12 - Manpower

Summary

foreigners

Among the many myths of Venice was that of a commercial governing class active at sea but passive, to the point of craven pacificity, on land. The Terraferma had been won by the hired help of mercenaries whose success, as Machiavelli put it, constituted a miracle; the Venetians' subsequent defeat at Agnadello was the result, he claimed, of ‘their miserable baseness of spirit, caused by a wretched military system’. The allies of Cambrai put it about in 1509 that ‘the Venetians would have to return to their original jobs as fishermen, for they were not worthy to rule a state and an empire’, a gibe echoed in the contemptuous tirade Henry VIII addressed to the Venetian ambassador in 1516: ‘Vos estis piscatores.’ The view was fostered by the Venetians themselves. The bitterness of defeat led Girolamo Priuli to reflect that the Venetians had become better at thinking than acting; emasculated by peace and prosperity they had left the defence of the fatherland to foreigners who had no concern beyond their pay. In the flush of victory, with the Terraferma regained in 1517, a party of patricians bragged to the Turks' ambassador (who had compared their military system unfavourably with his own) that ‘in the recent cruel war, in which all the monarchs of the world were ranged against us, not one man in this city was killed; all was done with money and at the cost of foreign soldiers' lives’. This connivance in projecting a pacific image was later confirmed by the most influential of all contributions to the mature Myth of Venice, Gasparo Contarini's De magistratibus et republica Venetorum.