We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 March 2016
It is now over two decades since a cluster of studies by Natalie Zemon Davis, Bob Scribner, Marc Venard, Roger Chartier, Richard Trexler, William Christian, Carlo Ginzburg and others significantly modified our ways of thinking about religion in early modern Europe and in particular about the relationship between ‘elite’ and ‘popular’ religion, or as many had conceived it, between religion as preached and religion as practised. It had been simpler when writers who thought about such things had drawn neat boundaries between elite and popular and regarded communication between them as an exclusively one-way, top-down, process. They had also tended to regard the popular aspect of the polarity as qualitatively inferior to its elite corollary, depicting it variously as instrumental, functional, un-spiritual, somatic, irrational, unreflective, mechanical, amoral, magical or superstitious, or indeed as all of these things together, as if ‘the people’, a group generally defined in class terms as the socially subordinate, exhibited a vast collective unconscious. Additionally, much ethnography had taken such a divide as axiomatic, the German Volkskunde tradition, for example, often positing a process of transmission or ‘sinking’ of cultural forms from the elite down to the popular level. Such assumptions, which moreover uncritically reflected a notion of ‘religion’ which is restricted to a formal doctrinal corpus, defined and authenticated by the very body charged with its maintenance, were damaged by the historical revolution of the 1970s and 1980s and will not do for most scholars now, despite having informed a number of still influential historical schemata.
1 Landmark discussions of these developments include: Davis, Natalie Zemon, ‘From “Popular Religion” to Religious Cultures’, in Ozment, Steven, ed., Reformation Europe: a Guide to Research (St Louis, LA, 1982), 321–41 Google Scholar; Scribner, R. W., ‘Interpreting Religion in Early Modern Europe’, European Studies Review 13 (1983), 89–105 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Harline, Craig, ‘Official Religion – Popular Religion in Recent Historiography of the Catholic Reformation’, Archiv für Reformationsgeschichte 81 (1990), 239–62.Google Scholar
2 Scribner, Robert W., ‘Volksglaube und Volksfrömmigkeit. Begriffe und Historiographie’, in Molitor, Hansgeorg and Smolinsky, Heribert, eds, Volksfrömmigkeit in der Frühen Neuzeit (Münster, 1994), 121–38.Google Scholar
3 To cite perhaps the two best known works: Delumeau, Jean, Le Catholicisme entre Luther et Voltaire (Paris, 1071)Google Scholar; Thomas, Keith, Religion and the Decline of Magic: Studies in Popular Beliefs in Sixteenth- and Seventeenth-Century England (London, 1971).Google Scholar
4 ‘All evidence indicates that the kind of local religion described was shared by most of the people of Madrid and Toledo (and, for that matter, of Seville, Barcelona and Florence) and was as characteristic of the royal family as it was of unlettered peasants. One is therefore led to question the idea of “popular religion”, as distinct from some other kind’: Christian, William, Local Religion in Sixteenth-Century Spain (Princeton, 1981), 8 Google Scholar. See also Ditchfield, Simon, ‘ “In Search of Local Knowledge”: Rewriting Early Modern Italian Religious History’, Cristianesimo nellastoria 19 (1998), 255–96.Google Scholar
5 Duffy, , Stripping of the Altars. On ‘ordinary’ versus ‘sensational’Google Scholar, see Harline, , ‘Official Religion – Popular Religion’, 252, n. 83.Google Scholar
6 Gentilcore, David, From Bishop to Witch. The System of the Sacred in Early Modern Terra d’Otranto (Manchester, 1992).Google Scholar
7 Ryan, Salvador, ‘ “The Most Contentious of Terms”: Towards a New Understanding of Late Medieval “Popular Religion” ’, Irish Theological Quarterly 68 (2003), 281–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
8 Scribner, Bob, ‘Introduction’, in Scribner, Bob and Johnson, Trevor, eds, Popular Religion in Germany and Central Europe, 1400–1800 (Basingstoke, 1996), 1–15 CrossRefGoogle Scholar. On early modern dual classification, Clark, Stuart, Thinking with Demons. The Idea of Witchcraft in Early Modern Europe (Oxford, 1997)Google Scholar.
