Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-18T12:09:47.460Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Problem of ‘Atheism’ in Early Modern England

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 February 2009

Michael Hunter
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

To speak of ‘atheism’ in the context of early modern England immediately invites confusion, and it is for this reason that I shall place the word in inverted commas throughout this paper. On the one hand, I intend to deal with what a twentieth-century reader might expect ‘atheism’ to imply, namely overt hostility to religion. On the other, I want to consider at some length the profuse writings on ‘atheism’ that survive from the period: in these, as we shall see, the word if often used to describe a much broader range of phenomena, in a manner typical of a genre which often appears frustratingly heightened and rhetorical. Some might argue that this juxtaposition displays—and will encourage—muddled thought. But, on the contrary, I think that it is precisely from such a combination that we stand to learn most. Not only are we likely to discover how contemporaries experienced and responded to the threat of irreligion in the society of their day. In addition, by re-examining the relationship between the real and the exaggerated in their perceptions of such heterodoxy, we may be able to draw broader conclusions about early modern thought.

Type
Research Article
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 35 , December 1985 , pp. 135 - 157
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 1985

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 For comments on an earlier draft of this paper I am indebted to various seminar audiences and to Stuart Clark, Patrick Collinson, Margaret Spufford and Keith Thomas.

2 See Michael Hunter, ‘Science and Heterodoxy: An Early Modern Problem Reconsidered’, in Reappraisals of the Scientific Revolution, eds. D. C. Lindberg and R. S. Westman (forthcoming).

3 For example, the characterisation of ‘The Ranters’ in Pagitt, Ephraim, Heresiography (5th edn, 1654), 143–4Google Scholar, has many echoes of the stock figure of the ‘atheist’ outlined in this paper, and Pagitt's book shares other features with the anti-atheist literature.

4 Bacon's Essays, ed. Wright, W. A. (3rd edn., Cambridge and London, 1865), 64–70Google Scholar.

5 For shared opinions, see Rogers, Thomas, The Catholic Doctrine of the Church of England, ed. Perowne, J.J. S. (Parker Society, Cambridge, 1854), 78, 147–8, 246Google Scholar. On heresy as a route to ‘atheism’, e.g. Heywood, Thomas, A True Discourse of the Two Infamous Upstart Prophets (1636), 7Google Scholar.

6 Beard, Thomas, The Theatre of Gods Iudgements (1597), 147–8Google Scholar; Vaughan, William, The Golden-groue, moralized in three books (1600)Google Scholar, sigs. C4V–5. The relevant papers from British Library, Harleian MSS 6848, 6849 and 6853, are printed in Danchin, F. C., ‘Etudes Critiques sur Christopher Marlowe’, Revue Germanique, 9 (1913), 566–87Google Scholar (with commentary in ibid., 10 (1914), 52–68), and Brooke, C. F. Tucker, The Life of Christopher Marlowe and the Tragedy of Dido Queen of Carthage (1930)Google Scholar (each has some material not included by the other). On the context of the accusations, see, in addition to these works, Bakeless, John, The Tragicall History of Christopher Marlowe (2 vols., Harvard, 1942)Google Scholar, chap. 5, and Kocher, P. H., Christopher Marlowe (Chapel Hill, 1946), chaps. 2–3Google Scholar.

7 This juxtaposition is made particularly plain by the transcripts and abstracts of the material by the antiquary Thomas Baker, from whom Harley acquired the documents, in British Library, Harleian MS 7042, ff. 193–236. For the material relating to the sectaries, see The Writings of John Greenwood and Henry Barrow, 1591–3, ed. Carlson, L. H. (Elizabethan Nonconformist Texts, vi, 1970)Google Scholar.

8 BL, Harl. MS 6849, ff. 183–90, printed in Danchin, , ‘Etudes Critiques’, 578–87Google Scholar, and Willobie His Avisa, ed. Harrison, G. B. (1926), 255–71Google Scholar. See also Strathmann, E. A., Sir Walter Ralegh: A Study in Elizabethan Skepticism (New York, 1951), 46–52Google Scholar, and Lefranc, Pierre, Sir Walter Ralegh, Ecrivain (Paris, 1968), 379–93Google Scholar (who stresses the local context of the enquiry).

