Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-f46jp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-23T16:42:34.621Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Historical Paths and Contemporary Evolution of Sharia-Compliant Finance in Central Asian Regions

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2025

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This research paper has been complied by Abhishek Thommandru, Abdumukhtor Rakhmanov, Shokhrukhbek Tillaboev and Varda Mone. It explores the historical trajectories and modern dynamics of Islamic financial law in Central Asia, a region characterised by a rich tapestry of cultural influences and a predominantly Muslim population. The paper traces the evolution of Islamic finance from its roots in Sharia principles, such as the avoidance of riba, gharar, and maysir, to its current sophisticated framework that promotes equity, transparency, and social welfare. The unique blend of traditional practices and modern regulations in Central Asian Islamic financial jurisprudence is examined, along with the factors driving the industry's growth, including increasing awareness, regulatory support, and integration with global markets.

The paper also delves into the key principles underpinning Islamic financial institutions, such as the prohibition of interest, risk-sharing, and asset-backed financing, and discusses the progress made by Central Asian countries in establishing regulatory frameworks, Shariah compliance oversight, and legal infrastructure. The development of Islamic banking practices, capital markets and takaful in the region is also explored, highlighting the availability of Sharia-compliant products and services. However, the challenges of harmonising Islamic and conventional laws, ensuring consistent Shariah interpretation, and establishing effective dispute resolution mechanisms are also addressed.

The economic impact of Islamic finance in promoting financial inclusion, attracting investments, and fostering stability is also analysed, along with the influence of cultural considerations, social welfare, and ethical investing on the acceptance and growth of Islamic finance in Central Asia. Case studies from Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and Tajikistan are presented to illustrate successful implementation strategies. The paper concludes by emphasising the potential for Islamic finance to drive sustainable economic development in Central Asia and the need for ongoing research, collaboration, and policy support to navigate the complex dynamics of this evolving field. The findings contribute to a deeper understanding of the historical trajectories and modern dynamics of Islamic financial law in Central Asia, providing valuable insights for policymakers, practitioners, and researchers in this rapidly growing sector.

Type
International Perspectives
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2025. Published by British and Irish Association of Law Librarians

INTRODUCTION

Islamic finance is firmly grounded in the principles of Sharia, or Islamic law. At the core of this financial system is the strict prohibition of riba (usury), gharar (uncertainty), and maysir (gambling). By adhering to these principles, Islamic finance aims to promote fairness, justice, and the well-being of society within the financial realm. The origins of Islamic finance can be traced back to the time of Prophet Muhammad, when trade transactions and partnerships based on Islamic principles first emerged. Over time, a sophisticated array of financial instruments has developed, including mudarabah (profit-sharing), musharakah (joint venture), ijara (lease agreements), and sukuk (Islamic bonds). This evolved framework is governed by a complex set of guidelines infused with ethical mandates. These guidelines are designed to enhance transparency, encourage risk-sharing, and ensure commitment to social responsibilities within financial transactions.Footnote 1

In the heart of the global stage lies Central Asia, encompassing nations such as Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan. This region is crucial due to its prime position and historical richness. The shared legacy of these countries is marked by influences from Turkic tribes, Persian traditions, and Russian imperial expansion. A significant Muslim demographic resides in Central Asia, with Islam playing a pivotal role in shaping the legal and financial structures historically within the area. When delving into Islamic financial jurisprudence within this context, one finds a distinctive mixture of age-old customs and contemporary regulatory measures. Navigating Islamic finance's advancement here requires comprehension of indigenous habits, spiritual convictions, alongside modifications in the worldwide fiscal scenery. Investigations into Central Asia's panoramic view afford scholars an avenue to understand how Islamic financial statutes engage with varied sociocultural and economical encounters across this territory.Footnote 2

In Central Asia, Islamic financial principles play a significant role in shaping the economic landscape. By embracing Islamic financing concepts such as profit and risk sharing, countries in this region can strengthen their financial systems and attract investments from global Islamic finance institutions. This shift towards an Islamic economic model can contribute to achieving financial stability and inclusivity, providing an alternative avenue for both individuals and businesses to access capital. Moreover, implementing regulations based on Islamic finance principles can encourage investment practices that align with ethical and socially responsible values, which resonate with the cultural norms prevalent throughout Central Asia. As these nations strive to promote economic growth and attract foreign investors, harnessing the tenets of Islamic finance presents a compelling strategy to drive economic development and ensure financial resilience within the region.Footnote 3

HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF ISLAMIC FINANCE

Islamic finance has its origins in the fundamental principles of Islam, which were established at the religion's inception. These principles include the prohibition of riba (interest) and the promotion of risk-sharing mechanisms. The modern era of Islamic finance began in 1963 in Egypt with the establishment of the Mit Ghamr Savings Bank, marking a significant milestone in the development of Islamic banking. Since then, the sector has experienced rapid growth, with numerous institutions offering Sharia-compliant products and services worldwide. The cornerstone of Islamic finance is adherence to Sharia, or Islamic law, which prohibits practices considered unethical, such as speculation and gambling. Instead, Islamic finance focuses on promoting economic transactions that are transparent, fair, and socially responsible. This ethical framework appeals not only to Muslims but also to non-Muslim individuals who seek a financial system that aligns with their moral values.Footnote 4

Several factors have influenced the spread of Islamic finance in Central Asia. The region is home to a predominantly Muslim population, which provides a natural foundation for the acceptance of Islamic financial principles. Additionally, a growing awareness and understanding of Islamic finance concepts have led to an increased demand for Sharia-compliant financial products in Central Asian countries such as Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and Tajikistan. The efforts of international Islamic financial institutions and organisations in promoting Islamic finance practices have significantly contributed to the sector's growth in the region. Moreover, governments’ initiatives to create regulatory frameworks that accommodate Islamic finance have played a role in its expansion. As Central Asian economies become increasingly integrated with global financial markets, it is expected that the adoption of Islamic finance will continue to grow, creating opportunities for further development in this field.Footnote 5

The evolution of Islamic financial jurisprudence in Central Asia has been shaped by a complex interplay of historical contexts, socio-economic factors, and political influences. Traditionally, the region relied heavily on conventional Islamic methods of finance and trade, which were significantly influenced by neighbouring countries and historical practices. However, as globalisation intensified and integration with the global economy increased, there was a notable shift towards modernising Islamic financial regulations to align with international standards and practices. This transition posed unique challenges for policymakers as they sought to maintain the fundamental principles of Islamic finance while adapting to a changing economic landscape. The incorporation of Islamic financing principles into the legal frameworks of Central Asian countries reflects a growing recognition of the importance of ethical and sustainable financial practices in the region.

