Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-r5fsc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T20:51:43.141Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Police forces and political crises: revolutions, policing alternatives and institutional resilience in Paris, 1848–1871

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 June 2015

QUENTIN DELUERMOZ
QUENTIN DELUERMOZ*
Affiliation:
Université Paris 13 – Sorbonne Paris Cité, Pléiade, Villetaneuse, France
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

This article examines the relationship between police forces and Parisian society during the two final revolutions of nineteenth-century France in 1848 and 1871. The comparison between these two events reveals the existence of an alternative revolutionary project of ‘urban police’. It also shows, however, the relatively weak impact of these moments on long-term transformations of police organizations. This is all the more notable if we consider the Second Empire's municipal reform of 1854 that had a deep impact on the landscape of the Parisian police. Observing this general sequence helps thus to explore the modifications of police powers during revolutionary moments, and the dynamics of the non-linear transformation of police orders and urban societies in the nineteenth century.

Type
Special section on policing and urban crisis
Information
Urban History , Volume 43 , Issue 2 , May 2016 , pp. 232 - 248
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2015 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Berlière, J.-M., Le monde des polices en France, XIXe–XXe siècles (Brussels, 1998)Google Scholar; Price, R. (ed.), Revolution and Reaction: 1848 and the French Republic (London, 1975)Google Scholar; Faure, A. and Vigier, P. (eds.), Maintien de l’ordre et polices en France et en Europe au XIXe siècle (Paris, 1987)Google Scholar; Tombs, R., La guerre contre Paris (Paris, 1997; 1st edn 1981)Google Scholar; Brown, H.G., ‘Domestic state violence: repression from the Croquants to the Commune’, Historical Journal, 42 (1999), 597–622CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Denis, V. and B., Garnot (eds.), Un siècle d’ordre public en révolution (Paris, 2009)Google Scholar.

2 On these ‘fluid situations’, see in particular Dobry, M., Sociologie des crises politiques (3rd edn, Paris, 2009)Google Scholar.

3 Berlière, Le monde des polices en France; Denys, C. (ed.), Circulations policières, 1750–1914 (Villeneuve-d’Ascq, 2012)Google Scholar.

4 See for example Bayly, C.A., The Birth of the Modern World (1780–1914) (Oxford, 2003)Google Scholar.

5 The expression ‘police system’ is used here in a narrow sense, namely the relationships that connected the various actors responsible for policing, combining tensions and a certain institutional or practical coherence. The study of ‘police systems’ in the broader sense considers these junctions and disjunctions on a much wider scale: not just this core entity, but other institutional actors (judicial, municipal, military), other social environments (media, cultural representations, social organizations), other geo-political levels (nation, Europe, empire) and other temporal frameworks (nineteenth century, seventeenth to nineteenth centuries, etc.). The question is then to examine the shifting configurations of the police system and what they reveal about the historicity of power relations (cf. the Agence Nationale de Recherche project ‘European police systems, 18th–19th centuries’, ANR-12-BSH3-0004).

6 Chagniot, J., Paris et l’armée au XVIIIe siècle, étude politique et sociale (Paris, 1985)Google Scholar.

7 M. Larrère, ‘La garde nationale de Paris sous la monarchie de Juillet. Le pouvoir au bout du fusil?’, Université Paris I Ph.D. thesis, 2000; Girard, L., La garde nationale, 1814–1871 (Paris, 1964)Google Scholar; Dupuy, R., La garde nationale, 1789–1872 (Paris, 2010)Google Scholar.

8 Cardoni, F., La Garde Républicaine. D’une République à l’autre, 1848–1871 (Rennes, 2008)Google Scholar.

9 See Kaplan, S., ‘Notes sur les commissaires de police à Paris au XVIIIe siècle’, Revue d’Histoire Moderne et Contemporaine, 4 (1981), 669–86Google Scholar; Farge, A., Vivre dans la rue à Paris au XVIIIe siècle (Paris, 1979), 197–208Google Scholar; Berlière, J., Policer Paris au Siècle des Lumières. Les commissaires du quartier du Louvre dans la seconde moitié du XVIIIe siècle (Paris, 2012)Google Scholar. On this major figure of everyday law and order in the nineteenth century, see Merriman, J., Police Stories: Building the French State 1815–1851 (Oxford, 2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Kalifa, D. and Karila-Cohen, P. (eds.), Le commissaire de police au XIXe siècle (Paris, 2008)Google Scholar.

