Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-7cvxr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T05:35:07.903Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Black Death in English towns

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 February 2009

Richard Britnell
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

It seems likely that historians in the past have seriously underestimated the number of English townsmen in the early fourteenth century. In London alone there may have been 80–100,000 around 1300. The population of Norwich in the early fourteenth century was higher than used to be thought, and it was growing: Rutledge proposes 17,000 for 1311 and 25,000 for 1333. Keene's estimate of about 10,000 for Winchester in the early fourteenth century can serve as a basis for estimating the population of other towns in the same period. Those whose taxable value in 1334, and whose contribution to the poll tax of 1377, was at least as great as Winchester's, probably had a population equal to Winchester's or greater around 1300. By this argument about fifteen towns, including London, are likely to have had 10,000 or more people at the beginning of the fourteenth century, and perhaps 5 per cent of England's population lived in towns of this rank. Estimates taking account of smaller towns are much more precarious, but it is possible that all told 10 per cent of England's population lived in towns of over 2,000 inhabitants and that a further 5 per cent lived in small boroughs, some with as few as 300 people. Even this estimate does not take account of many small market towns, not described as boroughs, that had elementary urban characteristics.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 21 , Issue 2 , October 1994 , pp. 195 - 210
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1994

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

This paper was originally prepared for a weekend school on the Black Death directed by Dr Mark Bailey at Madingley Hall, Cambridge in March 1993. I am grateful to Dr lan Doyle and to Dr Pamela Nightingale for reference to sources I should otherwise have missed.

References

1 Keene, D., ‘A new study of London before the great fire’, Urban History Yearbook (1984), 20;Google Scholar Rutledge, E., ‘Immigration and population growth in early fourteenth-century Norwich: evidence from the tithing roll’, Urban History Yearbook (1988), 27.Google Scholar

2 Campbell, B.M.S., Galloway, J.A., Keene, D. and Murphy, M., A Medieval Capital and its Grain Supplies: Agrarian Production in the London Region c. 1300, Historical Geography Research Series, 30 (London, 1993), 10–11;Google Scholar Britnell, R.H., ‘Commercialisation and economic development in England, 1000–1300’, in Britnell, R.H. and Campbell, B.M.S. (eds), A Commercialising Economy: England 1086 to c. 1300 (Manchester, forthcoming);Google Scholar Dyer, C., ‘The hidden trade of the Middle Ages: evidence from the West Midlands of England’, Journal of Historical Geography, 18 (1992), 141–2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

3 Keene, D., Cheapside before the Great Fire (London, 1985), 20.Google Scholar

4 Rosser, G., Medieval Westminster, 1200–1540 (Oxford, 1989), 170.Google Scholar

5 Keene, D., Survey of Medieval Winchester, 2 vols, Winchester Studies (Oxford, 1985), 1, 116, 210.Google Scholar

6 Butcher, A.F., ‘Rent and the urban economy: Oxford and Canterbury in the later Middle Ages’, Southern History, 1 (1979), 19–21;Google Scholar Cooper, J., ‘Medieval Oxford’, in V.C.H. Oxon., IV, 39–40;Google Scholar A Cartulary of the Hospital of St. John the Baptist, 3 vols, ed. Salter, H.E. (Oxford, 1914–1916), III, 29.Google Scholar

7 Martin, J.D., ‘St Michael's church and parish, Leicester’, Leicestershire Archaeology and History Society Transactions, 64 (1990), 21–5.Google Scholar

8 Britnell, R.H., Growth and Decline in Colchester, 1300–1525 (Cambridge, 1986), 20–1.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

9 Searle, E., Lordship and Community: Battle Abbey and its Banlieu, 1066–1538 (Toronto, 1974), 354–6.Google Scholar

10 Miller, E., ‘The fortunes of the English textile industry in the thirteenth century’, Economic History Review, 2nd ser., 18 (1965), 68–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

11 Cooper, , ‘Medieval Oxford’, 40.Google Scholar

12 Hill, J.W.F., Medieval Lincoln (Cambridge, 1948), 248, 320, 322, 326.Google Scholar

13 Rotuli Parliamentorum, 6 vols (London, c. 1777–1783), II, 85–6.Google Scholar

14 Hadwin, J.F., ‘The medieval lay subsidies and economic history’, Economic History Review, 2nd ser., 36 (1983), 212.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