PRINCIPLES OF ISLAMIC FINANCIAL LAW

Prohibition of Riba (Interest)

In Islamic economic jurisprudence, the prohibition of riba is a fundamental principle that aims to promote fairness and ethical conduct in financial transactions. Riba encompasses the practices of charging, paying, or receiving interest on loans, which are considered exploitative and unjust within the Islamic framework. The primary justification for this prohibition is to ensure the equitable distribution of wealth and prevent its concentration among a select group of individuals or entities. In regions like Central Asia, where Islamic finance is gaining prominence, adherence to this prohibition plays a crucial role in shaping the financial landscape and promoting economic development in accordance with Islamic principles. By upholding the ban on riba, Central Asian countries seek to establish an economic system that not only aligns with Islamic ethical standards but also fosters shared prosperity and mitigates financial risks.Footnote 6

Concept of Risk-Sharing

In Islamic banking, the principle of risk sharing is a distinguishing feature that sets it apart from conventional financial systems. Adhering to the principles of Islamic finance, there is a strong emphasis on shared risk-taking, as it aligns with the values of fairness and ethical behaviour. Under this framework, where risks and rewards are jointly shouldered by both financiers and entrepreneurs, a more equitable distribution of wealth is achieved while promoting accountability among all stakeholders. This approach not only fosters trust and transparency but also strengthens the relationships between parties involved in financial transactions. By incorporating the concept of risk sharing into its financial practices, Islamic finance seeks to mitigate moral hazards while encouraging genuine economic growth. Scholars emphasise the crucial role of risk sharing in achieving the ultimate goal of promoting socio-economic justice and balance, not only within predominantly Muslim countries but also on a global scale. This emphasis on equitable risk management underscores why Islamic finance can be regarded as an ethical alternative to conventional financial systems.Footnote 7

Asset-Backed Financing

In the context of Islamic financial regulations in Central Asia, asset-backed financing plays a crucial role in providing alternative methods of financing that comply with Sharia principles. This financial approach involves the creation of sukuk, which represents ownership in physical assets, thus avoiding interest-based transactions. The use of asset-backed financing promotes a more equitable distribution of risk between investors and issuers, reflecting the core principles of Islamic finance that emphasise shared risk and profit. As Islamic finance gains traction in Central Asia, asset-backed financing serves as a means to access capital markets while adhering to religious guidelines. By structuring financial offerings around tangible assets such as infrastructure projects or real estate, Islamic financial institutions in Central Asia have the opportunity to tap into new sources of funding, thereby supporting economic growth in the region. Moreover, asset-backed financing enhances financial stability by diversifying funding sources and encouraging adherence to prudent risk management practices.Footnote 8

REGULATORY FRAMEWORK FOR ISLAMIC FINANCE IN CENTRAL ASIA

Central Bank Regulations

Central banks play a crucial role in shaping the Islamic finance landscape in Central Asia through their regulatory frameworks. These institutions ensure compliance with Sharia principles while contributing to the stability and growth of the sector. By supervising Islamic financial institutions, central banks mitigate risks and safeguard the interests of both consumers and investors. Moreover, these regulations foster innovation and adaptability in response to changing market conditions, encouraging the development of new Islamic financial products tailored to regional needs. Through their oversight and enforcement of standards, central banks maintain the integrity and credibility of Islamic financing practices, ultimately contributing to the stability of the Central Asian economy.Footnote 9

Shariah Compliance Oversight

In Islamic finance institutions in Central Asia, ensuring compliance with Sharia principles is of utmost importance, guaranteeing that operations are conducted in accordance with the fundamental beliefs and laws of Islam. This regulatory framework is maintained through the establishment of Sharia boards, which consist of knowledgeable scholars who review financial products and transactions to ensure their conformity with Islamic jurisprudence. These supervisory bodies play a crucial role in assessing both the ethical and legal aspects of financial activities, providing guidance and direction to ensure adherence to Sharia principles. Additionally, internal audit mechanisms are essential for monitoring compliance with Islamic principles within these institutions. Through regular audits and assessments, Islamic finance organisations ensure operational transparency and integrity, mitigating any risks of non-compliance. Robust supervisory frameworks enhance the credibility of institutions offering Islamic financial services while fostering confidence among stakeholders, thereby contributing to the thriving development of this sector.Footnote 10

Legal Infrastructure for Islamic Finance

In Central Asia, the legal framework plays a crucial role in supporting the growth and development of Islamic financial institutions. Establishing regulatory environments that are compatible with Sharia principles is essential for creating an ecosystem in which Islamic financial products and services can thrive. Countries in Central Asia, such as Kazakhstan, have made significant progress in implementing laws and regulations that facilitate Islamic finance, including the issuance of sukuk and the establishment of Islamic banks. However, challenges remain in aligning existing legal systems with Islamic financial practices and strengthening the capacity of supervisory authorities. Policymakers and regulators must continue to refine the legal frameworks to address these challenges and promote the ongoing development of Islamic financial sectors across Central Asia. Despite the progress made thus far, sustained efforts are necessary to ensure that Islamic financial institutions operate effectively within a well-defined legal framework.Footnote 11

ISLAMIC BANKING PRACTICES IN CENTRAL ASIA

Types of Islamic Banking Institutions

Islamic banking institutions can be classified into various categories based on their organisational structure and operational functions. One of the primary categories is Islamic banks themselves, which operate in accordance with Sharia principles. These banks offer a range of financial services while avoiding interest-based transactions. They adhere to specific Islamic finance contracts such as Mudarabah (profit-sharing), Murabaha (cost-plus financing), and Ijarah (leasing). Another category within the Islamic finance ecosystem is Islamic investment banks, which focus on equity-based financing, venture capital initiatives, and project financing while refraining from interest-bearing instruments. Takaful companies, which provide cooperative-based Islamic insurance services, are also an integral part of the Islamic financial institution landscape. These organisations ensure compliance with Sharia laws, catering to the ethical standards and religious preferences of Muslim customers seeking financial products and services. The diversity of Islamic banking institutions reflects the growing demand for Sharia-compliant solutions in modern economies.Footnote 12

