Hostname: page-component-f554764f5-8cg97 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-04-22T13:32:05.579Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Employer theft of temporary migrant workers’ wages in Australia: Why has the state failed to act?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2023

Stephen Clibborn  and
Chris F Wright
Stephen Clibborn*
Affiliation:
The University of Sydney, Australia
Chris F Wright
Affiliation:
The University of Sydney, Australia
*
Stephen Clibborn, Discipline of Work and Organisational Studies, The University of Sydney Business School, The University of Sydney, Abercrombie Building (H70), Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Wage theft has emerged as a major problem for regulation of work in Australia. Yet, the state has done little to address the issue. In this context, this article considers why there has been recent growth in reported cases of underpayment of wages, particularly of temporary migrant workers, and why the state has failed to implement a strategy to adequately address this problem. The article examines the fragmented nature of employment regulation and visa categories constraining worker agency which, combined with widening avenues for temporary migration, have contributed to the underpayment problem. We also consider how conflicting imperatives of the state, business influence over the policy process and weak political incentives to address underpayment help to account for the state’s inaction.

Keywords

J58J61J81Enforcement of standardslow-paid workersmigrant workersregulationvulnerable workers
Type
Symposium Articles
Information
The Economic and Labour Relations Review , Volume 29 , Issue 2: Symposium: Wage Theft and Minimum Labour Standards Enforcement Part 2 , June 2018 , pp. 207 - 227
Copyright
© The Author(s) 2018

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd (2017) Wage repayment program. Available at: http://www.wagerepaymentprogram.com.au (accessed 21 November 2017).Google Scholar
Anderson, B (2010) Migration, immigration controls and the fashioning of precarious workers. Work, Employment & Society 24(2): 300–317.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) (2015a) 7-Eleven: the price of convenience. Four Corners, 31 August. Available at: http://www.abc.net.au/4corners/7-eleven-promo/6729716 (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) (2015b) Slaving away. Four Corners, 4 May. Available at: http://www.abc.net.au/4corners/slaving-away-promo/6437876 (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2016a) Characteristics of employment. Cat no. 6333.0, August. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Australian Bureau of Statistics.Google Scholar
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2016b) Employee earnings and hours. Cat no. 6306.0, May. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Australian Bureau of Statistics.Google Scholar
Australian Government (2017) Budget paper number 1 2017-18, budget strategy and outlook, statement 6: expenses and net capital investment, 9 May. Available at: http://www.budget.gov.au/2017-18/content/bp1/html/ (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Australian Government (n.d.) Evidence of Payment for Specified Work or Specified Subclass 462 Work. Department of Home Affairs. Available at: https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/Trav/Work/evidence-payment (accessed 4 January 2018).Google Scholar
Bagshaw, E (2016) 80 per cent of international students in restaurants paid below minimum wage, survey finds. Sydney Morning Herald. 21 April. Available at: https://www.smh.com.au/education/80-per-cent-of-international-students-in-restaurants-paid-below-minimum-wage-survey-finds-20160421-gobkzh.html (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Barry, M, You, K (2017) Employer and employer association matters in Australia in 2016. Journal of Industrial Relations 59(3): 288–304.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bauder, H (2006) Labor Movement: How Migration Regulates Labor Markets. Oxford, NY: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Befort, SF, Budd, JW (2009) Invisible Hands, Invisible Objectives: Bringing Workplace Law and Public Policy into Focus. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Berg, L, Farbenblum, B (2017) Wage Theft in Australia: Findings of the National Temporary Migrant Work Survey. Sydney, NSW, Australia: UNSW Law and UTS.Google Scholar
Boswell, C (2007) Theorizing migration policy: is there a third way? International Migration Review 41(1): 75–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boucher, A (2016) Australia’s de facto low skilled labour migration programs. In: Centre for Economic Development of Australia (ed.) Migration: The Economic Debate. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Centre for Economic Development of Australia, pp. 43–54.Google Scholar
Bowden, B (2011) The rise and decline of Australian unionism: a history of industrial labour from the 1820s to 2010. Labour History 100: 51–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bray, M, Underhill, E (2009) Industry differences in the neoliberal transformation of Australian industrial relations. Industrial Relations Journal 40(5): 372–392.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bray, M, Waring, P (2005) ‘Complexity’ and ‘congruence’ in Australian labour regulation. Journal of Industrial Relations 47(1): 1–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bray, M, Waring, P, Cooper, R, et al . (2014) Employment Relations: Theory and Practice. Sydney, NSW, Australia: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