9 For a recent discussion of this theme, Parish, Helen and Naphy, William G., eds, Religion and Superstition in Reformation Europe (Manchester, 2002), ‘Introduction’, 1–22.Google Scholar
10 Grosin, Francisco Santos y, Promptuario de la theologia moral, compuesto primeramente por el P. M. Fr. Francisco Larraga, del Sagrado Orden de Predicatores, despues reformado, y corregido … (Madrid, 1780), 422–4.Google Scholar
11 Sales, François de, Introduction a la Vie Devote, Part I, Chapter 3, in Les Oeuvres de Sainct Francois de Sales, Evesque et Prince de Geneve, Instituteur des Religieuses de la Visitation de Sancte Marie, Vol. I (Paris, 1669)Google Scholar, cols 4–5.
12 Behringer, Wolfgang, Mit dem Feuer vom Lehen zum Tod: Hexengesetzgebung in Bayern (Munich, 1988), 174: ‘If the Blessed Virgin Mary bore the Child Jesus, lift the sickness from this animal, in the name of God, the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit’Google Scholar (my translation).
13 Ibid.
14 Brauneck, M., Religiöse Volkskunst (Cologne, 1978), 296–7.Google Scholar
15 Teresa, Fray José de Santa, Flores del Carmelo. Vidas de los Santos de Nuestra Señora del Carmen, que reza su religion, assi en comun, como en particulares conventos (Madrid, 1678), 351.Google Scholar
16 Göttler, Christine, Die Kunst des Fegefeuers nach der Reformation. Kirchlkhe Schenkungen, Ablaβ und Almosen in Antwerpen uni Bologna urn 1600 (Mainz, 1996)Google Scholar, and, for a similar emphasis, Scaramella, Pierroberto, Le Madonne del Purgatorio. Iconografia e religione in Campania tra Rinascimento e Controriforma (Genoa, 1991).Google Scholar
17 Bossy, John, ‘The Counter-Reformation and the People of Catholic Europe’, P&P 47 (1970), 51–70.Google Scholar
18 Ditchfield, Simon, Liturgy, Sanctity and History in Tridentine Italy: Pietro Maria Campi and the Preservation of the Particular (Cambridge, 1995)Google Scholar; idem, , ‘Sanctity in Early Modern Italy’, JEH 47 (1996), 98–112.Google Scholar
19 Papa, Giovanni, Le cause di canonizzazione nel primo periodo della Congregazione dei Riti (1588–1634) (Vatican City, 2001), 260.Google Scholar
20 Gentilcore, , From Bishop to Witch, 165–7.Google Scholar
21 Maria, José de Jesús, Historia de la vida y virtudes de fray Francisco del Niño Jesús (Madrid, 1670), 39.Google Scholar
22 Boeckl, Christine M., ‘Plague Imagery as Metaphor for Heresy in Rubens’ The Miracles of Saint Francis Xavier’, The Sixteenth Century Journal 27 (1996), 979–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
23 On Jesuit songs set to popular melodies, see Moser, Dietz-Rüdiger, Verkündigung durch Volksgesang. Studien zur Liedpropaganda und -katechese der Gegenreformation (Berlin, 1981).Google Scholar
24 Balbin, Bohuslav, Vita S. Joannis Nepomuceni sigilli sacramentalis Protomartyris (Augsburg, 1730).Google Scholar
25 Ilg, Matthias, ‘Der Kult des Kapuzinermàrtyrers Fidelis von Sigmaringen als Ausdruck katholischer Kriegserfahrungen im Dreiβigjährigen Krieg’, in Asche, Matthias and Schindling, Anton, eds, Das Strafgericht Gottes. Kriegserfahrungen und Religion im Heiligen Römischen Reich Deutscher Nation im Zeitalter des Dreiβigjährigen Krieges (Münster, 2002), 291–439.Google Scholar
26 Cassar, Carmel, Society, Culture and Identity in Early Modern Malta (Msida, Malta, 2000), 199–219.Google Scholar
27 Rowland, Ingrid D., The Ecstatic Journey: Athanasius Kircher in Baroque Rome (Chicago, IL, 2000), 84.Google Scholar
28 On the deserts, Sainte-Croix, Benoit Marie de la, Les Saints Déserts des Carmes Déchaussés (Paris, 1927)Google Scholar. The classic description of Varallo is Butler, Samuel, Ex Voto (London, 1888).Google Scholar
29 Kloczowski, Jerry, A History of Polish Christianity (Cambridge, 2000), 158.Google Scholar
30 For the most recent work on Scala Sancta reproductions, with a focus on the Czech lands, see Martin Elbel, ‘Budování poutního místa: Svaté schody pri františkánském kláštere v Olomouci’, Folia Historica Bohemica 20 (2002), 215–39, which charts how the richly- indulgenced Scala Sancta erected by the Franciscans of Olomouc in the early eighteenth century was initially opposed by other religious orders but received popular support, especially after a via dolorosa was added to it.
