Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-04T09:16:13.593Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Appendix II - Supplementary Tables

from 5 - Health Service Delivery

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 September 2021

Jo. M. Martins
Affiliation:
International Medical University, Malaysia
Indra Pathmanathan
Affiliation:
United Nations University - International Institute for Global Health
David T. Tan
Affiliation:
United Nations Development Programme
Shiang Cheng Lim
Affiliation:
RTI International
Pascale Allotey
Affiliation:
United Nations University - International Institute for Global Health

Summary

Type
Chapter
Information
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Print publication year: 2021
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BYCreative Common License - NCCreative Common License - SA
This content is Open Access and distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence CC-BY-NC-SA 4.0 https://creativecommons.org/cclicenses/

Appendix II Supplementary Tables

Supplementary Table 5-a Interaction of forces that shaped the evolution of STC during the 1960s and 1970s

Larger ecosystem(A) Influence of the larger ecosystem on STC(B) Influence of STC on the larger ecosystem OR other components of health system
Population behaviour and demographic profile
  • During the 1960s and early 1970s

  • Largely rural population (74%)

  • Low literacy (58%)

  • Low health literacy

  • Resulted in:

  • Need and demand for access to hospital care by the rural population

  • By the mid-1970s

  • Rising demand for more complex secondary care, evidenced in the bypassing of district hospitals to seek care in larger hospitals able to provide better investigations and surgical services

  • During the period

  • Probably increased awareness of hospital services (no data)

  • By the end of the period

  • Improved availability of hospitals in rural areas (no data on access or utilisation at that time)

Morbidity and mortality profile
  • High rates of maternal and infant mortality, vaccine-preventable diseases, malaria, TB, water- and soil-borne diseases, malnutrition

  • Resulted in:

  • Need for hospital care for treatment of more severe illness (TB, malaria, complications of childbirth)

  • By the end of the period

  • Deaths from serious illness and pregnancy-related causes declined

Economy and macro policies
  • Steady increase in GDP

  • Rapid integrated rural development, including rural agriculture land development schemes (roads/bridges, schools, clinics, women’s mobilisation for income generation, basic literacy, nutrition and health)

  • Resulted in:

  • Improved transportation to hospitals

  • Expanding network of hospitals

Increased political awareness of the popularity of provision of healthcare services
Education sector
  • Rapid expansion of primary and secondary schools

  • Rising education level of school leavers

  • Resulted in:

  • Better-qualified candidates for the health workforce

  • Probably increasing health literacy and empowerment of women, particularly for use of health services (no Malaysian data)

Components of the health system
Health services (STC)

Public sector

  1. 1. Inherited dilapidated hospitals, mostly in urban areas in state capitals – some were refurbished during this period.

  2. 2. New district-level hospitals were constructed.

  3. 3. District hospitals had staff and basic investigation facilities capable of managing major communicable diseases (malaria, TB, leprosy) and childbirth to reduce maternal deaths. Few had surgical facilities.

  4. 4. Ambulances provided free transport for patients from health centres and district hospitals to larger hospitals.

  5. 5. State-level hospitals provided more sophisticated imaging, laboratory and surgical services and specialists for basic specialties.

  6. 6. There were strong linkages (referrals, case finding, leadership support) with rural maternal and child health (MCH) services and TB and malaria programmes.

    Private sector

  7. 7. A few not-for-profit missionary hospitals had specialist services.

  8. 8. Several small nursing homes catered mainly for childbirth.

  9. 9. In the late 1970s, a few specialists resigned from the public sector and set up the first few doctor-owned private for-profit hospitals.

Influence of other components of the health system on STCInfluence of STC on other components of the health system
Other modalities of service delivery
  • Public sector:

  • Rural MCH services and TB control programme formed close bidirectional links with hospitals, especially for maternal health, which helped to popularise safe childbirth, and for TB treatment.

  • Private sector (NGOs):

  • Private hospitals had links with TCM providers.

Health workforce
  • Shortage of doctors and specialists dictated the types of services available at each type of hospital.

  • Introduction of compulsory year of post-registration service in the public sector for all doctors to provide staff for more rural facilities.

  • Nurses, midwives and medical assistants were the backbone of district-level hospitals.

  • Demand for expanded health workforce to provide services in the expanding network of hospitals.

  • Demand for health workforce willing and able to work in less developed states (e.g. East Coast states of Peninsular Malaysia).

  • ‘Task shifting’ – the MoH granted authority to nurses and medical assistants to perform some tasks of doctors in remote locations where doctors were unavailable (e.g. anaesthesia, trauma care, some complications of childbirth).

Governance and financing of health sector
  • Financing

  • Public sector: Provision of highly subsidised medical care funded by the government was almost free at point of delivery.

  • Private sector: Payment was on a fee-for-service basis, being mostly out-of-pocket expenditure for patients and their families.

  • Governance

  • Laws and regulations under the MoH regulated the practice of the medical, nursing, midwifery, dental and pharmacy professions. The Boards also had oversight of recognition of qualifications.

Health information
  • Very little information was available on hospital utilisation (only volume of admissions, childbirth, deaths and attendance at clinics).

  • Resulted in:

  • Inadequate data for management of hospital services.

