Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-gb8f7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-27T19:48:41.221Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A liberal countryside? The Manchester Ramblers' Federation and the ‘social readjustment’ of urban citizens, 1929–1936

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 April 2011

BEN ANDERSON
BEN ANDERSON*
Affiliation:
School of Arts, Histories and Cultures, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester, M13 9PL, UK
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

Ramblers often voiced reformist ideas about how cities and their inhabitants might be improved. This article demonstrates how the Manchester Ramblers' Federation utilized themes of freedom and order to define and regulate urban movements in rural space. It explores how this group of ramblers defined rambling as a ‘readjustment’ to illiberal aspects of urban life, portrayed other performances in the countryside as harmful and illegitimate and finally sought to utilize technologies drawn from their experience of urban culture to regulate conduct in the countryside.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 38 , Issue 1 , May 2011 , pp. 84 - 102
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Joyce, P. The Rule of Freedom: Liberalism and the Modern City (London, 2003), 7–8, 15, 98–105, 112–13Google Scholar; Rose, N., Powers of Freedom: Reframing Political Thought (Cambridge, 1999), 4, 7, 94–5, 167–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Rose, N., ‘Governing “advanced” liberal societies’, in Osborn, T., Barry, A. and Rose, N. (eds.), Foucault and Political Reason: Liberalism, Neo-Liberalism, and Rationalities of Government (London, 1996), 37–64Google Scholar; Gunn, S., ‘From hegemony to governmentality: changing conceptions of power in social history’, Journal of Social History, 39 (2006), 713–17CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Joyce, Freedom, 102.

3 See Dreyer, N.H., ‘The virtuous and the verminous: turn of the century moral panics in London's public parks’, Albion, 29 (1997), 246–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Gunn, ‘Hegemony to governmentality’, 713.

5 Matless, D., Landscape and Englishness (London, 1998), 1–102Google Scholar; Matless, D., ‘The English outlook: a mapping of leisure, 1918–1939’, in Alfrey, N. and Daniels, S. (eds.), Mapping the Landscape: Essays on Art and Cartography (Nottingham, 1990), 28–32Google Scholar; Matless, D., ‘Nature, the modern and the mystic: tales from early twentieth-century geography’, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, n.s., 16 (1991), 272–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Matless, D., ‘“The art of right living”: landscape and citizenship, 1918–39’, in Pile, S. and Thrift, N. (eds.), Mapping the Subject: Geographies of Cultural Transformation (London, 1995), 93–122Google Scholar; Matless, D., ‘Moral geographies of English landscape’, Landscape Research, 22 (1997), 141–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Also Readman, P., ‘Landscape preservation, “advertising disfigurement”, and English national identity c. 1890–1914’, Rural History, 12 (2001), 61–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Mandler, P., ‘How modern is it?’, Journal of British Studies, 42 (2003), 271–2CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Light, A., Forever England: Femininity, Literature and Conservatism between the Wars (London, 1991)Google Scholar.

6 Tebbutt, M., ‘Rambling and manly identity in Derbyshire's Dark Peak, 1880s–1920s’, Historical Journal, 49 (2006), 1125–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Westaway, J., ‘The German community in Manchester, middle-class culture and the development of mountaineering in Britain, c. 1850–1914’, English Historical Review, 124, 508 (2009), 572–92Google Scholar.

8 Hickox, M.S., ‘The English middle-class debate’, British Journal of Sociology, 46 (1995), 311–24CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hill, H., Freedom to Roam (Ashbourne, 1980)Google Scholar; Hollett, D., The Pioneer Ramblers 1850–1940 (Manchester, 2002)Google Scholar; Holt, A. (ed.) and Stephenson, T., Forbidden Land: The Struggle for Access to Mountain and Moorland (Manchester, 1989)Google Scholar.

9 Reid, D.A., ‘Playing and praying’, in Daunton, M. (ed.) The Cambridge Urban History of Britain, vol. III: 1840–1950 (Cambridge, 2000), 745–807Google Scholar.

10 Darby, W.D., Landscape and Identity: Geographies of Nation and Class in England (Oxford, 2000), 136–7Google Scholar; Riordan, J., ‘Amateurism, sport and the left: amateurism for all versus amateur elitism’, Sport in History, 26 (2006), 480–1CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lowerson, J., ‘Battles for the countryside’, in Gloversmith, F. (ed.), Class, Culture and Social Change: A New View of the 1930s (Brighton, 1980), 258–80Google Scholar.

11 Royce, E., ‘National parks and reserves’, in Royce, E. (ed.), The Ramblers Federation Handbook Being the Official Yearbook of the Ramblers’ Federation (Manchester and District) (Manchester, 1929), 33Google Scholar.