9 The Triall of Maist. Dorrell (1599), 88; Hawarde, John, Les Reportes del Cases in Camera Stellata, 1593–1609, ed. Baildon, W. P. (1894), 17Google Scholar.

10 A selection of such cases will be noted in the course of this paper. See also Thomas, Keith, Religion and the Decline of Magic (1971), 168–72Google Scholar.

11 Beard, , Theatre, 148Google Scholar. For the hypothesis that the Baines note is based on a written text by Marlowe, see Kocher, Marlowe, chap. 3.

12 Hill, Adam, The Crie of England (1595), 32Google Scholar.

13 Fuller, Thomas, The Holy Slate and the Profane State (Cambridge, 1642), 383Google Scholar (cf. Greenham, Richard, Workes, ed. Holland, H. (3rd edn, 1601), 3)Google Scholar; Nashe, Thomas, Works, ed. McKerrow, R.B. (2nd edn, 5 vols., Oxford, 1958), ii. 121–2Google Scholar.

14 Hooker, Richard, Works, ed. Keble, John (3 vols., Oxford, 1836), ii. 26Google Scholar (cf. Daniel, iii. 29); Perkins, William, Workes (3 vols., Cambridge, 1608–1609), i, 130Google Scholar, ii. 527; Adams, Thomas, A Commentary or, Exposition Upon the Divine Second Epistle Generall, [of] St. Peter (1633), 1179Google Scholar. On More's views, see below.

15 Dove, John, A Confutation of Atheisme (1605), 14Google Scholar.

16 The Triall of Maist. Dorrell, 88.

17 For early examples of the use of the word, see, e.g., Veron, John, A Fruteful treatise of predestination ([1561])Google Scholar (where it is used as a synonym for ‘anabaptists’) or Bennett, H. S., English Books and Readers, 1558–1603 (Cambridge, 1965), 148Google Scholar. Other early instances of usage are included in Brie, Friedrich, ‘Deismus und Atheismus in der Englischen Renaissance’, Anglia, 48, (1924), 54–98, 105–68Google Scholar, and Buckley, G. T., Atheism in the English Renaissance (Chicago, 1932Google Scholar; repr. New York, 1965). See also Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. ‘atheism’, ‘atheist’, and, on the continental background, Henri Busson, ‘Les Noms des Incredules au XVIe siècle’, Bibliotheque d'Humanismeet Renaissance, 16 (1954), 273–83Google Scholar, and Bianca, Concetta, ‘Per la Storia del Termine “Atheus” nel Cinquecento: Fonti et Traduzioni Greco-Latine’, Studi Filosofici, 3 (1980), 71–104Google Scholar (I owe this reference to Charles Schmitt).

18 Nichols, Josias, The Plea of the Innocent (1602), 221Google Scholar (bis); Smith, Samuel, The Great Assize (3rd impression, 1618), 263Google Scholar. Cf. Collinson, Patrick, The Religion of Protestants (Oxford, 1982), 200Google Scholar.

19 Calendar of State Papers Domestic, 1601–3, 23.

20 Hull, John, The Unmasking of the Politike Atheist (2nd edn, 1602), 42Google Scholar and passim.

21 Palfreyman, Thomas, The Treatise ofHeauenly Philosophic (1578), 83Google Scholar.

22 Primaudaye, Pierre de la, The Second Part of the French Academic, trans. Bowes, Thomas (1594)Google Scholar, sig. b3V. For accusations against individuals, e.g. Prouty, C. T., George Gascoigne (New York, 1942), 61Google Scholar.

23 Wingfield, John, Atheisme Close and open, Anatomized (2 pts, 1634), ii. 20–1Google Scholar.

24 Ascham, Roger, English Works, ed. Wright, W. A. (Cambridge, 1904), 228–36Google Scholar.

25 Lyly, John, Euphues: The Anatomy of Wit and Euphues & his England, ed. Croll, M.W. and Clemons, H. (1916), 147–62Google Scholar; Public Record Office, SP 12/83, ff 114–5.

