Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-xbtfd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-03T01:15:48.308Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Reputation of Robert Cecil: Libels, Political Opinion and Popular Awareness in the Early Seventeenth Century

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 February 2009

Pauline Croft
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

On 29 April 1612 the London letter writer John Chamberlain penned another of his regular epistles to his friend Sir Dudley Carleton, ambassador in Venice. For weeks a chief news item had been the declining health of the Lord Treasurer, Robert Cecil Earl of Salisbury. ‘I wish I could send you better assurance’ Chamberlain wrote, ‘but as far as I can learn there is more cause of fear than hope’. Salisbury was journeying to Bath, where he had often sought relief before, but he had been ‘very yll by the way yesterday and was almost gon once or twise’. His death was assumed to be imminent. ‘He is alredy much lamented and every man sayes what a misse there wold be of him and indeed [he] is much prayed for’. The news later in June was more of a surprise. Salisbury's passing, on the return journey from Bath, had been followed not by the expected tributes to his irreplaceability, but by a flood of ‘outragious speaches’.

Type
Research Article
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 1 , December 1991 , pp. 43 - 69
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 1991

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The Letters of John Chamberlain, ed. McClure, N. E. (2 vols., Philadelphia, 1939), i. 346–7. 350. 362, 364–5Google Scholar.

2 British Library, Stowe MS 172, fo. 319, 22 June 1612. Strong, Roy, Henry Prince of Wales and England's lost Renaissance (1986), 8–9Google Scholar.

3 Recent studies include Nicholl, Charles, A Cup of News: the life of Thomas Nashe (1984)Google Scholar, Clark, Sandra, The Elizabethan Pamphleteers: popular moralistic pamphlets 1580–1640 (1983),Google ScholarSalzman, Paul, English Prose Fiction 1558–1700: a critical history (Oxford, 1985)Google Scholar, and Selden, Raman, English Verse Satire 1590–1765 (1978)Google Scholar. For the bishops' ban, Selden, 72.

4 ‘Epigram’ with regard to verse satire describes any length of poem. Wilcox, John, Informal publication of late 16th century verse satire, Huntington Library Quarterly, xiii (1) 1949–1950, 191–200Google Scholar. The Letters and Epigrams of Sir John Harington, ed. McClure, N. E. (Philadelphia, 1930), 44–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 For a printed version of the fart poem and discussion of the texts, Whitlock, Baird W., John Hoskyns, Sergeant-at-Law (Washington D.C., 1982), 283–92Google Scholar. The Non-dramatic Works of Thomas Dekker, ed. Grosart, A. B. (5 vols., 1884–1886), ii. 240Google Scholar.

6 Richard Roberts' commonplace book is now Bodleian Library, MS Don c 54. For a printed example, The Doctor Farmer Chetham MS., being a commonplace book in the Chetham Library, ed. Grosart, A. B. (2 vols., Manchester, 1873)Google Scholar.

7 Love, Harold, ‘Scribal publication in 17th century England’, Transactions of the Cambridge Bibliographical Society, ix (2) 1987, 130–54Google Scholar. It is notable that the manuscript satires and epigrams on the Overbury scandal openly name Robert Carr and Frances Howard, but the printed pamphlets do not. Clark, 87.

8 Bodleian Malone MS 23, pp. 10, 19. Public Record Office, State Papers Domestic Jas. I, SP 14/69/67. Bodleian, MS Hearne's Diaries 67, pp. 28–9. Folger Shakespeare Library, Washington D.C., MS 1027.2, p. 6. Bodleian, MS Rawlinson poet 65, fo. 2. Bodleian, MS Tanner 306, fo. 422. Bodleian, MS Eng poet e 14, fo. 95V. rev. Bodleian, MS Don c 54, fo. 6v.

9 Doctor Farmer Chetham MS, ii. 198. Bodleian, MS Malone 23, p. 1a.

10 Les reportes del cases in Camera Stellata, ed. Baildon, W. P. (1894), 223Google Scholar. Bodleian, MS Ashmole 1463, fo. 13. Cust, Richard, ‘News and Politics in early 17th century England’, Past and Present, 112 (1986), 60–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Cogswell, Thomas, ‘The Politics of Propaganda: Charles I and the people in the 1620s’, Journal of British Studies, 29 (1990), 187–215CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 PRO, SP 12/180/23, 47.

