Christian Piety in Late Antiquity

doi:10.1017/9781108932981.008

Chapter 7 - Christian Piety in Late Antiquity

Contexts and Contestations

from Part II - Religion

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 August 2021

Claudia Rapp

Edited by

Harriet I. Flower

Show author details

Harriet I. Flower: Affiliation:
Princeton University, New Jersey

Book contents

Get access

Summary

What is the most virtuous form of Christian life and the best path to perfection? And what is the best form of social organization and context to achieve this? This chapter addresses these questions by bringing together three different sets of sources for Egypt and Palestine in the fourth to seventh centuries: normative monastic treatises on the desirable and undesirable ways to achieve spiritual perfection, hagiographical narratives that praise the “hidden sanctity” of laypeople, and descriptive historical sources (including papyri) regarding the activities of pious lay groups (spoudaioi, philoponoi). Taken together, these sources reveal that the charitable activities of laypeople played a sufficiently large role in late antique society to challenge the sense of spiritual superiority that began to prevail in monastic circles.

Keywords

monasticism Egypt late antiquity charitable organizations Christianity spoudaioi philoponoi

Type: Chapter
Information: Empire and Religion in the Roman World , pp. 161 - 186

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108932981.008 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2021

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Primary Sources

Apophthegmata Patrum, in Migne, J.-P. (ed.) (1857–1866) Patrologiae Cursus Completus. Series Graeca, Vols. 65, Paris; B. Ward (trans.) (1984) The Sayings of the Desert Fathers: The Alphabetical Collection, London and Kalamazoo.Google Scholar

Benedict, Regula, in Hanslik, R (ed.) (1960) Regula Monachorum Sancti Benedicti, Corpus Scriptorum Ecclesiasticorum Latinorum LXXV, Vienna; T. Fry, I. Baker, T. Horner, A. Raabe, and M. Sheridan (trans.) (1981) The Rule of St. Benedict in Latin and English with Notes, Collegeville.Google Scholar

Dmitrievskij, A. A. (ed.) (1965) Opisanie liturgičeskich rukopisej, chranjaščichsja v bibliotekach pravoslavnago vostoka, Vol. 2: Euchologia, Hildesheim.Google Scholar

Histoires, in F. Nau (ed.) (1907) “Histoires des solitaires égyptiens,” Revue de l’Orient Chrétien, 12: 43–69, 171–193, 393–413; 13 (1908), pp. 47–66, 266–297; 14 (1909), pp. 357–379; 17 (1912), pp. 204–211, 294–301; 18 (1913), pp. 137–144; J. Wortley (trans.) (2013) The Anonymous Sayings of the Desert Fathers: A Select Edition and Complete English Translation, Cambridge.Google Scholar

Jerome, Letters, in Labourt, J. (ed.) (1949–1963) Saint Jérôme. Lettres, 6 vols., Paris; trans. H. W. Ph. Schaff, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, ser. 2, vol. IV, bit.ly/2I6CHz0 (last accessed March 27, 2018).Google Scholar

Cassian, John, Conferences, in Petschenig, M (ed.) and G. Kreuz (rev.) (2004) Cassiani Opera. Conlationes XXIIII, Corpus Scriptorum Ecclesiasticorum Latinorum XIII, Vienna; C. Liubheid (trans.) (1985) John Cassian Conferences, Mahwah.Google Scholar

Moschus, John, Pratum spirituale, in E. Mioni (ed.) (1951) “Il Pratum Spirituale di Giovanni Mosco: gli episodi inediti del Cod. Marciano greco II.21,” OCP 17: 61–94; Th. Nissen (ed.) (1938) “Unbekannte Erzählungen aus dem Pratum Spirituale,” ByzZ 38: 351–376; J. Wortley (trans.) (1992) The Spiritual Meadow by John Moschos, Kalamazoo.Google Scholar

Life of Alexander the Akoimetos, in de Stroop, E. (ed.) (1911) La Vie d’Alexandre l’Acémète, Patrologia Orientalis 6, Paris; Caner, D. (trans.) (2002) Wandering, Begging Monks: Spiritual Authority and the Promotion of Monasticism in Late Antiquity, Berkeley, Los Angeles, and London.Google Scholar

Palladius, Historia Lausiaca, in Bartelink, G. J. M. (ed.) (1974) Palladio, La storia Lausiaca, Vite dei Santi 2, Milan.Google Scholar

