Skip to main content Accessibility help

We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.

Close cookie message
×
Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-l4dxg Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-10T12:17:51.231Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

15 - Modern approaches to early Islamic history

from PART IV - THE HISTORIOGRAPHY OF EARLY ISLAMIC HISTORY

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 March 2011

By
Fred Donner
Edited by
Chase F. Robinson
Chase F. Robinson
Affiliation:
The Graduate Center, The City University of New York
Get access

Summary

Preliminary considerations

Western writing on Islam, including early Islamic history, has roots reaching back to the medieval period. These earliest Western writings were almost without exception religious polemics – tracts intended to assert the theological claims of Christianity and to disprove or discredit those of Islam. They often pursued these goals by presenting grotesque misrepresentations of Islam and its history. Polemicists devoted special attention to discrediting the Qurʿān and Muḥammad because this, they thought, would most effectively undermine Islam’s faith-claims – that Muḥammad was a prophet, and that the Qurʿān was God’s revealed word.

This polemical tradition cannot, of course, be considered scientific scholarship, the goal of which is to understand the subject of its study, not to discredit it; but it is important to remember that the Western tradition of anti-Islamic polemic formed the background against which more scholarly writings first developed, and thus in some ways inevitably helped shape the latter. Early Islamic history in particular, because it includes the story of the life of Muḥammad, the revelation of the Qurʿān and the early expansion of the Believers, was long closely entangled with polemic. Moreover, the polemical tradition never completely died out, but has survived right up to the present in a variety of guises.