Brown, W, Deakin, S, Nash, D, et al . (2000) The employment contract: from collective procedures to individual rights. British Journal of Industrial Relations 38(4): 611–629.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Buchanan, J, Callus, R (1993) Efficiency and equity at work: the need for labour market regulation in Australia. Journal of Industrial Relations 35(4): 515–537.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cameron, SM, McAllister, I (2016) Trends in Australian Political Opinion: Results from the Australian Electoral Study 1987–2016. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Australian National University.Google Scholar
Campbell, I, Boese, M, Tham, JC (2016) Inhospitable workplaces? International students and paid work in food services. Australian Journal of Social Issues 51(3): 279–298.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cash, M (2015) Strengthening integrity in working holiday visa programme. Media release, Assistant Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, 1 May, Canberra, ACT, Australia. Available at: http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query%3DId%3A%22media%2Fpressrel%2F3804276%22 (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Castles, F (1988) Australian Public Policy and Economic Vulnerability. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Allen & Unwin.Google Scholar
Clibborn, S (2015) Why undocumented immigrant workers should have workplace rights. The Economic and Labour Relations Review 26(3): 465–473.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clibborn, S (2016) Multiple frames of reference: why international students in Australia are underpaid. In: Comparative and international perspectives on Australian labour migration workshop, University of Melbourne Law School, Melbourne, VIC, Australia, 22 July.Google Scholar
Clibborn, S (in press) Multiple frames of reference: why international student workers in Australia tolerate underpayment. Economic and Industrial Democracy. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0143831X18765247.Google Scholar
Collins, J (2013) Rethinking Australian immigration and immigrant settlement policy. Journal of Intercultural Studies 34(2): 160–177.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Colvin, A, Darbishire, O (2013) Convergence in industrial relations institutions: the emerging Anglo-American model? ILR Review 66(5): 1047–1077.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Commonwealth Parliament (2005) Migration Regulation Amendments 2005 (No. 9) Regulatory Impact Statement: Changes to the Migration Regulations – Proposals to Expand the Working Holiday Makers Program (Supplementary material). Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.Google Scholar
Cooney, S, Howe, J, Murray, J (2006) Time and money under workchoices: understanding the new workplace relations act as a scheme of regulation. UNSW Law Journal 29(1): 215–241.Google Scholar
Cooper, R (2010) The ‘new’ industrial relations and international economic crisis: Australia in 2009. Journal of Industrial Relations 52(3): 261–274.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cooper, R, Ellem, B (2008) The neoliberal state, trade unions and collective bargaining in Australia. British Journal of Industrial Relations 46(3): 532–554.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Culpepper, P (2011) Quiet Politics and Business Power. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Deegan, B (2008) Visa subclass 457 integrity review: final report, October. Available at: https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/WorkinginAustralia/Documents/457-integrity-review.pdf (accessed 2 January 2018).Google Scholar
Donaghey, J, Reinecke, J, Niforou, C, et al . (2014) From employment relations to consumption relations: balancing labor governance in global supply chains. Human Resource Management 53(2): 229–252.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ewing, KD (2005) The function of trade unions. Industrial Law Journal 34(1): 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fair Work Ombudsman (2016) Entity Resources and Planned Performance, 3 May, Department of Employment. Available at: https://docs.jobs.gov.au/system/files/doc/other/pbs_2016-17_-_fwo.pdf (accessed 3 January 2017).Google Scholar
Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) (n.d.) Our role. Available at: https://www.fairwork.gov.au/about-us/our-role (accessed 7 September 2017).Google Scholar
Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) and Registered Organisations Commission (ROC) Entity (2017a) Annual report 2016–17. Available at: https://www.fairwork.gov.au/annual-reports/annual-report-2016-17 (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) and Registered Organisations Commission (ROC) (2017b) Entity resources and planned performance, 9 May. Available at: https://docs.jobs.gov.au/system/files/doc/other/2017-18_employmentpbs_fwoandroc.pdf (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Ferguson, A (2017) Bruce Billson warns Joe Hockey about potential US concerns for Turnbull’s new franchise laws. Australian Financial Review, 10 July. Available at: http://www.afr.com/business/bruce-billson-warns-joe-hockey-about-potential-us-concerns-for-turnbulls-new-franchise-laws-20170709-gx7n0c (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Forsyth, A (2016) Victorian Inquiry into the Labour Hire Industry and Insecure Work: Final Report. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Department of Economic Development, Jobs, Transport and Resources.Google Scholar