Products and Services Offered

In Central Asia, Islamic financial institutions provide a wide range of products and services that comply with Sharia principles. They offer various financing options such as Mudarabah (profit-sharing), Musharakah (partnership), and Ijarah (leasing). In addition to these financing facilities, Islamic banks in the region also provide additional services, including Takaful (Islamic insurance), Sharia-compliant investment funds, and microfinance solutions that adhere to Islamic guidelines. By tailoring their offerings to meet the needs of both individuals and businesses while ensuring compliance with Sharia requirements, these institutions offer a diverse array of interest-free financial instruments, which are essential for those seeking ethical financial options in Central Asia. Their contribution is not only crucial for the growth of a robust Islamic financial sector but also instrumental in promoting financial inclusion and strengthening the economic framework of Central Asia.Footnote 13

Customer Base and Market Penetration

In the context of Islamic financial jurisprudence in Central Asia, understanding customer demographics and market penetration is of utmost importance. For Islamic financial institutions operating in this region, it is crucial to develop products and services that cater to the ethical standards and needs of their target audience. Strategies to expand market reach include developing Sharia-compliant innovations and leveraging advanced technologies to engage a wider customer base, which are essential for increasing the impact of Islamic financial institutions across Central Asian markets. Conducting thorough market research, analysing demographic trends, and identifying potential growth areas enable these institutions to optimise their operations and expand their regional presence. Therefore, a deep understanding of customer profiles and effective market penetration strategies are key drivers for the advancement of Islamic finance in Central Asia.Footnote 14

ISLAMIC CAPITAL MARKET IN CENTRAL ASIA

Sukuk Market Development

In the sphere of Islamic finance in Central Asia, the development of the sukuk market has been a key focus. Countries are seeking to diversify their financial instruments and attract international investors, and sukuk presents an attractive avenue due to its compliance with Sharia principles. However, the growth of a robust sukuk market faces challenges such as standardisation issues, lack of legal frameworks, and limited investor awareness. Addressing these challenges requires collaborative efforts between regulators and market participants to enhance transparency, establish standardised practices, and initiate educational initiatives. By doing so, Central Asian countries can fully harness the potential of Islamic finance, attract a broader range of investors, and support infrastructure development. If properly developed, the sukuk market has the potential to make a significant contribution to the region's economic growth and stability.Footnote 15

Equity-Based Financing

In Islamic finance, equity-based financing is a fundamental principle that upholds the values of risk-sharing and partnership. Unlike debt-based financing, this model creates an environment where both profits and risks are shared between the financier and the entrepreneur. It promotes a more equitable distribution of wealth while fostering entrepreneurship within the community. Particularly in Central Asia, where Islamic finance practices are gaining prominence, the use of equity-based financing can significantly enhance financial inclusion and economic development. By channelling investments into businesses and projects through ownership stakes, Islamic financial institutions can drive growth in a manner consistent with Sharia principles. This approach not only encourages sustainable development but also helps mitigate the risks associated with debt-based financing methods. Therefore, incorporating equity-based financing strategies into the Islamic finance landscape in Central Asia has the potential to create a more robust and inclusive financial system.Footnote 16

Regulatory Challenges and Opportunities

Navigating the complex landscape of Islamic financial law regulation in Central Asia presents a range of intricate challenges and opportunities. The diverse regulatory frameworks across the region, shaped by historical, cultural, and geopolitical factors, complicate the implementation and enforcement of Islamic finance principles. However, these challenges also present opportunities for fostering regulatory harmonisation and collaboration among Central Asian countries to create a more conducive environment for Islamic financial institutions. By leveraging shared values and best practices, regulators across Central Asia have the potential to enhance cross-border cooperation, standardise regulatory frameworks, and promote greater financial inclusion throughout the region. This could result in a more robust and adaptable Islamic finance ecosystem that not only responds effectively to the evolving needs of the Central Asian market but also maintains strict adherence to Sharia principles.Footnote 17

TAKAFUL (ISLAMIC INSURANCE) IN CENTRAL ASIA

Growth of Takaful Industry

Central Asia has recently experienced significant growth in the takaful sector, driven by an increasing demand for financial products that adhere to Islamic principles. As a Sharia-compliant alternative to conventional insurance, takaful distinguishes itself through its emphasis on mutual assistance and compliance with Islamic tenets. The growing awareness of the importance of risk management among both individuals and businesses has further fuelled the expansion of the takaful industry. Moreover, government support and favourable regulations for Islamic finance have paved the way for takaful operators in Central Asia. As the sector evolves, it is essential for policymakers and stakeholders to address challenges related to standardisation, consumer protection, and product innovation to sustain and enhance the relevance and effectiveness of takaful in the region.Footnote 18

Takaful Models in Central Asia

In Central Asia takaful systems are gaining prominence as a means of delivering Islamic financial solutions in the region. These frameworks provide a unique alternative to conventional insurance, adhering to Sharia principles of mutual assistance and risk-sharing. With the growing presence of Islamic finance in Central Asian countries, takaful can serve as a crucial link between banking services and the Muslim population. However, the implementation of takaful faces challenges related to regulatory frameworks, product development, and issues of consumer understanding and awareness. Exploring different models of takaful tailored to the specific needs of various Central Asian nations could present opportunities to enhance financial inclusion while promoting Islamic finance in the region. Further research is needed to assess the feasibility and impact of different takaful structures to ensure their successful integration into the economic landscape.Footnote 19

Regulatory Framework for Takaful

In Central Asia, a strong regulatory framework for takaful is crucial for ensuring the stability and credibility of Islamic financial institutions in the region. The practices governing takaful operations are primarily influenced by adherence to Sharia law, ensuring compliance with Islamic principles. These regulations encompass aspects related to capital requirements, investment guidelines, risk management, and disclosure standards specifically designed for takaful operators. Central Asian countries are faced with the task of developing comprehensive regulatory frameworks that recognise the unique characteristics of takaful to enhance confidence and transparency among all stakeholders. Harmonising these regulations across the region can help foster the growth of takaful and strengthen its role in contributing to the broader economic landscape. The establishment of robust regulatory environments enables these countries to attract investors while promoting sustainable development within the Islamic finance sector.Footnote 20