Keywords

early Islamic historyEnlightenment thinkerscontemporary scholarsnationalist conceptualisationspractical impedimentsWestern approaches
Type
Chapter
Information
The New Cambridge History of Islam , pp. 623 - 647
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Print publication year: 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abū, l-Fidāʾ, Ismāʿīl ibn, ʿAlī, Mukhtaṣar taʾrīkh al-bashar, trans. Reiske, J. as Annales Moslemici, Leipzig, 1754.
Agha, Saleh Said, and Khalidi, Tarif, ‘Poetry and identity in the Umayyad age’, al-Abhath –1 (2002–3), 55–120.
al-Ṣanʿānī, ʿAbd al-Razzāq ibn Hammām, al-Muṣannaf, ed. Ḥabīb, al-Raḥmān al-Aʿẓamī, 11 vols., n.p. and Beirut, 1970–2.
al-Ṭabarī, Abū Jaʿfar Muḥammad ibn Jarīr, Kitāb al-rusul wa l-mulūk, ed. Goeje, M. J. et al., 15 vols. in 3 series, Leiden, 1879–1901; English translation: The history of al-Ṭabarī, 39 vols., Albany, 1985–99.
al-Balādhurī, Aḥmad ibn Yaḥyā ibn Jābir, Futūḥ al-buldān, ed. Goeje, M. J., Leiden, 1866.
Albrecht, Noth, Quellenkritische Untersuchungen zu Themen, Formen, und Tendenzen frühislamischer Geschichtsüberlieferung (Bonn, 1973
Andrae, Tor, ‘Die Legenden von der Berufung Muḥammeds’, Le monde oriental, 6 (1912) –18.Google Scholar
Andrae, Tor, Die Person Muhammads in Lehre und Glauben seiner Gemeinde, Stockholm, 1918.
Becker, Carl Heinrich, ‘The expansion of the Saracens’, in Gwatkin, H. M. et al. (eds.), The Cambridge medieval history, vol. II, Cambridge, 1913, chs. 11 and 12.Google Scholar
Bell, Richard, The origin of Islam in its Christian environment, London, 1926.
Bennett, Clinton, Victorian images of Islam, London, 1992.
Bousquet, Georges Henri, ‘Observations sur la nature et les causes de la conquête arabe’, Studia Islamica, 6 (1956) –52.Google Scholar
Brown, Peter, The world of Late Antiquity, AD 150–750, London, 1971.
Bulliet, Richard, ‘Orientalism and medieval Islamic studies’, in John Van Engen (ed.), The past and future of medieval studies, Notre Dame, 1994, 94–104.Google Scholar
Burgmer, Christoph (ed.), Streit um den Koran: Die Luxenberg-Debatte: Standpünkte und Hintergründe, n.p., 2004.
Caetani, Leone, Studi di storia orientale, 3 vols., Milan, 1911–14.
Cahen, Claude, La Syrie du Nord à l’époque des croisades et la principauté d’Antioche, Paris, 1940.
Calder, Norman, Studies in early Muslim jurisprudence, Oxford, 1993.
Cameron, Averil, and Lawrence, I. Conrad (eds.), The Byzantine and early Islamic Near East, vol. I: Problems in the literary source material, Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam 1, Princeton, 1993.
Carlyle, Thomas, On heroes, hero-worship, and the heroic in history, London, 1841.
Casanova, Paul, Mahomet et la fin du monde, 3 vols., Paris, 1911–24.
Chabbi, Jacqueline, Le seigneur des tribus: L’Islam de Mahomet, Paris, 1997.
Conrad, Lawrence I., ‘The conquest of Arwād: A source-critical study in the historiography of the medieval Near East’, in Cameron, A. and Conrad, L. I. (eds.), The Byzantine and early Islamic Near East, vol. I: Problems in the literary source material, Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam 1, Princeton, 1993, 317–401.Google Scholar
Cook, David, Studies in Muslim apocalyptic, Princeton, 2002.
Cook, Michael, ‘An early Islamic apocalyptic chronicle’, Journal of Near Eastern Studies, 52 (1993) –9.Google Scholar
Crone, Patricia, Meccan trade and the rise of Islam, Princeton, 1987; repr. Piscataway, NJ, 2004.
Crone, Patricia, Slaves on horses: The evolution of the Islamic polity, Cambridge, 1980.
Crone, Patricia, and Michael, Cook, Hagarism: The making of the Islamic world, Cambridge, 1977.
Crone, Patricia, Déscription de l’Égypte: Ou, recueil des observations et des recherches qui ont été faites en Égypte pendant l’expédition de l’armée française/publié par les ordres de Sa Majesté l’empereur Napoléon le Grand, 23 vols., Paris, 1809–29.
Daniel, Norman, Islam and the West: The making of an image, Edinburgh, 1960; 2nd edn Oxford, 1993.