12 The State of England Anno Dom. 1600 by Thomas Wilson, ed. Fisher, F. J., Camden 3rd ser., Miscellany xvi, (1936), 42Google Scholar.

13 Historical Manuscripts Commission, Salisbury, xi, 586, xiv, 162.

14 PRO, SP 12/278/23. I have modernised the spelling in this and other libels.

15 Bodleian, MS Don c. 54, fo. 20. For an allegation in 1592 that Burghley deliberately suppressed the ancient nobility, British Library, Additional MS 12510, fos. 8v, 22v.

16 Bodleian, MS Don c. 54, fo. 19. The copyist has written the identifications in the margin.

17 Morse, David, England's Time of Crisis: from Shakespeare to Milton (1989), 62–7Google Scholar. Bodleian, MS Tanner 299, fo. 12. BL, Trumbull Misc. v, fo. 11.

18 The Autobiography and Correspondence of Sir Simonds D'Ewes during the reigns of James I and Charles I, ed. Halliwell, J. O. (2 vols., 1845), i. 50–51Google Scholar. Cecil was blamed for the death sentence. In 1615 the historian William Camden, who had attended Essex's trial, considered that ‘to this day but few there are which have thought it a capital crime’. Camden, William, Annales, translated Norton, R. (1635), 542–3, 549Google Scholar.

19 Calendar of the Carew MSS 1601–3 preserved the Archiepiscopal Library at Lambeth, ed. Brewer, J. S. and Bullens, W. (1870), 157, 221, 260, 358–9Google Scholar. HMC Salisbury, xix. 21.

20 Croft, P., A Collection of several speeches and treatises of the late Lord Treasurer Cecil Camden 4th ser., Miscellany xxix (1987), 262–3, 280, 290Google Scholar. Bodleian, Tanner MS 299, fo. IIV.

21 Ibid. fo. 12. Northants Record Office, Isham (Lamport) MS 4304. BL, Harleian MS 1221, fo. 74. Harleian MS 6038, fo. 18.

22 N.R.O., Isham (Lamport) MS 4304. Croft, , A Collection, 261, 290–1Google Scholar. PRO, SP 14/67/43, 22 Nov. 1611. The collection of privy seals was at the forefront of attention early in 1612. Chamberlain noted that they were ‘dispersed all over” and that payments were being made by ‘the meaner sort’ in January, and the Venetian ambassador reported in February that ‘every diligence will be used in calling up the loan without delay’. Chamberlain i. 330. Calendar of State Papers Venetian, 1610–13, pp. 291, 294.

23 N.R.O., Isham (Lamport) MS 4304. For Salisbury's efforts on the woods, Croft, , A Collection, 259–60Google Scholar.

24 N.R.O., Isham (Lamport) MS 4304. For Salisbury's efforts to improve the rents of crown lands, Hill, L. M., ‘Sir julius Caesar's journal of Salisbury's first two months and twenty days as lord treasurer, 1608’, Bulletin of the Institute of Historical Research, xlv (1972), 311–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

25 Letters and Epigrams of Sir John Harrington, 301, ‘How England may be reformed’. Bodleian, , Malone MS 23, p. 121Google Scholar.

26 Bodleian, Tanner MS 299, fo. 1 IV.

27 Cambridge University Library, MS Ee v. 24, fo. 3.

28 BL, MS Trumbull Misc. v, fo. 11. Bodleian, MS Malone 23, p. 19.

29 ‘The richer the taxpayer, the less his true wealth was captured by the subsidy assessments’. Schofield, R., ‘Taxation and the political limits of the Tudor state’, Law and Government under the Tudors: essays presented to Sir Geoffrey Elton, eds. Cross, C., Loades, D. and Scarisbrick, J. J. (Cambridge, 1988), 253Google Scholar. Salisbury was rated at 2s. 8d. in the pound on £300 in 1606, when his income was approaching £50,000 per year. HMC Salisbury, xix. 272. Stone, L., Family and Fortune: studies in aristocratic finance in the 16th and 17th centuries (Oxford, 1973), 59–60Google Scholar.

30 See above p. 49.

31 The contrast with other European states was realised at the time. On the question of a catholic bride for Henry, Prince, the Venetian ambassador reported that ‘it is very openly said that if a Tuscan woman comes here she will counsel taxation’. CSPVen., 1610–1613, p. 396Google Scholar.

