Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T20:15:17.224Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The “Other Braceros”

Temporary Labor and German Prisoners of War in the United States, 1943-1946

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 January 2016

Barbara Schmitter Heisler
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article explores the contradictions between the bracero program and the temporary labor program using German prisoners of war in the United States during World War II. Despite the bilateral agreement between Mexico and the United States aimed at protecting the braceros, “who came as allies,” they remained alien workers and outsiders. In contrast, German prisoners of war, who came as enemies, were often transformed into personal friends “like our own boys.” This article uses archival records, in-depth interviews with former prisoners of war, and secondary sources to analyze several structural factors that help explain these divergent outcomes.

Type
Articles
Information
Social Science History , Volume 31 , Issue 2 , Summer 2007 , pp. 239 - 271
Copyright
Copyright © Social Science History Association 2007 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Andersch, Alfred (1946) “Die Kriegsgefangenen, Licht und Schatten—eine Bilanz.” Der Ruf, October 15, 6–7.Google Scholar
Association of New York State Canners (1944) Letter to brigadier general, Aliens Division, POW Division, December 26. RG 107, Records of the Secretary of War, Entry 114, Records of the Legal Services Branch, General Records, 1942-45. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
Basok, Tanya (2000) “He came. He saw. He… stayed: Guest worker programmes and the issue of non-return.” International Migration 38: 215–36.Google Scholar
Billinger, Robert Jr. (2000) Hitler’s Soldiers in the Sunshine State: German POWs in Florida. Gainesville: University of Florida Press.Google Scholar
Blum, John Morton (1976) V Was for Victory: Politics and American Culture during World War II. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.Google Scholar
Butler, Joseph (1973) “Prisoner of war labor in the sugar cane fields of Lafourche Parish, Louisiana, 1943–44.” Louisiana History 14: 283–96.Google Scholar
Calavita, Kitty (1992) Inside the State: The Bracero Program, Immigration, and the I.N.S. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Carlson, Lewis (1997) We Were Each Other’s Prisoners: An Oral History of World War II American and German Prisoners of War. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Clark, Penny (1988) Farm Work and Friendship: The German Prisoner of War Camp at Lake Wabaunsee. Emporia, KS: School of Graduate and Professional Studies, Emporia State University.Google Scholar
Copp, Nelson (1963) “Wetbacks and braceros: Mexican migrant laborers and American immigration policy, 1930-1960.” PhD diss., Boston University.Google Scholar
Cowley, Betty (2002) Stalag Wisconsin: Inside WW II Prisoner-of-War Camps. Oregon, WI: Badger.Google Scholar
Craig, Richard (1971) The Bracero Program: Interest Groups and Foreign Policy. Austin: University of Texas Press.Google Scholar
Dell’Angela, Tracy (1996) “German fondly revisits POW site in Des Plaines.” Chicago Tribune, June 5.Google Scholar
Eishaur, Heinz (2004) Author interview, Sun City, FL, February 28.Google Scholar
Erichsen, Heino, and Nelson-Erichsen, Jean (2001) The Reluctant Warrior: Former German POW Finds Peace in Texas. Austin, TX: Eakin.Google Scholar
Ertel, Guenther Peter (1996) My Story. Cuyahoga Falls, OH: The author.Google Scholar
Fairchild, Byron, and Grossman, Jonathan (1959) The Army and Industrial Manpower. Washington, DC: Office of the Chief of Military History, Department of the Army.Google Scholar
Fernholz, Otto (1997) “American way of life,” Camp Ruston World War II Prisoner of War Camp, Ruston, Louisiana, www.latech.edu/tech/library/campruston/slide167.htm.Google Scholar
Fickle, James, and Ellis, Donald (1990) “POWs in the piney woods: German prisoners of war in the southern lumber industry, 1943-1945.” Journal of Southern History 56: 695–724.Google Scholar
Fiedler, David (2003) The Enemy among Us: POWs in Missouri during World War II. St. Louis: Missouri Historical Society Press.Google Scholar
Fiedler, Martin (2004) Author interview, Wood Dale, IL, June 25.Google Scholar
Floeter, Ernst (2002) Author interview, Grand Ledge, MI, October 23.Google Scholar
Galarza, Ernesto (1964) Merchants of Labor: The Mexican Bracero Story. Charlotte, NC: McNally and Loftin.Google Scholar
Gamboa, Erasmo (1990) Mexican Labor and World War II: Braceros in the Pacific North-west, 1942-1947. Austin: University of Texas Press.Google Scholar
Garcia y Griego, Manuel (1981) The Importation of Mexican Contract Laborers to the United States, 1942–1964: Antecedents, Operation, and Legacy. Working Papers in U.S.–Mexican Studies 11. La Jolla: Program in United States-Mexican Studies, University of California, San Diego.Google Scholar
Geiger, Jeffrey (1996) German Prisoners of War at Camp Cooke, California: Personal Accounts of Fourteen Soldiers, 1944-1946. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.Google Scholar