12 Matless, Landscape, 71–4.

13 See footnotes in P. Mandler, ‘“Against Englishness”: English culture and the limits to rural nostalgia’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 6 (1997), 156; H.J. Walker, ‘The outdoor movement, 1900–1939’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of Sussex 1987), 62–88; Trentmann, F., ‘Civilisation and its discontents: English neo-romanticism and the transformation of anti-modernism in twentieth-century western Culture’, Journal of Contemporary History, 29 (1994), 592–4CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Prynn, D., ‘The Clarion Club, rambling and the holiday associations in Britain since the 1890s’, Journal of Contemporary History, 11 (1976), 65–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Snape, R., ‘The Co-operative Holidays Association and the cultural formation of countryside leisure practice’, Leisure Studies, 23 (2004), 143–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Howkins, A., ‘Rurality and English identity’, in Morley, D. and Robins, K. (eds.), British Cultural Studies: Geography, Nationality and Identity (Oxford, 2001), 145–56Google Scholar; Colls, R., Identity of England (Oxford, 2002)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Vernon, J., ‘Border crossings: Cornwall and the English imagi(nation)’, in Cubitt, G. (ed.), Imagining Nations (Manchester, 1998), 153–72Google Scholar; Brace, C., ‘Finding England everywhere: regional identity and the construction of national identity’, Ecumene, 6 (1999), 90–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14 Wiener, M., English Culture and the Decline of the Industrial Spirit, 1850–1980 (Cambridge, 1981), 41–2Google Scholar; Rubenstein, W.D., ‘Cultural explanations for Britain's economic decline: how true?’, in Collins, B. and Robbins, K. (eds.), British Culture and Economic Decline (London, 1990), 59–90Google Scholar.

15 Mandler, ‘Against “Englishness”’, 155–7.

16 Mandler, P. ‘The consciousness of modernity? Liberalism and the English national character, 1870–1940’, in Daunton, M. and Rieger, B. (eds.), Meanings of Modernity: Britain from the Late Victorian Era to World War III (Oxford, 2001), 119–44Google Scholar; Mandler, P., The English National Character: The History of an Idea from Edmund Burke to Tony Blair (London, 2006), 148–76, 184–5Google Scholar; Mandler, P. ‘What is “national identity”? Definitions and applications in modern British historiography’, Modern Intellectual History, 3 (2006), 271–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tebbutt, M., ‘“In the Midlands but not of them”: Derbyshire's Dark Peak – an imagined northern landscape’, in Kirk, N. (ed.), Northern Identities: Historical Interpretations of ‘the North’ and ‘Northernness’ (Aldershot, 2000), 163–94Google Scholar; P.J. Taylor, ‘Which Britain? Which England? Which North?’, in Morley and Robins (eds.), British Cultural Studies, 127–44; Cosgrove, D., Roscoe, B. and Rycroft, S., ‘Landscape and identity at Ladybower Reservoir and Rutland Water’, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, n.s., 21 (1996), 534–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Matless, Landscape, 18.

17 M. Tebbutt, ‘“‘Men of the hills’ and street corner boys”: northern uplands and the urban imagination: Derbyshire's Dark Peak 1880–1914’, Conference of Regional and Local Historians (ed.), Rural and Urban Encounters in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries: Regional Perspectives (Conference of Regional and Local Historians, 2004), 59–77; Tebbutt ‘Rambling and manly identity’, 1125–53.

18 A.W. Hewitt, ‘On the Cheshire border’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1934), 242–5.

19 H.E. Wild, ‘Genesis’, London Metropolitan Archive (LMA)/4287/02/449, 11; C.E.M. Joad, A Charter for Ramblers: The Future of the English Countryside (London, 1934), 73.

20 E. Royce ‘Federation notes’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1930), 9.

21 McKibbin, R., Classes and Cultures: England 1918–1951 (Oxford, 1998), 379CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Langhamer, C., Women's Leisure in England, 1920–1960 (Manchester, 2000), 77–8Google Scholar.

22 Average 1936 membership of northern rambling clubs averaged 105. Membership of the Federation where statistics are available (including associate members) were therefore approximately: 1929 – 11,340, 1933 – 12,950, 1934 – 10,607. This excludes multiple memberships. E. Royce, ‘Federation notes’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1929), 12; E. Royce, ‘Federation notes – rambler and motorist’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1934), 173; Smith, ‘Ramblers’ Association’, 15.

