Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T15:20:47.327Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Third Reduction Of Giuseppe Piazzi's Star Catalogue

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 August 2017

E. Proverbio
E. Proverbio*
Affiliation:
Astronomical Observatory - Cagliari, Italy

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

The star observations carried out by Giuseppe Piazzi with Ramsden's large altazimuth circle, which he began in 1792, led to the realization of a 1st and 2nd Catalogue, published by Piazzi in Palermo in 1803 and 1814.

During 1845, the original astronomical observations in Piazzi's catalogue, included in “La storia celeste of the Palermo Observatory from 1792 to 1814”, which had been kept at the Brera Observatory in Milan, were published in Vienna.

The publication of these observational data revealed a series of errors, real or presumed, which cast doubt on the reliability of the Palermo Catalogue.

Towards the end of the last century, upon the suggestion of Giovanni Schiaparelli, work on the reduction of Piazzi's catalogue was once again taken up for the purpose of producing an independent catalogue based on the original observations. This work, carried out by Francesco Porro, led to the production of a corrected catalogue purged of systematic and accidental errors.

The third fundamental star catalogue of Palermo may represent the basis for the final reduction of the great Palermo Catalogue of 7646 stars.

Type
Part I: Historical Research
Information
Symposium - International Astronomical Union , Volume 133: Mapping the Sky: Past Heritage and Future Directions , 1988 , pp. 75 - 86
Copyright
Copyright © Kluwer 1988 