Gruenheit, Johann (2003) Author interview, Bellingham, WA, April 28.Google Scholar
Gutierrez, David (1995) Walls and Mirrors: Mexican Americans, Mexican Immigrants, and the Politics of Ethnicity. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Hansen, L. O. (1988) “The political and socio-economic context of legal and illegal Mexican migration to the United States (1942-1984).” International Migration 26: 95–106.Google Scholar
Heintz, Julie (1998) “The war at home: Prisoner of war camps in Iowa during World War II.” MA thesis, University of Northern Iowa.Google Scholar
Hetz, Harry (2003) Author interview, Kenilworth, IL, April 11.Google Scholar
Hörner, Helmut, and Powell, Allan Kent (1991) A German Odyssey: The Journal of a German Prisoner of War. Golden, CO: Fulcrum.Google Scholar
Jung, Hermann (1972) Die deutschen Kriegsgefangenen in amerikanischer Hand: USA. Munich: Gieseking.Google Scholar
Kirstein, Peter (1977) Anglo over Bracero: A History of the Mexican Worker in the United States from Roosevelt to Nixon. San Francisco: R and E Research Associates.Google Scholar
Kiser, George C., and Kiser, Martha Woody, eds. (1979) Mexican Workers in the United States: Historical and Political Perspectives. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.Google Scholar
Krammer, Arnold (1991) Nazi Prisoners of War in America. Chelsea, MI: Scarborough House.Google Scholar
Lewis, George, and Mewha, John (1955) History of Prisoner of War Utilization by the United States Army, 1776–1945. Washington, DC: Department of the Army.Google Scholar
Liebergesell, Otto (2002) Author interview, Salt Lake City, UT, September 23.Google Scholar
Luick-Thrams, Michael, ed. (2002) Signs of Life: The Correspondence of German POWs at Camp Algona, Iowa, 1943–46. Mason City, IA: Stoyles.Google Scholar
Margulies, Newton (1945) “Proper treatment of war prisoners.” Vital Speeches, May 15.Google Scholar
McCrady, Grace (1943) “Manpower from Mexico.” New York Herald Tribune, November 28.Google Scholar
McKnight, Maxwell (1944) “The employment of prisoners of war in the United States.” International Labor Review 50: 47–64.Google Scholar
Metzroth, Rupert (2004) Think for Yourself. Stuart, FL: Backyard.Google Scholar
Moore, John Hammond (1978) The Faustball Tunnel: German POWs in America and Their Great Escape. New York: Random House.Google Scholar
Mueller, Alfred (2003) Author interview, Faribault, MN, September 23.Google Scholar
New Mexico Farm and Ranch Heritage Museum (n.d.) “Prisoners of war in New Mexico agriculture,” NMF and RHM Oral History Program, archives.nmsu.edu/rghc/index/pow/categories.html (accessed June 21, 2005).Google Scholar
New York Times (2002) “Town’s fond memories of the enemy.” March 17.Google Scholar
Newsweek (1945a) “Anger at Nazi atrocities is rising, but U.S. treats prisoners fairly.” May 7, 58–61.Google Scholar
Newsweek (1945b) “The Kriegsmarine escape.” January 8, 33.Google Scholar
Newsweek (1945c) “Swastika over Arizona.” February 26, 58.Google Scholar
Norz, Ludwig (2004) Author interview, Big Rapids, MI, August 24.Google Scholar
Oberdieck, William (1995) America’s Prisoner of War, 1943-1946. New York: Carlton.Google Scholar
Overmans, Rüdinger (2000) Soldaten hinter Stacheldraht: Deutsche Kriegsgefangene des zweiten Weltkriegs. Berlin: Econ Ullstein List Verlag.Google Scholar
Pabel, Reinhold (1955) Enemies Are Human. Philadelphia: Winston.Google Scholar
Pechmann, Kurt (2002) Author interview, Madison, WI, July 27.Google Scholar
Pepin, John (2004) “Viewer’s guide: The enemy in our midst; Nazi prisoner of war camps in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula,” www.nmu.edu/wnmutv/enemy_guide72.pdf.Google Scholar
Pfeffer, M. J. (1980) “The labour process and corporate agriculture: Mexican workers in California.” Insurgent Sociologist 10: 25–44.Google Scholar
Pluth, Edward (1970) “The American operation of German prisoner of war camps in the United States during World War II.” PhD diss., Ball State University.Google Scholar
Pluth, Edward (1975) “Prisoner of war employment in Minnesota during World War II.” Minnesota History 44: 290–303.Google Scholar
Powell, Allan Kent (1989) Splinters of a Nation: German Prisoners of War in Utah. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.Google Scholar
Provost Marshal General (1944a) Memorandum from Armed Forces Office to commanding generals, nine service divisions, February 17. RG 389, Records of the Provost Marshal General’s Office, Entry 439A, Prisoner of War Operations, Historical File, 1941–58. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
Provost Marshal General (1944b) Memorandum from Armed Forces Office to commanding generals, nine service divisions, March 24. RG 389, Records of the Provost Marshal General’s Office, Entry 439A, Prisoner of War Operations, Historical File, 1941-58. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
Provost Marshal General (1945) Handbook for Work Supervisors of Prisoner of War Labor. Army Service Forces Manual M811, July. RG 389, Records of the Provost Marshal General’s Office, Entry 439A, Prisoner of War Operations, Historical File, 1941–58. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
