Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jn8rn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T19:34:11.988Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

LANGUAGES OF FREEDOM IN DECOLONISING AFRICA*The Gladstone Prize Winner

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 November 2017

Emma Hunter
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The ‘triumph of liberalism’ in the mid-twentieth-century west is well known and much studied. But what has it meant for the way the decolonisation of Africa has been viewed, both at the time and since? In this paper, I suggest that it has quietly but effectively shaped our understanding of African political thinking in the 1950s to 1960s. Although the nationalist framing that once led historians to neglect those aspects of the political thinking of the period which did not move in the direction of a territorial nation-state has now been challenged, we still struggle with those aspects of political thinking that were, for instance, suspicious of a focus on the individual and profoundly opposed to egalitarian visions of a post-colonial future. I argue that to understand better the history of decolonisation in the African continent, both before and after independence, while also enabling comparative work with other times and places, we need to think more carefully and sensitively about how freedom and equality were understood and argued over in local contexts.

Type
Research Article
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 27 , December 2017 , pp. 253 - 269
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

I am grateful to Charles West and the two anonymous reviewers for comments on earlier drafts of this paper.

References

1 Ruhumbika, Gabriel, Village in Uhuru (Harlow, 1969), 93 Google Scholar.

2 Ibid., 94.

3 Bell, Duncan, Reordering the World: Essays on Liberalism and Empire (Princeton, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Armitage, David, Foundations of Modern International Thought (Cambridge, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Cooper, Frederick, Africa since 1940: The Past of the Present (Cambridge, 2002)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Cooper, Frederick, ‘Possibility and Constraint: African Independence in Historical Perspective’, Journal of African History, 49 (2008), 167–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Macola, Giacomo, Liberal Nationalism in Central Africa: A Biography of Harry Mwaanga Nkumbula (New York, 2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Harri Englund has called on scholars to ask ‘harder questions about the place that the liberal values of equality and freedom might have both among the instances being studied and in scholars’ own commitments’. Englund, Harri, ‘Zambia at 50: The Rediscovery of Liberalism’, Africa: The Journal of the International African Institute, 83 (2013), 670–89, at 685CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Peterson, Derek, Ethnic Patriotism and the East African Revival: A History of Dissent c. 1935–1972 (Cambridge, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Larmer, Miles, Rethinking African Politics: A History of Opposition in Zambia (Farnham, 2011), 4 Google Scholar.

9 Summarising a body of new research in this vein, Harri Englund has described a ‘rediscovery of liberalism’ among historians. Englund, ‘Zambia at 50’. Though at the same time, it is unclear how far other options were realistic possibilities. Moyn, Samuel, ‘Fantasies of Federalism’, Dissent, 62 (2015), 145–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 Englund, ‘Zambia at 50’.

11 For example, Burbank, Jane and Cooper, Frederick, Empires in World History: Power and the Politics of Difference (Princeton, 2010)Google Scholar.

12 Emerson, Rupert, From Empire to Nation: The Rise of Self-Assertion of Asian and African Peoples (Cambridge, MA, 1960), 3 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

13 Rathbone, Richard, ‘Kwame Nkrumah and the Chiefs: The Fate of “Natural Rulers” under Nationalist Governments’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 10 (2000), 45–63, at 57CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14 Independence and Beyond: The Speeches of Kenneth Kaunda, ed. Colin Legum (1966), 208–9; Julius Nyerere, ‘Democracy and the Party System’, in Freedom and Unity, ed. Julius Nyerere (1966), 195–203.

15 Bell, Reordering the World, 87.

16 Ibid .

17 Freeden, Michael, Liberalism: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford, 2015), 1 Google Scholar.

18 Den Otter, Sandra M., British Idealism and Social Explanation: A Study in Late Victorian Thought (Oxford, 1996), 152 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Morefield, Jeanne, Covenants without Swords: Idealist liberalism and the Spirit of Empire (Princeton, 2005), 45 Google Scholar.

20 Hunter, Emma, ‘Dutiful Subjects, Patriotic Citizens, and the Concept of “Good Citizenship” in Twentieth-Century Tanzania’, Historical Journal, 56 (2013), 257–77, at 259CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21 Lonsdale, John, ‘States and Social Processes in Africa: A Historiographical Survey’, African Studies Review, 24 (1981), 139–225, at 143CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

22 Rathbone, ‘Kwame Nkrumah and the Chiefs’.

23 Recent work is starting to uncover the dynamism of these transnational networks, for example James, Leslie, George Padmore and Decolonization from Below: Pan-Africanism, the Cold War, and the End of Empire (Basingstoke, 2015)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and research groups such as Afro-Asian Networks, http://afroasiannetworks.com.

24 Willis, Justin, ‘Chieftaincy’, in The Oxford Handbook of Modern African History, ed. Parker, John and Reid, Richard (Oxford, 2013), 208–23Google Scholar; Leonardi, Cherry and Vaughan, Chris, ‘“We Are Oppressed and our Only Way Is to Write to Higher Authority”: The Politics of Claim and Complaint in the Peripheries of Condominium Sudan’, in Citizenship, Belonging and Political Community in Africa: Dialogues between Past and Present, ed. Hunter, Emma (Athens, OH, 2016), 74–100 Google Scholar.

25 Peterson, Derek, ‘Introduction’, in The Politics of Heritage in Africa: Economies, Histories, and Infrastructures, ed. Peterson, Derek (Cambridge, 2015), 1–36 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 Rathbone, ‘Kwame Nkrumah and the Chiefs’.

27 Peterson, Ethnic Patriotism and the East African Revival, 127–8.

28 Ibid., 16.

29 Lonsdale, John, ‘KAU's Cultures: Imaginations of Community and Constructions of Leadership in Kenya after the Second World War’, Journal of African Cultural Studies, 13 (2000), 107–24CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

30 Englund, Harri, Human Rights and the African Airwaves: Mediating Equality on the Chichewa Radio (Bloomington, 2011), 224 Google Scholar.

31 Kilimanjaro Chagga Citizens Union, ‘A History of the Mila ya Wachagga’, Tanzania National Archives (TNA) 5/584, fo. 154.

32 Hunter, Emma, ‘In Pursuit of the “Higher Medievalism”: Local History and Politics in Kilimanjaro’, in Recasting the Past: History Writing and Political Work in Modern Africa, ed. Peterson, Derek and Macola, Giacomo (Athens OH, 2009), 149–70Google Scholar.

33 Nathaniel Mtui, Nine Notebooks of Chagga History, paragraph 160. A microfilm copy of a 1958–9 English translation is available in Leipzig University Library.

34 Fiedler, Klaus, Christianity and African Culture: Conservative German Protestant Missionaries in Tanzania, 1900–1940 (Leiden, 1996), 42, 115 Google Scholar.

35 Gutmann, Bruno, ‘The African Standpoint’, Africa, 8 (1935), 1–19, at 9–10CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

36 To see how the principles of indirect rule were explained by the government in Tanganyika, see for example: No author, ‘Namna nci inavyotawaliwa’, Mambo Leo, Dec. 1925, 265. Charles Dundas and his political thinking is discussed at greater length in Hunter, ‘In Pursuit of the “Higher Medievalism”’.

37 It is important to emphasise this point. Karuna Matena's recent book has argued that indirect rule, the colonial practice of government through the framework of the ‘tribe’ and chief, was a response to the perceived failure of the liberal projects of the mid-nineteenth century and that in Africa it ‘took on preemptive, and therefore more systematic, character’, aiming to prevent the dissolution of social bonds before it was too late. Yet indirect rule in Africa was never simply a project of conservation and, as Duncan Bell has argued, reading it as a rejection of liberalism rests on a narrow definition of liberalism. Mantena, Karuna, Alibis of Empire: Henry Maine and the Ends of Liberal Imperialism (Princeton, 2010), 173 Google Scholar; Bell, Reordering the World, 57.

