No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Structural Hobbling: Regressive Harm, Diffuse Responsibility, and Structural Injustice
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 06 February 2025
Abstract
The past five years have seen a dramatic increase in scholars working to supplement or challenge accounts of structural injustice. Almost without exception, scholars in this area assume that the move from personal responsibility to political or public responsibility will represent a net gain in justice, at least in modern liberal regimes. In this essay, I challenge this assumption and introduce the concept of “structural hobbling” as a parallel cause of injustice, but one whose origins derive from neutral state activities rather than from intentional bad faith or diffuse private action (as in structural injustice). Using health-care regulations as a lens, I offer two narratives of individuals navigating health-care regulations that demonstrate how seemingly neutral regulatory decisions create regressive hobbling effects. Structural hobbling challenges structural-injustice theorists to take more seriously the complex and often subtle ways in which apparently benevolent state activity can create downstream injustice, while adding complexity to existing narratives around public responsibility and what it demands.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- © 2025 Social Philosophy and Policy Foundation. Printed in the USA
References
1 de Tocqueville, Alexis, Democracy in America: Historical-Critical Edition of De la Démocratie en Amérique, ed. , Eduardo Nolla, , trans. Schleifer, James T., vol. 4 (1840; repr., Indianapolis, IN: Liberty Fund Press, 2010), 140, https://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/schleifer-democracy-in-america-historical-critical-edition-vol-4 Google Scholar.
2 Young, Iris Marion, Responsibility for Justice (New York: Oxford University Press, 2011)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
3 McKeown, Maeve, “Structural Injustice,” Philosophy Compass 16, no. 7 (2021), https://compass.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/phc3.12757 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; McKeown, Maeve, With Power Comes Responsibility: The Politics of Structural Injustice (London: Bloomsbury Academic, 2024)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Powers, Madison and Faden, Ruth, Structural Injustice: Power, Advantage, and Human Rights (New York: Oxford University Press, 2019)Google Scholar; Sankaran, Kirun, “‘Structural Injustice’ as an Analytical Tool,” Philosophy Compass 16, no. 10 (2021): e12780 Google Scholar.
4 Joseph’s story comes from a New York Times article about his and his daughter’s case, but the same story could be told about tens of thousands of patients across the United States. Nina Bernstein, “Fighting to Honor a Father’s Last Wish: To Die at Home,” The New York Times, September 25, 2014, https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/26/nyregion/family-fights-health-care-system-for-simple-request-to-die-at-home.html. The National Institutes of Health provide an overview of the structural problems with our existing policies in their seminal report Dying in America (Washington, DC: National Academies Press, 2015), https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK285681/.
5 Bernstein, “Fighting to Honor a Father’s Last Wish.”
6 Makary, Martin A. and Daniel, Michael, “Medical Error: The Third Leading Cause of Death in the U.S.,” British Medical Journal 353, no. 2139 (2016), https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i2139 Google Scholar; Rodziewicz, Thomas L. et al., “Medical Error Reduction and Prevention,” in StatPearls (Treasure Island, FL: StatPearls Publishing, 2024), http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK499956/ Google Scholar.
7 Mariana is a composite of a number of women I interviewed over the past seven years for my work on maternity care regulations. Some are CPMs, some are doulas, and some are struggling to navigate the Certificate of Need (CON) system in New York state. Each of the state regulations I discuss here is still in place in New York state at the time of writing. Different states have different combinations of these regulations.
8 She also could pursue a Certified Midwife credential, one that requires an M.S. but not an undergraduate nursing degree. However, because this certification is only recognized in New York and a few other states, without the nursing degree she would be unemployable again if she were to move to another state.
9 NIH, Dying in America, 119.
10 Divall, Bernie et al., “Plans, Preferences or Going with the Flow: An Online Exploration of Women’s Views and Experiences of Birth Plans,” Midwifery 54 (2017): 29–34 CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.
11 Fawsitt, Christopher Godfrey et al., “What Women Want: Exploring Pregnant Women’s Preferences for Alternative Models of Maternity Care,” Health Policy 121, no. 1 (2017): 66–74 Google ScholarPubMed.
12 Young, Responsibility for Justice; McKeown, With Power Comes Responsibility.
13 Tocqueville, Democracy in America, vol. 4, 140, https://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/schleifer-democracy-in-america-historical-critical-edition-vol-4.
14 Merriam-Webster Dictionary, s.v. “hobble,” https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/hobble.
15 Arnold, Denis G., “Coercion and Moral Responsibility,” American Philosophical Quarterly 38, no. 1 (2001): 53–67 Google Scholar; Wertheimer, Alan, “Remarks on Coercion and Exploitation,” Denver University Law Review 74, no. 4 (1997): 889–906 Google Scholar.