32 Bodleian, MS Ashmole 1463, fo. 13. MS Ashmole 38, p. 182. Bodleian, MS Rawl. poet 1155 p. 70. Bodleian, MS Tanner 299 fos. 12–12V. Bodleian, MS Eng. poet f 10 fo. 97. N.R.O. Isham (Lamport) MS 4304.

33 I am grateful to Mr. Robin Harcourt Williams, librarian and archivist to the Marquess of Salisbury, for information from the Hatfield Manor Papers on the concentration of commoners' rights in Hatfield Wood; there were none elsewhere in the park. For the importance of woodland in the local economy of Brigstock, , Pettit, P.A.H., The Royal Forests of Northants, (Northants. Record Society xxiii, 1968), 171–4Google Scholar.

34 Chamberlain i. 353, 365. PRO, SP 14/70/49, 14 Aug. 1612.

35 Bodleian, MS Tanner 299, fo. 11. Huntington Library California, MS HM 198, fo. 126. The juggler simile proves that this was one of the libels seen by Chamberlain in July 1612.

36 cf. ‘Religion's scoffer’ in Bodleian, , MS Tanner 299, fo. IIVGoogle Scholar. For further discussion, P. Croft, ‘The Religion of Robert Cecil’, forthcoming in Historical Journal.

37 CSPVen., 1610–13, pp.270, 275, 278, 280–1, 375. PRO SP 14/71/12. The negotiations are outlined by Strong, Roy, ‘England and Italy: the marriage of Henry Prince of Wales’, For Veronica Wedgwood These, eds. Ollard, R. and Tudor-Craig, P. (1986), 59–87Google Scholar.

38 SirNaunton, Robert, Fragmenla Regalia: or, observations on the late queen Elizabeth, her times and favourites (1824), 137Google Scholar. Naunton was present at Salisbury's deathbed.

39 BL, Add. MS 25348, fo.gv. N.R.O., Isham (Lamport) MS 4304. Variants in Bodleian, Malone 23, p. 65, and Huntington, MS HM 198, f. 125V.

40 Bodleian, MS Tanner 299, fo. 11, Bodleian, MS Firth d 7, fo. 156. Huntington, MS HM 198, fo. 126. BL, MS Egerton 2230, fo. 34.

41 Bodleian MS Tanner 299, fo. 11.

42 Ibid fo. 13. Bodleian, MS Malone 23, p. 10, MS Malone 26, pp. 65–6.

43 Chamberlain i. 356. PRO, SP 14/69/67 (1).

44 The Riverside Shakespeare, eds. Blakemore, G.et al., (Boston, 1974), 708–9Google Scholar. Riggs, David, Ben Jonson: a life (1989) 90–1Google Scholar.

45 Gurr, Andrew, Playgoing in Shakespeare's London (Cambridge, 1987), 141–7Google Scholar. Bevington, David, Tudor Drama and Polities (Cambridge, Mass., 1968), 233CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

46 The Works of John Day, ed. Bullen, A. H. (2 vols., 1881), i. 5Google Scholar (each play separately paginated). Tricomi, A. H., Anticourt Drama in England 1603–42 (Charlottesville, Virginia, 1989), 34–41Google Scholar.

47 Bodleian, MS Tanner 299, fo. 11. Bodleian, MS Ashmole 38, p. 182. Ashmole 1463, p. 13. N.R.O., Isham (Lamport) MS 4304. Tricomi, 41. For Jonson's relations with Salisbury, Dutton, Richard, Ben Jonson (Cambridge, 1983), 144–53Google Scholar. Rowlands' epitaph on Salisbury, ‘In Vulponem’ begins, ‘The Fox is earthed now in ground’ and contains the lines, ‘Of whose successe-full thriving wit, Bookes have been made, and playes been writ’. Complete Works of Samuel Rowlands ed. Gosse, E. W. (3 vols., Glasgow, 1880), iii. 13Google Scholar.

48 Francis Bacon: The Essays, ed. Pitcher, John (1985), 191–2Google Scholar. The Letters and the Life of Francis Bacon, ed. Spedding, J. (7 vols., 1857–1874), iv. 313, 371Google Scholar.