26 Parsons, Robert, A Christian Directorie Guiding Men to their Salvation ([Louvain], 1585)Google Scholar, chaps. 2, 4 (these chapters do not appear in the 1582 edition; they recur in the 1598 edition but are omitted from that of 1607); cf. Strathmann, Ernest, ‘Robert Parsons' Essay on Atheism’, in Joseph Quincy Adams Memorial Studies, eds. McManaway, J. G., Dawson, G. E. and Willoughby, E. E. (Washington, D.C., 1948), 665–81Google Scholar. SirSidney, Philip, The Countess of Pembroke's Arcadia, ed. Evans, Maurice (Harmondsworth, 1977), 487–92Google Scholar; cf. Walker, D. P., ‘Atheism, the Ancient Theology and Sidney's Arcadia’, in The Ancient Theology (1972), 132–63Google Scholar. Hooker, , Works, ii. 24–30Google Scholar.

27 For an account of various of these books, see Strathmann, Ralegh, chap. 3. See also Aylmer, G. E., ‘Unbelief in Seventeenth-century England’, in Puritans and Revolutionaries, eds. Pennington, Donald and Thomas, Keith (Oxford, 1978), 22–46Google Scholar.

28 Corderoy, Jeremy, A Warning for Worldlings (1608), 37Google Scholar and passim; Dent, C. M., Protestant Reformers in Elizabethan Oxford (Oxford, 1983), 159Google Scholar.

29 Corderoy, , Warning, 202–3Google Scholar.

30 Perkins, , Workes, ii. 451Google Scholar.

31 Cuffe, Henry, The Differences of the Ages of Mans Life (1607), 24Google Scholar.

32 Gardiner, Samuel, Doomes-day Booke (1606), 1Google Scholar; Stephens, John, Salyrical Essayes Characters and Others (1615), 212Google Scholar.

33 Carpenter, John, A Preparatiue to Contentation (1597), 233Google Scholar; Corderoy, , Warning, 12Google Scholar.

34 Fotherby, Martin, Atheomastix (1622)Google Scholar, sig. A2V; Nashe, , Works, ii. 124Google Scholar.

35 Stephens, , Satyrical Essayes, 216Google Scholar; Burton, Robert, The Anatomy of Melancholy (3rd edn, Oxford, 1628), 618Google Scholar; Corderoy, , Warning, 38Google Scholar; Cuffe, , Differences, 20Google Scholar. On ‘atheists’ as proselytizers, see Bacon's Essays, 65.

36 Hooker, , Works, ii. 26Google Scholar. Cf. 2 Peter iii. 3.

37 Fuller, , Holy State, 378Google Scholar.

38 Adams, Thomas, Workes (1630), 16Google Scholar.

39 E.g. Perkins, compare, Workes, i. 479Google Scholar, with ibid., ii. 526.

40 Ames, William, An Analyticall Exposition of both the Epistles of the Apostle Peter (1641), 237–8Google Scholar.

41 Fuller, , Holy State, 379Google Scholar; Adams, , Workes, 14Google Scholar.

42 Fuller, , Holy State, 380Google Scholar; Fitzherbert, Thomas, The Second Part of a Treatise Concerning Policy, and Religion ([Douai], 1610), 69–70Google Scholar.

43 Adams, , Workes, 498Google Scholar; Spicer, John, The Sale of Salt (1611), 32Google Scholar. See also Elton, W. R., King Lear and the Gods (San Marino, 1966)Google Scholar, chap. 2.

44 Wingfield, , Atheisme, esp. i. 66–7Google Scholar; Nicholas, , Plea, 208–9Google Scholar (bis).

45 Corderoy, Warning, sig. A6v.

46 Fuller, , Holy State, 383Google Scholar; Bacon's Essays, 66.

47 Morton, Thomas, A Treatise of the Mature of God (1599), 30Google Scholar (a statement by the Gentleman who acts as an interlocutor in the dialogue); SirMore, George, A Demonstration of Godin his workes (1597), sig. A2V, pp. 20, 25–6Google Scholar and passim.