15 Carus-Wilson, E.M., Medieval Merchant Venturers, 2nd ed. (London, 1967), 242–3.Google Scholar

16 Miller, , ‘Fortunes’, 79.Google Scholar Bridbury's characteristically optimistic comments on Lincoln in 1348 do not dispose of the statement that between 1321 and 1331 no weavers were working in the city or within a twelve-mile radius of it: Bridbury, A.R., Medieval English Clothmaking: An Economic Survey (London, 1992), 31Google Scholar; Hill, , Medieval Lincoln, 326.Google Scholar

17 Page, W., Ladds, S.I. et al. , ‘Huntingdon borough’, in V.C.H. Hunts., II, 123.Google Scholar

18 Rigby, S.H., Medieval Grimsby: Growth and Decline (Hull, 1993), 20, 29–33.Google Scholar

19 Bailey, M. (ed.), ‘The Bailiffs’ Minute Book of Dunwich, 1404–1430 (Suffolk Records Society 34, 1992), 2.Google Scholar

20 Platt, C., Medieval Southampton: The Port and Trading Community, A.D.1000–1600 (London, 1973), 109–11.Google Scholar

21 For example, Poos, L.R., ‘The rural population of Essex in the later Middle Ages’, Economic History Review, 2nd ser., 38 (1985), 515–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

22 Kershaw, I., ‘The great famine and agrarian crisis in England, 1315–1522’, in Hilton, R.H. (ed.), Peasants, Knights and Heretics: Studies in Medieval English Social History (Cambridge, 1976), 88–98, 111–18.Google Scholar

23 Prestwich, M.C., ‘Currency and the economy of early fourteenth-century England’, in Mayhew, N.J. (ed.), Edwardian Monetary Affairs (1270–1344), British Archaeological Reports, 36 (Oxford, 1977), 45–58Google Scholar; Waugh, S.L., England in the Reign of Edward III (Cambridge, 1991), 78–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

24 Farmer, D.L., ‘Prices and wages’, in Hallam, H.E. (ed.), The Agrarian History of England and Wales, II: 1042–1350 (Cambridge, 1988), 720, 791, 806, 810;Google Scholar Ormrod, W.M., ‘The crown and the English economy, 1290–1348’, in Campbell, B.M.S. (ed.), Before the Black Death: Studies in the ‘Crisis’ of the Early Fourteenth Century (Manchester, 1991), 182–3.Google Scholar

25 Knighton, Henry, Chronicon, 2 vols, ed. Lumby, J.R. (Rolls Ser. 92, 1889–1895.), II, 61;Google Scholar Shrewsbury, J.F.D., A History of the Bubonic Plague in the British Isles (Cambridge, 1970), 38;Google Scholar Ziegler, P., The Black Death (London, 1969), 135.Google Scholar

26 Hope, W.St.J., The History of the London Charterhouse from its Foundation until the Suppression of the Monastery (London, 1925), 24.Google Scholar Stow knew of this from Fabyan and from ‘the king's charters which I haue seene’: Fabyan, R., The New Chronicles of England and France, ed. H. Ellis (1811), 461–2Google Scholar; Stow, J., A Summarie of Englyshe Chronicles (1565), 118;Google Scholar Stow, J., The Chronicles of England from Brute unto this Present Yeare of Christ, 1580 (c. 1580), 406.Google Scholar

27 This inscription was described in 1565 by Stow, who had not at that time seen it. By 1598, however, he had seen and read the inscription, whose text he prints: Stow, , Summarie of Englyshe Chronicles, 118.Google Scholar Stow, J., A Survey of London, ed. Kingsford, C.L., 2 vols (Oxford, 1908), II, 81–2.Google Scholar Camden's brief report of such an ‘inscriptio in aere’ may be derived from Stow: Camden, , Britannia (1607), 311.Google Scholar The figure of 40,000 that appears in Gough's three-volume English version of Camden (1789) is a translator's error.

28 The Charterhouse register reports 60,000 burials, on the evidence of a papal bull (perhaps that of 1351, authorizing the foundation of a new college of a prior and twelve chaplains within the new churchyard). However, these 60,000 are not said to have been all plague victims: Hope, , History of the London Charterhouse, 6, 8, 30.Google Scholar

29 Hope, , History of the London Charterhouse, 5–6.Google Scholar The figure of 50,000 burials relates to the Spittle Croft, which Sir Walter Mauny purchased late in 1348 or early in 1349: ibid., 4–5.