Freeman, GP (1995) Modes of immigration politics in liberal democratic states. International Migration Review 29(4): 881–902.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Fudge, J (2014) Making claims for migrant workers: human rights and citizenship. Citizenship Studies 18(1): 29–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gallie, D (2007) Employment Regimes and the Quality of Work. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gartrell, A (2017) Bruce Billson spearheads campaign to water down worker exploitation bill. Sydney Morning Herald, 7 April. Available at: https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/bruce-billson-spearheads-campaign-to-water-down-worker-exploitation-bill-20170404-gvdaiv.html (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Gautié, J, Schmitt, J (2010) Low-Wage Work in the Wealthy World. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
Givens, T, Luedtke, A (2005) European immigration policies in comparative perspective: issue salience, partisanship and immigrant rights. Comparative European Politics 3(1): 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goodwin, M, Maconachie, G (2007) Unpaid entitlement recovery in the federal industrial relations system: strategy and outcomes 1952–95. Journal of Industrial Relations 49(4): 523–544.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gunderson, M (2013) Changes in the labour market and the nature of employment in Western countries. In: Stone, KVW, Arthurs, H (eds) Rethinking Workplace Regulation: Beyond the Standard Contract of Employment. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, pp. 23–41.Google Scholar
Hardy, T (2011) Enrolling non-state actors to improve compliance with minimum employment standards. The Economic and Labour Relations Review 22(3): 117–140.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hardy, T, Howe, J (2009) Partners in enforcement? The new balance between government and trade union enforcement of employment standards in Australia. Australian Journal of Labour Law 22(3): 306–336.Google Scholar
Hardy, T, Howe, J (2015) Chain reaction: a strategic approach to addressing employment noncompliance in complex supply chains. Journal of Industrial Relations 57(4): 563–584.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Heery, E (1993) Industrial relations and the customer. Industrial Relations Journal 24(4): 284–295.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Holgate, J (2005) Organizing migrant workers: a case study of working conditions and unionization in a London sandwich factory. Work, Employment & Society 19(3): 463–480.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Howe, J (2013) Is the net cast too wide? An assessment of whether the regulatory design of the 457 Visa meets Australia’s skill needs. Federal Law Review 41(3): 443–470.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Howe, J, Owens, R (2016) Temporary Labour Migration in the Global Era: The Regulatory Challenges. Oxford: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
Howe, J, Reilly, A, van den Broek, D, et al . (2017) Sustainable Solutions: The Future of Labour Supply in the Australian Vegetable Industry. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Horticulture Innovation Australia.Google Scholar
Howell, C (2005) Trade Unions and the State: Constructing Industrial Relations Institutions in Britain, 1890–2000. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Johnstone, R, McCrystal, S, Nossar, I, et al . (2012) Beyond Employment: The Legal Regulation of Work Relationships. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Federation Press.Google Scholar
Knox, A, Warhurst, C, Nickson, D, et al . (2015) More than a feeling: using hotel room attendants to improve understanding of job quality. International Journal of Human Resource Management 26(12): 1547–1567.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laurie, V (2006) Free trade in cheap labour. The Australian, 11 March, p. 24.Google Scholar
Lever-Tracy, C, Quinlan, M (1988) A Divided Working Class: Ethnic Segmentation and Industrial Conflict in Australia. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.Google Scholar
Liberal Party and National Party Coalition (2016) The coalition’s policy to protect vulnerable workers. Available at: https://cdn.liberal.org.au/pdf/policy/2016%20Coalition%20Election%20Policy%20-%20Protecting%20Vulnerable%20Workers.pdf (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Maconachie, G, Goodwin, M (2010) Employer evasion of workers’ entitlements 1986–1995: why, what and whose? Journal of Industrial Relations 52(4): 419–437.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maconachie, G, Goodwin, M (2011) Does institutional location protect from political influence? The case of a minimum labour standards enforcement agency in Australia. Australian Journal of Political Science 46(1): 105–119.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Markus, A, Jupp, J, McDonald, P (2009) Australia’s Immigration Revolution. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Allen & Unwin.Google Scholar
Maurice Blackburn (2017) Submission to the senate education and employment legislation committee’s inquiry into the fair work amendment (Protecting vulnerable workers) bill 2017. Submission 024, April. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Maurice Blackburn Lawyers.Google Scholar