48 Beard, Thomas, The Theatre of God's Judgements (3rd edn, 1631), 150–1Google Scholar.

49 Nashe, , Works, ii. 121Google Scholar.

50 Palfreyman, , The Treatise, 702–4Google Scholar, and see, e.g., Primaudaye, Second Part, sig. b4v; Hull, John, Saint Peters Prophesie of these Last Daies (1610), 127Google Scholar; Jackson, Thomas, Londons New-Yeeres Gift (1609), f. 18Google Scholar.

51 Rogers, , Catholic Doctrine, 78, 148Google Scholar; Adams, , Commentary, 1159–66Google Scholar: other sources include Bacon.

52 For instance, Greenham's, Richard account of an ‘atheist’ (Workes, 3)Google Scholar was reused in Mosse, Miles, Justifying and Saving Faith distinguished from the faith of the Deuils (Cambridge and London, 1614), 17–18Google Scholar, and in Adams, , Commentary, 16Google Scholar.

53 Hull, , Saint Peters Prophesie, 8Google Scholar.

54 Origen: Contra Celsum, trans. Chadwick, Henry (Cambridge, 1953), 22, 28, 37, 297Google Scholarand passim. For an instance of a typical formulaic description of ‘atheism’, see Price, Daniel, Sauls Prohibition Staide (1609)Google Scholar, sig. E3.

55 Lyly, , Euphues, 150, 161–2Google Scholar; More, , Demonstration, 34Google Scholar.

56 E.g. Dove, , Confutation, 70Google Scholar.

57 Fotherby, Atheomastix, sig. A2.

58 Weemes, John, A Treatise of the Foure Degenerate Sonnes (1636), 7Google Scholar; Morton, , Treatise, 7Google Scholar.

59 Clark, Stuart, ‘Inversion, Misrule and the Meaning of Witchcraft’, Past & Present, 87 (1980), 98–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

60 Hooker, , Works, ii. 24Google Scholar; Burton, , Anatomy, 614Google Scholar; Weemes, , Treatise, 6Google Scholar.

61 See Boyce, Benjamin, The Theophrastan Character in England to 1642 (Cambridge, Mass., 1947)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Greenough, C. N., A Bibliography of the Theophrastan Character in English (Cambridge, Mass., 1947)Google Scholar.

62 Breton, Nicholas, The Good and the Badde (1616), 20Google Scholar.

63 Hall, Joseph, Works, new edn., ed. Wynter, Philip (10 vols., Oxford, 1863), vi. 106Google Scholar.

64 Nichols, Josias, An Order of Houshold Instruction (1596)Google Scholar, sig. E5.

65 Parsons, , Christian Directorie, 25Google Scholar.

66 Beard, , Theatre (1597), 147Google Scholar. For Beard's additions, see the 1631 edition, esp. 548–9.

67 Gibbens, Nicholas, Questions and Disputations Concerning the Holy Scripture (1601), 168–9Google Scholar.

68 Hawarde, , Reportes, 41Google Scholar.

69 Brooke, , Life, 98Google Scholar; Beard, , Theatre (1597), 148Google Scholar. Compare Robert Parsons' accusation against Ralegh (Lefranc, , Ralegh, 356Google Scholar), or the allegations against the Earl of Oxford in 1581, in which appear such clichès as ‘The trinity a fable’ and ‘Scriptures for pollicye’: see ibid., 340–1, and PRO, SP 12/151, ff. 102, 109, 118.

70 For such a suggestion in a comparable context, see Wootton, David, Paolo Sarpi: between Renaissance and Enlightenment (Cambridge, 1983), 143CrossRefGoogle Scholar. On Marlowe's originality, see Kocher, Marlowe, chap. 3.