16 Zwolinski, Matt, “Structural Exploitation,” Social Philosophy & Policy 29, no. 1 (2012): 154–79Google Scholar.
17 Rudinow, Joel, “Manipulation,” Ethics 88, no. 4 (1978): 338–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
18 Thus, I ignore situations in which one might hobble an animal for its own good, as might be the case for horses. The hobbling on which I focus reduces choiceworthy action, not merely action per se.
19 In my research, midwives I interviewed were often ignorant of the existence of impactful regulations until they had to comply with them. This is likely true of most other heavily regulated professions. I know from experience that it is also true of education. One would certainly not expect voters to be more aware of the effects of regulations than are the professionals whose work is directly impacted. The same is likely true of patients and other affected groups. The epistemic problem becomes relevant again later on.
20 For more on this point, see David Schmidtz, Elements of Justice (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2006), 20, where he argues that “successful theories are maps” and “[m]aps do not tell us where we want to go.” Structural hobbling allows us to map a particular kind of (constrained) terrain, but does not necessarily tell us what an ideal terrain will look like in each case.
21 Iris Young, Marion, Responsibility for Justice, repr. ed. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013)Google Scholar; Young, Iris Marion and Allen, Danielle S., Justice and the Politics of Difference, rev. ed. (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2011)Google Scholar.
22 Wright, Erik Olin, Class Counts: Comparative Studies in Class Analysis (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000)Google Scholar; Marx, Karl and Engels, Friedrich, The Communist Manifesto (1848; repr., New York: International Publishers Co., 2014)Google Scholar.
23 Okin, Susan Moller, Justice, Gender, and the Family, 3rd ed. (New York: Basic Books, 1991)Google Scholar.
24 Massey, Douglas S. and Denton, Nancy A., American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1993)Google Scholar.
25 Lu, Catherine, “Colonialism as Structural Injustice: Historical Responsibility and Contemporary Redress,” Journal of Political Philosophy 19, no. 3 (2011): 261–81Google Scholar.
26 Powers and Faden, Structural Injustice.
27 Beckett, Katherine, “The Politics, Promise, and Peril of Criminal Justice Reform in the Context of Mass Incarceration,” Annual Review of Criminology 1, no. 1 (2018): 235–59Google Scholar.
28 Hayward, Clarissa Rile, “Responsibility and Ignorance: On Dismantling Structural Injustice,” The Journal of Politics 79, no. 2 (2017): 396–408 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
29 Herzog, Lisa, “What Could Be Wrong with a Mortgage? Private Debt Markets from a Perspective of Structural Injustice,” Journal of Political Philosophy 25, no. 4 (2017): 411–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
30 McKeown, “Structural Injustice”; Herzog, “What Could Be Wrong with a Mortgage?”
31 Sample, Ruth J., Exploitation: What It Is and Why It’s Wrong (Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, 2003)Google Scholar; McKeown, “Structural Injustice”; McKeown, With Power Comes Responsibility.
32 Bicchieri, Cristina, The Grammar of Society: The Nature and Dynamics of Social Norms, illus. ed. (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2005)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
33 Young and Allen, Justice and the Politics of Difference, 235.
34 Depro, Brooks, Timmins, Christopher, and O’Neil, Maggie, “White Flight and Coming to the Nuisance: Can Residential Mobility Explain Environmental Injustice?” Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists 2, no. 3 (2015): 439–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Iris Marion Young, Inclusion and Democracy (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002).
35 Lu, “Colonialism as Structural Injustice”; Young, Inclusion and Democracy; Powers and Faden, Structural Injustice.
36 Zwolinski, “Structural Exploitation.”
37 Michael Munger calls this bias (in other contexts) “unicorn governance.” Michael Munger, “Unicorn Governance,” Foundation for Economic Education, August 11, 2014, https://fee.org/articles/unicorn-governance/. He argues that theorists will often compare existing corporate actors to “unicorn” (or ideal) political actors who have never existed. Comparing real corporate actors against ideal government actors ignores political corruption, graft, fraud, and the many incentives that political actors have to engage in harmful or dishonest behavior. It also overlooks the incentives corporate actors might have to engage in beneficial behavior.
38 Young, Responsibility for Justice, 45.
39 McKeown, “Structural Injustice.”
40 McKeown, With Power Comes Responsibility, chap. 4.
41 Browne, Jude and McKeown, Maeve, eds., What Is Structural Injustice? (New York: Oxford University Press, 2024)Google Scholar.