23 Anon., in Manchester Guardian, 27 Jun. 1932, 11; Rothman, B., The 1932 Kinder Trespass: A Personal View of the Kinder Scout Mass Trespass (Altrincham, 1982), 46Google Scholar; Joad, Charter, 59–61; E. Royce, ‘Federation notes: access to mountains’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1933), 86–7; Langhamer, Women's Leisure, 49–80; Todd, S., ‘Young women, work and leisure in interwar England’, Historical Journal, 48 (2005), 805CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Beaven, B., Leisure, Citizenship and Working-Class Men in Britain, 1850–1945 (Manchester, 2005), 173–4Google Scholar.

24 Holt, A., ‘Hikers and ramblers: surviving a thirties fashion’, International Journal of the History of Sport, 4 (1987), 59CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Taylor, H., A Claim on the Countryside: A History of the British Outdoor Movement (Keele, 1997), 3Google Scholar; Walker, ‘Outdoor movement’, 90–120; E. Royce, ‘Continental rambling’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1929), 44–50; H. Gilliatt, ‘A few days in the Pyrenees’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1931), 46–9.

25 Holt, ‘Hikers and ramblers’, 56–67; E. Royce, ‘Federation notes – the Warden Guides in 1935’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1936), 9; Langhamer, Women's Leisure, 77–8.

26 Matless, Landscape, 1–102; Matless, ‘“Art of right living”’, 93–122; Matless, ‘Moral geographies’, 141–55.

27 L.S. Jast, ‘Scenery’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1932), 25–30; H. Cook, ‘Look up! Pages from nature's open book’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1935), 281–3.

28 Mandler, ‘“Against Englishness”’, 155–75; Howkins, ‘English identity’, 145–56; Colls, Identity of England, 204–25.

29 Joad, Charter, 141–2.

30 W. Murray Marsden, ‘Can ramblers help nature?’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1931), 43; Anon., ‘Fables of Um V’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1933), 130–1; J. Cuming Walters, ‘Romantic Cheshire’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1932), 76; E. Royce, ‘Federation notes – see Britain – if you can’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1932), 11; E. Royce, ‘Merrie England (from an English guidebook of the seventeenth century)’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1936), 58.

31 Prynn, ‘The Clarion club’, 71–4; Taylor, Claim on the Countryside, 191–225; Walker, ‘Outdoor movement’, 23–60, 148–77; Rose, J., The Intellectual Life of the British Working Classes (London, 2001), 62–79Google Scholar; Conway, H., People's Parks: The Design and Development of Victorian Parks in Britain (Cambridge, 1991), 11Google Scholar; Joyce, Freedom, 222–3.

32 J.R. Ashton, ‘A plague of rambling clubs’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1930), 27; Stocks, F.A. and Ashton, J.R., The Open Air Guide, 2nd edn (Manchester, 1929)Google Scholar; A.W. Hewitt, ‘A Peak District National Park’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1931), 14.

33 Palmer, W.T., Tramping in Derbyshire (London, 1934), 1Google Scholar; A.W. Hewitt, ‘National Countryside Conference – Lake District extension summary’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1930), 79–80; E. Royce, ‘Here are sportsmen: access, trespass and sportsmanship in the year A. N.’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1933), 137; Mair, J. and Delafons, J., ‘The policy origins of Britain's National Parks: the Addison Committee 1929–31’, Planning Perspectives, 16 (2001), 293–309CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

34 Report of the National Park Committee HCPP 1930–31: Cmd 3851, 72.

35 Hewitt, ‘Peak District’, 17, original emphasis; F.A. Holmes, ‘Dovedale – a national park’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1930), 23.

36 Tebbutt, ‘Rambling and manly identity’, 1147–9.

37 V.G. Billier, ‘The camping movement’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1931), 65; Cpt. S.J.C. Russell, ‘The complete rambler has to be – a camper’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1935), 304; N. Willington, ‘The spirit of rambling’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1930), 43.

38 E. MacColl, ‘The Manchester rambler’, quoted in Rothman, Kinder, 8–9; Solnit, R., Wanderlust: A History of Walking (London, 2002), 104–248Google Scholar.

39 Monkhouse, P.J., On Foot in the Peak (London, 1932), 43Google Scholar; Symonds, H.H., Walking in the Lake District (London 1933), ixGoogle Scholar; Minute Book 1, Rucksack Club Archive, 1–2.

40 S.F. Wicks, ‘A reverie’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1927), 14; E. Royce, ‘Federation notes: the rambler imperfect’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1930), 13; T.A. Coward, ‘Ramblers and the fauna’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1930), 19–20; T.E. Bean, ‘The complete rambler’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1931), 22–3; ‘The hiking season begins’, Observer, 10 May 1931, 13.