Goeje, Michael Jan, Mémoire sur la conquête de la Syrie, Mémoires d’histoire et de géographie orientales 2, 1st edn, Leiden, 1864.
Prémare, Alfred-Louis, Les fondations de l’Islam: Entre écriture et histoire, Paris, 2002.
Donner, Fred M., Narratives of Islamic origins: The beginnings of Islamic historical writing, Princeton, 1998, introduction.
Donner, Fred M., ‘Centralized authority and military autonomy in the early Islamic conquests’, in Cameron, A. (ed.), The Byzantine and early Islamic Near East, vol,.III: States, resources, and armies, Studies in Late Antiquity and Early Islam 1, Princeton, 1995 –60.Google Scholar
Donner, Fred M., ‘From believers to Muslims: Confessional self-identity in the early Islamic community’, al-Abhath –1 (2002–3), 9–53.Google Scholar
Donner, Fred M., ‘Modern nationalism and medieval Islamic history’, al-ʿUsur al-Wusta, 13 (2001) –2.Google Scholar
Donner, Fred M., ‘Orientalists and the rise of Islam’, in Khasawnih, Sami A. (ed.), Conference on Orientalism: Dialogue of Cultures, 22–24 October 2002, Amman, 2004 –84.Google Scholar
Donner, Fred M., ‘Piety and eschatology in early Khārijite poetry’, in Ibrahim, As-Saʿāfīn (ed.), Fī miḥrāb al-maʿrifa: Festschrift for Iḥsān ʿAbbās, Beirut, 1997, 13–19 (English section).Google Scholar
Donner, Fred M., ‘The Qurʾān in recent scholarship: Challenges and desiderata’, in Reynolds, Gabriel Said (ed.), Towards a new reading of the Qurʾān, Abingdon, 2008 –50.Google Scholar
d’Herbelot, Barthélemy, Bibliothèque orientale, Paris, 1697.
Dunlop, D. M., ‘Some remarks on Weil’s history of the caliphs’, in Bernard, Lewis and Holt, P. M. (eds.), Historians of the Middle East, London, 1962 –29.Google Scholar
El-Hibri, Tayeb, Reinterpreting Islamic historiography: Hārūn al-Rashīd and the narrative of the ʿAbbāsid caliphate, Cambridge, 1999.
Fowden, Garth, Empire to commonwealth: Consequences of monotheism in Antiquity, Princeton, 1993.
Fück, J. W., ‘Islam as an historical problem in European historiography since 1800’, in Lewis, B. and Holt, P. M. (eds.), Historians of the Middle East, London, 1962 –14.Google Scholar
Geiger, Abraham, Was hat Mohamed aus dem Judenthume aufgenommen, Berlin, 1833.
Gibbon, Edward, The history of the decline and fall of the Roman empire, 6 vols., London, 1776–88.
Goddard, Hugh, A history of Muslim–Christian relations, Edinburgh and Chicago, 2000.
Goldziher, Ignaz, Muhammedanische Studien, 2 vols., Halle, 1889–90; trans. , S. M. and Barber, C. R. as Muslim studies, 2 vols., London, 1967–71.
Goldziher, Ignaz, Vorlesungen über den Islam, Heidelberg, 1910; trans. Andras, and Ruth, Hamori as Introduction to Islamic theology and law, Princeton, 1981.
Grimme, Hubert, Mohamed, 2 vols., Münster, 1892–5.
Hawting, Gerald R., The first dynasty of Islam: The Umayyad caliphate, AD 661–750, Beckenham and Carbondale, 1987.
Hawting, Gerald R., The idea of idolatry and the emergence of Islam: From polemic to history, Cambridge, 1999.
Hawting, Gerald R., ‘The rise of Islam’, in Choueiri, Youssef M. (ed.), A companion to the history of the Middle East, Oxford, 2005 –27.Google Scholar
Hitti, Philip, The Arabs in history, London, 1937.
Hourani, Albert H., Islam in European thought, Cambridge, 1991.
Huntington, Samuel P., The clash of civilizations and the remaking of the world order, New York, 1996.
Hurgronje, C. Snouck, selected works, ed. in French and English by G. H. Bousquet and J. Schacht, Leiden, 1957.
Hurgronje, C. Snouck, ‘Ibn Warraq’ [pseud.] (ed.), The quest for the historical Muhammad, Amherst, NY, 2000.Google Scholar
Ibn Saʿd, Muḥammad, al-Ṭabaqāt al-kabīr, ed. Sachau, E. et al., 9 vols., Leiden, 1917–40.
Juynboll, Gautier, Muslim tradition, Cambridge, 1983.
Kister, M. J., ‘“A booth like the booth of Moses..”: A study of an early ḥadīth’, Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, 25 (1962) –5.Google Scholar
Kister, M. J., Studies in jāhiliyya and early Islam, London, 1980.
Klier, Klaus, Hālid und ʿUmar: Quellenkritische Untersuchung zur Historiographie der frühislamischen Zeit, Berlin, 1998.
