Book contents
- Frontmatter
- PART I THE LAND AND THE PEOPLE
- I The mid-eighteenth-century background
- II Agrarian Relations
- III Regional Economy (1757-1857)
- IV National Income
- V Population (1757–1947)
- VI The Occupational Structure
- PART II THE BEGINNINGS OF THE MODERN ECONOMY
- PART III POST-INDEPENDENCE DEVELOPMENTS
- Glossary
- Bibliography
- Map 7: Factory employment 1931
- Map 8: Factory employment 1961
- References
IV - National Income
from PART I - THE LAND AND THE PEOPLE
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 28 March 2008
By
Book contents
- Frontmatter
- PART I THE LAND AND THE PEOPLE
- I The mid-eighteenth-century background
- II Agrarian Relations
- III Regional Economy (1757-1857)
- IV National Income
- V Population (1757–1947)
- VI The Occupational Structure
- PART II THE BEGINNINGS OF THE MODERN ECONOMY
- PART III POST-INDEPENDENCE DEVELOPMENTS
- Glossary
- Bibliography
- Map 7: Factory employment 1931
- Map 8: Factory employment 1961
- References
Summary
The subject of Indian national income has generated partisanship and controversy. As Daniel Thorner has remarked, where can one find a more dramatic presentation of conclusions than that of William Digby, who had imprinted in gold on the spine of his book the per capita income of ‘Prosperous’ British India in 1850 as 2d, 1882 at ½d, and 1900 as less than ¾d? And Digby's adversaries were persons of moment like Lord Curzon of Kedleston who had claimed that per capita income in India had risen between 1880 and 1900. And when his claims were attacked, Curzon could fall back on reliable statistical studies, to take on the likes of Digby; such a confrontation took place between Fred T. Atkinson, allegedly Curzon's man, and Digby at the 1902 meeting of the Royal Statistical Society, where Digby was asked to comment on Atkinson's paper which confirmed Curzon's claim. As one of the observers of the session noted, ‘…. rarely that they had the extreme views on both sides of the question presented so clearly and fully as they had been on that occasion. Both sides had adopted more of a tone of advocacy than they were accustomed to in that room, both in the treatment and criticism of the paper’.
While the temper of this controversy has long since subsided, many of the questions raised are important and remain unanswered. One question concerning many students of India was its level of income relative to England.
Keywords
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- The Cambridge Economic History of India , pp. 376 - 462Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 1983
References
and , ‘Long Term Growth of National Income in India, 1900–1955’, Papers on National Income and Allied Topics (Asia Publishing House, Bombay), 1, 1960.Google Scholar
‘A Statistical Review of the Income and Wealth of British India’. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society June 1902.Google Scholar
, ‘Social and Cultural Foundations of Health Service Systems’, Economic and Political Weekly, Special Number. August, 1974.Google Scholar
, ‘Size, Productivity, and Returns to Scale: An Analysis of Farm-Level Data in Indian Agriculture’, Journal of Political Economy, November-December 1973.Google Scholar
, ‘On Life and Death Questions’, Economic and Political Weekly, Special Number, August 1974.Google Scholar
Agricultural Trends in India 1891–1947 (Philadelphia, 1966).
, ‘Agricultural Production in Bengal, 1850–1900: Coexistence of Decline and Growth’, Bengal Past and Present. 152–205.Google Scholar
The Economic Development of India under the East India Company 1814–1858: A Selection of Contemporary Writings (Cambridge, 1971).
, The Conditions of Economic Progress, 3rd edn (London, Macmillan, 1957).
, A Sketch of the Commercial Resources and Monetary and Mercantile System of British India, with suggestions for their improvements by means of Banking Establishments (1837).
The Population of India and Pakistan (Princeton, 1951).
, The Population of India and Pakistan (Princeton, New Jersey, 1951).
and , British Economic Growth, 1688–1959, 2nd edn (Cambridge, 1967).
‘Prosperous’ British India: a Revelation from Official Records (London, 1901).
and , Development of the Labor Surplus Economy (Homewood, Ill., 1964).
