Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2plfb Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-24T09:33:37.187Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Pseudoparadox of Partisan Mapmaking and Congressional Competition

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 January 2021

Nicholas Goedert
Nicholas Goedert*
Affiliation:
Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, USA
*
Nicholas Goedert, Virginia Tech, Major Williams Hall, 220 Stanger St., Blacksburg, VA 24061, USA. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Why are fewer congressional elections competitive at the district level when the national electoral environment is at its most competitive? This article explores this “pseudoparadox,” and argues that the answer can be found in partisan redistricting. Through an analysis of 40 years of congressional elections, I find that partisan gerrymanders induce greater competitiveness as national tides increase, largely due to unanticipated consequences of waves adverse to the map-drawing party, particularly in seats held by that party. The phenomenon anecdotally coined by Grofman and Brunell as the “dummymander” is thus actually quite common and has significant effects on rates of congressional competition nationally. In contrast, bipartisan maps are shown to induce lower competition, while nonpartisan maps induce higher competition, under all electoral conditions and competitiveness measures. But the effects of partisan gerrymanders on competition, though strong, can only be seen in interaction with short-term national forces.

Keywords

redistrictinglegislative electionslegislative politicspolitical behaviorelectoral systemsfederalism
Type
Research Article
Information
State Politics & Policy Quarterly , Volume 17 , Issue 1 , March 2017 , pp. 47 - 75
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2017