41 Symonds, Lake District, vii; H.H. Symonds, ‘The Lake District: friends and foes’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1935), 275–6; Ashton, ‘Plague’, 28.

42 Matless, ‘English outlook’, 28–32; Anon., ‘The map (a memory of October)’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1930), 14; Veritas, ‘The Lud church legends’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1929), 61–2; Jast, ‘Scenery’, 25–30; Cook ‘Look up!’, 281–3.

43 There is a list in every copy of Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1928–39).

44 J.E. MacDonald, ‘Roosdyche, an ancient quarry’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1934), 264; E.H. Shackleton, ‘The Norseman in Lakeland’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1936), 21–4; J.E. MacDonald, ‘The Kettleshulme Valley’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1934), 186–92.

45 J. Wilfred Jackson, ‘Early man in Derbyshire’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1930), 15–19; Jast ‘Scenery’; Manley, K.A., ‘Jast, Louis Stanley (1868–1944)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (Oxford, 2004) (www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/72370, accessed 24 Jul. 2009)Google Scholar.

46 Rose, Intellectual Life, 62–79; Prynn, ‘The Clarion Club’, 71–4; Taylor, Claim on the Countryside, 191–225; Walker, ‘Outdoor movement’, 23–60, 148–77; Tebbutt, ‘Rambling and manly identity’, 1137–8.

47 Joyce, Freedom, 128–43, 219–40; Conway, People's Parks, 10–11, 20–38; Elliott, P., Daniels, S. and Watkins, C., ‘The Nottingham Arboretum (1852): natural history, leisure and public culture in a Victorian regional centre’, Urban History, 35 (2008), 48–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Royce, ‘National parks’, 43; Hewitt, ‘Peak District’, 14.

48 Joyce, Freedom, 1–4; Rose, Powers, 4.

49 Skipper, ‘A day through the forest’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1931), 77; Willington, ‘Rambling’, 43; Matless ‘Modern and the mystic’, 279–80.

50 Willington ‘Rambling’, 43.

51 Bean, ‘Complete rambler’, 22.

52 Joyce, Freedom, 35.

53 Tebbutt, ‘Rambling and manly identity’, 1149.

54 Ibid., 1149.

55 Shaya, G., ‘The flâneur, the badaud, and the making of a mass public in France, circa 1860–1910’, American Historical Review, 109 (2004), 41–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Dianina, K., ‘Passage to Europe: Dostoevskii in the St. Petersburg arcade’, Slavic Review, 62 (2003), 245–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

56 Solnit, Wanderlust, 175–6.

57 500,000 ‘walkers’ are estimated by the late 1930s, and 10,000 ramblers was a contemporary estimate for the Peak District in the early 1930s. A. Howkins and J. Lowerson, Trends in Leisure 1919–1939: A Review for the Joint Panel on Leisure and Recreation Research (Sports Council, 1979), 46–50.

58 Taylor, Claim on the Countryside, 233–6; Merriman, P., ‘“Respect the life of the countryside”: the country code, government and the conduct of visitors to the countryside in post-war England and Wales’, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, n.s., 30 (2005), 338CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Holt, ‘Hikers and ramblers’, 56–63; Matless, ‘Moral geographies’, 143.

59 McKibbin, Classes and Cultures, 394–7.

60 E.g. Anon., ‘Saturday competition: “What is hiking?”’, Manchester Guardian, 26 Aug. 1931, 16; ‘Miscellany: ramblers north and south’, Manchester Guardian, 25 May 1931, 7.

61 Anon., ‘The hiker-cum-rambler’, Manchester Guardian, 3 Oct. 1932, 6; Veteran Climber, ‘The true joys of walking’, letter to Manchester Guardian, 4 Sep. 1931, 16; anon., ‘Miscellany’, Manchester Guardian, 29 May 1931, 7; anon., ‘Miscellany’, Manchester Guardian, 26 Jun. 1931, 7.

62 Above, n. 21; Holt, ‘Hikers and ramblers’, 57–8.

63 Royce, ‘Access to mountains’, 87; Royce, ‘Federation notes: this hiking’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1932), 10.

64 Willington, ‘Rambling’, 43; E. Royce, ‘Federation notes – the rambler of 1928’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1929), 13; Royce, ‘This hiking’, 10.

65 H.E. Wild, ‘The unobtrusive rambler’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1928), 29, my ellipses; Manchester Guardian, 2 Oct. 1934, 6; Coward, ‘Ramblers’, 19.

66 I. Brown, ‘The moors again [quoted from Manchester Guardian 17 Oct. 1933]’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1934), 185.