LEGAL CHALLENGES IN IMPLEMENTING ISLAMIC FINANCIAL LAW

Harmonisation with Conventional Laws

Ensuring compatibility with conventional laws is a crucial consideration for the implementation of Islamic financial regulations in Central Asia. The relationship between the products and services offered by Islamic finance and the existing legal frameworks has a significant impact on its acceptance and growth in these countries. Given that the legal systems in Central Asian nations are predominantly secular, achieving harmony with conventional laws is necessary for the successful integration of Islamic finance. Such alignment can help minimise potential conflicts, creating a supportive environment for the operations of Islamic financial institutions. By incorporating Islamic financial practices into the existing legal frameworks, Central Asian countries can foster the development of their respective Islamic finance sectors while adhering to international standards and guidelines. Ultimately, aligning with conventional laws enhances regulatory transparency and legal certainty, which are essential for the sustainable growth of Islamic finance in the region.Footnote 21

Shariah Interpretation and Consistency

In the field of Islamic financial law, the interpretation of Sharia is essential for ensuring that financial practices align with the fundamental principles of Islam. Scholars and legal experts are tasked with the responsibility of examining the primary sources of Islam to provide guidance on modern financial transactions, a challenge compounded by the dynamic nature of finance. Finding a balance between accommodating the evolving financial landscape while firmly adhering to the immutable tenets of Sharia presents a significant challenge. This endeavour highlights the importance of achieving a unified understanding through scholarly consensus and dialogue within the Islamic finance community, aimed at addressing emerging issues. Although opinions may vary on specific matters, fostering a harmonised interpretation of Sharia rulings is crucial for maintaining stability and growth within Islamic financial systems across Central Asia and beyond. Collaborative efforts among experts are vital in navigating the complexities associated with Sharia interpretation while ensuring consistency in the application of Islamic financial regulations.Footnote 22

Dispute Resolution Mechanisms

In the context of Islamic financial law in Central Asia, dispute resolution mechanisms play a crucial role in ensuring the stability and credibility of the finance industry. One of the primary methods employed is Sharia-compliant arbitration, which involves the resolution of disputes by arbitrators well-versed in Islamic jurisprudence. This approach ensures that decisions are in line with Islamic principles, thereby enhancing trust among the parties involved. Additionally, mediation is often used to reach mutually acceptable solutions, reducing the need for lengthy legal proceedings. These practices not only expedite the resolution of disputes but also enhance the overall effectiveness and efficiency of the Islamic finance sector in the region. By combining traditional Islamic principles with modern dispute resolution techniques, Central Asia effectively addresses complex financial issues while upholding the ethical standards set forth in Islamic finance. Ultimately, these strategies are essential for fostering a robust and sustainable financial landscape in the region.Footnote 23

ECONOMIC IMPACT OF ISLAMIC FINANCE IN CENTRAL ASIA

A crucial aspect of Islamic financial regulation in Central Asia is its significant role in promoting financial inclusion. By providing alternative financial solutions that comply with Islamic principles, such as profit-sharing arrangements and the avoidance of interest, Islamic financial institutions can serve individuals who may be excluded from conventional banking systems due to religious or ethical considerations. This aspect is particularly important in regions where access to traditional banking services may be limited or incompatible with the beliefs of the local population. By fostering inclusive finance through Islamic mechanisms, it becomes possible not only to empower marginalised communities but also to drive economic growth and strengthen social cohesion. Thus, the incorporation of Islamic finance principles into the financial frameworks of Central Asian countries contributes significantly to expanding access to financial services and promoting sustainable development throughout the region.Footnote 24

Leveraging Islamic financial regulations to stimulate investment and drive economic growth in Central Asia requires a strategic approach. Integrating Islamic finance principles into the region's financial systems can open up new avenues for capital, attract foreign investment, and encourage entrepreneurship. This can be achieved by developing legal frameworks that accommodate Islamic finance transactions, such as the issuance of sukuk and the provision of sharia-compliant banking services. Moreover, increasing public awareness and acceptance of Islamic financial products through education can lead to greater participation in the market economy. Collaborating with international organisations and experts in Islamic finance can provide valuable insights for capacity building and knowledge transfer, enabling Central Asian countries to fully harness the potential of Islamic finance as a driver of sustainable economic development. Ultimately, incorporating Islamic financial regulations into the local financial infrastructure can act as a catalyst for investment and economic growth while promoting inclusive financial participation that benefits all stakeholders.Footnote 25

To promote stability within Central Asia's financial ecosystem, it is crucial to mitigate systemic risks in Islamic financial institutions. Addressing this challenge requires the strengthening of supervisory frameworks that govern these entities. Enhancing regulatory measures helps identify and manage risks effectively, preventing a chain reaction of failures that could be triggered by the collapse of a single institution. Furthermore, it is essential to increase transparency and accountability among Islamic finance organisations. Through improved disclosure, stakeholders are better equipped to make informed decisions, reducing uncertainty and the likelihood of widespread financial disruptions. Additionally, promoting risk-sharing mechanisms in Islamic finance can lead to a more balanced distribution of risks among stakeholders, thereby reducing the potential for systemic failures. In summary, adopting a comprehensive approach that focuses on regulatory enhancements, increased transparency, and risk-sharing mechanisms serves as an effective way to mitigate systemic risks within Islamic financial institutions across Central Asia.Footnote 26

CULTURAL AND SOCIAL CONSIDERATIONS IN ISLAMIC FINANCE

In Central Asia, cultural acceptance and perception play a significant role in shaping the implementation of Islamic financial law. The varying degrees of acceptance of Islamic finance across different cultural contexts influence its development and evolution in the region. Central Asian countries exhibit diverse attitudes; while some are open to embracing Islamic finance principles, others remain hesitant due to prevailing cultural norms and beliefs. Understanding the nuanced cultural differences and sensitivities specific to each country is crucial for positively shaping public opinion towards Islamic finance. This highlights the need for tailored approaches that cater to the unique cultural landscape of each Central Asian nation, with the aim of fostering greater acceptance and implementation of Islamic finance practices. By directly addressing issues related to cultural acceptance and perception, policymakers and financial institutions can more effectively integrate Islamic finance into the existing economic framework of Central Asia.Footnote 27