Provost Marshal General (1946) Poll of German prisoner of war opinion. RG 389, Records of the Provost Marshal General’s Office, Entry 439A, Prisoner of War Operations, Historical File, 1941-58. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
Rasmussen, Wayne (1951) A History of the Emergency Farm Labor Supply Program, 1943-1947. Agricultural Monograph no. 13. Washington, DC: Bureau of Agricultural Economics, U.S. Department of Agriculture.Google Scholar
Reiss, Matthias (2005) “Bronzed bodies behind barbed wire: Masculinity and the treatment of German prisoners of war in the United States during World War II.” Journal of Military History 69: 475–504.Google Scholar
Richter, Heinz (2003) Author interview (telephone), Milwaukee, WI, February 17.Google Scholar
Ruhe, Henry (2001) Author interview, Charlottesville, VA, January 10.Google Scholar
Ruhe, Henry (n.d.) “Lykins.” Typescript.Google Scholar
Schlauch, Wolfgang (2003) In amerikanischer Kriegsgefangenschaft: Berichte deutscher Soldaten aus dem Zweiten Weltkrieg. Crailsheim, Germany: Baier.Google Scholar
Schmid, Walter (2005) A German POW in New Mexico. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.Google Scholar
Schmoling, Oskar (2002) Author interview, Clinton Township, MI, October 24.Google Scholar
Schott, Matthew (1995) “Prisoners like us: German POWs encounter Louisiana’s African Americans.” Louisiana History 36: 277–90.Google Scholar
Smith, Beverly (1945) “Nazi supermen hit the dirt.” American Magazine 140: 45–61.Google Scholar
Strahler, Willi (2003) Author interview, Darien, IL, April 10.Google Scholar
Thill, Rudolf (2004) Adrift in Stormy Times. Decorah, IA: South Bear.Google Scholar
Thompson, Glenn (1993) Prisoners on the Plains: German POWs in America. Holdrege, NE: Phelps County Historical Society.Google Scholar
Tissing, Robert Jr. (1973) “Utilization of prisoners of war in the United States during World War II: Texas, a case study.” MA thesis, Baylor University, www.rootsweb.com/~txrober2/Tissing.htm.Google Scholar
Tissing, Robert Jr. (1976) “Stalag Texas, 1943-45.” Military History of Texas and the Southwest 13: 24–34.Google Scholar
Tri-State Packers Association (1944) Letter to War Manpower Commission, May 13. RG 211, Records of the War Manpower Commission, Entry 175, General Records Relating to POWs, 1944-45, Regions I-VII. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
El Universal (2004) “Braceros march to U.S. embassy, demand funds.” February 11.Google Scholar
Waecker, Hans (2003) Author interview, Georgetown, ME, May 17.Google Scholar
War Department (1943) “Employment of prisoners of war off reservations.” Memorandum to commanding generals, nine regional service commands, August 24. RG 107, Records of the Secretary of War, Entry 114, Records of the Legal Services Branch, General Records, 1942–45. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
War Department (1944a) “POW circular 24,” April 24. RG 107, Records of the Secretary of War, Entry 114, Records of the Legal Services Branch, General Records, 1942–45. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
War Department (1944b) “POW circular 26,” May 6. RG 107, Records of the Secretary of War, Entry 114, Records of the Legal Services Branch, General Records, 1942–45. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
War Department (1945) Letter to Pennsylvania Forest Products Committee, April 3. RG 211, Records of the War Manpower Commission, Entry 175, General Records Relating to POWs, 1944-45, Regions I–VII. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
War Manpower Commission (1943a) “Employment of prisoners of war.” War Manpower Commission field instructions 65, October 15. RG 211, Records of the War Manpower Commission, Entry 155, Records of the Legal Services Branch, General Records, 1942-45. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
War Manpower Commission (1943b) “Reimbursement of prisoner of war officers and non-commissioned officers as supervisors and interpreters on work projects, and charging for services of prisoners of war.” War Manpower Commission field instructions 69, October 19. RG 211, Records of the War Manpower Commission, Entry 155, Records of the Legal Services Branch, General Records, 1942–45. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
War Manpower Commission (1945a) Letter from regional director, Cleveland, Ohio, to Washington office, April. RG 211, Records of the War Manpower Commission, Entry 175, General Records Relating to POWs, 1944-45, Regions I–VII. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
War Manpower Commission (1945b) Minutes of the Labor Management Policy Committee, August 14. RG 211, Records of the War Manpower Commission, Entry 155, Records of the Legal Services Branch, General Records, 1942-45. National Archives II, College Park, MD.Google Scholar
Waters, Michael (2004) Lone Star Stalag: German Prisoners of War at Camp Hearne. College Station: Texas A&M University Press.Google Scholar
Wilcox, Walter (1947) The Farmer in the Second World War. Ames: Iowa State College Press.Google Scholar