71 Ibid., 30n and chap. 3 passim.

72 Corderoy, Warning, sig. A6. For examples—though more of heretical than atheistic ideas—see the manuscript owned by Kyd in which an anti-Arian work was eviscerated for heretical opinions (Danchin, , ‘Etudes Critiques’, 568–70Google Scholar, and Briggs, W.D., ‘On a Document concerning Christopher Marlowe’, Studies in Philology, 20 (1923), 153–9)Google Scholar or the claim of the Sherborne shoemaker, Robert Hyde, at the Cerne Abbas hearing, to have derived his notions from reports of a local priest's sermon attacking sectarian views: Willobie his Avisa, 264, 269–70.

73 Ibid., 259. For the possibility that this was Charles Thynne, see Lefranc, , Ralegh, 387Google Scholar; on John Thynne, to whom Carew Ralegh was gentleman of horse and whose widow Carew married, see DNB s.v. ‘Sir Walter Ralegh’. Thynne's view was possibly heretical rather than atheistic: see the different positions distinguished in Gosson, Stephen, The Trumpet of Wane (1598), 52–4Google Scholar.

74 Hotson, Leslie, Shakespeare versus Shallow (1931), 54–8, 198, 202, 228–9Google Scholar.

75 Brooke, , Life, 98–100Google Scholar, 107. According to Simon Aldrich, Marlowe's ‘booke’ was ‘against the Scriptur’: Bakeless, , Tragicall History, i. 120Google Scholar.

76 PRO, STA 8/59/11, memb. 2. For the reference, I am indebted to Ingram, M.J., ‘Eccclesiastical Justice in Wiltshire, 1600–1640’ (Oxford D.Phil, thesis, 1977), 103–4Google Scholar.

77 Willobie his Avisa, 262–3; Bakeless, , Tragicall History, i. 120, 122–3Google Scholar; Wiltshire Record Office, Diocese of Salisbury Dean's Presentments, 1607–9 (10), f.66: this is another case to which I was alerted by Ingram, ‘Ecclesiastical Justice’, 81; he does not, however, note the circumstances in which Derpier was accused of uttering these words, as referred to below. Such cases seem to me distinct from the non-atheistic mortalism dealt with in Burns, N. T., Christian Mortalism from Tyndale to Milton (Cambridge, Mass., 1972)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

78 Borthwick Institute, York, HC CP 1637/3: I am indebted to Bill Sheils for his help with this case. Cf Brooke, , Life, 98–9, 107Google Scholar.

79 The Triall of Moist. Dorrell, 88; Brooke, , Life, 99Google Scholar.

80 The Acts of the High Commission Court within the Diocese of Durham, ed. Longstaffe, W. H. D. (Surtees Society, xxxiv, Durham, 1858), 116Google Scholar: I am indebted to Pete Rushton for his advice on this case. On wit, see Kocher, , Marlowe, 48, 56–7Google Scholar, and Willobie his Avisa, esp. 266–8.

81 Hawarde, , Reportes, 42Google Scholar. See above, p. 149.

82 PRO, STA 8/59/11, memb. 2.

83 Willobie his Avisa, 262–3, 256 (these, like other words cited in the ‘Interrogatories’, are clearly based on hearsay reports of those accused: cf. ibid., 264, for a slightly different version of the same story about Allen).

84 Ibid., 258, 260, 261, 262, 266. It is interesting that Ralegh's opinion on the godhead had been uttered on an earlier occasion, but was ‘shutt up’ till brought to light by the enquiry (ibid., 258).

85 Cf. the suggestive remarks in Febvre, Lucien, The Problem of Unbelief in the Sixteenth Century: the Religion of Rabelais, trans. Gottlieb, Beatrice (Cambridge, Mass., 1982), 142Google Scholarf, though my disagreement with the general thrust of Febvre's argument should have become apparent in the course of this paper.

86 SirD'Ewes, Simonds, Autobiography and Correspondence, ed. Halliwell, J. O. (2 vols., 1845), i. 253Google Scholar. Cf. Thomas, , Religion and the Decline of Magic, 167–8, 474–5Google Scholar.