67 Royce, ‘This hiking’, 10 (brackets original). See also Sir M. Abbot-Anderson, ‘How ramblers can help nature: “wardens of the countryside”’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1932), 32; Joad, Charter, 19, 167–71; L. Ramsbottom, ‘Countryside wardens – a practical scheme in operation in Derbyshire’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1932), 60; Royce, ‘Federation notes’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1929), 13; Skipper, ‘O'er Wrekin by Severn Side’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1932), 57.

68 Bean, ‘Complete rambler’, 23–4; Clarion Rambler, ‘The lost lands of Derbyshire’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1931), 25.

69 Matless, Landscape, 62–73.

70 Holt, ‘Hikers and ramblers’, 63.

71 Royce, ‘This hiking’, 10.

72 Ashton, ‘Plague’, 29.

73 Nora Willington ‘Manchester: how the Federation benefits the tramper’, Manchester Guardian, 9 Feb. 1931, 4.

74 Hewitt, ‘Peak District’, 14.

75 Royce, ‘Access to mountains’, 87.

76 Ashton, ‘Plague’, 28.

77 Royce, ‘Federation notes’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1929), 13; B. Gill, ‘The neglect of Cheshire: preserve your footpaths by using them’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1931), 51–2.

78 Anon., ‘Are you clean or dirty’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1931), 40b; Daily Express, ‘“How nice it is to get into the real country”’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1929), 70.

79 E. Royce, ‘Federation notes’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1932), 11; Ashton, ‘Plague’, 28.

80 A.W. Hewitt to National Council of Rambling Federations, 27 Feb. 1933, LMA/4287/02/447.

81 Ibid.; Coward, ‘Ramblers’, 21; A.W. Hewitt, ‘Manchester and district – the next observation ramble’, Manchester Guardian, 10 Jul. 1933, 5.

82 Royce, ‘Federation notes’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1929), 13.

83 Marsden, ‘Help nature’, 43; Symonds, Lake District, viii; Ramsbottom ‘Countryside wardens’, 60.

84 W. Knott, ‘Why the Warden-Guides and whither?’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1936), 68.

85 Knott, ‘Warden-Guides’, 69; Rose, Powers, 10.

86 Knott, ‘Warden-Guides’, 69.

87 A. Smith, ‘The Manchester Federation and the Ramblers’ Association’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1936), 18–19.

88 Anon., ‘Keepers of the countryside’, Manchester Guardian, 7 Mar. 1933, 11.

89 Anon., ‘In Manchester’, Manchester Guardian, 11 Feb. 1933, 13.

90 Ibid.

91 E. Royce, ‘Federation notes’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1933), 85.

92 Ashton, ‘Plague’, 29; E. Royce, ‘Countryside conference’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1930), 76; anon., ‘Draft annual report, 1933–34’, LMA/4287/02/498, 5; E. Royce, ‘Federation notes – events’, in Royce (ed.), MRF Handbook (1934), 176.

93 National Council of Rambling Federations, minutes, 1 Oct. 1932, LMA/4287/02/498, 2; A.W. Hewitt, ‘The Ramblers’ Federation Manchester and district – delegates’ report, National Council of Rambling Federations’ Conference [draft]’, LMA 4287/02/498, 2.

94 Stocks and Ashton, Open Air, 6, my ellipses.

95 Symonds, Lake District, ix; Royce, ‘Access to mountains’, 87; Billier, ‘Camping’, 65.

96 Smith, ‘Ramblers’ Association’, 19, my ellipses.

97 M. Foucault, ‘Different spaces’, in Michel Foucault, Aesthetics, Method and Epistemology, ed. J. Faubion (London, 2000), 175–85; Shields, R., Places on the Margin: Alternative Geographies of Modernity (London, 1991)Google Scholar; Rosenberg, R., Landscape and Power in Vienna (Baltimore, 1995)Google Scholar; Hetherington, K., The Badlands of Modernity: Heterotopia and Social Ordering (London, 1997)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Genocchio, B., ‘Discourse, discontinuity, difference: the question of “other” spaces’, in Watson, S. and Gibson, K. (eds.), Postmodern Cities and Spaces (Cambridge, MA, 1995), 35–46Google Scholar; Guarrasi, V., ‘Paradoxes of modern and postmodern geography: heterotopia of landscape and cartographic logic’, in Minca, C. (ed.), Postmodern Geography: Theory and Praxis (Oxford, 2001), 226–37Google Scholar.

98 Tebbutt, ‘Rambling and manly identity’; Brace, ‘England everywhere’.

99 Otter, C., ‘Making liberalism durable: vision and civility in the late Victorian city’, Social History, 27 (2002), 1–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar.