Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-grxwn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-27T03:00:50.414Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Complements or Substitutes? Taxation, Social Welfare and Labour Market Regulation: An Industrial Relations Perspective on the ‘Five Economists’ Plan

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2023

Julien Barbara  and
Peter Gahan
Julien Barbara
Affiliation:
Department of Management, University of Melbourne
Peter Gahan
Affiliation:
School of Industrial Relations and Organizational Behaviour, UNSW
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to critically appraise the assumptions and proposals put forward in the Five Economists’ plan to change the balance between social welfare, taxation and labour market regulation. The core theme developed here is that the proposal is based on questionable assumptions about the nature of employment relationships and labour market processes. An alternative framework is advanced. Using the Dutch case, it is argued that a more appropriate balance between these policy instruments, which requires an account of the distribution of risk between workers, firms and the state, provides a better theoretical basis on which linkages between taxation, social welfare and labour market regulation can be recast.

‘Let me say, at the outset, that you should be sceptical of anyone who suggests that there are any easy solutions. Solutions which most economists would agree could enable a return to “full employment” or very low unemployment, are either socially or politically unacceptable, or we do not know how to Implement them. The best solution is to achieve a large increase in the rate of economic growth.’

(Dawkins 1996: 16)

Type
Research Article
Information
The Economic and Labour Relations Review , Volume 11 , Issue 1 , June 2000 , pp. 8 - 45
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2000

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

We would like to thank Nicholas Brunton, Peter Kell, Peter Kriesler, and John Nevile for comments on earlier drafts. All errors of omission and interpretation remain our own.

References

Australian Centre for Industrial Relations Research and Training (1999), Australia at Work: Just Managing? Prentice Hall, Sydney Google Scholar
Australian Council of Trade Unions (1998) ‘Cutting Low Wages Will Not Boost Jobs’, ACTU Media Office, 26th OctoberGoogle Scholar
Addison, , Blackburn, (1999) ‘Minimum Wages and Poverty,’ Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 52(3), April: 393–409 Google Scholar
Akerlof, G (1982) ‘Labor Contracts as Partial Gift Exchange,’ Quarterly Journal of Economics, 97(4), November: 543–69Google Scholar
Arulampalam, W., Booth, A. (1998) ‘Training and Labour Market Flexibility: Is there a Trade Off?’ British journal of Industrial Relations, 36(4), December: 459–467 Google Scholar
Atkinson, A. B., Mlcklewright, J. (1991) ‘Unemployment Compensation and Labor Market Transitions: A Critical Review,’ Journal of Economic Literature, 23(4), December: 1679–1727 Google Scholar
Bazzoll, L., Klrat, T., Vllleval, M. (1994) ‘Rules, Contract and Institution in the Wage-Labor Relationship: A Return to Institutionalism?’ Journal of Economic Issues, XXVIII (4), December: 1137–1171 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Becker, G.L. (1996), ‘How to end welfare “as we know it” - fast’, Business Week, June 3, p. 8 Google Scholar
Becker, U (1999), The Dutch “Employment Miracle”: Employment Growth in a Retrenched But Still Generous Welfare System, Social Policy Research Centre, Discussion Paper No. 99, MayGoogle Scholar
Belman, D, Wolfson, (1999) ‘Its bark is Worse than its Bite: The Wage and Employment Effects of the Minimum Wage in the US,’ Australian Economic Papers, June: 143–163 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blank, R.M., Freeman, R.B. (1994) ‘Evaluating the connection between social protection and economic flexibility’ in Blank, R.B. (ed.) Social Protection versus Economic Flexibility: Is There a Trade-off? The University of Chicago Press, Chicago Google Scholar
Blyton, P., Turnbull, P. (1998) The Dynamics of Employee Relations, Second edition, Houndsmill, UK: Macmillan Google Scholar
Bowles, S (1985) ‘The Production Process in a Competitive Economy: Walrasian, Marxian and Neo-Hobbeslan Models,’ American Economic Review, 75(1), March: 16–36 Google Scholar
Boyer, R., Hollongsworth, J.R. (1997) ‘The Variety of Institutional Arrangements and Their Complementarity in Modern Economies,’ in Hoolongsworth, , Boyer, (eds), Contemporary Capitalism: The Embeddedness of Institutions, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 49–54 Google Scholar
Bray, M (1986) ‘Management, Industrial Relations and the Capitalist Enterprise,’ in Bray, Mark, Taylor, Vic (eds), Managing Labour? Essays in the Political Economy of Australian Industrial Relations, Roseville, NSW: McGraw Hill, 124–146 Google Scholar
Breen, R (1997) ‘Risk, Recommodification and Stratification,’ Sociology, 31(3), August: 473–489 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brosnan, P (1996), ‘Labour markets and social deprivation’, Labour and Industry, 7, 2: 3–34 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, W., Nolan, P. (1988) ‘Wages and Labour Productivity: The Contribution of Industrial Relations Research to the Understanding of Pay Determination,’ British Journal of Industrial Relations, 26(3), November: 339–62Google Scholar
Brown, W., Hayles, J., Hughes, B., Rowe, L. (1978) ‘How far does arbitration constrain Australia’s labour market?’ Australian Bulletin of labour, 4, 4:31–9Google Scholar
Buchanan, J., Watson, I. (1999) ‘BCA Wrong to use US Model’, Australian Financial Review, 30 AprilGoogle Scholar
Buchanan, J., Callus, R. (1993) ‘Efficiency and Equity at Work: The Need for Labour Market Regulation in Australia,’ Journal of Industrial Relations, 35(4), December: 515–537 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burgess, J., Campbell, I. (1998) ‘Casual Employment: Growth, Characteristics, A Bridge or a Trap?’ The Economic and Labour Relations Review, Vol. 9, 1, June: 31–54 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Campbell, I (1996) ‘Casual employment, labour regulation and Australian trade unions’, Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 38, No. 4, December: 571–599 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Campbell, I., Webber, M. (1996) ‘Retrenchment and Labour Market Flows In Australia’, The Economic and Labour Relations Review, Vol. 7, 1, June: 88–119 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Card, D., Freeman, R.B. (1993) Small Differences That Matter: Labor Markets and Income Maintenance in Canada and the United States (eds), Chicago, Chicago University Press CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Card, D., Krueger, A.B. (1995) Myth and Measurement: The New Economics of the Minimum Wage, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press Google Scholar