Social Welfare and Zakat Distribution

In the context of financial jurisprudence in Central Asia, the distribution of zakat and its integration with social welfare programmes is a crucial aspect of Islamic tradition. As one of the Five Pillars of Islam, zakat mandates the obligatory giving of a portion of one's wealth for the benefit of the poor. Given the high levels of poverty in Central Asian countries, zakat plays a vital role in alleviating economic hardship and promoting social well-being. By embracing the principles of zakat, Islamic financial institutions in the region can contribute to the creation of a more equitable society through the redistribution of wealth to those in need. Moreover, when Islamic banking institutions manage and distribute these charitable funds with transparency and efficiency, they significantly strengthen the socio-economic fabric of Central Asian nations, ultimately improving the quality of life for their citizens.Footnote 28

Ethical Investment Practices

In the realm of Islamic financial legislation in Central Asia, ethical investment practices hold a prominent position. The integration of moral considerations into investment decision-making aligns with Islamic principles of fairness, transparency, and social responsibility. Ethical investment practices not only ensure compliance with Sharia regulations but also contribute to fostering sustainable development and promoting economic growth in the region. By adhering to ethical investment frameworks, investors have the potential to generate positive social impacts while achieving financial returns. Moreover, ethical investments enhance trust and credibility within the financial industry, attracting a broader range of investors who prioritise moral considerations. The adoption of ethical investment strategies strengthens the integrity of Central Asian economies, promoting long-term stability and prosperity while upholding the moral values inherent in Islamic financial jurisprudence.Footnote 29

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS WITH OTHER REGIONS

Contrasting Islamic Finance in Central Asia with the Middle East

Islamic finance in the Middle East and Central Asia exhibits both similarities and differences, reflecting the diverse applications of Islamic financial principles within different geopolitical contexts. Compared to the well-established Islamic finance sector in the Middle East, the Islamic finance industry in Central Asia is still in its nascent stages, reflecting varying levels of financial development and regulatory frameworks. While adhering to the core principles of Islamic finance, such as the prohibition of interest (riba) and uncertainty (gharar), Islamic financial institutions in Central Asia face challenges due to a lack of expertise and infrastructure. In contrast, the Middle East presents a more advanced and diverse landscape for Islamic finance, characterised by a wide range of products and services catering to both domestic and international markets. Understanding these nuanced differences is crucial for policymakers, researchers, and industry practitioners seeking to promote efficiency and inclusivity within Islamic financial systems across different regions.Footnote 30

Lessons from Southeast Asia's Islamic Finance Experience

The experience of Islamic finance in Southeast Asia can provide valuable insights for the development of Islamic financial laws in Central Asia. Examining how countries such as Malaysia and Indonesia have established their regulatory frameworks, navigated market dynamics, and built institutional capacities can assist policymakers in Central Asian countries in identifying successful strategies and avoiding potential pitfalls. These nations have effectively integrated Islamic finance into their economic landscapes, attracting investments, improving financial inclusion, and fostering economic growth. Understanding the approaches these countries have taken to address challenges such as ensuring Sharia compliance, developing human capital, and expanding market reach can guide Central Asian policymakers in formulating a roadmap for the adoption of Islamic finance principles. By leveraging lessons from Southeast Asia, decision-makers in Central Asia can create a strong and sustainable Islamic financial ecosystem that is well-suited to their unique socio-economic contexts.Footnote 31

Global Integration of Islamic Finance Practices

The integration of Islamic financial practices into the global market has recently gained momentum, drawing on a rich historical legacy. With a predominantly Muslim population, Central Asia is poised to embrace Sharia-compliant financial regulations. This endeavour involves adapting local regulatory frameworks to align with Sharia principles and tapping into the extensive global Islamic finance network. A major challenge in this process is harmonising the diverse regional Islamic finance practices to facilitate seamless international transactions. Moreover, there is a growing emphasis on fostering collaboration between local banks and international Islamic financial institutions to effectively share knowledge and resources. By strengthening cross-border partnerships and enhancing its regulatory infrastructure, Central Asia aims to position itself as an emerging hub for Islamic finance on the global stage, playing a crucial role in expanding and promoting Islamic financial norms.Footnote 32

FUTURE PROSPECTS OF ISLAMIC FINANCIAL LAW IN CENTRAL ASIA

The potential for growth and expansion of Islamic financial jurisprudence in Central Asia is remarkably significant, driven by the increasing appetite for Sharia-compliant financing. Countries such as Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan demonstrate a willingness to integrate Islamic principles into their financial systems, creating a promising opportunity for the development of Islamic finance in the region. The strong economic stability and abundant natural resources in these Central Asian nations provide a solid foundation for the growth of Islamic financial institutions, including takaful (Islamic insurance), sukuk (Islamic bonds), and Islamic banks. By embracing Islamic finance principles, these countries are well-positioned to attract foreign direct investment from predominantly Muslim nations and tap into a global market estimated to be worth trillions. As the expansion of Islamic financial services progresses in Central Asia, it has the potential to not only diversify the regional economy but also enhance financial inclusion and strengthen ties with the extensive global network of the Islamic finance industry.

Within the realm of Islamic finance, innovation and technology are becoming increasingly crucial in shaping the financial services landscape. The adoption of advanced technologies such as blockchain and artificial intelligence offers the potential to improve efficiency, enhance transparency, and increase accessibility in Islamic banking and finance systems. By leveraging these tools, financial institutions can provide a wider range of Sharia-compliant products and services that cater to the evolving needs of customers while adhering to Islamic principles. Moreover, embracing fintech solutions in Islamic finance can lead to reduced costs, mitigated risks, and improved customer satisfaction. As Central Asia strives to develop its Islamic finance sector, harnessing innovation and technological advancements will be essential for driving economic growth and promoting financial inclusion across the region.