Rufinus of Aquileia, Historia Monachorum, in Schulz-Flügel, E. (ed.) (1990) Tyrannius Rufinus. Historia Monachorum Sive De Vita Sanctorum Patrum, Patristische Texte und Studien XXXIV, Berlin, Boston, and New York; N. Russell (trans.) (1981) The Lives of the Desert Fathers: The Historia Monachorum in Aegypto, London and Kalamazoo.Google Scholar

Saint Daniel of Sketis, in Dahlman, B. (ed., trans., and commentary) (2007) Saint Daniel of Sketis; A Group of Hagiographic Texts Edited with Introduction, Translation and Commentary, Studia Byzantina Upsaliensia 10, Uppsala.Google Scholar

The Acts of the Council of Chalcedon, Canons, in Ioannou, P. P. (ed.) (1962) Discipline générale antique, Vol. I.1: Les canons des conciles oecuméniques (IIe–IXe s.), Grottaferrata; R. Price and M. Gaddis (trans.) (2010) The Acts of the Council of Chalcedon, 3 vols., Translated Texts for Historians XLV, Liverpool.Google Scholar

The Miracles of St. Artemios, in Crisafulli, V. S and Nesbitt, J. W (eds. and trans.) (1997) The Miracles of St Artemios: A Collection of Miracle Stories by an Anonymous Author of Seventh-Century Byzantium, Medieval Mediterranean 13, Leiden, New York, and Cologne.Google Scholar

Zacharias of Mytilene, Life of Severus, in Brock, S. P. and Fitzgerald, B. (trans.) (2013) Two Early Lives of Severos, Patriarch of Antioch, Translated Texts for Historians LIX, Liverpool.Google Scholar

Secondary Sources

Anson, J. (1974) “The Female Transvestite in Early Monasticism: The Origin and Development of a Motif,” Viator 5: 1–32.Google Scholar

Blanchard, M. J. (2007) “Sarabaitae and Remnuoth: Coptic Considerations,” in Goehring, J. E. and Timbie, J. A. (eds.), The World of Early Egyptian Christianity: Language, Literature, and Social Context. Essays in Honor of David W. Johnson, Washington, DC: 49–60.Google Scholar

Bowersock, G. W. (2010) “Parabalani: A Terrorist Charity in Late Antiquity,” Anabases 12: “Hommage à Leandro Polverini. Historiographie et Histoire”: 45–54.Google Scholar

Brown, P. (2016) Treasure in Heaven: The Holy Poor in Early Christianity, Charlottesville, VA.Google Scholar

Bumazhnov, D. F. (2010) “Some Further Observations Concerning the Early History of the Term ΜΟΝΑΧΟΣ (Monk),” in Baun, J., Cameron, A., Edward, M., and Vinzent, M. (eds.), Studia Patristica, Vol. XLV, Leuven: 21–26.Google Scholar

Camplani, A. (2013) “The Transmission of Early Christian Memories in Late Antiquity: The Editorial Activity of Laymen and Philoponoi,” in Bitton-Ashkelony, B. and Perrone, L. (eds.), Between Personal and Institutional Religion: Self, Doctrine, and Practice in Late Antique Eastern Christianity, Cultural Encounters in Late Antiquity and the Middle-Ages XV, Turnhout: 129–153.Google Scholar

Caner, D. (2009) “‘Not of this World’: The Invention of Monasticism,” in Rousseau, P. and Raithel, J. (eds.), A Companion to Late Antiquity, Chichester, UK and Malden: 588–600.Google Scholar

Caseau, B. (2009) “L’image du mauvais moine: les remnuoths et les sarabaites de Jérôme et de Cassien,” Zbornik Radova Vizantinoloshkog Instituta 46: 11–25.Google Scholar

Choat, M. (2002) “The Development and Usage of Terms for ‘Monk’ in Late Antique Egypt,” JbAC, 45: 5–23.Google Scholar

Choat, M. (2004) “Philological and Historical Approaches to the Search for the ‘Third Type’ of Egyptian Monk,” in Immerzeel, M. and van der Vliet, J. (eds.), Coptic Studies on the Threshold of a New Millennium: Proceedings of the Seventh International Congress of Coptic Studies, Leiden, 27 August-2 September 2000, Orientalia Lovaniensia Analecta CXXXIII, Leuven: 857–865.Google Scholar

Dagron, G. (1991) “‘Ainsi rien n’échappera à la réglementation.’ État, Église, corporations, confréries: à propos des inhumations à Constantinople (IVe–Xe. siècle),” in Kravari, V., Lefort, J., and Morrisson, C. (eds.), Hommes et richesses dans l’Empire byzantine, Vol. 1, Réalités Byzantines III, Paris: 155–182.Google Scholar