Castles, F (1985) The Working Class and Welfare, Allen and Unwin: Wellington Google Scholar
Champlin, D (1995), ‘Understanding job quality in an era of structural change: What can economics learn from industrial relations?’ Journal of Economic Issues, SeptemberGoogle Scholar
Coelli, M., Fahrer, J., Lindsay, H. (1994) ‘Wage Dispersion and Labour Market Institutions: A Cross Country Study’, Research Discussion Paper 9404, Reserve Bank of Australia, SydneyGoogle Scholar
Colling, T., Dickens, L. (1998) ‘Selling the Cae for Gender equity: Deregulation and Equity Bargaining,’ British Journal of Industrial Relations, 36(3), September: 389–411 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Costa, M (1998) ‘Economists’ Plan Ignores Real Problem: Casualisation’, Media Release, Labor Council of NSW, October 26Google Scholar
Cukierman, A, Tommasi, M. (1998) ‘When Does it Take a Nixon to go to China?,’ American Economic Review, 88(1), March: 180–197 Google Scholar
Dawkins, P (1996a) ‘Inaugural Lecture,’ Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research, Faculty of Economists and Commerce, Tuesday, 14 May, 1996Google Scholar
Dawkins, P (1996b) ‘The distribution of work in Australia’, The Economic Record, 72, 218, September: 272–86Google Scholar
Dawkins, P (1998a) ‘Solutions to Unemployment and Avoiding the “Diabolical Trade-off”: A Discussion’ in Debelle, G., Borland, J. (ed.) Unemployment and the Australian Labour Market, Proceedings of a conference held at the H.C. Coombs Centre for Financial Studies, Kirribilli on 9–10 JuneGoogle Scholar
Dawkins, P (1998b) ‘The economic effects of deregulation and decentralisation of wage determination’, Journal of Industrial Relations, 40, 4, DecemberCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dawkins, P., Buckingham, D. (1999) ‘Trade-off gives credit to those who just want to work’, The Australian Financial Review, Thursday June 10 1999Google Scholar
Dawkins, P., Freebairn, J. (1997) ‘Towards Full Employment’, Australian Economic Review, 30, 4: 405–17CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dawkins, P., Beer, G., Harding, A., Johnson, D., Scutella, R. (1998) ‘Towards a Negative Income Tax System for Australia’, The Australian Economic Review, 31, 3, September: 237–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dawkins, P.P., Freebairn, J., Garnaut, R., Keating, M., Richardson, C. (1998) ‘Dear John: How to Create More Jobs’, The Australian, Monday October 26Google Scholar
Debelle, G., Vickery, J. (1998) The macroeconomic of Australian unemployment’ in Debelle, G., Borland, J. (ed.) Unemployment and the Australian Labour Market, Proceedings of a conference held at the H.C. Coombs Centre for Financial Studies, Kirribilli on 9–10 JuneGoogle Scholar
Dickens, R., Machin, S., Manning, A. (1993) The Effects of Minimum Wages on Employment: Theory and Evidence From the UK,’ Discussion Paper No. 183, Centre for Economic Performance, London School of EconomicsCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Doeringer, Peter, Piore, Micahel (1971) Internal Labor Markets and Manpower Analysis, Lexington, MA: Heath Google Scholar
Dullard, J., Hayward, D. (1998) ‘The democratic paradox of public choice theory: the case of-the Costello cuts’, Journal of Australian Political Economy, No. 42, December: 16–47 Google Scholar
Elster, Jon (1989) The Cement of Society. A Study of Social order, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Esping-Andersen, G. (1990) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press Google Scholar
Esping-Andersen, G. (1999) The Social Foundations of Post-industrial Economies, Oxford University Press Press CrossRefGoogle Scholar
European Commission (1995) European Economy, Reports and Studies, No. 3, BrusselsGoogle Scholar
Ford, Michael (1992) ‘Citizenship and Democracy in Industrial Relations: The Agenda for the 1990s,’ The Modem Law Review, 55, March: 241–258 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Freeman, R (1994) ‘Minimum wages - again’, International Journal of Manpower, 15(2/3): 8–25 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Freeman, R.B. (ed) (1994) Working Under Different Rules, New York: Russell Sage Google Scholar
Gahan, P., Barbara, J. (2000) ‘An Industrial relations Perspective on the Five Economists Plan,’ Working Paper 131, School of Industrial relations and Organisational Behaviour, University of New South WalesGoogle Scholar