Nyland, C, Forbes-Mewett, H, Marginson, S, et al . (2009) International student-workers in Australia: a new vulnerable workforce. Journal of Education and Work 22(1): 1–14.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Patty, A (2016) The great student swindle. Sydney Morning Herald, 10 December. Available at: https://www.smh.com.au/interactive/2016/great-student-swindle/ (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Patty, A (2017) Are the 457 Visa reforms an illusion act? Sydney Morning Herald, 22 April. Available at: https://www.smh.com.au/business/careers/are-the-457-visa-reforms-an-illusion-act-20170420-gvokqk.html (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Piore, M (1979) Birds of Passage: Migrant Labor and Industrial Societies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Productivity Commission (2015) Workplace relations framework: Productivity commission inquiry report. No. 76, volume 2, 30 November. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.Google Scholar
Quinlan, M, Sheldon, P (2011) The enforcement of minimum labour standards in an era of neo-liberal globalisation: an overview. The Economic and Labour Relations Review 22(2): 5–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ram, M, Edwards, P, Meardi, G, et al . (2017) Non-Compliance and the National Living Wage: Case Study Evidence from Ethnic Minority and Migrant-Owned Businesses. London: Low Pay Commission.Google Scholar
Reilly, A (2015) Low-cost labour or cultural exchange? Reforming the working holiday visa programme. The Economic and Labour Relations Review 26(3): 474–489.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reilly, A, Howe, J, Berg, L, et al . (2017) International Students and the Fair Work Ombudsman. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Fair Work Ombudsman.Google Scholar
Robertson, S (2014) Time and temporary migration: the case of temporary graduate workers and working holiday makers in Australia. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 40(12): 1915–1933.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ruhs, M (2013) The Price of Rights: Regulating International Labor Migration. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Schneiders, B (2017) Migrant farm workers take on one of Australia’s richest families, the Smorgons. Sydney Morning Herald, 29 July. Available at: https://www.smh.com.au/business/careers/migrant-farm-workers-take-on-one-of-australias-richest-families-the-smorgons-20170729-gxla75.html (accessed 27 February 2018).Google Scholar
Senate (2016) A National Disgrace: The Exploitation of Temporary Work Visa Holders (Senate education and employment references committee). Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.Google Scholar
Senate (2017) Corporate Avoidance of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Senate education and employment references committee). Canberra, ACT, Australia: Commonwealth of Australia.Google Scholar
Sheldon, P, Thornthwaite, L (1999) Employer Associations and Industrial Relations Change: Catalysts or Captives? Sydney, NSW, Australia: Allen & Unwin.Google Scholar
Tham, J-C, Campbell, I, Boese, M (2016) Why is labour protection for temporary migrant workers so fraught? In: Howe, J, Owens, R (eds) Temporary Labour Migration: The Regulatory Challenges. Oxford: Hart Publishing, pp. 173–200.Google Scholar
Underhill, E, Rimmer, M (2016) Layered vulnerability: temporary migrants in Australian horticulture. Journal of Industrial Relations 58(5): 608–626.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Waldinger, R, Lichter, M (2003) How the Other Half Works: Immigration and the Social Organization of Labor. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Weil, D (2014) The Fissured Workplace. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Weil, D (2018) Creating a strategic enforcement approach to address wage theft: One academic’s journey in organizational change. Journal of Industrial Relations 60(3). DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0022185618765551.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wright, CF (2014) How do states implement liberal immigration policies? Control signals and skilled immigration reform in Australia. Governance 27(3): 397–421.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wright, CF (2015) Why do states adopt liberal immigration policies? The policymaking dynamics of skilled visa reform in Australia. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 41(2): 306–328.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wright, CF (2017) Employer organizations and labour immigration policy in Australia and the United Kingdom: the power of political salience and social institutional legacies. British Journal of Industrial Relations 55(2): 347–371.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wright, CF, Clibborn, S (2017) Back door, side door or front door? An emerging de-facto low-skilled immigration policy in Australia. Comparative Labor Law and Policy Journal 39(1): 165–188.Google Scholar
Wright, CF, Clibborn, S, Piper, N, et al . (2016) Economic Migration and Australia in the 21st Century. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Lowy Institute for International Policy.Google Scholar
Wright, CF, Groutsis, D, van den Broek, D (2017) Employer-sponsored temporary labour migration schemes in Australia, Canada and Sweden: enhancing efficiency, compromising fairness? Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 43(11): 1854–1872.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zou, M (2015) The legal construction of hyper-dependence and hyper-precarity in migrant work relations. International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations 31(2): 141–162.CrossRefGoogle Scholar