Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-03T01:28:46.218Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Religion and the doctrine of nationalism in England at the time of the French revolution and Napoleonic wars

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

William Stafford
William Stafford*
Affiliation:
Huddersfield Polytechnic
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The Maxim my country right or wrong is unquestionably difficult and perhaps impossible to justify; certainly no Christian can easily regard the nation as the supreme object of loyalty. Yet during the revolutionary and Napoleonic wars intensive efforts were made in press and pulpit, through the courts and through informal social pressure, to enhance patriotism. Patriotism almost certainly became stronger and more widely diffused. How did the denominations respond to this dilemma? My aim is to suggest some links between denominational affiliation and attitudes to nationalism. The topic is an important one; at this time religion usually set the terms of the debate about loyalty.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 18: Religion and National Identity , 1982 , pp. 381 - 395
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1982

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Emsley, C., British Society and the French Wars 1793-1815 (London 1979) pp 67 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 113, 115. But acute social and religious tensions prevented patriotic unanimity.

2 Especially Unitarians, but radically minded rationalists could be found in other branches of old dissent.

3 Lincoln, A. H., Some Political and Social Ideas of English Dissent (Cambridge 1938) p 20 Google Scholar. Watts, M. R., The Dissenters: from the Reformation to the French Revolution (Oxford 1978) p 479 Google Scholar.

4 [Richard], Price, [A Discourse on the Love of our Country, delivered on November 4, 1789 at the meeting-house in the Old Jewry, to the Society for commemorating the Revolution in Great Britain] (4 ed London 1790) pp 2–11 Google Scholar.

5 Ibid p 6.

6 This is argued at length in my article, ‘Dissenting religion translated into politics: Godwin’s Political Justice’, History of Political Thought 1 no 2 (1980) pp 279-99.

7 William, Godwin, Enquiry Concerning Political Justice, ed Kramnick, I. (London 1976: reprint of 3 ed 1798) pp 508-9Google Scholar.

8 Ibid pp 169-171.

9 Price p 46.

10 Price like Godwin abandoned the Calvinism of his youth but remained greatly influenced by it. Thomas, D. O., The Honest Mind: The Thought and Work of Richard Price (Oxford 1977) p 6 Google Scholar.

11 An influential statement was Jonathan, Edwards, ‘The Nature of True Virtue’, Two Dissertations, 1. Concerning the end for which God created the World 2. The Nature of True Virtue (Boston 1765)Google Scholar.

12 Newton, [J.], ‘On the comforts and snares of social and relative affections’, [The Works of the Rev. John Newton, late rector of the united parishes of St. Mary Woolnoth, and St. Mary Woolchurch Haw, London], ed Cecil, R., 6 vols (3 ed London 1824) 6 p 481 Google Scholar.

13 Ward, W. R., Religion and Society in England 1790-1810 (London 1972) pp 52 Google Scholar, 56.

14 Ibid p 25.

15 [William] Enfield, [‘Enquirer’ Monthly Magazine (May 1796)] pp 274-277.

16 [Robert], Hall, [Modern infidelity considered with respect to its influence on society: in a sermon preached at the baptist meeting, Cambridge] (2 ed Cambridge 1800) pp 51-7Google Scholar.

17 [Samuel Taylor], Coleridge, Lectures 1795 [on Politics and Religion], ed Patton, L. and Mann, P. (London 1971) pp 46 Google Scholar, 162-5, 351-3.

18 The debate between Godwin and his critics is discussed and the influence of Hartley demonstrated by Patton and Mann in Coleridge Lectures 1795 pp ixix-ixxi.

19 Samuel, Parr, A Spital sermon, preached at Christ Church upon Easter Tuesday, April 15, 1800 (London 1801) pp 2–12, 44nGoogle Scholar.

20 Hall p 51.

21 Coleridge, Lectures 1795 p 163.

22 Enfield p 275.

23 Hall p 55.

24 Edward, Parsons, The true patriot. A sermon, preached at Salem-Chapel, Leeds, on the fast-day, Wednesday, February 8, 180g (Leeds 1809) p 34 Google Scholar; see also pp 36-7.

25 Ibid pp 16-17.

26 Ibid p 27.

27 Ibid p 31.

28 The argument of Pinson, K. S., Pietism as a Factor in the Rise of German Nationalism (New York 1934)Google Scholar.

29 Armstrong, A., The Church of England, the Methodists and Society, 1700-1850 (London 1973) pp 87 Google Scholar, 151-2. For evangelicalism in particular, see Kiernan, [V.G.], [‘Evangelicalism and the French revolution’ PP 1] pp 44–56 Google Scholar.

30 William, Wiberforce, A practical view of the prevailing religious system of professed Christians in the higher and middle classes in this country, contrasted with real Christianity (London 1797) p 398 Google Scholar.

31 Ibid p 489.

32 [‘Motives to] humiliation and praise. [A sermon preaced in the parish church of St. Mary Woolnoth, on December 9, 1797, the day of general thanksgiving to Almighty God for our late naval victories’), Newton 5 p 297.

33 Ibid p 280.

34 ‘The imminent danger and the only sure resource of this nation. A sermon preached in the parish church of St. Mary Woolnoth on Friday February 28 1794, the day appointed for a general fast’, Newton 5 p 263.