Gahan, P., Harcourt, T. (1998) ‘Labour Markets, Firms and Institutions: Labour Economics and Industrial Relations,’ Journal of Industrial Relations, December: 40(4), 508–532 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gahan, P., Harcourt, T. (1999) ‘Australian Labour Market Institutions, ‘Deregulation’ and the Open Economy,’ Economic and Labour Relations Review, 10(2), December: 296–318 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gahan, P.G. (1998) ‘European Unemployment: The Role of Labor Market Regulation?’ Comparative Labor Law and Policy Journal, 19(3), September, 801–818 Google Scholar
Gregg, P., Manning, A. (1997) ‘Labour Market Regulation and Unemployment,’ in Snower, Dennis J., de la Dehesa, Guillermo (eds), Unemployment Policy: Government Options for the Labour Market, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 395–432 Google Scholar
Gregory, R.G. (1996) ‘Wage deregulation, low paid workers and full employment’ in Sheehan, P., Grewal, B., Kumnick, M. (eds) Dialogue on Australia’s Future, In Honour of the Late Ronald Henderson, Centre for Strategic Economic Studies, Victoria University of Technology, Melbourne Google Scholar
Hancock, K (1999) ‘Economics, Industrial Relations and the Challenge of Unemployment,’ Keynote Address to the Association of Industrial Relations Academics of Australia and New Zealand, Adelaide, 4 FebruaryGoogle Scholar
Harley, B (1993) ‘Working Conditions Associated with Irregular Employment in Australian Industry: An Empirical Analysis and Some Policy Prescriptions’, paper presented to the National Social Policy Conference, University of New South Wales, JulyGoogle Scholar
Hausman, Daniel M. (1989) ‘Economic Methodology in a Nutshell,’ Journal of Economic Perspectives, 3(2), Spring: 115–127 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hemerijck, A.C. (1993) ‘Corporatist Immobility in the Netherlands,’ in Crouch, C., Traxler, F. (eds), Organised Industrila Relations in Europe: What Future?, Aldershot: Avebury, 183–224 Google Scholar
Hepple, B (1986) ‘Introduction,’ in Hepple, B. (ed) The making of Labour law in Europe. A Comparative Study of Nine Countries up to 1945, pp. 1–30, Mansell: London Google Scholar
Isaac, J.E. (1992) ‘Performance Related Pay: The Importance of Fairness,’ Working Paper #64, Melbourne: Centre for Industrial Relations and Labour Studies, University of MelbourneGoogle Scholar
Klass, B.S., Ullman, J.C. (1995) ‘Sticky Wages Revisited: Organizational Responses to a Declining Market-Clearing Wage,’ Academy of Management Review, 20(2): 281–310 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Knight, (1992) Institutions and Social Conflict, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Google Scholar
Lindbeck, A., Snower, D.J. (1988) The Insider-Outsider Theory of Employment and Unemployment, Cambridge MA: MIT Press Google Scholar
Machin, S (1996) ‘Wage Inequality in the UK,’ Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 12, 47–64 Google Scholar
Machin, S (1997) ‘The Decline of Labour Market Institutions and the Rise in Wage Inequality in Britain,’ European Economic Review, 41, 647–657 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Machin, S., Manning, A. (1997) ‘Minimum Wages and Economic Outcomes in Europe,’ European Economic Review, 41, 733–742 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Manning, A (1996) ‘The Equal Pay Act as an Experiment to Test Theories of the Labour Market,’ Economica, 63(250), May: 191–212 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McCallum, (1998) ‘Collective Labour Law, Citizenship and the Future’, Melbourne University Law Review, 22 Google Scholar
McFarlane Shore, L., Tetrick, L.E. (1994) ‘The Psychological Contract as an Explanatory Framework in the Employment Relation,’ in Cooper, C.L., Rousseau, D.M. (eds), Trends in Organizational Behavior, 1, New York: John Wiley, 91–109 Google Scholar
Mitchell, Andrew (1997) ‘Industrial Democracy: Reconciling Theories of the Firm and State,’ Working Paper #14, Centre for Employment and Labour Relations Law, Law Faculty, University of Melbourne, DecemberCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mitchell, D.J.B., Erickson, C.L. (1995) ‘Labour Market Regulation, Flexibility and Employment’, Labour, 9(3), Autumn: 443–62Google Scholar
Mückenberger, U., Deakin, S. (1989) ‘From Deregulation to a European Floor of Rights: Labour Law, Flexibilisation and the European Single Market,’ Zeitschrift für ausländissches und internationales Arbeits- und Sozialrecht (ZAIS), 3:153–97Google Scholar
Nevile, J.W. (1996), ‘Minimum wages, equity and unemployment’, The Economic and Labour Relations Review, 7, 2, December: 198–212 Google Scholar