Koren, Judith, and Yehuda, Nevo, ‘Methodological approaches to Islamic studies’, Der Islam, 68 (1991) –107.Google Scholar
Lammens, Henri, Fatima et les filles de Mahomet: Notes critiques pour l’étude de la Sîra, Rome, 1912.
Lammens, Henri, ‘La république marchande de la Mecque vers l’an 600 de notre ère’, Bulletin de l’Institute Égyptien, 5, 4 (1910) –54.Google Scholar
Landau-Tasseron, Ella, ‘Sayf ibn ʿUmar in medieval and modern scholarship’, Der Islam, 67 (1990) –26.Google Scholar
Lane, Edward W., An account of the manners and customs of the modern Egyptians, London, 1836.
Lassner, Jacob, Islamic revolution and historical memory: An inquiry into the art of ʿAbbāsid apologetics, AOS Series 66, New Haven, 1986.
Lecker, Michael, The ‘Constitution of Medina’: Muḥammad’s first legal document, Princeton, 2004.
Leder, Stefan, Das Korpus al-Haitam ibn ʿAdī (st. 207/822): Herkunft, Überlieferung, Gestalt früher Texte der ahbār-Literatur, Frankfurt, 1991.
Lester, Toby, ‘What is the Koran?’, The Atlantic Monthly (January 1999) –56.Google Scholar
Lewis, Bernard, The Arabs in history, London, 1958.
Lewis, Bernard, ‘The roots of Muslim rage’, The Atlantic Monthly (September 1990) –60.Google Scholar
Lewis, Bernard, and Peter, M. Holt (eds.), Historians of the Middle East, London, 1962.
Lockman, Zachary, Contending visions of the Middle East: The history and politics of Orientalism, Cambridge, 2004.
Lüling, Günter, Über den Ur-Qurʾān: Ansätze zur Rekonstruktion vorislamischer christlicher Strophenlieder im Qurʾān, Erlangen, 1974.
Luxenberg, Christoph [pseud.], Die syro-aramäische Lesart des Koran: Ein Beitrag zur Entschlüsselung der Koransprache, Berlin, 2000.
Madelung, Wilferd, ‘Apocalyptic prophecies in Ḥimṣ in the Umayyad age’, Journal of Semitic Studies, 31 (1986) –85.Google Scholar
Madelung, Wilferd, The succession to Muḥammad: A study of the early caliphate, Cambridge, 1997.
Motzki, Harald, Die Anfänge der islamischen Jurisprudenz, Stuttgart, 1991.
Muir, Sir William, The life of Muhammad, Edinburgh, 1861.
Nevo, Yehuda D., and Judith, Koren, Crossroads to Islam: The origins of the Arab religion and the Arab state, Amherst, NY, 2003.
Nevo, Yehuda D., ‘The origins of the Muslim descriptions of the jāhilī Meccan sanctuary’, Journal of Near Eastern Studies, 49 (1990) –44.Google Scholar
Nöldeke, Theodor, Geschichte des Qorāns, Göttingen, 1860; 2nd rev. edn ed. Schwally, F. and Bergsträsser, G., 3 vols., Leipzig, 1909–38.
Nöldeke, Theodor, Orientalische Skizzen, Berlin, 1892.
Noth, Albrecht, ‘Früher Islam’, in Ulrich Haarmann et al. (eds.), Geschichte der arabischen Welt, Munich, 1987 –101.Google Scholar
Noth, Albrecht, ‘Iṣfahān-Nihāwand: Eine quellenkritische Studie zur frühislamischen Historiographie’, Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft, 118 (1968) –96.Google Scholar
Noth, Albrecht, Quellenkritische Untersuchungen zu Themen, Formen, und Tendenzen frühislamischer Geschichtsüberlieferung, Bonn, 1973; rev. edn (with Lawrence I. Conrad), trans. Michael, Bonner as The early Arabic historical tradition, Princeton, 1994.
Petersen, Erling Ladewig, ʿAlī and Muʿāwiya in early Arabic tradition: Studies on the genesis and growth of Islamic historical writing until the end of the ninth century, 2nd edn, Odense, 1974 [Copenhagen, 1964].
Qureshi, Emran, and Sells, Michael A. (eds.), The new Crusades: Constructing the Muslim enemy, New York, 2003.
Qureshi, Emran, Recueil des historiens des croisades, Paris, 1869–1906.
Retsö, Jan, The Arabs in Antiquity, London and New York, 2003.
Robinson, Chase F., ‘The conquest of Khūzistān: A historiographical reassessment’, Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, 67 (2004) –39.Google Scholar
Rodinson, Maxime, La mystique de l’Islam, Paris, 1980; trans. Roger, Veinus as Europe and the mystique of Islam, Seattle, 1987.
Rosenthal, Franz, Das Fortleben der Antike im Islam, Zurich, 1965; trans. Emile, and Jenny, Marmorstein as The classical heritage in Islam, Berkeley, 1975.