35 Newton, ‘Humiliation and praise’ p 292.

36 Ibid pp 297-8.

37 [Henry], Moore, [Fear God: honour the King. A discourse on MATT. xxii. 21. preached in the methodist chapel, Bath, on Sunday January 19, 1794] (London 1794) p 12 Google Scholar.

38 [Thomas], Wood, [Essays on civil government and subjection and obedience to the higher powers] (Wigan 1796) p 42 Google Scholar.

39 Ibid p 49.

40 Ibid p 9.

41 Moore pp 12, 19-21.

42 Wood pp 17, 51-72.

43 This is argued in Kiernan.

44 [John], Bowles, [A] view [of the moral state of society at the close of the eighteenth century. Much enlarged, and continued to the commencement on the year 1804] (London 1804) pp 10 Google Scholar, 44.

45 [Edmund], Burke, ‘Speeches on the impeachment of Warren Hastings’, [The Works of the Right Honourable Edmund Burke], 8 vols (Bohn, ed London 1854-8) 8 p 141 Google Scholar.

46 [Burke, , Letters on a] regicide peace, 5 p 278 Google Scholar.

47 [Burke, ,] Reflections [on the revolution in France] (Everyman, ed London 1910) pp 44 Google Scholar, 193.

48 Burke, ‘A letter from Mr. Burke to a member of the National Assembly’, Reflections pp 263-4.

49 Bradley, F. H. ‘My station and its duties’ Ethical Studies (2 ed Oxford 1927) pp 160–206 Google Scholar.

50 [Burke, , An appeal from the] new to [the] old Whigs, 3 pp 79–80 Google Scholar.

51 Oakeshott, M., On Human Conduct (Oxford 1975) pp 55–60 Google Scholar.

52 Reflections p 91. Bowles, View p 13; Bowles, , The Retrospect (London 1798) p 297 Google Scholar.

53 Reflections p 85.

54 See also Bowles, View p 14.

55 New to old Whigs p 86.

56 Reflections p 89.

57 New to old Whigs pp 82-3.

58 Regicide peace pp 219-20.

59 Burke, , ‘Letter to William Burgh, Esq.’, 8 pp 455-6Google Scholar; ‘Speech on the second reading of a bill for the relief of protestant dissenters’, Ibid 6 pp 104, 110; Reflections p 147.

60 Burke, ‘Speech on the petition of the Unitarians’ Burke 6 pp 118-9, 123.

61 [Coleridge, ,] Essays on his times, [ed Erdman, D. V.], 3 vols (London 1978) 1 p 324 Google Scholar, 2 p 94, 3 p 191.

62 Ibid 2 p 330; [Coleridge, ,] Table Talk (Bohn, ed London 1884) p 244 Google Scholar.

63 Willey, B., ‘Coleridge and religion’, [S. T.Coleridge, ed Brett, R. L.] (London 1971) p 238 Google Scholar; Table Talk p 129.

64 Coleridge, , Biographia Literaria, ed Shawcross, J., 2 vols (Oxford 1907) 2 p 129 Google Scholar.

65 Table Talk p 103.

66 Ibid p 173; [Coleridge, ,] The Friend, [ed Rooke, B. E.], 2 vols (London 1969) 1 p 500 Google Scholar; [ Coleridge, , On the Constitution of the] Church and [the] State, [ed Colmer, J.] (London 1976) pp 42-3Google Scholar.

67 Coleridge’s contribution to the philosophy of culture is discussed by Mill, J. S., ‘Coleridge’ Mill on Bentham and Coleridge, ed Leavis, F.R. (London 1950)Google Scholar and by Williams, R., Culture and Society 1780-1950 (London 1958)Google Scholar.

68 For a vivid and powerful expression of this conception, see Church and State pp 61-70.

69 [Coleridge, ,] Lay Sermons, [ed White, R. J.] (London 1972) p 201 Google Scholar. Sanders, [C. R.], [Coleridge and the Broad Church Movement] (Durham, North Carolina 1942) p 51 Google Scholar. Barth, [J.R.], [Coleridge and Christian doctrine] (Cambridge, Massachusetts 1969) p 164 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

70 Lay Sermons p 179. See also p 191.

71 Church and State p 54.

72 Table Talk p 157.

73 Essays on his times 2 pp 432-3.

74 Table Talk p 274.

75 The Friend 1 pp 292-3.

76 Coleridge makes the yet stronger claim that the individual has no identity, no self, apart from his nation—he is a mere abstraction. Calleo, [D.P.], [Coleridge and the idea of the Modern State] (New Haven 1966) pp 80-3Google Scholar.

77 White, R. J., The Political Thought of Samuel Taylor Coleridge (London 1938) pp 139-41Google Scholar.

78 Coleridge, , ‘Religious Musings’, Poetical Works, ed Coleridge, E.H. (London 1967) pp 113-14Google Scholar lines 126-31.

79 Coleridge, , The Philosophical Lectures, ed Coburn, K. (London 1949) p 196 Google Scholar.

80 Table Talk p 146.

81 Sanders p 88.

82 Barth pp 164-5.

83 Table Talk p 162.

84 Coleridge’s avoidance of relativism is linked to his Christianity by Calleo pp 129-34.

85 This is the judgement also of Baron, S. W., Modem Nationalism and Religion (New York 1947) pp 88 Google Scholar, 129, 161; though he does not examine English thought of this period in any detail.