No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
The Decalogue, Patriarchy and Domestic Religious Education in Reformation England*
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 January 2016
Extract
The Decalogue was central to religious education in Reformation England, but this had not always been the case. The early Christian communities sought to distance themselves from the Ten Commandments and what they saw as the legalism of the Jewish faith, while the Middle Ages saw the ascendency of a parallel moral tradition: that of the seven deadly sins. Although the Decalogue never disappeared entirely from Christian life, by the fourteenth century, the parson from Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales could remark of the Commandments that ‘so heigh a doctrine I lete to divines’. The eventual triumph of the Decalogue over the sins during the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries was enormously significant, for the Ten Commandments not only taught religious doctrine; they also conditioned personal and communal devotions and moral and ethical behavioural norms. To an unparalleled extent, the Ten Commandments engendered a sense not only of the individual’s bond with God but also of the social and familial bonds they shared with mother and father, brother and sister, master and servant, and the broader community of neighbours wherein they dwelt. This essay will argue that one unintended consequence of the increasing prominence of the Decalogue in the households of sixteenth-century England was that it not only reinforced traditional understandings of household authority: it also modified them significantly. Understandings of gender relations in early modern England have been framed in a number of different ways over the past forty years: in terms of the essential stability of the household, the tightening of patriarchal control, and even in terms of crisis. But what these approaches fail to recognize is that, while the Decalogue undoubtedly reinforced parental (and particularly patriarchal) authority, it did so by stressing in equal measure the responsibility that was also inherent in authority, and the duties of care owed by superiors to inferiors. In both senses of the word, the commandments came to constitute a new, universal ‘moral system of the west’, given authority by Scripture and ubiquity through catechesis. An important aspect of this system was a much more nuanced understanding of patriarchal responsibility than has often hitherto been recognized.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 2014
Footnotes
*
This essay conies out of a Leverhulme Trust Early Career Fellowship project on the Ten Commandments and the English Reformation, and I would like to thank the trust for its generous support.
References
1 Bloomfield, Morton W., The Seven Deadly Sins (East Lansing, MI, 1952), 12–60 Google Scholar; Green, Ian G., The Christian’s ABC: Catechisms and Catechizing in England c. 1530-1740 (Oxford, 1996), 13–15 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bossy, John, ‘Moral Arithmetic: Seven Sins into Ten Commandments’, in Leites, Edmund, ed., Conscience and Casuistry in Early Modem Europe (Cambridge, 1988), 214–34 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 219-20.
2 Chaucer, Geoffrey, The Canterbury Tales, ed. Mann, Jill (London, 2005), 770 Google Scholar.
3 Hill, Bridget, ‘Women’s History: A Study in Change, Continuity, or Standing Still?’, Women’s History Review 2 (1993), 5–22 Google Scholar, at 13; Capp, Bernard, When Gossips Meet: Women, Family and Neighbourhood in Early Modern England (Oxford, 2003), 20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
4 Stone, Lawrence, The Family, Sex and Marriage in England, 1500-1800 (London, 1977)Google Scholar; cf. MacFarlane, Alan, ‘Review of Lawrence Stone, The Family, Sex and Marriage in England, 1500-1800 ’, History and Theory 18 (1979), 103–26 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
5 Underdown, David, ‘The Taming of the Scold: The Enforcement of Patriarchal Authority in Early Modern England’, in Fletcher, A. J. and Stevenson, J., eds, Order and Disorder in Early Modern England (Cambridge, 1985), 116–36 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
6 According to Bossy, the change was ‘revolutionary’. On this and some of the associated changes, see Bossy, John, Christianity in the West 1500-1700 (Oxford, 1985), 38, 161, 171 Google Scholar; idem, ‘Some Elementary Forms of Durkheim’, P&P, no. 95 (1982), 3-18, at 11-12; idem, ‘Moral Arithmetic’, 216-17; cf. Shagan, Ethan, Popular Politics and the English Reformation (Cambridge, 2003), 10–20 Google Scholar; Ditchfield, Simon, ‘Introduction’, in Christianity and Community in the West: Essays for John Bossy, ed. idem (Aldershot, 2001), xxii.Google Scholar
7 Iniunctions gyuen by th auctoritie of the kynges highnes (London, 1538), fol. [Iv],
8 Iniunctions geuen by the Queues Maiestic (London, 1559), sig. Aiiir; cf. Cecil, William, Ordinances made … for … the hospitall at Stanford Baron (London, 1597), 1.Google Scholar
9 Gouge, William, Of domesticall duties eight treatises (London, 1622)Google Scholar, sig. ¶2V.
10 Burton, Robert, The anatomy of melancholy what it is (London, 1621), 586.Google Scholar
11 Carpenter, John, Contemplations for the institution of children in the Christian religion (London, 1601)Google Scholar, sigs Aviv–Aviir.
12 Sternhold, Thomas, Certayne Psalmes chosen out of the Psalter of Dauid (London, 1549)Google Scholar, sig. Aiiir.
13 Cf. Bossy, , ‘Moral Arithmetic’, 232.Google Scholar
14 Green, , ABC, 41–3.Google ScholarPubMed
15 Hooper, John, ‘A declaration of the Ten holy Commandements of Almighty God’ (c.1548), in Early Writings of John Hooper, ed. Samuel Carr, PS (Cambridge, 1843), 271 Google Scholar.
16 Hooper, E.g.. ‘A declaration’, 255 Google Scholar; Broughton, Hugh, A reuelation of the holy Apocalyps (London, 1610), 174 Google Scholar; Bullinger, Heinrich, Looke from Adam, transl. Miles Coverdale (London, 1624), 38 Google Scholar; Calvin, Jean, Sermons … vpon the fifth booke of Moses called Deuteronomie, transl. Arthur Golding (London, 1583), 391.Google Scholar
17 Calvin, , Sermons upon Deuteronomie, 391.Google Scholar
18 Ex. 20: 2-3. In the Catholic and Lutheran traditions, the first commandment included the prohibition against the making of graven images, but in the Jewish, Orthodox and Reformed traditions this constituted a second, separate commandment.
19 Bullinger, , Looke from Adam, 38.Google Scholar
20 Hooper, , ‘A declaration’, 255 Google Scholar; Brinsley, John, The true watch (London, 1606), 17.Google Scholar
21 Bullinger, , Looke from Adam, 39.Google Scholar
22 Bodin, Jean, The six bookes of a common-weale, transl. Knolles, Richard (London, 1606), 20 Google Scholar.
23 Bodin, , The six bookes, 20–1.Google Scholar
24 Philo Volume VII, transl. Colson, F. H., LCL 320 (London, 2006), 3–4, 31, 33.Google Scholar
25 Brinsley, , The true watch, 37 Google Scholar; cf. Hooper, , ‘A declaration’, 353.Google Scholar
26 Becon, Thomas, A new postil conteinyng most godly and learned sermons (London, 1566)Google Scholar, fol. 38r.
27 Byfield, Nicholas, A commentary: or, sermons upon the second chapter ofthe first epistle of Saint Peter (London, 1623), 733.Google Scholar
28 ‘The third part of the sermon of good works’, Sermons, or Homilies, appointed to be read in churches, in the time of Queen Elizabeth (Dublin, 1821), 49; cf. Parker, Henry, Here endith a compendioues treetise dyalogue of Dines and pauper (London, 1493)Google Scholar, sig. miiv; Luther, Martin, ‘The Fourth Commandment’, from ‘Ten Sermons on the Catechism’, LW 51: Sermons I, ed. and transl. Doberstein, John W. (Philadelphia, PA, 1980), 146 Google Scholar; Gouge, , Of domesticall duties, 441–2.Google Scholar
29 Bossy, Christianity in the West, 116; cf. Perkins, William, A golden chaine (London, 1600), 67 Google Scholar.
30 Batt, Barthélemy, The Christian mans closet, ed. Lowth, William (London, 1581)Google Scholar, fol. 32r.
31 Ibid., fol. 32r-v.
32 Gouge, , Of domesticall duties, 497.Google Scholar
33 Brinsley, , The true watch, 41–2.Google Scholar
34 Lyster, John, A rule how to bring vp children (London, 1588)Google Scholar, fols 1r, 138r.
35 Perkins, , A golden chaine, 67–72.Google Scholar
36 Bullinger, Heinrich, The golden boke of christen matrimonye, transl. Basille, Theodore (London, 1543), fol. lxxv Google Scholar.
37 Gouge, , Of domesticall duties, 502.Google Scholar
38 Ibid. 503.
39 E.g. Boys, John, An exposition of the dominical epistles and gospels used in our English liturgie throughout the whole yeare (London, 1610), 120 Google Scholar; Bellarmine, Robert, An ample declaration of the Christian doctrine, transl. Richard Hadock (Roan [English secret press], 1604), 4.Google Scholar