42 Powers and Faden, Structural Injustice, 3.
43 Sankaran, “‘Structural Injustice’ as an Analytical Tool.”
44 Sankaran, “‘Structural Injustice’ as an Analytical Tool,” 6.
45 We do have some possible examples from the international development literature; while these are not framed in the context of structural injustice, they could be. Acemoglu, Daron and Robinson, James, Why Nations Fail (London: Profile Books, 2013)Google Scholar; William Easterly, The White Man’s Burden: Why the West’s Efforts to Aid the Rest Have Done So Much Ill and So Little Good (New York: Penguin Press, 2007).
46 Harriet Washington, Medical Apartheid: The Dark History of Medical Experimentation on Black Americans from Colonial Times to the Present (New York: Anchor Books, 2008); Young, Inclusion and Democracy.
47 Powers and Faden, Structural Injustice.
48 Sankaran, “‘Structural Injustice’ as an Analytical Tool.”
49 Young, Responsibility for Justice.
50 Easterly, The White Man’s Burden.
51 Young, Responsibility for Justice, 20–21.
52 Sankaran, “‘Structural Injustice’ as an Analytical Tool.”
53 Browne and McKeown, What Is Structural Injustice?; McKeown, With Power Comes Responsibility.
54 Hall, Lauren, The Medicalization of Birth and Death (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2019)Google Scholar.
55 Sankaran, “‘Structural Injustice’ as an Analytical Tool,” 8.
56 McKeown, With Power Comes Responsibility, 45.
57 For an illuminating alternative approach as it relates to policing, see Monaghan, Jake, Just Policing (New York: Oxford University Press, 2023)Google Scholar.
58 McKeown, With Power Comes Responsibility, 180.
59 When I interviewed midwives in New York about why the birth-center model of care was so rare, most midwives assumed it was due to market forces, not to government regulations increasing the cost of entry. Midwives only knew that a reasonable alternative was rare and difficult to achieve, but not why.
60 Schmidtz, Elements of Justice.
61 We see this in the growth of concierge medical care, where well-off people buy their way around standard regulated care. Interestingly, home birth has long been a form of accessible concierge care that allowed disadvantaged or oppressed women to avoid standard hospital care. Predictably, regulators responded and limited access in many states. See Luke, Jenny M., Delivered by Midwives: African American Midwifery in the Twentieth-Century South (Jackson, MS: University Press of Mississippi, 2018), and Hall, The Medicalization of Birth and Death, for extensive discussions of black midwifery as an exit strategy from racist medical practicesGoogle Scholar.
62 Hager, Eli, “CPS Workers Search Millions of Homes a Year: A Mom Who Resisted Paid a Price,” NBC News, October 13, 2022, https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/child-abuse-welfare-home-searches-warrant-rcna50716 Google Scholar; Dorothy Roberts, Torn Apart (New York: Basic Books, 2022); Roberts, Sarah C. M. and Nuru-Jeter, Amani, “Universal Screening for Alcohol and Drug Use and Racial Disparities in Child Protective Services Reporting,” The Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research 39, no. 1 (2012): 3–16 Google ScholarPubMed.
63 Monaghan, Just Policing; Balko, Radley, “How Municipalities in St. Louis County, Mo., Profit from Poverty,” Washington Post, September 3, 2014, https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-watch/wp/2014/09/03/how-st-louis-county-missouri-profits-from-poverty/ Google Scholar; Balko, Radley, Rise of the Warrior Cop: The Militarization of America’s Police Forces (New York: PublicAffairs, 2013)Google Scholar.
64 Somin, Ilya, Free to Move: Foot Voting, Migration, and Political Freedom, rev. ed. (New York: Oxford University Press, 2020)Google Scholar.
65 Sylla v. Kohler et al. (2014), https://ij.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/wa-hair-braiding-complaint-6-17-14.pdf Google Scholar.
66 Roberts, Dorothy, Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction, and the Meaning of Liberty (New York: Vintage, 1997); Roberts, Torn Apart Google Scholar.
67 Brookland, Jennifer, “Inside Detroit’s 24-Hour Child Care: A Fragile Lifeline for Working Parents,” Detroit Free Press, October 27, 2022, https://www.freep.com/in-depth/news/local/michigan/2022/10/27/24-hour-child-care-detroit-fragile-lifeline/69573122007/ Google Scholar.
68 Ehrenreich, Barbara and English, Deirdre, For Her Own Good: Two Centuries of the Experts’ Advice to Women (New York: Anchor Books, 2005)Google Scholar; Wertz, Richard W. and Wertz, Dorothy C., Lying-In: A History of Childbirth in America (New York: Free Press, 1977)Google Scholar.
69 For a related discussion, see Scott, James C., Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1998)Google Scholar.