49 Bodleian, MS Tanner 299, fo. IIV.

50 Letters of King James VI and I, ed. Akrigg, G.P.V. (1984), 234Google Scholar. Loomie, A. J., ‘Sir Robert Cecil and the Spanish Embassy’, Bull. Insl. Hist. Res., xlii (1969) 30–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar. There are numerous versions of the will. I have used that from Hatfield House, MSS Box V/182.

51 HMC Salisbury, xx. 149. Chamberlain i. 273. Hatfield MSS Box V/182.

52 Bodleian, MS Tanner 299, fos. 11–12.

53 Cuddy, Neil, ‘The revival of the entourage: the Bedchamber of James I', Starkey, Davidet al., The English Court (1987), 173–225Google Scholar. The Poems English and Latin of the Rev. Thomas Bastard M.A., ed. Grosart, A. B. (1880), 23Google Scholar.

54 Tricomi, 101. By 1631 eight English countesses were thought to merit the description.

55 Bodleian, MS Tanner 299, fos. 11–12. N.R.O., Isham (Lamport) MS 4304. Wall, Alison, ‘Elizabethan Precept and Feminine Practice: the Thynne family of Longleat’, History, 75, no. 243 (1990), 24–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar. The Lake scandal of 1619 brought forth similar libels describing Lady Lake as ‘A bitch of Court, a common stinking snake’. Bodleian, , Malone MS 23, p. 5Google Scholar.

56 Burghley's widely-circulated ‘Advice to a son’ begins, ‘Son Robert, the virtuous inclination of thy matchless mother…’. Advice to A Son: Precepts of Lord Burghley, Sir Walter Raleigh and Francis Osborne, ed. Wright, L. B. (Folger Shakespeare Library, Washington D.C., 1962), 9–13Google Scholar.

57 For a discussion of other aspects of ‘the problem of diminished majesty’ Russell, Conrad, The Causes of the English Civil War (Oxford, 1990), 23Google Scholar.

58 Mayerne's, notes of the consultation of 28 07 1611 are in his Ephemerides (BL, MSS Sloan 2058–76)Google Scholar, from which an abbreviated version was printed by SirEllis, Henry, Original Letters Illustrative of British History (11 vols., 1824–1846), 2nd ser., iii. 246Google Scholar. There is a full account of Salisbury's condition, based on Mayerne's notes, together with the regimen proposed for his cure, in a document made by or for Dr. Henry Atkins, another of his medical men. Hertfordshire Record Office, MS 65440.

59 Bodleian, MS Tanner 299, fo. 2.

60 Ibid. f. II. Kernan, Alvin, The Cankered Muse (New Haven, 1959), 247–9Google Scholar, notes that disgust at sex and emphasis on the corruptions of the flesh became an increasingly common theme in the literary satire of the early 17th century.

61 Clark, 167–8. Huntington, MS HM 198, fo. 125V. Bodleian, MS Malone 23, p. 65, reads ‘sirrop for ‘syringe’.

62 Bodleian, MS Tanner 299, fo. 11. Chamberlain i. 338. Carpenter, K. J., The History of Scurvy and Vitamin C (Cambridge, 1986), 1–17Google Scholar. Although ‘fruits in their seasons’ were allowed, Salisbury underwent purges and glisters, together with punctures to draw off the waters of the accompanying dropsy. HMC Downshire, iii. 266.

63 Bodleian, MS Rawl. poet 26, fo. 78. Bodleian, MS Eng. poet e 14, fo. 79. The Poems of Sir Walter Ralegh, ed. Latham, A. M. C. (1929), 196Google Scholar.

64 BL, Trumbull MS Misc. v, fo. 11. HMC Downshire, iv. 20.

65 PRO, S.P. 14/71/16. Northampton's usual description of Salisbury as ‘the little lord’ here became ‘the littel one itself and in an extraordinary passage, writing to James I, he insinuated that Salisbury was in hell with Queen Elizabeth, ‘whear he kneels befor his olde mistress by an extreeme whotte fieres side’. PRO, SP 14/71/3.

66 Spedding, iv. 52–3. Peck, Linda Levy, Northampton (1982)Google Scholar.

67 N.R.O., Isham (Lamport) MS 4296.

68 It is noteworthy that later in 1612 there was a campaign of defamation against Northampton, who prosecuted his denigrators in Star Chamber. Chamberlain i. 396.

