In this clearly wrought translation from Italian,
the philosopher Patrizia Violi analyzes and criticizes in exacting
detail the development of lexical semantics from the classical
models through structuralism, prototype theory, and frame
semantics, to end at the threshold of cognitive semantics (cf.
Violi 1997). Her critique expounds on both well-known and
little-known concepts, but she does not innovate theory. Her
account could be useful as a handbook to anyone who teaches
lexical semantics or who wishes to match his or her overview
of this field with that of an accomplished academic who has
given it vast thought; the work is too advanced for most students.
The reader likely will disagree with some of Violi's
explications, all of which, nevertheless, are sufficiently informed
to force clarification of any contrary position. The book rivals
the main synopses published in English (Durbin & Radden
1987, Hjelmslev 1953, Johnson-Laird 1983, Taylor 1989), but
it adds a semiotic facet derived mainly from works of Umberto
Eco, Diego Marconi, and Algirdas J. Greimas. Of its references,
248 are in English, 24 in Italian, 24 in French, and 16 in other
languages; all but two are generally available. Many of the
277 notes are immediately germane to the text, although others
are dispensable distractions. The nine-page index is taxonomic
but cryptic; for example, externalism appears under
both Linguistics and Meaning, each appearance
with different pages, but intension and extension
are elusive; because the book is a review of concepts, this
handicap is grave.