by LaFollette, Hugh. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, 2013. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781444367072.wbiee758.Google Scholar
Wicclair, Mark Conscientious Objection. In Encyclopedia of Global Bioethics, edited by ten Have, Henk, 729–40. Cham: Springer, 2014a.Google Scholar
Wicclair, Mark Managing Conscientious Objection in Health Care Institutions. HEC Forum 26 (2014b): 267–83.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wicclair, Mark Commentary: Special Issue on Conscientious Objection. HEC Forum 33 (2021): 307–24.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wildes, Kevin Wm. Institutional Identity, Integrity, and Conscience. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 7 (1997): 413–19.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wilkinson, Dominic J. C. Positive or Negative? Consistency and Inconsistency in Claims of Conscience. Journal of Clinical Ethics 31 (2020): 143–45.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Williams, Bernard. Integrity. In Utilitarianism: For and Against, edited by Smart, J. J. C and Williams, Bernard, 108–17. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1973.Google Scholar
- 4
- Cited by