The global landscape presents complex dynamics of challenges and opportunities for the adoption of Islamic financial law in Central Asia. These challenges stem from the region's historical lack of development in Islamic finance, the absence of regulatory frameworks, and limited awareness among the population about Sharia-compliant financial practices. Additionally, external factors such as geopolitical instability and economic fluctuations add further layers of complexity to the adoption process. However, within these challenges lie significant opportunities for growth and sustainable development. Leveraging Central Asia's strategic geographical location, vast natural resources, and growing global interest in Islamic finance presents a unique opportunity for the region to establish itself as a hub for Islamic financial activities. Building strong partnerships with established Islamic financial institutions, developing human capital through education and training programmes, and fostering innovation in financial products tailored to regional needs could propel Central Asia to a prominent position on the Islamic finance map.Footnote 33

CASE STUDIES OF SUCCESSFUL IMPLEMENTATION

Kazakhstan's Experience with Islamic Finance

Kazakhstan's engagement with Islamic finance has become a crucial element within the country's financial landscape. As a predominantly Muslim nation, there has been a growing interest in integrating Islamic finance principles to diversify its economic sector and attract foreign investments. The government has been actively working on establishing the necessary legal framework for Islamic financial institutions to operate, including the development of sukuk (Islamic bonds) and the establishment of Islamic banks. However, challenges remain, such as the limited awareness of Islamic finance practices among the population and the lack of qualified professionals in the field. Despite these obstacles, Kazakhstan's embrace of Islamic finance reflects a broader trend across Central Asia, where countries are seeking to incorporate these principles into their existing financial systems, contributing to economic development and growth in the region.Footnote 34

Uzbekistan's Adoption of Islamic Banking

Uzbekistan's strategic move towards embracing Islamic banking reflects a commitment to financial inclusion and adherence to Islamic values. Uzbekistan's entry into Islamic finance is a response to the growing global demand for Sharia-compliant financial solutions. This initiative by Uzbekistan highlights a broader trend across Central Asia towards the integration of Islamic financial instruments, aiming to attract international capital and enhance diversification within the financial sector. The implementation of Islamic banking practices in Uzbekistan seeks to cater to the preferences of its Muslim population while positioning the country as a regional hub for Islamic finance. This shift demonstrates the Uzbek government's progressive approach, leveraging Islamic finance principles as a means to promote economic growth and maintain financial stability across the nation. It sets a precedent for other Central Asian countries to explore similar strategies for financial innovation and growth.Footnote 35

Tajikistan's Regulatory Framework for Islamic Finance

Tajikistan has recently made significant strides in updating its regulatory framework to accommodate the growing demand for Sharia-compliant financial products. The establishment of the National Bank of Tajikistan (NBT) as the primary supervisory authority for Islamic banking activities underscores the country's commitment to Islamic finance. The NBT has introduced specific guidelines and regulations designed to govern the operations of Islamic financial institutions, ensuring compliance with Sharia principles while maintaining financial stability across the sector. Moreover, Tajikistan has taken steps to harmonise its regulatory environment with international standards, aiming to enhance transparency and attract foreign investment into its Islamic finance industry. These proactive measures demonstrate the government's recognition of the potential for Islamic finance to drive economic growth and promote financial inclusion within the country. As a result, it is evident that Tajikistan's strategic approach to strengthening regulations for Sharia-compliant banking is focused on harnessing the associated benefits while ensuring robust oversight of its financial ecosystem.Footnote 36

IMPACT OF GEOPOLITICAL FACTORS ON ISLAMIC FINANCIAL LAW IN CENTRAL ASIA

The influence of global interactions on the development of Islamic financial law in Central Asia is substantial. Central Asian countries, such as Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan, are increasingly aligning their Islamic finance regulations with international standards, reflecting the global nature of Islamic finance. This trend is evident in the adoption of best practices from organisations like the Islamic Financial Services Board (IFSB) and the Accounting and Auditing Organisation for Islamic Financial Institutions (AAOIFI). Moreover, international collaborations and partnerships with regions such as the Middle East and Southeast Asia have facilitated knowledge sharing and capacity-building initiatives in these countries with respect to Islamic finance. As Central Asian nations further integrate into the global financial system, the impact of international interactions on Islamic financial regulations will continue to play a crucial role in shaping the regulatory landscape across the region.Footnote 37

The pursuit of collective action and mutual development in the heart of Asia has garnered interest, given the region's pivotal geopolitical position and burgeoning economic potential. The driving force behind strengthening ties among nations such as Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and Tajikistan lies in their desire to expand commercial networks, enhance infrastructure development, and foster economic prosperity. Leveraging platforms like the Central Asia Regional Economic Cooperation (CAREC) initiative enables these states to tackle shared challenges while reaping the benefits of collective gains. Such a collaborative approach facilitates resource sharing and knowledge exchange to address issues encompassing the improvement of inter-country transportation routes, fostering connections in the energy sectors, and amplifying financial synergies. Through persistent commitment to regional unity and integration, the countries of Central Asia are poised to elevate their standing in international markets while charting paths toward sustainable progress.Footnote 38

In the realm of Islamic financial jurisprudence in Central Asia, concerns related to stability and safeguarding hold paramount importance. The region's propensity for socio-economic instability necessitates a robust regulatory framework aimed at maintaining the resilience of institutions grounded in Islamic finance. Inadequate safeguard measures may expose these entities to various perils, such as fraud, money laundering, and financing of terrorist activities, thereby undermining the foundational integrity of the broader financial ecosystem. Nations within Central Asia are tasked with mitigating these vulnerabilities through enhanced oversight mechanisms, adept risk management practices, and rigorous compliance frameworks. Collaborative efforts between regulatory bodies, financial institutions, and international organisations are crucial in bolstering the security and stability of the Islamic finance sector within the region. By fortifying the governing landscape, Central Asian nations can instil confidence among stakeholders and foster the growth of Islamic finance as a credible alternative to traditional banking systems.

CONCLUSION

The fascination with Islamic financial regulation in Central Asia has surged due to the region's rich cultural tapestry and untapped economic potential. While Islamic doctrines have historically influenced the territory, the actual implementation of Islamic fiscal mechanisms remains somewhat limited. Obstacles such as a general lack of knowledge, inadequate legislative frameworks, and a deficit in expert personnel have hindered the expansion of Islamic monetary practices in Central Asia. However, recent trends suggest an impending shift towards embracing Sharia-compliant banking solutions more fully, fuelled by an escalating demand for ethically aligned and religiously permissible financial options.