, Industrial Evolution in India in Recent Times (London, 1924).
, ‘Gross National Product in the United States, 1834–1909’, in Output, Employment, and Productivity in the United States after 1800, NBER, (Columbia University Press, 1966).Google Scholar
, ‘A Comparison of Some Short-Cut Methods of Estimating Real Product Per Capita’, Review of Income and Wealth, March, 1973, and sources cited therein.Google Scholar
, ‘Official Yields Per Acre in India, 1886-1947: Some Questions of Interpretation’, Indian Social and Economic History Review, December 1973.Google Scholar
‘Railways and the Expansion of Markets in India, 1861–1921’, Explorations in Economic History, 12, 1975.Google Scholar
, ‘The Quality of the Official Crop Statistics of Bengal, 1920–47’, Bulletin of Quantitative and Computer Methods in South Asian Studies, No. 1, June 1973.Google Scholar
and , Lessons from Japanese Development (Chicago, 1974), Chaps. 3 and 4.
, , and , Dualistic Economic Development: Theory and History (Chicago, 1972).
, , and , International Comparisons of Real Product and Purchasing Power, International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, Johns Hopkins University Press (Baltimore, 1978).
and , ‘India’, chap. 12, in Tropical Development 1880–1913, (ed.) (Allen and Unwin, 1970).Google Scholar
, India and Pakistan Since tbe Mogbuls. (Norton York, 1971).
, Value and Price in the Labour-Surplus Economy (Oxford, 1976).
, Textbook of Indian Agriculture (Bombay, 1901).
and . ‘Selected Railway Statistics for the Indian Subcontinent 1853–1946/7’, Artha-Vijnana, XVII, 3, September 1975.Google Scholar
Levels of Economic Activity and Public Expenditure in India (Bombay, 1962).
The Economic History of India 1600–1800 (Allahabad, 1967).
, The Economic History of India, 1600–1800. (Allahabad, 1967), Chap. 3.
, ‘A Note on the long-term Growth of National Income of India, 1900-01 to 1951-52, Papers on National Income and Allied Topics, III, 1962.Google Scholar
National Income of India (Calcutta, 1969).
Poverty and UnBritish Rule in India (Delhi, 1962).
, Povertys and Un-British Rule in India, Reprinted by Government of India (Delhi, 1962), p..
, An Essay on National Income and Expenditure in India, Government of Madras, 1949.
, Problems of Wage Policy for Economic Development (Bombay, 1962), table 20, 68.
, ‘Long Term Changes in Output and Income in India’, Indian Economic Journal, V, No. 3, January, 1958.Google Scholar
, An Essay on India's National Income, 1925–9.
An Essay on India's National Income 1924–1929 (London, 1929).
(ed.) Papers on National Income and Allied Topics, vol. I (Bombay, 1960).
and , ‘Trends in Industrial and Agricultural Real Wages in India, 1882–1922’, Indian Statistical Institute (Calcutta, 1959) (mimeograph).Google Scholar
, ‘Public Health Measures and Mortality in Madras, 1901–41’, paper delivered to the Association for Asian Studies Meetings, March, 1975.
, ‘Cost of Living Indices and Wages’, in and , (eds.), Economic Prob in Modern India, in Modern India, II, 1941.Google Scholar
, ‘Surplus Labor in India: A Critique of Schultz's Statistical Test’, Economic Journal, 1967.Google Scholar
, ‘Comparison of Yield Estimates Prepared on the Basis of Traditional and Crop-Cutting Methods’, Indian journal of Agricultural Economics, XVII, No. 4, 1962.Google Scholar
, The Science of Public Finance (Macmillan, London, 1924).
Finance and hanking (Macmillan, London, 1935).
(ed.) Economic History of India 1857–1956 (Bombay, 1965).
and , Indian Agricultural Statistics, An Introductory Study, University of Madras (Madras, 1939).
The Working Force in India, 1881–1951 (Bombay 1960, mimeo).
and Land and Labour in India (New York and Bombay, 1962).
, Economic Prosperity of the United Provinces, 1921–39 (Bombay, 1951).
- 20
- Cited by