References

Bibliographical Notes

1. Giuseppe Piazzi was born in July of 1746 at Ponte in the Valtellina district, which at that time belonged to the Helvetic Confederation. He attended the Theatine schools and became a member of the Order, which he later abandoned in order to follow his vocation for the exact sciences. He was a professor of mathematics in Malta and Rome. In 1780 he was appointed Professor of Mathematics at the University of Palermo and subsequently became the director of the Palermo Observatory (cf., Scrofani, S., “Elogio di Giuseppe Piazzi”, Giornale di Scienze Lettere ed Arte per la Sicilia, Tomo XVII, ANNO V, 1827).Google Scholar
2. King, H.C., “The History of the Telescope”, New York, 1979, 148–69.Google Scholar
3. A detailed description of the instruments is given by Piazzi in the volume “Della Specola Astronomica de' Regi studi di Palermo, Libro IV”, Palermo, 1792.Google Scholar
4. Piazzi, G., “Della Specola Astronomica, Libro V”, Palermo, 1794, 198–208.Google Scholar
5. Piazzi, G., “Precipuarum Stellarum Inerrantium, etc.”, Panormi, 1803.Google Scholar
6. Maskelyne, Nevil, “Astronomical Observations Made at the R. Observatory at Greenwich in the Years 1765–69”, London, 1774.Google Scholar
7. Piazzi, G., “Del R. Osservatorio di Palermo, Libro VI”, Palermo, 1806.Google Scholar
8. Piazzi, G., “Precipuarum Stellarum Inerrantium Positiones Mediae ineunte seculo XIX, etc.”, Panormi, 1814.Google Scholar
9. Grant, Robert, in his “History of Physical Astronomy”, London (1832) on referring to Piazzi's second catalogue, states: “this great work is justly considered to be one of the most important that has ever been executed by a single individual”.Google Scholar
10. The letter is a part of the copious correspondence between Giuseppe Piazzi and Barnaba Oriani edited by Schiaparelli, G. and Cacciatore, G. (cf., “Corrispondenza astronomica fra Giuseppe Piazzi e Barnaba Oriani”, Milano, 1875).Google Scholar
11. In a letter to Oriani dated 10 August 1814, Piazzi informs his friend that “In Napoli si pensa di intraprendere la stampa di tutte le mie osservazioni”. But since these hopes were never realized Piazzi decided (letter dated 26 May 1815) to ask his friend to “vedere, se l'Istituto o qualche librajo di costì volesse incaricarsi di pubblicarla”, (cf. “Corrispondenza astronomica” between Piazzi and Oriani, cit., 106–122).Google Scholar
12. “Eccovi la prima parte della Storia di questo Osservatorio”, (letter from Piazzi to Oriani, 28 May 1816, in “Corrispondenza astronomica”, cit., 133).Google Scholar
13. “Eccovi in 89 fogli la continuazione delle osservazioni fino al 1813, termine della mia esistenza astronomica, e dei lavori sui quali sono fondati i due Cataloghi e le altre mie bagatelle”. (letter from Piazzi to Oriani, 21 July 1817, in “Corrispondenza astronomica”, cit. 151).Google Scholar
14. Right up to the end Piazzi hoped that his observations would be published by Oriani at the Istituto Cesareo in Milan. It appears that the main obstacles to publication were administrative (see Oriani's letter to Piazzi dated 10 September 1821, in “Corrispondenza astronomica”, cit. 185).Google Scholar
15. Letters from Piazzi to Oriani, 25 August and 3 December 1821 (cf. “Corrispondenza astronomica”, cit., 183–84, 185–86).Google Scholar
16. “Lascio pure alla stessa specola la copia manoscritta delle osservazioni fatte a Palermo dall'astronomo Giuseppe Piazzi risposte in una scatola di latta” (cf. Testamento di Barnaba Oriani of 2 May 1832, at the Archivio dell'Osservatorio di Brera).Google Scholar
17. Visconti, F., “Breve Compendio delle opere astronomiche etc.”, Atti R. Accademia delle Scienze, Napoli, 1832, 72–76.Google Scholar
18. “Storia Celeste del R. Osservatorio di Palermo dal 1792 al 1813”, in Annalen der K. K. Sternwarte in Wien, Vols. IV-XII, 1845–1849.Google Scholar
19. See the Introduction by Littrow, C. L. (Vols. IV, V) of the “Annalen”, cit. in 18.Google Scholar
20. Argelander's first catalogue based on observations carried out at Abo were published in 1895 (cf., “DLX Stellarum Fixarum Positiones Mediae ineunte anno 1830, etc. adjecit Mag. Fredr. Giul. Aug. Argelander”, Helsingfors, 1835.Google Scholar
21. Struve, F.G.W., “Stellarum fixarum imprimis duplicium et multiplicium Positiones Mediae pro Epoca 1830.0, etc.”, Petropoli, 1852.Google Scholar
22. Auwers, A., “Reduction der Beobachtungen der Fundamentalsterne am Passageinstrument der Sternwarte zu Palermo in den Jahren 1803 bis 1805, etc.”, Leipzig, 1866.Google Scholar
23. Schiaparelli, G., “Idea e piano delle operazioni da intraprendere per una nuova discussione delle osservazioni fatte a Palermo allo istrumento dei passaggi sulle stelle fondamentali del Catalogo di Piazzi, etc.”, 1896, in: Porro, Fr., fondamenti delle riduzioni per un nuovo Catalogo di stelle dedotte dalle osservazioni di Giuseppe Piazzi a Palermo, Rome, 1933.Google Scholar
24. Francesco Porro was born in Cremona in 1861. In 1882 he was a student astronomer at the Brera Observatory in Milan. In December 1885 he was appointed astronomer at the Turin Observatory and was put in charge of the astronomy course at the University of Turin. He became professor of astronomy and director of the Turin Observatory in 1896. In 1901 he transferred to the University of Genoa. In 1906, upon the recommendation of Schiaparelli, G., he was appointed director of the La Plata Astronomical Observatory in Argentina. He returned to Italy in 1910 and once again occupied his chair at the University of Genoa. He died in Genoa in 1937.Google Scholar
25. The quotation is given in: Porro, Fr., op. cit., 28. See Note 31.Google Scholar
26. Cf., letter from Struve to Porro dated 11 January 1900, in Fr. Porro, op. cit., 27.Google Scholar
27.Cf., letter from Schiaparelli, G. to Fr. Porro of 8 November 1895, in Porro, Fr., op. cit., 34. Schiaparelli must have already calculated the Besselian constants necessary for the reduction of Piazzi's catalogue (see G. Schiaparelli, “Costanti generali besseliane calcolate di sei in sei ore per il periodo compreso tra il 31 luglio 1803 e il 2 novembre 1805”, in Fr. Porro, op. cit., 155–276.Google Scholar
28. Cf., letter from Lewis Boss to Fr. Porro dated 14 April 1899, in Porro, Fr., op. cit., 36.Google Scholar
29. Cf., letter from Schiaparelli, G. to Fr. Porro dated 20 February 1893, in Porro, Fr., op. cit., 24.Google Scholar
30. Cf., letter from Schiaparelli to Porro quoted in Note 35, 29 and 33. For Bradley's new catalogue see: Auwers, A., “Neue Reduction der Bradley'schen Beobachtungen aus den Jahren 1750-bis 1762”, St. Petersburg, Erster Band, 1903, Zweiter Band, 1882, Dritter Band, 1838.Google Scholar
31. Cf., letter from A. Auwers to Fr. Porro dated 17 June 1888, in Porro, Fr., op. cit., 29.Google Scholar
32. Cf., letter from A. Auwers to Fr. Porro dated 2 December 1895, in Porro, Fr., op. cit., 31. For Mayer's catalogue, see: Auwers, A., “Tobias Mayer's Sternverzeichniss nach den Beobachtungen auf der Göttinger Sternwarte in den Jahren 1756 bis 1760”, Leipzig, 1894.Google Scholar
33. Cf., letter from Schiaparelli to Fr. Porro dated 7 February 1896, in Porro, Fr., op. cit., 24.Google Scholar
34. Cf., letter quoted in Note 28, 37–38.Google Scholar
35. Schiaparelli, G., op. cit., in Note 23.Google Scholar
36. Of the correspondence between Francesco Porro and Giovanni Schiaparelli, Arthur Auwers, Lewis Boss and Ludwig Struve on the subject of revising Piazzi's and Cacciatore's observations, only the excerpts quoted in this work and published by Porro remain. Despite this author's patient research in the archives, the original letters have not been found.Google Scholar
37. This line of uncertainty seems to be borne out by the executive plan that Porro set up, presumably at the end of 1895. (Cf., Porro, Fr., op. cit., 34).Google Scholar
38. Cf., Porro, Fr., op. cit., 35.Google Scholar
39. Ibid., 36.Google Scholar
40. Porro, F., “Fondamenti delle riduzioni per un nuovo catalogo di stelle dedotto dalle osservazioni di Giuseppe Piazzi”, Torino, 1911.Google Scholar
41. Porro, F., “Ueber den gegenwärtigen Stand der Berechnungen, welche in Turin und New York behufs einer neuen Reduction der Piazzischen Beobachtungen, etc.”, Vierteljahrsschrift der Astronomischen Gesellschaft, 33, 1898.Google Scholar
42. Porro, F., op. cit. in Note 31.Google Scholar
43. Annuario, R. Accademia d'Italia, Vol II, 1929–30, 394.Google Scholar
44. Annuario, R. Accademia d'Italia, Vol III, 1930–31, 192, 210.Google Scholar
45. Annuario R. Accademia d'Italia, Vol IV, 1931–32, 270, 291.Google Scholar
46. Cf., Porro, Fr., op. cit. in Note 31, 47.Google Scholar
47. Ibid., 29–30.Google Scholar