38 Hunter, ‘Dutiful Subjects’, 259.

39 Ruben Moshi, Ufalme wa Mungu, Jan. 1930, 8.

40 Joseph Maliti, ‘Letter from the President’, Uremi, 3 June 1932, TNA 20984.

41 Letter from S. M. Ngooly, ‘Uzembe katika mabaraza ya wenyeji wa utawala wa Moshi’, Kwetu, 8 Sept. 1939.

42 This section draws on arguments made in Hunter, Emma, Political Thought and the Public Sphere in Tanzania: Freedom, Democracy and Citizenship in the Era of Decolonization (Cambridge, 2015), ch. 4CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

43 ‘Mkutano maalumu wa wanachama’, 2 Feb. 1956, TNA 5/25/7, fo. 266.

44 Kilimanjaro Chagga Citizens Union Pamphlet No. 4 of 1954, ‘Urithi wa Wenyeji wa Nchi ni Mila, Iliyotokana na Wakale Wao’, 26 July 1954, 5, TNA 5/25/7, fo. 221; ‘Kilimanjaro Chagga Union amezaliwa Moshi’, TNA 5/584, fo. 31.

45 Stilwell, Sean, Slavery and Slaving in African History (Cambridge, 2014), 8 Google Scholar.

46 District commissioner to secretary, Chagga Citizens Union, Oct. 1951, TNA 5/23/20, vol. 1, fo. 104. Emphasis in original.

47 ‘Minutes of the Meeting of the Chagga Congress which Met in the Welfare Centre on Saturday 30th January 1954’, TNA 12844/4, fo. 538.

48 ‘Wanafunzi Wachagga wa Makerere wamejita’, Komkya, Feb. 1955, 1; Stahl, Kathleen, ‘The Chagga’, in Tradition and Transition: Studies of the Tribal Element in the Modern Era (Berkeley, 1969), 209–22, at 218Google Scholar.

49 J. Merinyo to D. C., ‘Tangazo Maalum kwa Wachagga la Tarehe 1st June 1958’, TNA 5/23/20, fo. 149.

50 E. Alemyo, ‘Serikali ni Sisi’, Makerere College Chagga Society Magazine, The National Archives (UK) (TNA UK), FCO 141/17864, fo. 10A.

51 A. R. Denny, ‘A Note on Chagga Tribal Politics Prior to Referendum in Jan. 1960’, TNA UK, FCO 141/17864, 4 Jan. 1960, 3, fo. 55a.

52 Emma Hunter, ‘Economic Man in East Africa’, in The Moral Economies of Ethnic and Nationalist Claims, ed. Bruce Berman, Andre Laliberté and Stephen Larin (Vancouver, 2016), 101–22. On the eclectic sources of Nyerere's thinking about society, see Molony, Tom, Nyerere: The Early Years (Woodbridge, 2014)Google Scholar. The term ujamaa, used by Nyerere to describe his policy of African socialism, was used in colonial didactic texts in the 1920s and 1930s to describe the choice of humans to live together rather than separately, and the responsibilities to each other which follow from that. This was, for the authors of the didactic primer Uraia, ‘the basis of citizenship’. Emma Hunter, ‘Languages of Politics in Twentieth-Century Kilimanjaro’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of Cambridge, 2008), 231.

53 A debate in the pages of Kusare in Mar. 1962 about chiefship and whether women could hold positions of local political authority is telling in this regard. See for example a letter from Makunduwira Kiwari, ‘Umangi wa Ukoloni Hatutaki’, Kusare, 26 Mar. 1962, 3. Letters to Kusare over the course of the 1960s also suggest that although local political associations could no longer be formed, this did not mean that all had reconciled themselves to the nationalist party, TANU. Letter from Abdullah S. Kweka, ‘Wazee Waukaribisha Ujinga Mkoani Kilimanjaro’, Kusare, 11 Sept. 1965, 3.

54 Moyn, ‘Fantasies of Federalism’.

55 Englund, ‘Zambia at 50’; Ferguson, James, ‘Debating “the Rediscovery of Liberalism” in Zambia: Responses to Harri Englund’, Africa, 84 (2014), 658–68, at 666Google Scholar.