Delouis, A. and Mossakowska-Gaubert, M. (eds.) (2015) La vie quotidienne des moines en Orient et en Occident (IVe-Xe siècle), Vol. 1: L’état des sources, Bibliothèque d’étude CLXIII, Cairo and Athens.Google Scholar

Diem, A. and Rapp, C. (2020) “The Monastic Laboratory: Perspectives of Research in Late Antique and Early Medieval Monasticism,” in Beach, A. I. and Cochelin, I. (eds.), History of Medieval Monasticism in the Latin West, 2 vols., Cambridge: 19–39.Google Scholar

Duncan, J. (1983) Coislin 213. Euchologe de la Grande Eglise, PhD diss., Pontificio Istituto Orientale, Rome.Google Scholar

Frøyshov, S. S. R. (2004) L’horologe ‘géorgien’ du Sinaiticus Ibericus 34. Édition, traduction et commentaire, 2 vols, PhD diss., Université Paris-Sorbonne, Paris.Google Scholar

Frøyshov, S. S. R. (2007) “The Cathedral-Monastic Distinction Revisited. Part I: Was Egyptian Desert Liturgy a Pure Monastic Office?,” Studia Liturgica, 37: 198–216.Google Scholar

Giorda, M. (2011) Il regno di Dio in terra. Le fondazioni monastiche egiziane tra V e VII secolo, Rome.Google Scholar

Goehring, E. J. (1999) “Through a Glass Darkly: Diverse Images of the Ἀποτακτικοί(αί) in Early Egyptian Monasticism,” in Ascetics, Society and the Desert: Studies in Early Egyptian Monasticism, Harrisburg, PA: 53–72.Google Scholar

Grossmann, P. (2002) “Überlegungen zu den Discipuli-Räumen in den Hermitagen der Kellia,” Bulletin de la Société d’Archéologie Copte 51: 27–47.Google Scholar

Guillaumont, A. (1995) “Les ‘Remnuoth’ de saint Jérôme,” in Coquin, R. G. and Rosenstiehl, J. M. (eds.), Christianisme d’Égypte. Hommages à René-Georges Coquin, Cahiers de la Bibliothèque Copte IX, Paris and Louvain: 87–92.Google Scholar

Harmless, S. J. W. (2000) “Remembering Poimen Remembering: The Desert Fathers and the Spirituality of Memory,” ChHist 69: 483–518.Google Scholar

Harmless, W. (2004) Desert Christians: An Introduction to the Literature of Early Monasticism, Oxford.Google Scholar

Harvey, S. A. (2012) “Performance as Exegesis: Women’s Liturgical Choirs in Syriac Tradition,” in Groen, B., Hawkes-Teeples, S., and Alexopoulos, S. (eds.), Inquiries into Eastern Christian Worship: Selected Papers of the Second International Congress of the Society for Oriental Liturgy, Rome, 17–21 September 2008, Eastern Christian Studies XII, Louvain: 47–64.Google Scholar

Harvey, S. A. (2005 [2009]) “Revisiting the Daughters of the Covenant: Women’s Choirs and Sacred Song in Late Ancient Christianity,” Hugoye: Journal of Syriac Studies 8 (2): 125–149.Google Scholar

Horden, P. (1986) “The Confraternities of Byzantium,” in Shiels, W. J. and Wood, D. (eds.), Voluntary Religion: Papers Read at the 1985 Summer Meeting and the 1986 Winter Meeting of the Ecclesiastical History Society, Studies in Church History XXIII, Oxford: 25–45.Google Scholar

Horden, P. (2004) “The Christian Hospital in Late Antiquity. Break or Bridge?,” in Steger, F. and Jankrift, K. P. (eds.), Gesundheit – Krankheit. Kulturtransfer medizinischen Wissens von der Spätantike bis in die Frühe Neuzeit, Cologne, Weimar, and Vienna: 77–99.Google Scholar

Horn, J. (1994) “Tria sunt in Aegypto genera monachorum. Die ägyptischen Bezeichnungen für die ‘dritte Art’ des Mönchtums bei Hieronymus und Johannes Cassianus,” in Behlmer, H (ed.), Quaerentes scientiam. Festgabe für Wolfhart Westendorf zu seinem 70. Geburtstag, Göttingen: 63–82.Google Scholar

Ivanov, S. A. (2006) Holy Fools in Byzantium and Beyond, trans. by Simon Franklin. Oxford Studies in Byzantium, New York.CrossRef Google Scholar

