The reaction against Proclus

doi:10.1017/CHOL9780521040549.032

Chapter 31 - The reaction against Proclus

from Part VI - THE GREEK CHRISTIAN PLATONIST TRADITION FROM THE CAPPADOCIANS TO MAXIMUS AND ERIUGENA

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 28 March 2008

Edited by

A. H. Armstrong

Book contents

Get access

Summary

John of Scythopolis

No attempt is here made to intervene in the apparently interminable debate as to who the ps.-Dionysius was and when he lived, though this must have been later than the Cappadocians, some of whose notions he developed, and before 528, the latest possible date for the first historical reference to his writings. Obviously he had both Christian and Platonist sympathies, though it is difficult to assess their relative weight. It is probably safe to say that he was a Christian philosopher who presented his beliefs in terms of the contemporary Neoplatonism both because it had a strong appeal for him and because these beliefs could best be defended by turning the arguments of what he considered the most satisfactory of the rival philosophies against itself.

In this, his position was not unlike that of St Gregory of Nyssa: but the Neoplatonism of Gregory was that of Plotinus while the Neoplatonism of the ps.-Dionysius was that of Proclus. The trend from the one to the other was a deviation in the direction contrary to Christianism, and the ambiguities of the ps.-Dionysius are the symptoms of a tension between Christianism and Platonism that was nearing breaking point. This was felt at once. No sooner had the Corpus Dionysianum been made public than commentators leapt to the task of defending not only its genuineness, but also its orthodoxy. In the first half of the sixth century commentaries were written by John and George of Scythopolis, by St Maximus in the seventh, by Germanus I, Patriarch of Constantinople in the eighth, and by other anonymous commentators who belong to these three centuries.

Type: Chapter
Information: The Cambridge History of Later Greek and Early Medieval Philosophy , pp. 473 - 491

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521040549.032 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 1967

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Anonymous Commentator on St John's Gospel Ed. Hausmann, K.. Paderborn, 1930.Google Scholar

Balthasar, H. von. ‘Das Scholienwerk des Johannes von Scythopolis’, in Scholastik, 15, 1 (1940).Google Scholar

Balthasar, H. von.Kosmische Liturgie, 2nd edn. Einsiedeln, 1961 (French translation of 1st edn. Paris, 1947).Google Scholar

Bignone, E.L'Aristotele perduto e la formazione filosofica di Epicuro, 2 vols. Florence, 1936.Google Scholar

Brooks, E. W., Corpus scriptorum christianorum orientalium, LXXXVII–LXXXVIII (Paris, 1924);Google Scholar

Bulgakov, , The Lamb of God (YMCA Press, 1928), p. (in Russian).Google Scholar

Chenu, P., Revue des sciences philosophiques et théologiques, XXVI (1937)

Courcelle, P. ‘Boèce et l'école d'Alexandrie’, in Mélanges de l'école française de Rome, 53 (1935).Google Scholar

Cramer, J. A., Anecdota graeca e codd. manuscr. Bibl. Reg. Paris. IV (Oxford, 1841).Google Scholar

,DamasciusLife of Isidoros, ed. and tr. Asmus, R.. Leipzig, 1911 [extracts from Photius, Bibliotheca cod. 242. (Migne, Migne, Patrologia Graeca 103)].

Damascius, , Vita Isidori, ed. Asmus, (Leipzig, 1911), 37 n.;Google Scholar

Diekamp, , Analecta patristica (Rome, 1938).Google Scholar

Duhem, P., Système du monde, 11 (Paris 1914), p.,Google Scholar

Évrard, E., ‘Les convictions religieuses de Jean Philopon et la date de son commentaire aux Météorologiques’, Academie royale de Belgique: Bulletin de la classe des lettres et des sciences morales etpolitiques, ser. 5, XXXIX (1953) ;Google Scholar

Fortin, E. L., ‘The Definitio fidei of Chalcedon and its philosophical sources,‘ Studia patristica, V (Berlin, 1962).Google Scholar

Gross, J., ‘Ur- und Erbsünde in der Theosophie des ps.- Dionysius Areopagita’, Zeitschrift für Religions- und Geistesgeschichte, IV (1952).Google Scholar

Honigmann, E., Patristic studies (= Studi e testi, Rome, no. 173) (1953).

Hornus, J. M. ‘Les recherches dionysiennes du 1955–60’, ibid. 41 (1961).Google Scholar

Hornus, J. M. ‘Les recherches récentes sur le ps. Denys l'Aréopagite’, in Revue d'histoire et de philosophie religieuse, 35 (1955).Google Scholar

Ivánka, E., ‘La signification historique du Corpus areopagiticum’, Recherches de science religieuse, XXXI (Paris, 1949).Google Scholar

Joannou, P., ’Le premier essai chrétien d'une philosophie systématique, Jean Philopon’, Studia patristica, V (Berlin, 1962).Google Scholar

,Johannes Scottus EriugenaAnnotationes in Marcianum, ed. Lutz, C.. Cambridge (Mass.), 1939.Google Scholar

,Johannes Scottus EriugenaCommentary on Boethius, ‘Deconsolatione Philosophiae iii met.9’, ed. Silvestre, H., in Revue d'histoire ecclésiastique, 17 (1952).

