Book contents
- Protection from Refuge
- Cambridge Asylum and Migration Studies
- Protection from Refuge
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Preface
- Acknowledgements
- Abbreviations
- 1 Journeys in Search of Refuge
- 2 Refuge as a Concept and a Place
- 3 Using Human and Refugee Rights to Resist Encampment
- 4 Using Human Rights Law to Travel in Search of Refuge in Europe
- 5 Direct Challenges to Regional Containment Instruments
- 6 Seeking Refuge as a Palestinian Refugee
- 7 Resisting the Prospect of Refuge in an IDP Camp
- 8 Elusive Refuge
- Index
6 - Seeking Refuge as a Palestinian Refugee
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 17 March 2022
- Protection from Refuge
- Cambridge Asylum and Migration Studies
- Protection from Refuge
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Preface
- Acknowledgements
- Abbreviations
- 1 Journeys in Search of Refuge
- 2 Refuge as a Concept and a Place
- 3 Using Human and Refugee Rights to Resist Encampment
- 4 Using Human Rights Law to Travel in Search of Refuge in Europe
- 5 Direct Challenges to Regional Containment Instruments
- 6 Seeking Refuge as a Palestinian Refugee
- 7 Resisting the Prospect of Refuge in an IDP Camp
- 8 Elusive Refuge
- Index
Summary
In Chapter 6, I examine protection from refuge claims made by Palestinian refugees. Some Palestinian refugees leave an UNRWA area of operation (Jordon, Lebanon, Syria, the Gaza strip, East Jerusalem or the West Bank) and seek refugee protection elsewhere. In making these journeys, they confront article 1D of the Refugee Convention, which provides that Palestinian refugees are excluded from protection under the Refugee Convention unless their UN protection or assistance has ceased for any reason. When decision-makers reflect on the nature of Palestinian refugeehood and expand their juridical borders, they come close to setting a broad scope of refuge for Palestinian refugees and characterising refuge as a right, duty and act of international solidarity. However, most decision-makers determine these claims in a way that truncates the scope of refuge, positions refuge not as a right but as an act of benevolence and entrenches article 1D as a containment mechanism. This inhibits Palestinian refugees’ ability to find a place of refuge outside the UNRWA region unless their circumstances are deemed exceptional in some way. A feminist analysis of the case law indicates that the approach to exceptionality in article 1D jurisprudence creates additional barriers for female Palestinian refugees.
Keywords
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Protection from RefugeFrom Refugee Rights to Migration Management, pp. 149 - 173Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2022