87 Mornay, Phillippe Duplessis, A Woorke concerning the trewnesse of the Christian Religion, trans. SirSidney, Philip and Golding, Arthur (1587)Google Scholar, sig. *3.

88 Burton, , Anatomy, 614–21Google Scholar (pt 3, sect. 4, memb. 2, subsect. 1).

89 Greenham, , Workes, 3Google Scholar.

90 E.g. the case of Barker, Richard in Hale, W. H., A Series of Precedents and Proceedings in Criminal Causes (1847), 176Google Scholar.

91 Brooke, , Life, 103, 104Google Scholar.

92 Meres, Francis, Palladis Tamia. Wits Treasury (1598), f. 303VGoogle Scholar; Woolton, John, A Treatise of the Immortalilie of the Soule (1576)Google Scholar, Ep. Ded., f. 26.

93 Strathmann, Ralegh, passim; Lefranc, Ralegh, chap. 12; Greenblatt, S.J., Sir Walter Ralegh: the Renaissance Man and his Roles (New Haven, 1973), 99–101Google Scholar; Willobie his Avisa, 266–8.

94 E.g. Clark, Stuart, ‘Wisdom Literature of the Seventeenth century: a Guide to the Contents of the “Bacon-Tottel” Commonplace Books’, Transactions of the Cambridge Bibliographical Society, 6 (1976), 300Google Scholar. See also particularly Mosse, G.L., The Holy Pretence (Oxford, 1957)Google Scholar and Raab, Felix, The English Face of Machiavelli (1964)Google Scholar, chap. 3.

95 Abernethy, John, A Christian and Heavenly Treatise Containing Physicke for the Soule (3rd edn, 1630)Google Scholar, sig. A7V. On this theme see also Kocher, P.H., Science and Religion in Elizabethan England (San Marino, 1953)Google Scholar, esp. chap. 5.

96 See particularly Quinn, D.B. and Shirley, J.W., ‘A Contemporary List of Hariot References’, Renaissance Quarterly, 22 (1969)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, esp. 18f. But see also Jacquot, Jean, ‘Thomas Harriot's Reputation for Impiety’, Notes and Records of the Royal Society, 9 (1952), 164–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Greenblatt, Stephen, ‘Invisible Bullets: Renaissance Authority and its Subversion’, Glyph: Johns Hopkins Textual Studies, 8 (1981), 40–61Google Scholar (a reference I owe to Moti Feingold): Harriot almost certainly had Deistic tendencies.

97 The Historic of the World. Commonly called, The Naturall Historie ofC. Plinius Secundus, trans. Philemon Holland (1601), ‘The Preface to the Reader’.

98 See Brooke, , Life, 98–9, 107Google Scholar; Kocher, , Marlowe, 61–3Google Scholar and passim. On this aspect of Marlowe's ideas see, for instance, Palmer, D.J., ‘Marlowe's Naturalism’, in Christopher Marlowe, ed. Morris, Brian (1968), 151–75Google Scholar.

99 The word is used by Nichols, Josias in his Order of Houshold Instruction (1596)Google Scholar, sig. E7, although the earliest usage given in OED is Burton's of 1621; it is symptomatic, however, that Nichols uses the word as a synonym for ‘atheist’. On its (rare) use in sixteenth-century France, see Busson, , ‘Les Noms’, 278–9Google Scholar.

100 Wiener, C.Z., ‘The Beleaguered Isle. A Study of Elizabethan and Early Stuart Anti-Catholicism’, Past & Present, 51 (1971), 27–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Collinson, Patrick, ‘A Comment: Concerning the Name Puritan’, Journal of Ecclesiastical History, 31 (1980), 483–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and English Puritanism (Historical Association, 1983), 7–11.

101 Cf. Cohen, Stanley, Folk Devils and Moral Panics: the Creation of the Mods and Rockers (1972)Google Scholar. See also Erikson, K. T., Wayward Puritans: a Study in the Sociology of Deviance (New York, 1966)Google Scholar.