30 Murimuth, Adam, Continuatio Chronicarum and Robert of Avesbury, De Gestis Mirabilibus Regis Edwardi Tertii, ed. Thompson, E.M. (Rolls Ser. 93, London, 1889), 407.Google Scholar Any possibility that Avesbury started from the figure of 50,000 burials and divided it by a period of 250 days is ruled out by his having restricted his observation to the weeks between the feast of the Purification (2 February) and after Easter (which fell on 12 April) and by his optimistic belief that the epidemic died away after Whitsun (31 May).

31 Ziegler, , Black Death, 157.Google Scholar

32 Hawkins, D., ‘The Black Death and the new London cemeteries of 1348’, Antiquity, 64 (1990), 642.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

33 Stow, , Chronicles, 407;Google Scholar Stow, J., The Annales of England (London, 1592), 379.Google Scholar Stow's source is identified as a late one by Hudson, W. and Tingey, J.C. (eds), The Records of the City of Norwich, 2 vols (Norwich, 1906–1910), II, cxx–cxxi.Google Scholar In the 1605 edition of Stow's Annales the number of burials is printed as 57, 104.

34 Rutledge, , ‘Immigration’, 27;Google Scholar Dyer, A., Decline and Growth in English Towns, 1400–1640 (London, 1991), 72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

35 Stow, , Chronicles, 407;Google Scholar Stow, , Annales, p. 379.Google Scholar The taxable wealth of Yarmouth in 1334, which was over half as much again as that of Winchester, placed it sixth in rank amongst English towns: The Lay Subsidy of 1334, ed. Glasscock, R.E., The British Academy: Records of Social and Economic History, new ser., II (London, 1975), 121, 198;Google Scholar Campbell et al., Medieval Capital, 9n.

36 Butcher, A.F., ‘English urban society and the revolt of 1381’, in Hilton, R.H. and Aston, T.H. (eds), The English Rising of 1381 (Cambridge, 1984), 93, 97.Google Scholar

37 Ibid., 94–5.

38 Chronicon Henrici Knighton, II, 61.Google Scholar

39 British Library, Harley MS 618, fo. 15v. For comment on the reliability of this census, see Dyer, A., ‘The bishops' census of 1563’, Local Population Studies, 49 (1992), 19–37.Google Scholar By Holy Cross parish Knighton meant the parish of St Martin, : V.C.H. Leics., IV, 368.Google Scholar

40 Russell, J.C., British Medieval Population (Albuquerque, 1948), 285, 293–4.Google Scholar Russell's figure is unlikely to be preposterously low since Leicester's taxable wealth in 1334 was only half that of Winchester, : Lay Subsidy of 1334, 121, 158.Google Scholar

41 Gottfried, R.S., Bury St. Edmunds and the Urban Crisis, 1290–1539 (Princeton, 1982), 51.Google Scholar

42 Cobban, A.B., The King's Hall within the University of Cambridge in the Later Middle Ages (Cambridge, 1969), 221;Google Scholar V.C.H. Cambs., III, 8.Google Scholar

43 Herbert, N.M., ‘Medieval Gloucester, 1066–1547’, in V.C.H. Gloucs., IV, 35.Google Scholar

44 Hill, , Medieval Lincoln, 251–2.Google Scholar

45 Britnell, , Growth and Decline, 22.Google Scholar

46 Cooper, , ‘Medieval Oxford’, 18.Google Scholar

47 Keene, , Survey, 1, 116.Google Scholar

48 Green, B. and Young, R.M.R., Norwich – The Growth of a City (Norwich, 1963), 17.Google Scholar

49 Blomefield, F. and Parkin, C., An Essay toward the Topographical History of the County of Norfolk, 11 vols (London, 1805–1810), XI, 366.Google Scholar

50 Baratier, E., La démographie provençale du Xllle au XVIe siècle (Paris, 1961), 82, 120;Google Scholar Cherubini, G., Signori, contadini, borghese: ricerche sulla società italiana del basso medioevo (Florence, 1974), 167;Google Scholar Lomas, R.A., ‘The Black Death in County Durham’, Journal of Medieval History, 15 (1989), 127–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

51 Shrewsbury, , History, 114, 116–17.Google Scholar For criticism of Shrewsbury's handling of historical evidence, see Gottfried, R.S., Epidemic Disease in Fifteenth Century England: The Medical Response and the Demographic Consequences (Leicester, 1978), 238–40;Google Scholar Morris, C., ‘The plague in Britain’, Historical Journal, 14 (1971), 205–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