Jeffreys, E. (2016) “Women Supporting Women: A Reading of Some Twelfth Century Homilies on the Theotokos,” unpublished paper presented at the round table “Forces of Stability: Personal Agency and Microstructures,” 23rd International Congress of Byzantine Studies, Belgrade (August 22–27, 2016).Google Scholar

Judge, E. A. (1977) “The Earliest Use of Monachos for ‘Monk’ (P.Coll.Youtie 77) and the Origins of Monasticism,” JbAC 20: 72–89.Google Scholar

Magdalino, P. (1990) “Church, Bath and Diakonia in Medieval Constantinople,” in Morris, R. (ed.), Church and People in Byzantium: Society for the Promotion of Byzantine Studies, Twentieth Spring Symposium of Byzantine Studies, Manchester 1986, Birmingham: 165–188.Google Scholar

Patlagean, E. (1976) “L’histoire de la femme déguisée en moine et l’évolution de la sainteté féminine à Byzance,” Studi Medievali ser. 3, 17 (2): 597–623.Google Scholar

Petrides, S. (1900–1901) “Le monastère des Spoudaei à Jérusalem et les Spoudaei de Constantinople,” Échos d’Orient 4: 225–231.CrossRef Google Scholar

Petrides, S. (1904) “Spoudaei et Philopones,” Échos d’Orient 7: 341–348.Google Scholar

Rapp, C. (2008) “Spiritual Guarantors at Penance, Baptism and Ordination in the Late Antique East,” in Firey, A (ed.), A New History of Penance, Leiden and Boston: 121–148.CrossRef Google Scholar

Rapp, C. (2011) “Early Monasticism in Egypt: Between Hermits and Cenobites,” in Melville, G. and Müller, A. (eds.), Female Vita Religiosa between Late Antiquity and the High Middle Ages: Structures, Developments and Spatial Contexts, Vita Regularis: Ordnungen und Deutungen religiösen Lebens im Mittelalter XLVII, Münster, Hamburg, Berlin, and London: 21–42.Google Scholar

Rapp, C. (2016) Brother-Making in Late Antiquity and Byzantium: Monks, Laymen, and Christian Ritual, Oxford and New York.Google Scholar

Rapp, C. (2017) “The Social Organization of Early Monasticism in the East: Challenging Old Paradigms,” in Menesto, E. et al. (eds.), Monachesimi d’Oriente e d’Occidente nell’Alto Medioevo: Spoleto, 31 marzo–6 aprile 2016, Vol. 2, Settimana di Studi sull’Alto Medioevo LXIV, Spoleto: 33–54.Google Scholar

Rebillard, E. (2009) The Care of the Dead in Late Antiquity, trans. E. Trapnell Rawlings and J. Routier-Pucci, Cornell Studies in Classical Philology LIX, Ithaca, NY and London.Google Scholar

Rotman, Y. (2016) Insanity and Sanctity in Byzantium: The Ambiguity of Religious Experience, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar

Stewart, C. (2010) “The Origins and Fate of Monasticism,” Spiritus: A Journal of Christian Spirituality 10 (2): 257–264.Google Scholar

Tetz, M. (1990) “Eine asketische Ermunterung zur Standhaftigkeit aus der Zeit der maximinischen Verfolgung (311/313),” ZNTW 81: 79–102.Google Scholar

Wipszycka, E. (1970) “Les confréries dans la vie religieuse de l’Égypte chrétienne,” in Samuel, D. (ed.), Proceedings of the Twelfth International Congress of Papyrology, Ann Arbor, Michigan, 12–17 August 1968, American Studies in Papyrology VII, Toronto: 511–525.Google Scholar

Wipszycka, E. (2009) Moines et communautés monastiques en Égypte (IVe–VIIIe siècles), JJP Supplement XI, Warsaw.Google Scholar

Wipszycka, E. (2015a) The Alexandrian Church: People and Institutions, JJP Supplement XXV, Warsaw.Google Scholar

Wipszycka, E. (2015b) “Les activités de production et la structure sociale des communautés monastiques égyptiennes,” in Delouis, A. and Mossakowska-Gaubert, M. (eds.), La vie quotidienne des moines en Orient et en Occident (IVe–Xe siècle), Vol. 1: L’état des sources, Bibliothèque d’étude CLXIII, Cairo and Athens: 57–68.Google Scholar

Wortley, J. (1992) “The Spirit of Rivalry in Early Christian Monasticism,” GRBS 33: 383–404.Google Scholar