Rubin, Uri, The eye of the beholder: The life of Muḥammad as viewed by the early Muslims: A textual analysis, Princeton, 1995.
Rubin, Uri, ‘Morning and evening prayers in Islam’, Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam, 10 (1987) –64.Google Scholar
Said, Edward W., Orientalism, New York, 1978.
Schacht, Joseph, The origins of Muhammadan jurisprudence, Oxford, 1950.
Schoeler, Gregor, Écrire et transmettre dans les débuts de l’Islam, Paris, 2002.
Schoeler, Gregor, ‘Die Frage der schriftlichen oder mündlichen Überlieferung der Wissenschaften in frühen Islam’, Der Islam, 62 (1985) –30.Google Scholar
Sellheim, Rudolf, ‘Abū ʿAlī al-Qālī: Zum Problem mündlicher und schriftlicher Überlieferung am Beispiel von Sprichwörtersammlungen’, in Roemer, H. R. and Noth, A. (eds.), Studien zur Geschichte und Kultur des vorderen Orients: Festschrift für Bertold Spuler, Leiden, 1981 –74.Google Scholar
Sezgin, Fuat, Geschichte des arabischen Schrifttums, vol. I, Leiden, 1967.
Shaban, M. A., Islamic history: A new interpretation, 2 vols., Cambridge, 1971.
Sharon, Moshe, ‘The birth of Islam in the Holy Land’, in Moshe, Sharon (ed.), Pillars of smoke and fire: The Holy Land in history and thought, Johannesburg, 1988, 225–35.Google Scholar
Shoshan, Boaz, Poetics of Islamic historiography: Deconstructing Ṭabarī’s History, Leiden, 2004.
Southern, R. W., Western views of Islam in the Middle Ages, Cambridge, MA, 1962.
Steinschneider, M., al-Farābī, Mémoires de l’Academie Impériale de Sciences de Saint-Petersbourg 7, 8, 4, St Petersburg, 1869.
Theodor, Nöldeke, Geschichte des Qorāns (Göttingen, 1860)
Tibawi, A. L., ‘English-speaking Orientalists: A critique of their approach to Islam and Arab nationalism’, Muslim World, 53 (1963) –204, 298–313.Google Scholar
Tibawi, A. L., ‘On the Orientalists again’, Muslim World, 70 (1980) –61.Google Scholar
Tibawi, A. L., ‘Second critique of English-speaking Orientalists and their approach to Islam and the Arabs’, Islamic Quarterly, 23 (1979) –54.Google Scholar
Tolan, John Victor, Saracens: Islam in the medieval European imagination, New York, 2002.
Torrey, Charles Cutler, The Jewish foundations of Islam, New York, 1933.
Veinus, Roger as Europe and the mystique of Islam (Seattle, 1987), pp. 67
Grunebaum, Gustave, ‘The first expansion of Islam: Factors of thrust and containment’, Diogenes, 54 (1966) –72.Google Scholar
Waardenburg, Jacques, Islam: Historical, social, and political perspectives, Religion and Reason 40, Berlin and New York, 2002.
Waardenburg, Jacques, Islam and Christianity: Mutual perceptions since the mid-twentieth century, Leuven, 1998.
Waldman, Marilyn Robinson, ‘New approaches to “biblical” materials in the Qurʾān’, Muslim World, 75 (1985) –16.Google Scholar
Wansbrough, John, Qurʾanic studies, Oxford, 1977.
Wansbrough, John, The sectarian milieu: Content and composition of Islamic salvation history, Oxford, 1978.
Wansbrough, John, Muḥammad at Medina, Oxford, 1956.
Wansbrough, John, Muhammad, Prophet and statesman, Oxford, 1961.
Watt, William Montgomery, Muslim–Christian encounters: Perceptions and misperceptions, London and New York, 1991.
Watt, William Montgomery, Muḥammad at Mecca, Oxford, 1953.
Wellhausen, Julius, Das arabische Reich und sein Sturz, Berlin, 1902; trans. Margaret, Graham Weir as The Arab kingdom and its fall, Calcutta, 1927.
Wellhausen, Julius, Muhammad in Medina, daß ist Vakidi’s Kitab al-Maghazi in verkürzter deutscher Wiedergabe herausgegeben, Berlin, 1882.
Wellhausen, Julius, Prolegomena zur ältesten Geschichte des Islams, Skizzen und Vorarbeiten 6, Berlin, 1899.

Save book to Kindle

To save this book to your Kindle, first ensure [email protected] is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about saving to your Kindle.

Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

Available formats
×

Save book to Dropbox

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Dropbox.

Available formats
×

Save book to Google Drive

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Google Drive.

Available formats
×