52 Biraben, J.-N., Les hommes et la peste en France et dans les pays européens et mediterranéens (Paris and The Hague, 1975–1976), I, 7–9;Google Scholar Flinn, M.W., The European Demographic System, 1500–1820 (Brighton, 1981), 55–7;Google Scholar Gottfried, R.S., The Black Death: Natural and Human Disaster in Medieval Europe (London, 1983), 8–10;Google Scholar McNeill, W.H., Plagues and Peoples (Harmondsworth, 1979), 157–8.Google Scholar For a recent bibliography, see Carmichael, A.G., Plague and the Poor in Renaissance Florence (Cambridge, 1986), 172–5.Google Scholar

53 Creighton, C., A History of Epidemics in Britain from A.D. 664 to the Extinction of Plague (Cambridge, 1891), 135.Google Scholar

54 Twigg, G., The Black Death: A Biological Reappraisal (London, 1984), 186–7.Google Scholar

55 Biraben, , Les hommes et la peste, I, 228, 287.Google Scholar

56 Herlihy, D. and Klapisch-Zuber, C., Les Toscans et leurs familles: une étude du catasto florentin de 1427 (Paris, 1978), 467–8.Google Scholar

57 Carmichael, , Plague and the Poor, 71;Google Scholar Albini, G., Guerra, fame, peste: crisi di mortalità e sistema sanitario nella Lombardia tardomedioevale (Bologna, 1982), 148–9.Google Scholar

58 Shrewsbury, , History, 67.Google Scholar

59 Hill, , Medieval Lincoln, 251.Google Scholar

60 Wood, A., Historia et Antiquitates Universitatis Oxoniensis, 2 vols (Oxford, 1674), 1, 171.Google Scholar

61 Shrewsbury, , History, 36, 109.Google Scholar Cf. Lomas, , ‘Black Death’, 127–40;Google Scholar Rees, W., ‘The Black Death in Wales’, in Southern, R.W. (ed.), Essays in Medieval History (London, 1968), 179–99.Google Scholar

62 Creighton, , History of Epidemics, 135.Google Scholar

63 Twigg, , Black Death, 187, 219–20Google Scholar

64 Gottfried, , Epidemic Disease, 138–42.Google Scholar

65 For comment on levels of rural mortality in 1348–49, see Hatcher, J., Plague, Population and the English Economy, 1348–1530 (London, 1977), 21–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Smith, R., ‘Human resources’, in Astill, G. and Grant, A. (eds), The Countryside of Medieval England (Oxford, 1988), 208–9;Google Scholar Waugh, S.L., England in the Reign of Edward III (Cambridge, 1991), 85–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

66 For example, Judicium, Pillorie, Statutum de Pistoribus: Statutes of the Realm (1101–1713), 11 vols, ed. Luders, A., Tomlins, T.E., France, J., Taunton, W.E. and Raithby, J. (London, 1808–1928), I, 201–4.Google Scholar

67 Calendar of Letter-Books Preserved among the Archives of the City of London, 11 vols, ed. Sharpe, R.R. (London, 1899–1912), book F, 199.Google Scholar

68 Stow, , Survey, II, 81–2;Google Scholar Hope, , History of the London Charterhouse, 4–5.Google Scholar

69 A Calendar of the Register of Wolstan de Bransford, Bishop of Worcester 1339–49, ed. Haines, R.M. (London, 1966), no. 999, p. 176.Google Scholar

70 Keene, , Survey, II, 565, 579–80 (with map on p. 574).Google Scholar

71 Calendar of Patent Rolls, 1348–1350, 441.Google Scholar

72 Stow, , Survey, II, 81–2;Google Scholar Hope, , History of the London Charterhouse, 4–6.Google Scholar

73 Stow, , Survey, 1, 124–5;Google Scholar The Cartulary of Holy Trinity, Aldgnte, ed. Hodgett, G.A.J., London Record Society, VII (London, 1971), nos 212,952,958, pp. 39, 186, 188–9;Google Scholar Hawkins, , ‘Black Death’, 637–42.Google Scholar