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abramowitz, Alan I., Alexander, Brad, and Gunning, Matthew. 2006. “Incumbency, Redistricting, and the Decline of Competition in US House Elections.” The Journal of Politics 68 (1): 75–88..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Adams, Florence P. 2005. “Minorities and Representation in the New Millennium.” In Redistricting in the New Millennium, ed. Galderisi, Peter F.. New York: Rowman & Littlefield, pp. 155–79.Google Scholar
Barone, Michael, and Cohen, Richard E.. The Almanac of American Politics. Washington, DC: National Journal Group, Bi-annual Publication.Google Scholar
Brennan Center for Justice. 2015. Redistricting Laws Roundup. https://www.brennancenter.org/redistricting-laws-roundup-2015 (accessed June 29, 2016).Google Scholar
Cain, Bruce E. 1985. “Assessing the Partisan Effects of Redistricting.” American Political Science Review 79:320–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cain, Bruce E., MacDonald, Karin, and McDonald, Michael. 2005. “From Equality to Fairness: The Path of Political Reform since Baker v. Carr.” In Party Lines, eds. Mann, Thomas E. and Cain, Bruce E.. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution, 6–30.Google Scholar
Carson, James L., and Crespin, Michael H.. 2004. “The Effect of State Redistricting Methods on Electoral Competition in United States House Races.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly 4 (4): 455–69..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carson, Jamie L., Crespin, Michael H., and Williamson, Ryan Dane. 2014. “Reevaluating the Effects of Redistricting on Electoral Competition, 1972–2012.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly 14 (2): 165–77..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cox, Gary W., and Katz, Jonathan. 2002. Elbridge Gerry's Salamander: The Electoral Consequences of the Reapportionment Revolution. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ferejohn, John A. 1977. “On the Decline of Competitiveness of Congressional Elections.” American Political Science Review 71:166–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gelman, Andrew, and King, Gary. 1994. “Enhancing Democracy through Legislative Districting.” American Political Science Review 88 (3): 541–59..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Glazer, Amihai, Grofman, Bernard, and Robbins, Marc. 1987. “Partisan and Incumbency Effects of 1970s Congressional Redistricting.” American Journal of Political Science 31:680–707.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goedert, Nicholas M. 2011. “Redistricting Institutions under Electoral Uncertainty.” Paper presented at the 2011 Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, Seattle, WA. Available at: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1900880.Google Scholar
Gopoian, David L., and West, Darrell M.. 1984. “Trading Security for Seats: Strategic Considerations in the Redistricting Process.” The Journal of Politics 46 (4): 1080–96..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grofman, Bernard, and Brunell, Thomas L.. 2005. “The Art of the Dummymander: The Impact of Recent Redistrictings on the Partisan Makeup of Southern House Seats.” In Redistrciting in the New Millennium, ed. Galderisi, Peter F.. New York: Rowman & Littlefield, pp. 183–200.Google Scholar
Hetherington, Marc J., Larson, Bruce, and Globetti, Suzanne. 2003. “The Redistricting Cycle and Strategic Candidate Decisions in U.S. House Races.” The Journal of Politics 65 (4): 1221–34..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hirsch, Sam. 2003. “The United States House of Unrepresentatives: What Went Wrong in the Latest Round of Congressional Redistricting.” Election Law Journal 2 (2): 179–216..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hood, M. V., and McKee, Seth C.. 2008. “Gerrymandering on Georgia's Mind: The Effects of Redistricting on Vote Choice in the 2006 Midterm Election.” Social Science Quarterly 89 (1): 60–77..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kang, Michael S. 2004. “The Bright Side of Partisan Gerrymandering.” Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy 14:443.Google Scholar
Lindgren, Eric, and Southwell, Priscilla. 2013. “The Effect of Redistricting Commissions on Electoral Competitiveness in U.S. House Elections, 2002-2010.” Journal of Politics and Law 6 (2): 13–18..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Makse, Todd. 2014. “The Redistricting Cycle, Partisan Tides, and Party Strategy in State Legislative Elections.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly 14 (3): 342–63..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Masket, Seth E., Winburn, Jonathan, and Wright, Gerald C.. 2012. “The Gerrymanderers Are Coming! Legislative Redistricting Won't Affect Competition or Polarization Much, No Matter Who Does It.” Political Science & Politics 45 (1): 39–43..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mayhew, David R. 1974. “Congressional Elections: The Case of the Vanishing Marginals.” Polity 6 (3): 295–317..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McDonald, Michael P. 2004. “A Comparative Analysis of Redistricting Institutions in the United States, 2001-02.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly 4 (4): 371–95..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McDonald, Michael P. 2006. “Drawing the Line on District Competition.” Political Science & Politics 39:91–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McGhee, Eric. 2014. “Measuring Partisan Bias in Single-Member District Electoral Systems.” Legislative Studies Quarterly 39 (1): 55–85..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moxley, Warden. 1973. Congressional Districts in the 1970s. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly.Google Scholar
Murphy, Chad, and Yoshinaka, Antoine. 2009. “Are Mapmakers Able to Target and Protect Congressional Incumbents? The Institutional Dynamics of Electoral Competition.” American Politics Research 37 (6): 955–82..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Niemi, Richard G., and Deegan, John Jr. 1978. “A Theory of Political Districting.” The American Political Science Review 72 (4): 1304–23..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Owen, Guillermo, and Grofman, Bernard. 1988. “Optimal Partisan Gerrymandering.” Political Geography Quarterly 7 (1): 5–22..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rogers, Steven. 2013. “Accountability in State Legislatures: How Parties Perform in Office and State Legislative Elections.” http://www.stevenmrogers.com/Dissertation/ChapterDrafts/CollectiveAccountability/Rogers-CollectiveAccountability.pdf (accessed June 29, 2016).Google Scholar
Seabrook, Nicholas R. 2010. “The Limits of Partisan Gerrymandering: Looking Ahead to the 2010 Congressional Redistricting Cycle.” The Forum 8 (2), Article 8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stephanopoulos, Nicholas O., and McGhee, Eric M.. 2015. “Partisan Gerrymandering and the Efficiency Gap.” University of Chicago Law Review 82:831–900.Google Scholar
Tufte, Edward R. 1973. “The Relationship between Seats and Votes in Two-Party Systems.” The American Political Science Review 67 (2): 540–54..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yoshinaka, Antoine, and Murphy, Chad. 2011. “The Paradox of Redistricting: How Partisan Mapmakers Foster Competition but Disrupt Representation.” Political Research Quarterly 64 (2): 435–47..CrossRefGoogle Scholar