10 Berlière, J.-M., ‘Images de policiers en France, Deux siècles de phantasmes’, Jahrbuch für Europäische Verwaltungsgescichte, 6 (1994), 125–48Google Scholar.

11 On these points, see Deluermoz, Q., Policiers dans la ville. La construction d’un ordre public à Paris, 1854–1914 (Paris, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Roncayolo, M., ‘La production de la ville’, in Duby, G. and Agulhon, M. (eds.), Histoire de la France urbaine, vol. IV: La ville de l’âge industriel (Seuil, 1980), 72–155Google Scholar; Marchand, B., Paris, histoire d’une ville, XIXe–XXe siècle (Paris, 1993)Google Scholar; Stierle, K.-H., La capitale des signes, Paris et son discours au XIXe siècle (Paris, 2001)Google Scholar.

13 With a few notable exceptions, which we refer to here: Cardoni, La Garde Républicaine and ‘“Faire de l’ordre avec le désorde”. Des gardes du peuple à la garde républicaine, février–juin 1848’, in Denis and Garnot (eds.), Un siècle d’ordre public, 149–64; P. O’Brien, ‘The revolutionary police of 1848’, in Price (ed.), Revolution and Reaction, 135–44.

14 G. Mihaely, ‘La moustache et la diffusion du modèle militaro-viril’, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales, Ph.D. thesis, 2003; on the history of masculinity, Corbin, A., Courtine, J.-J. and Vigarello, G. (eds.), Histoire de la virilité, 3 vols. (Paris, 2011)Google Scholar; Schmale, W., Geschichte der Mannlichkeit in Europa (1450–2000) (Vienna, 2003)Google Scholar; Mosse, G.L., The Image of Man: The Creation of Modern Masculinity (Oxford, 1996)Google Scholar; Stearns, P.N., Be a Man! Males in Modern Society (New York, 1990)Google Scholar.

15 Archives de la Préfecture de police (APP), DB 33 ‘police municipale, 1848–1852’.

16 Agulhon, M., 1848 ou l’apprentissage de la République, 1848–1852 (Paris, 1973)Google Scholar; Riot-Sarcey, M. and Moatti, C., La République dans tous ses états (Paris, 2009)Google Scholar.

17 Cardoni, La Garde Républicaine.

18 Traugott, M., Armies of the Poor. Determinants of Working-Class Participation in the Parisian Insurrection of June 1848 (Princeton, 1985)Google Scholar.

19 APP, DB 194, ‘chiffonniers’.

20 Dossier in APP, DB 32.

21 Hobsbawm, E.J., ‘Cities and insurrections’, in Revolutionaries: Contemporary Essays (New York, 1973)Google Scholar.

22 Bourillon, F., Les villes en France au XIXe siècle (Gap, 1992)Google Scholar.

23 See Gaillard, J., Paris, La ville (1852–1870) (Paris, 1976)Google Scholar.

24 On the matters outlined below, see Deluermoz, Policiers.

25 On the London police and its importance, see Emsley, C., The Great British Bobby: A History of British Policing from the Eighteenth Century to the Present (London, 2010)Google Scholar.

26 L. Hincker, Citoyens-combattants à Paris (1848–1851) (Villeneuve-d’Ascq, 2008); Girard, La garde nationale.

27 The project is explained by Senator Count Henri Siméon in ‘Commission des embellissements de Paris’, Rapport à l’empereur Napoléon III, Dec. 1853 (reproduced in Cahiers de la rotonde, 23 (2001)).

28 Du Camp, M., Paris, ses organes, ses fonctions et sa vie dans la seconde moitié du XIXe siècle (Paris, 1872)Google Scholar.