74 Slater, G., ‘Social and economic history’, in V.C.H. Kent, III, 346.Google Scholar

75 Hawkins, , ‘Black Death’, 638–41.Google Scholar

76 Hill, , Medieval Lincoln, 252.Google Scholar

77 Calendar of Letter-Books, book F, 186, 188, 191, 192.Google Scholar

78 Ibid., 110,173.

79 Ibid., 210.

80 Dobson, R.B., ‘Admissions to the freedom of the city of York in the later middle ages’, Economic History Review, 2nd ser., 26 (1973), 17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

81 Butcher, , ‘English urban society’, 94–5.Google Scholar

82 Britnell, , Growth and Decline, 279.Google Scholar See also Hudson, and Tingey, , Records of the City of Norwich, II, xxxi.Google Scholar

83 Shaw, D.G., The Creation of a Community: The City of Wells in the Middle Ages (Oxford, 1993), 48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

84 Butcher, , ‘English urban society’, 93–4.Google Scholar

85 Cartulary of the Hospital of St. John the Baptist, III, 29;Google Scholar Cooper, , ‘Medieval Oxford’, 42.Google Scholar

86 Keene, , Cheapside, 20.Google Scholar

87 Keene, , Survey, I, 210, 237, 239, 243.Google Scholar

88 Rubin, , Charity and Community, 48–9.Google Scholar

89 Green, and Young, , Norwich, 17.Google Scholar

90 Keene, , Survey, I, 143–4.Google Scholar

91 Hill, , Medieval Lincoln, 252;Google Scholar Gottfried, , Bury St. Edmunds, 81.Google Scholar

92 Bolton, D.K., ‘The city of Coventry: social history to 1700’, in V.C.H. Warks., VIII, 211.Google Scholar

93 Faraday, M., Ludlow, 1085–1660: A Social, Economic and Political History (Chichester, 1991), 160.Google Scholar

94 Rubin, , Charity and Community, 121, 282.Google Scholar

95 Shaw, , Creation of a Community, 126–7.Google Scholar

96 Hudson, and Tingey, , Records of the City of Norwich, II, 226–7;Google Scholar Britnell, , Growth and Decline, 116;Google Scholar Hill, , Medieval Lincoln, 242;Google Scholar Maitland, F.W., Township and Borough (Cambridge, 1898), 83;Google Scholar Rigby, , Medieval Grimsby, 31.Google Scholar

97 Keene, , Cheapside, 19;Google Scholar Keene, , ‘A new study’, 18;Google Scholar Keene, , Survey, I, 143–5, 162–5.Google Scholar

98 Searle, , Lordship and Community, 356–8.Google Scholar

99 Butcher, , ‘English urban society’, 97.Google Scholar

100 Keene, , Survey, I, 428–9.Google Scholar

101 Britnell, , Growth and Decline, 110.Google Scholar

102 Butcher, , ‘English urban society’, 96.Google Scholar

103 Hudson, and Tingey, , Records of the City of Norwich, I, xliii, xlv.Google Scholar

104 Carus-Wilson, , Medieval Merchant Venturers, 245, 247;Google Scholar Carus-Wilson, E.M. and Coleman, O., England's Export Trade, 1275–1547 (Oxford, 1963), 75, 77.Google Scholar

105 Britnell, , Growth and Decline, 16, 86–97;Google Scholar Phythian-Adams, C., Desolation of a City: Coventry and the Urban Crisis of the Late Middle Ages (Cambridge, 1979), 33.Google Scholar

106 Bartlett, J.N., ‘The expansion and decline of York in the later Middle Ages’, Economic History Review, 2nd ser., 12 (1959–1960), 17–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

107 Unwin, G., Studies in Economic History, ed. Tawney, R.H. (London, 1927), 264.Google Scholar

108 Farmer, D.L., ‘Prices and wages, 1350–1500’, in Miller, E. (ed.), The Agrarian History of England and Wales, III. 1348–1500 (Cambridge, 1991), 512;Google Scholar Lloyd, T.H., The Movement of Wool Prices in Medieval England, Economic History Review Supplements, 6 (Cambridge, 1973), 41, 46, 48.Google Scholar

109 Farmer, , ‘Prices and wages, 1350–1500’, 508.Google Scholar

110 Ormrod, W.M., The Reign of Edward III: Crown and Political Society in England, 1327–1377 (New Haven, 1990), 204–5.Google Scholar

111 Hatcher, J., English Tin Production and Trade before 1550 (Oxford, 1973), 90–1.Google Scholar

112 Farmer, , ‘Prices and wages, 1350–1500’, 512.Google Scholar

113 Hill, , Medieval Lincoln, 251, 253.Google Scholar