NLCC (1987), ‘Labour market flexibility in the Australian setting’, National labour Consultative Council, Canberra Google Scholar
North, D.C. (1991) ‘Institutions and a Transaction Theory of Exchange,’ in Alt, J.E., Sheple, K.A. (eds), Perspectives on Positive Political Economy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 182–194 Google Scholar
OECD (1986), Labour Market Flexibility: Report by a High-level Group of Experts to the Secretary-General (Dahrendorf Report), Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris Google Scholar
OECD (1996), Employment Outlook, Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris, JulyGoogle Scholar
OECD (1997), Employment Outlook, Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris, JulyGoogle Scholar
OECD (1998), Employment Outlook, Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris, JulyGoogle Scholar
OECD (1999), Employment Outlook, Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris, JulyGoogle Scholar
Peetz, D (1998) ‘The Safety Net, Bargaining and the Role of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission’, The Journal of Industrial Relations, 40, 4, December: 533–553 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pontusson, J., Swenson, Peter (1996) ‘Labour Markets, Production Strategies and Wage Bargaining Institutions,’ Comparative Political Studies, 29, 223–250 Google Scholar
Rebitzer, J.A. (1993) ‘Radical Political Economy and the Economics of Labor Markets,’ Journal of Economic Literature, 31(3), September: 1394–1434 Google Scholar
Reith, P (1998) ‘Reith cool on pay-tax trade-off to create jobs’, The Australian Financial Review, Friday, April 30Google Scholar
Rhodes, M (1998) ‘Globalization, Labour Markets and Welfare States: A Future of Competitive Corporatism,’ in Rhodes, M., Mény, Y (eds), The Future of European Welfare: A New Social Contract? London: Macmillan Google Scholar
Richardson, S (1998) ‘Who gets minimum wages?’ Journal of Industrial Relations, 40, 4, DecemberGoogle Scholar
Richardson, S., Harding, A. (1998), ‘Low wages and the distribution of family income in Australia,’ Paper given to the 25th General Conference of the International Association for Research in Income and WealthGoogle Scholar
Robinson, James (1996) The Political Economy of Labor Market reform,’ Unpublished paper, Department of Economics, University of Southern California, Los AngelesGoogle Scholar
Romeyn, J (1992) Flexible Working Time: Part-time and Casual Employment, Industrial Relations Research Monograph No.1, Canberra, Department of Industrial Relations, AGPS Google Scholar
Rubery, J (1997) ‘Wages and the Labour Market’, British Journal of Industrial Relations, 35, 3, September: 337–362 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rubery, J 1995. ‘Internal Labour Markets & Equal Opportunities: Women’s Position in Banks in Europe,’ European Journal of Industrial Relations, vol. 1(2): 203–227 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rubery, Jill, Wilkinson, Frank 1994. Employer Strategy and the Labour Market, Oxford: Oxford University Press Google Scholar
Solow, R. (1990) The Labour Market as a Social Institution, Basil Blackwell, Oxford Google Scholar
Soskice, D.W. (1990) ‘Wage Determination: the Changing Role of Institutions in Advanced Industrialized Countries,’ Oxford Review of Economic Policy, Winter, pp. 36–61 Google Scholar
Thompson, , McHugh, (1995) Work Organisations: A Critical Introduction, second edition, London: Macmillan CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tsebelis, G (1991) Nested Games. Rational Choice in Comparative Politics, University of California Press, Berkeley Google Scholar
Van Peijpe, T. (1998) Employment Protection Under Strain (Sweden, Denmark and the Netherlands), Bulletin of Comparative Labour Relations 33-1998, Kluwer Law International, London Google Scholar
Visser, Jelle (1998) ‘Two Cheers for Corporatism, One for the Market: Industrial Relations, Wage Moderation and Job Growth in the Netherlands’, British journal of Industrial Relations, 36(2), June: 269–292 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wallis, P.L. (1992) ‘The Protection of Job Security. The Case for Property Rights in One’s Job,’ Otago Law Review, 7, 640–662 Google Scholar
Withers, G., Pitman, D., Whittingham, B. (1986) ‘Wage adjustments and labour market systems: A cross-country analysis’, Economic Record, 62, 179:415–26Google Scholar
Yellen, J.L. (1984) ‘Efficiency Wage Theory,’ American Economic Review (Papers & Proceedings), 74(2), May: 200–204 Google Scholar
Zeytinoglu, I.U. (2000) ‘Gender, Race and Class Dimensions of Non-standard Work,’ Relations industrielies/lndustrial Relations, 55(1): 133165Google Scholar