29 This phenomenon invites an interactionist reading of the city, informed by the sociology of Erving Goffman. See in this respect Deluermoz, Q., ‘Présences d’état, une interrelation police-societé à Paris (1854–1880)’, Annales, Histoire Sciences Sociales, 2 (2009), 435–60Google Scholar.

30 The first analysis of disciplinarity as developed in Surveiller et punir (Paris, 1975) has been supplemented with new perspectives about ‘pastoral power. See ‘Omnes et singulatim: vers une critique de la raison politique’, in Dits et écrits, vol. IV (Paris, 2001), 134–61; and Sécurité, territoire, population: cours au Collège de France (1977–1978), edition prepared by Michel Sennellart under the direction of François Ewald and Alessandro Fontana (Paris, 2004).

31 Abbott, A., ‘On the concept of turning point’, Comparative Social Research, 16 (1997), 89–109Google Scholar. On the analysis of social transformations, see, too, Sewell, W.H., ‘Response to Steinmetz, Riley, and Pedersen’, Social Science History, 32 (2008), 579–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32 Denys, C., Milliot, V. and Marin, B. (eds.), Réformer la police. Les mémoires policiers en Europe au XVIIIe siècle (Rennes, 2009)Google Scholar.

33 Rougerie, J., La Commune de 1871 (Paris, 1988)Google Scholar.

34 A. Dalotel, ‘Maintien de l’ordre public à Paris et polices en 1870–1871’, in Faure and Vigier (ed.), Maintien de l’ordre et polices.

35 Denis, V., ‘Une police sans policiers: la police du quartier du Palais-Royal en 1789–1790’, in Métiers de police. Être policier en Europe, XVIIIe–XXe siècle (Rennes, 2008), 475–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

36 Archives de la ville de Paris, D1U6/9.

37 Deluermoz, Q. and Foa, J., ‘Titulatures, positions sociales et mouvement revolutionnaire: le cas des ‘usurpations de fonctions’ communardes (1871)’, in Deluermoz, Q. and Foa, J. (eds.), Usurpations de fonctions et appropriation du pouvoir en situation de crise (Paris, online edition, 2012), 50–64Google Scholar.

38 Service Historique de la Défense (SHD), series 8J. The dossiers have in fact kept some of the documents produced during the event.

39 Cottereau, A., ‘Droit et bon droit. Un droit des ouvriers instauré puis évincé par le droit du travail (France, XIXe siècle)’, Annales, Histoire Sciences Sociales, 6 (2002), 1521–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

40 Fournier, E., Paris en ruines: du Paris haussmannien au Paris Communard (Paris, 2008)Google Scholar.

41 Tombs, La guerre contre Paris.

42 Study based on the Répertoire du commissariat de police, 1871–73 (APP).

43 V. Denis, ‘Les commissaires de police parisiens, de la chute de la monarchie à la Restauration’, in Kalifa and Karila-Cohen (eds.), Le commissaire de police au 19e siècle.

44 Mark Traugott refers to ‘routines of collective action’; see his thought-provoking ideas in Traugott, M., The insurgent barricade (Berkeley, 2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

45 See for example Cohen, D., ‘Une institution musicale entre repli et implication politique: le quotidien de l’Opéra de Paris pendant la guerre de 1870 et sous la Commune’, Le Mouvement Social, special issue on ‘Musique et Politique’, 208 (2004), 7–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

46 On these perspectives and their difficulties, see Deluermoz, Q. and Singaravelou, P., ‘Explorer le champ des possibles: approche contrefactuelle et futurs non advenus en histoire’, Revue d’Histoire moderne et contemporaine, 3 (2012), 70–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

47 Rosanvallon, P., La democratie inachevée: histoire de la souveraineté du peuple en France (Paris, 2000)Google Scholar; Balandier, G., Le pouvoir sur scène (Paris, 1980)Google Scholar; Dobry, Sociologie des crises politiques.

48 For an example of these intertwined timeframes and their effects on analysis, see Sewell, W.H. Jr, ‘The temporalities of capitalism’, Socio-Economic Review, 6 (2008), 517–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar; on the city in particular, see Lepetit, B. and Pumain, D., Temporalités urbaines (Paris, 1999)Google Scholar.