  • As a result:

  • At federal level, the MoH began the process of strengthening hospital information systems and monitoring the quality of information.

Medical products
  • Standardised essential drug lists were implemented for different categories of public sector hospitals based on types of services available. This facilitated the implementation of clinical management protocols.

  • Central procurement at federal level and improved supply logistics.

  • Resulted in:

  • Better availability (volume, continuous supply) of medical products in hospitals.

Supplementary Table 5-b STC services: interaction of forces that shaped the evolution during the 1980s and 1990s

Larger ecosystem(A) Influence on STC(B) Influence of STC on the larger ecosystem
Population behaviour and demographic profile
  • Increased rural–urban migration

  • By 1991, 51% of the population was urban

  • Rapid rise in female literacy

  • By 1997: 49% of primary school enrolment was female

  • Resulted in:

  • Rising literacy rate (72%)

  • Improving health literacy

  • Increased demand for allopathic medical care

  • Improved access to basic STC services

  • Increased demand for more sophisticated clinical care (investigation facilities, surgical services, specialist services)

  • Outcome by the end of the period:

  • Reduced disparities in access to care between geographic regions, especially between the West and East Coast states of Peninsular Malaysia

Morbidity and mortality profile
  • Decline in major communicable diseases (CDs)

  • Remaining burden from re-emerging (dengue, TB) and new CDs (HIV/AIDS)

  • Rise in NCDs (cardiovascular, metabolic, neoplastic) and accidents

  • Recognition of need for more sophisticated clinical care by policy-makers and politicians across the country

  • Outcome by the end of the period:

  • Improved quality of care in the public sector in terms of clinical outcomes, patient satisfaction and resource utilisation

Economy and macro policies
  • Budget constraints

  • Macro policy directed towards:

    • Private sector as engine of growth

    • Improving efficiency to counter budget constraints

    • Nationwide quality-improvement initiatives in the public sector

    • Addressing imbalance between regions

    • Poverty-reduction programmes

  • Resulted in initiatives to:

  • Improve quality (clinical outcomes, patient satisfaction, resource utilisation)

  • Outsource some hospital support services

  • Begin the growth of private sector hospital and specialist services

Rise in private sector expenditure on health care (see Chapter 9)
Education sector
  • Better-qualified school levers were now demanding tertiary education.

  • Tertiary education was expanded, including local production of doctors and various allied health professionals (see Chapter 8). This contributed to changing the profile of the health workforce in hospitals.

Increased the demand for medical education by increasing the visibility and prestige of doctors and specialists (see Chapter 8)
  • Influence of other components of the health system

  • on STC

  • Influence of STC

  • on other components of the health system

Other modalities of healthcare delivery
  • Notification of CDs (dengue) improved through collaboration between the disease control programme and STC services.

  • Support from STC to the PHC level was strengthened through the QAP, whereby senior specialists in state-level hospitals had to take responsibility for quality in their discipline in district hospitals and health centres (e.g. maternal health, paediatrics, surgery).

  • Health workforce

  • (see Chapter 8 for details)

  • More doctors became available.

  • There was brain drain of doctors and nurses from the public to the private sector.

  • The competence and remuneration of nurses and hospital assistants (medical assistants) was upgraded.

  • More specialised categories of allied health personnel were recruited or trained to support the growing number of specialist services.

  • Management skills in public sector hospitals were upgraded.

  • Increased demand for doctors, dentists, pharmacists and nurses

  • Resulting in:

  • Increased local production

  • Increased financial support for foreign training of local candidates (doctors and dentists)

  • Establishment of local training programmes for a wider range of allied health personnel

Governance

Public sector

  • ‘Regionalisation’ of hospitals to improve geographic distribution of specialist services

  • Improved financial literacy of hospital managers

  • Improved community participation (hospital boards)

Private sector

  • Fee schedules agreed on for private sector doctors and specialists

  • Increased recognition of safety and quality issues in smaller private sector providers of inpatient care

  • Increasing influence of clinical specialists in health policy and programme management

  • Improved linkages with some public sector health programmes (disease control, e.g. dengue notification, clinical management protocol)

Healthcare financingProgressive decentralisation of financial authority and responsibility to state-level hospitals (modified budgeting system)

In 1985:

  • % national budget allocated to health: 4.3%

  • % GNP for health: 1.68%

  • Public sector funded 75% of THE

  • 13% of MoH budget spent on development

Demand for increasing share of the government budget for the health sector because of higher-cost personnel and high-cost technology

Health information
  • Better quality and timeliness of hospital data facilitated

  • Better allocation of resources (human, materials)

  • Improved monitoring of performance (utilisation, clinical quality, patient satisfaction)

  • Strengthened capacity for and production of health technology assessment contributed to rational acquisition of technology and products in the MoH network

  • Monitoring of quality of care in hospitals strengthened the quality of data generated in hospitals, e.g. causes of death, ICD coding

  • Strengthened capacity for clinical trials and management research in hospitals

  • Improved communication with patients (health promotion, patient education)

Save book to Kindle

To save this book to your Kindle, first ensure [email protected] is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about saving to your Kindle.

Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

Available formats
×

Save book to Dropbox

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Dropbox.

Available formats
×

Save book to Google Drive

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Google Drive.

Available formats
×