69 It could be one of those items entered, but never printed. Harrison, G.B., ‘Books and Readers 1591–94’, The Library 4th ser., viii (1927), 273–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

70 Chamberlain i. 365. Bodleian MS Eng. poet e 14, fos. 95v. rev.–96v. rev.

71 For a fuller discussion of Johnson's work, Croft, , A Collection, 250Google Scholar.

72 Ibid. 250–1. Tourneur's characterisation was erroneously attributed to Wotton by Smith, Logan Pearsall, who printed it in The Life and Letters of Sir Henry Wotton (2 vols., 1907), ii. 487–9Google Scholar.

73 For the Apology and the strong probability that Cope was responsible for other measures to defend Salisbury's reputation, Croft, , A Collection 251–4Google Scholar. SirCaesar's, Julius heavily underlined copy, endorsed ‘1 July 1612’, is BL, Lansdowne MS 151Google Scholar, fos. 112–23V. The mathematician and geographer Harriot, Thomas, friend of Ralegh and Northumberland, copied out passages of the Apology. BL. Add. MS 6789Google Scholar, fo. 527. PRO, SP 14/70/21.

74 Bodleian, MS Malone 23, p. 65. Huntington, MS HM 198, fo. 125V. SirBeeston, Hugh, another of the inner circle, was one of the six bannerolls at Salisbury's funeral. HMC Salisbury, xxi. 374Google Scholar.

75 Chamberlain i. 391, 393. The King ‘was quicklie wearie of Kensington because he saide the wind blew thorough the walles that he could not lie warme in his bed’.

76 Northampton noted the closeness of Salisbury and Pembroke. PRO, SP 14/69/56, SP 14/70/21. Chamberlain i. 324, 336, 351.

77 The holograph poem, presumably presented by Pembroke to the second Earl of Salisbury, is Hatfield MS 140/116. Kreuger, Robert, The Poems of William Herbert third earl of Pembroke (unpublished Oxford B. Litt. thesis, 1961), 72Google Scholar. There is a copy in N.R.O. Isham (Lamport) MS 4296, and other versions are discussed by Pitcher, J., Samuel Daniel: the Brotherton Manuscript (Leeds texts and monographs, new ser., 7, 1981), 173–5Google Scholar.

78 Gottfried, R. B., ‘The Authorship of “A Breviary of the History of England”’, Studies in Philology, 53 (1956), 172–90Google Scholar, proves that Daniel, not Ralegh, was the author. The earlier draft, seeking ‘your furtherance (righte Noble Earle of Salsbury)’ is BL, MS Cotton Titus iii. 33.

79 Pitcher, 175–6. There are two further verses.

80 Ballads from Manuscripts, ed. Morfill, W. R. (1 vols., The Ballad Society, 1873), ii. 297–8Google Scholar.

81 STC 4895.7. The only copy, bound in with other works, is at Hatfield House and I am grateful to Mr. Robin Harcourt Williams for producing it for me.

82 Abuses Stript and Wipt was very popular, with at least five editions in 1613. For the text quoted here, Wither, George, Juvenilia (3 vols., printed for the Spenser Society, 1871), i. 165–7Google Scholar. Grundy, Joan, The Spenserian Poets (1969), 14–5Google Scholar.

83 Collinson, P., ‘Puritans, men of business and Elizabethan parliaments’, Parliamentary History 7, pt. 2, (1988) p. 211 n. 97Google Scholar. For the outpouring of pamphlets in the low countries between 1566 and 1588, Kossman, E. H. and Mellink, A. F., Texts Concerning the Revolt of the Netherlands (Cambridge 1974)Google Scholar and for the remarkable manuscript circulation in 1587–8 of dream visions highly critical of Philip II's policies, Kagan, R. L., Lucrecia's Dreams: Politics and Prophecy in 16th century Spain (Berkeley, 1990)Google Scholar.

84 Gurr, 49–79. Clark, 19.

85 Cf. Hurstfield's, Joel review of Menna Prestwich, Cranfield: politics and profits under the early Stuarts (Oxford, 1966)Google Scholar, ‘The Political Morality of early Stuart statesmen’, History, 56, no. 187 (1971), 235–43.