As Central Asian administrations begin to appreciate the added value that could be harnessed by integrating Islamic financing into their broader economic fabric, there emerges an intensified call for deeper investigation and collaborative efforts aimed at fostering the maturation of Islamic finance jurisprudence across this locale. In the heartland of Central Asia, the laws governing Islamic finance hold profound consequences for both policy formulation and practical applications. Scholars argue that introducing Islamic financial mechanisms can promote economic expansion and inclusion by offering financing solutions aligned with Sharia mandates, thus appealing to a wider array of individuals who might have been sidelined by conventional banking frameworks.

For policymakers, it's imperative to meticulously scrutinise the regulatory infrastructure needed to bolster Islamic finance's growth while safeguarding consumer interests and maintaining steady financial conditions. Furthermore, professionals in this field must possess appropriate expertise and understanding to efficiently deliver products and services rooted in Islamic finance principles. Hence, a comprehensive strategy amalgamating legislative, regulatory, and educational components stands essential for seamlessly integrating Islamic financing within Central Asia's fabric – a move poised to significantly enhance its sustainable economic progression.

Moving forward, future inquiries within the sphere of Islamic financial jurisprudence in Central Asia should focus on several pivotal elements. Firstly, analysts are encouraged to undertake a more profound comparative analysis among various Central Asian nations concerning their adoption and infusion of Islamic fiscal tenets and regulations into their legislative structures. Such an inter-country examination will shed light on both triumphs and obstacles encountered by each state, thereby paving the way for devising sharper policy recommendations. Moreover, probing into how Islamic fiscal bodies foster economic progression across this locale emerges as another promising research avenue. Understanding the dynamics between these institutions and conventional monetary systems, as well as their role in broadening financial inclusivity, is paramount for both lawmakers and field professionals.

Additionally, scrutinising how cultural and social nuances influence the embrace and adaptation of Islamic financing tools in Central Asia might yield a comprehensive perspective on the intricate interactions characterising this territory. In summary, forthcoming studies should strive to provide practical and immediate guidance for policymakers, regulatory figures, and industry participants to further catalyse enhancement and stability regarding Islamic finance throughout Central Asia.

Delving into the nuances of Islamic financial laws within Central Asia has shed light on both the regulatory framework and barriers to enacting Islamic finance across this territory. This examination underscores the urgent call for more in-depth investigations and teamwork among academics, policymakers, and industry experts to enhance Islamic financing's landscape in Central Asia. The outcome highlights a critical need for an enriched understanding of the societal, juridical, and fiscal elements that influence the integration of Islamic financial norms into the local milieu. Prospective inquiries should aim to uncover creative solutions for navigating through impediments that stall Islamic finance's proliferation within Central Asia while also exploring how it could advantageously impact regional economies. In essence, this research signals a crucial ongoing necessity for scholarly exploration and exchanges as means to further propel the realm of Islamic finance both within Central Asian borders and elsewhere.

References

Endnotes

1 Pollard, J. and Samers, M. (2007), ‘Islamic banking and finance: postcolonial political economy and the decentring of economic geography’. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 32: 313330CrossRefGoogle Scholar. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-5661.2007.00255.x

2 Maurer, Bill. Mutual Life, Limited: Islamic Banking, Alternative Currencies, Lateral Reason, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2005Google Scholar. https://doi.org/10.1515/9781400840717

3 Karim, W. J. (2010). ‘The Economic Crisis, Capitalism and Islam: The Making of a New Economic Order?Globalizations, 7(1–2), 105125CrossRefGoogle Scholar. https://doi.org/10.1080/14747731003593315

4 Fang, E. S. (2014). ‘Islamic finance in global markets: Materialism, ideas and the construction of financial knowledge.’ Review of International Political Economy, 21(6), 11701202CrossRefGoogle Scholar. https://doi.org/10.1080/09692290.2013.858229

5 Hanieh, A. (2020). ‘New geographies of financial power: global Islamic finance and the Gulf.’ Third World Quarterly, 41(3), 525546CrossRefGoogle Scholar. https://doi.org/10.1080/01436597.2019.1675505

6 Rudnyckyj., DaromirFrom Wall Street to Halal Street: Malaysia and the Globalization of Islamic Finance.’ Journal of Asian Studies 1 November 2013; 72 (4): 831848CrossRefGoogle Scholar. doi: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0021911813001630

7 Cortelezzi, F., & Ferrari, A. (Eds.). (2022). ‘Contemporary Issues in Islamic Law, Economics and Finance: A Multidisciplinary Approach (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003155218

8 Jonathan Ercanbrack. ‘The Standardization of Islamic Financial Law: Lawmaking in Modern Financial Markets’ The American Journal of Comparative Law, Volume 67, Issue 4, December 2019, Pages 825–860, https://doi.org/10.1093/ajcl/avz010

9 Daly, S., Frikha, M. (2016). ‘Islamic Finance: Basic Principles and Contributions in Financing Economic.’ J Knowl Econ 7, 496512CrossRefGoogle Scholar. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13132-014-0222-7

10 Anwer, Z., Khan, S. and Abu Bakar, M. (2020), ‘Sharīʿah-compliant central banking practices: lessons from Muslim countries’ experience.’ ISRA International Journal of Islamic Finance, Vol. 12 No. 1, pp. 726CrossRefGoogle Scholar. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJIF-01-2019-0007

11 Grassa, R. (2013) ‘Shariah supervisory system in Islamic financial institutions: New issues and challenges: a comparative analysis between Southeast Asia models and GCC models.’ Humanomics, Vol. 29 No. 4, pp. 333348CrossRefGoogle Scholar. https://doi.org/10.1108/H-01-2013-0001

12 Conteh, S., Al Amine Sano, M., Sawaneh, K., Lawal Shuaib, B., & Hassan, R. (2022). “Chapter 4: Regulatory framework of Islamic finance in selected West African countries”. in Islamic Finance in Africa. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar PublishingGoogle Scholar. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781802209907.00014

13 Ali, S.N. (Ed.). (2011). Shari'a Compliant Microfinance (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203808832

14 Rudnyckyj, D. (2014), ‘Economy in practice: Islamic finance and the problem of market reason.’ American Ethnologist, 41: 110–127. https://doi.org/10.1111/amet.12063