31 For the following, Duerloo, Luc and Wingens, Marc, Scherpenheuvel. Het Jeruzalem van de Lage Landen (Leuven, 2002).Google Scholar
32 Isidoro Moreno Navarro, a student of the rituals surrounding sacred images in modern Spain, has described communal festivals as constituting important ‘signs of identification’ for the community as a whole which celebrates them, but also as representing ‘rituals of division’ when regarded from within that community: Isidoro Moreno Navarro, ‘Niveles de significación de los iconos religiosos y rituales de reproducción de identidad en Andalucía’, in Pierre Cordoba and Jean-Pierre Etienvre, eds, La fiesta, la ceremonia, el rito (Granada, 1990), 91–103, at 95.
33 Châtellier, Louis, The Religion of the Poor. Rural Missions in Europe and the Formation of Modern Catholicism, c.1500-1800 (Cambridge, 1997).Google Scholar
34 Piotr Skarga, architect of the Jesuit mission in Poland, commented that there was no need to go to the exotic and remote Indies to find pagans and infidels to missionize, since ‘Lithuania is a veritable India’: Harro, Höpfl;, Jesuit Political Thought. The Society of Jesus and the State, c.1540-1630 (Cambridge, 2004), 12 Google Scholar; Henry Kamen notes that the same metaphor was applied by Spanish Jesuits to Asturias and Galicia in the sixteenth century: The Phoenix and the Flame. Catalonia and the Counter Reformation (New Haven, CT, 1993), 85.
35 Höpfl, , Jesuit Political Thought, 70.Google Scholar
36 Salgado, Félix Herrero, La oratoria sagrada en los siglos XVI y XVII, Vol. III (Madrid, 2001), 3: 404.Google Scholar
37 Ibid., 3: 400.
38 Leach, Catherine S., Memoirs of the Polish Baroque. The Writings of Jan Chryzostom Pasek, a Squire of the Commonwealth of Poland and Lithuania (Berkeley and Los Angeles, CA, and London, 1976), 15.Google Scholar
39 Gentilcore, David, ‘ “Adapt Yourselves to the People’s Capabilities”: Missionary Strategies, Methods and Impact in the Kingdom of Naples, 1600–1800’, JEH 45 (1994), 269–94.Google Scholar
40 Johnson, Trevor, ‘Blood, Tears and Xavier-Water: Jesuit Missionaries and Popular Religion in the Eighteenth-Century Upper Palatinate’, in Scribner, and Johnson, , eds, Popular Religion, 183–202.Google Scholar
41 Duhr, Bernhard, ‘Die kurpfälzischen und kurbayerischen Volkmissionen im 18. Jahrhundert’, Historisch-politische Blätter für das katholische Deutschland 170 (1922), 510–26, 565–80, 637–55 Google Scholar, here at 572–3.
42 On the transformation of elite attitudes to pilgrimage, see Habermas, Rebekka, Wallfahrt und Aufruhr. Zur Geschichte des Wunderglaubens in der frühen Neuzeit (Frankfurt, 1991).Google Scholar
43 Scribner, Bob, ‘Introduction’, in Scribner, and Johnson, , eds, Popular Religion, 1–15.Google Scholar
44 Châtellier, , The Religion of the Poor, 182–3.Google Scholar