,Johannes Scottus EriugenaExpositiones super Ierarchiam caelestem iii–vii, ed. Dondaine, H. F., in Archives d'histoire doctrinale et littéraire du Moyen Âge, 18 (1951).

,John PhiloponusDe aeternitate mundi contra Proclum, ed. Rabe, H.. Leipzig, 1899 (reprinted 1964).Google Scholar

,John PhiloponusDe opificio mundi, ed. Reinhardt, G.. Leipzig, 1897.Google Scholar

Labriolle, P., Histoire de l'Église depuis les origines jusqu'à nos jours, IV (Paris, 1937).Google Scholar

,Leontius The HermitSolutio argumentorum Severi, PG 86. 2. 1916ff.

Mai, , Spicilegium Romanum, VII (Rome, 1842)Google Scholar

Massa, L., Collana di studi greci dir. da V. de Falco (Naples, 1950).Google Scholar

,Nicephorus of ConstantinopleContra Eusebium et Epiphanidem, ed. Pitra, J. B., Spicilegium solesmense (Paris, 1852–8), I; IV.

Norvin, W., Olympiodorus fra Alexandria (Copenhagen, 1915).Google Scholar

Nyssen, , Byzant. Zeitschr. (Munich, 1940).Google Scholar

,OlympiodorusIn Platonis Gorgiam, ed. Norvin, W.. Leipzig, 1936.Google Scholar

Praechter, K. ‘Richtungen und Schulen im Neuplatonismus’, in Genethliakon C. Robert.Berlin, 1910.Google Scholar

,Pseudo-DionysiusDe caelesti hierarchia, ed. and tr. Roques, R., Heil, G., Gandillac, M. (Sources Chrétiennes). Paris, 1958.

Saffrey, H. D. ‘Le chrétien Jean Philopon et la survivance de l'école d'Alexandrie au VIe siècle’, in Revue des études grecques, 72 (1954).Google Scholar

Sambursky, S.The Physical World of Late Antiquity.London, 1962.Google Scholar

(Sherwood, P., ‘Sergius of Rešaina and the Syriac Version of the ps.-Dionysius’, Sacris erudiri, IV (1952).Google Scholar

Skowronsky, L., De auctoris Heerenii et Olympiodori Alexandrini scholis cum universis turn iis singulis quae ad vitam Platonis spectant capita selecta (Breslau, 1884);Google Scholar

Basil, Homiliae in Hexaëmeron, ed. and tr. Giet, S. (Sources Chrétiennes). Paris, 1950.

Basil, On the Holy Spirit, ed. and tr. Pruche, B. (Sources Chrétiennes). Paris, 1947.

,St Gregory NazianzenOrationes 27–31 (Orationes theologicae), ed. Mason, A. J.. Cambridge, 1899.Google Scholar

,St Gregory of NyssaDe Vita Moysis, ed. and tr. Daniélou, J. (Sources Chrétiennes). Paris, 1956.

,St Gregory of NyssaOratio catechetica, ed. Srawley, J. H.. Cambridge, 1903.Google Scholar

,St Gregory of NyssaWorks, ed. Jaeger, W., Langerbeck, H., etc. Leiden, 1952–, in progress.Google Scholar

,St Maximus Confessor ‘Gnostic Century’, in Epifanović, S. L., Materials to serve in the Study of the Life and Works of S. Maximus Confessor.Kiev, 1917.Google Scholar

,St Maximus ConfessorAscetic Life and Centuries on Charity, tr. and annotated by Sherwood, P.. Westminster (Mld) and London, 1955.Google Scholar

Tannery, , ‘Sur la péiode finale de la philosophic grecque’, Revue philosophique, XLII (1896)Google Scholar

Tatakis, B.La philosophic byzantine.Paris, 1949.Google Scholar

Usener, H., De Stephano Alexandrino (Bonn, 1879);Google Scholar

Vancourt, R.Les derniers commentateurs alexandrins d'Aristote: l'école d'Olympiodore, Étienne d'Alexandrie.Lille, 1941.Google Scholar

Westerink, L. G.Anonymous Prolegomena to Platonic Philosophy.Amsterdam, 1962.Google Scholar

Westerink, , ‘Introduction to Elias on the Prior Analytics’, Mnemosyne, ser. 4, XIV (1961).Google Scholar