15 Aman, A., Naim, A.M., Isa, M.Y. and Ali, S.E.A. (2022), ‘Factors affecting sukuk market development: empirical evidence from sukuk issuing economies.’ International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, Vol. 15 No. 5, pp. 884–902. https://doi.org/10.1108/IMEFM-03-2020-0105

16 Choudhury, M.A., Hossain, M.S. and Mohammad, M.T. (2019), ‘Islamic finance instruments for promoting long-run investment in the light of the well-being criterion (maslaha).’ Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research, Vol. 10 No. 2, pp. 315–339. https://doi.org/10.1108/JIABR-11-2016-0133

17 Nouman, M., Siddiqi, M.F., Ullah, K. and Jan, S. (2021), ‘Nexus between higher ethical objectives (Maqasid Al Shari'ah) and participatory finance.’ Qualitative Research in Financial Markets, Vol. 13 No. 2, pp. 226–251. https://doi.org/10.1108/QRFM-06-2020-0092

18 Lee, H.S., Cheng, F.F., Har, W.M., Md Nassir, A. and Ab Razak, N.H. (2019), ‘Efficiency, firm-specific and corporate governance factors of the Takaful insurance.’ International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, Vol. 12 No. 3, pp. 368–387. https://doi.org/10.1108/IMEFM-06-2018-0187

19 Khan, I., Rahman, N.N.B.A., Yusoff, M.Y.Z.B.M. et al. ‘History, problems, and prospects of Islamic insurance (Takaful) in Bangladesh.’ SpringerPlus 5, 785 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40064-016-2400-5

20 Trokic, A. ‘An Analysis of Takaful: The Potential and Role in Financial Inclusion and Challenges Ahead.’ European Journal of Islamic Finance, (2017) (7). https://doi.org/10.13135/2421-2172/2085

21 Zaher, T.S. and Kabir Hassan, M. (2001), ‘A Comparative Literature Survey of Islamic Finance and Banking.’ Financial Markets, Institutions & Instruments, 10: 155–199. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0416.00044

22 Grais, W. and Kulathunga, A. (2007). “Capital Structure and Risk in Islamic Financial Services.” In Islamic Finance (eds S. Archer and R.A.A. Karim). https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118390443.ch4

23 Greuning, H.v. and Iqbal, Z. (2007). “Banking and the Risk Environment.” In Islamic Finance (eds S. Archer and R.A.A. Karim). https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118390443.ch2

24 Sundararajan, V. (2007). “Risk Characteristics of Islamic Products: Implications for Risk Measurement and Supervision”. In Islamic Finance (eds S. Archer and R.A.A. Karim). https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118390443.ch3

25 Archer, S. and Haron, A. (2007). “Operational Risk Exposures of Islamic Banks.” In Islamic Finance (eds S. Archer and R.A.A. Karim). https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118390443.ch6

26 DeLorenzo, Y.T. and McMillen, M.J.T. (2007). “Law and Islamic Finance: An Interactive Analysis.” In Islamic Finance (eds S. Archer and R.A.A. Karim). https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118390443.ch7

27 ElMassah, S. and Abou-El-Sood, H. (2022), ‘Selection of Islamic banking in a multicultural context: the role of gender and religion.’ Journal of Islamic Marketing, Vol. 13 No. 11, pp. 2347–2377. https://doi.org/10.1108/JIMA-05-2020-0160

28 Judijanto, L., Budi, H., Irwan, M., Kurniawan, R., & Awwalunnisa, N. (2024). ‘Analysis of the Effectiveness of Zakat Collection, Management, and Distribution in Improving Social Welfare in Indonesia.’ West Science Islamic Studies, 2(01), 15–23. https://doi.org/10.58812/wsiss.v2i01.586

29 Bissenova, A., Kikimbayev, M. (2024). “Fitting into a Secular Society: Hybrid Practices of the Islamic Public and Islamic Businesses in Astana.” In: Sharipova, D., Bissenova, A., Burkhanov, A. (eds) Post-Colonial Approaches in Kazakhstan and Beyond. The Steppe and Beyond: Studies on Central Asia. Palgrave Macmillan, Singapore. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-99-8262-2_8

30 Iqbal, M., Hakim, L. and Aziz, M.A. (2024), ‘Determinants of Islamic bank stability in Asia.’ Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research, Vol. ahead-of-print No. ahead-of-print. https://doi.org/10.1108/JIABR-07-2022-0174

31 Sulaiman, S. N. B. M., & Muneeza, A. (2024). “Chapter 13: Challenges in establishing digital Islamic banks in Malaysia”. In Islamic Finance in Eurasia. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781035308705.00023

32 Ha, D., Nguyen, M., Nguyen, K., & Şensoy, A. (2024). ‘Unveiling financial inclusion dynamics: Fintech's resonance in Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN).’ International Journal of Finance & Economics, 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1002/ijfe.2963

33 Asadov, A., Turaboev, I. and Yildirim, R. (2024), ‘Prospects of Islamic capital market in Uzbekistan: issues and challenges.’ International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, Vol. 17 No. 1, pp. 102–123. https://doi.org/10.1108/IMEFM-04-2022-0145

34 Kalimullina, M. (2024). “Chapter 2: Developments of Islamic Finance in Eastern Europe and Caucasus Region”. In Islamic Finance in Eurasia. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781035308705.00010

35 Muzaffarova, V., & Muneeza, A. (2024). “Chapter 14: The challenges facing Islamic finance in Uzbekistan”. In Islamic Finance in Eurasia. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781035308705.00024

36 Kenzhaliyev M. ‘Perspectives of the Court of the Astana International Financial Centre: Potential to Transform the Central Asian Legal Landscape.’ Asian Journal of Comparative Law. 2024;19(1):160–179. doi:10.1017/asjcl.2023.37

37 Hierman, B. (2024). Geopolitics in Central Asia. In: Cope, Z. (eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Contemporary Geopolitics. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-25399-7_17-1

38 Jalilov Z., Batyrkhan B., & Amirbekova S. (2024). ‘Kazakhstan And The Islamic World: Trade-Economic Interests And Initiatives.’ Adam's World, 99 (1), 91–106. https://doi.org/10.48010/aa.v99i1.479