Hostname: page-component-cc8bf7c57-ksm4s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-12T01:55:10.140Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Lonergan's Cognitional Theory: Toward A Critical Human Science

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 August 2009

David A. Nordquest
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Lonergan's cognitional theory, though generally unknown in the discipline, points the way toward a more concrete understanding of politics through its emphasis on the self-appropriation of our knowing. This article examines the invariant structure or method Lonergan finds in all practical or scientific knowing, the precepts that can be derived from the operations of the mind, the continuity between cognitive and moral self-transcendence, and the different horizons which may confine our knowing. It considers the biases which distort personal and political development, the need for cosmopolis, an informal community which helps to save practicality by transcending it, the methodological natural right which may be derived from norms inherent in our knowing, and the emergent probability of progress or decline set by the stock of insights or oversights operative in a society. It concludes that Lonergan's work makes a substantial contribution to the critical human science he seeks and that it could play a helpful role in unifying the discipline.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Review of Politics , Volume 56 , Issue 1 , Winter 1994 , pp. 71 - 99
Copyright
Copyright © University of Notre Dame 1994

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Voegelin, Eric, Anamnesis, trans. Niemeyer, Gerhart (Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 1978), p. 3.Google Scholar

2. Webb, Eugene, Philosophers of Consciousness (Seattle: University of Washington Press, 1988);Google ScholarGermino, Dante, Beyond Ideology (New York: Harper and Row, 1968);Google ScholarLonergan, Bernard, Insight: A Study of Human Understanding (New York: Harper and Row, 1978), p. 236.Google Scholar [Where possible, I will provide the equivalent citation to the Collected Works of Bernard Lonergan, ed. Crowe, F. E. and Doran, R. M. (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1988-; 4 vols, to date).Google Scholar Thus Insight, p. 236 = CWL 3: 261].Google Scholar

3. On the general character of Lonergan's effort, see Crowe, F. E., The Lonergan Enterprise (Cambridge: Cowley, 1980).Google Scholar Helpful studies of political implications include Lawrence, Frederick, “Political Theology and ‘The Longer Cycle of Decline,’” in Lonergan Workshop II, ed. Lawrence, F. (Chico: Scholars Press, 1978);Google ScholarDoran, Robert, “Education for Cosmopolis,” Method: Journal of Lonergan Studies 1: 134–57;Google ScholarLamb, Michael, “The Political and Social Dimensions of Lonergan's Theology,” in The Desires of the Heart (New York: Paulist Press, 1988);Google ScholarCrowe, F. E., Bernard Lonergan and the Community of Canadians (Toronto: Lonergan Institute and Canadian Institute of Jesuit Affairs, 1992);Google Scholar and Glendon, Mary Ann, “Comparative Law As Shock Treatment,” Method:JLS 11: 137–53.Google Scholar Unpublished materials and revised editions of published works are being prepared for publication in the Collected Works at the Lonergan Research Institute in Toronto, which generously allows scholars full access to unpublished materials. They maintain a library of printed primary and secondary materials, as well as archives of manu scripts, lecture notes, letters, recordings and other materials.

4. Going, Cathleen, ed., Dialogues in Celebration (Montreal: Thomas More Institute Press, 1980), p. 295.Google Scholar

5. Lonergan, , “Critical Realism and the Integration of the Sciences” (Toronto: Regis College typescript of Dublin transcript of lectures, 1961), p. 14.Google Scholar For Lonergan's related reinterpretation of St. Thomas, , see his Verbum, ed. Burrell, David (Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame, 1967).Google Scholar

6. See: Burrell, David, “Method and Sensibility: Novak's Debt to Lonergan,” Journal of the American Academy of Religion, 40: 349–67;Google ScholarCrowe, F. E., The Lonergan Enterprise, pp. 60–62;Google Scholar and Lonergan, , A Second Collection, ed. Ryan, F. J. and Tyrell, B. J. (Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1974), pp. 213–15.Google Scholar

7. A sample of Lonergan's later writings which nicely illustrates the wide range of his interests is his Third Collection (1985). His educational writings have just been published as Topics in Education and his economic work will be published soon as Essay in Circulation Analysis in the Collected Works.

8. Many applications have been published in Method:Journal of Lonergan Studies and in the volumes of Lonergan Workshop, edited by Frederick Lawrence. A continuing bibliography may be found in the Lonergan Newsletter, edited by F. E. Crowe and R. M. Doran and published by the Lonergan Research Institute.

9. For a summary treatment, see “Cognitional Structure,” in Collection, ed. Crowe, F. E. (New York: Herder and Herder, 1967)Google Scholar = CWL 4;Google ScholarLonergan, , Method in Theology (New York: Seabury Press, 1972), p. 4.Google Scholar

10. Lonergan, , Collection, p. 221Google Scholar = CWL 4: 206.Google Scholar

11. Lonergan, , “Critical Realism,” p. 19.Google Scholar

12. Lonergan, , The Subject (Milwaukee: Marquette University Press, 1968), p. 15.Google Scholar

13. Lonergan, , “Critical Realism,” p. 20.Google Scholar

14. Lambert, Pierrot et al. , Caring About Meaning:Patterns in the Life of Bernard Lonergan (Montreal: Thomas More Institute, 1982), p. 53.Google Scholar All references to this volume are to Lonergan's answers to questions put to him by a panel; Lonergan, , “Cognitional Structure,” p. 223Google Scholar = CWL 4: 206–207.Google Scholar

15. Going, , Dialogues, pp. 286–87.Google Scholar

16. Lonergan, , Understanding and Being, ed. E. A., and Morelli, M. D. (New York: The Edwin Mellen Press, 1980), p. 140Google Scholar = CWL 5: 114–15.Google Scholar

17. Insight, chap. 10.

18. Lonergan, , Second Collection, p. 38;Google ScholarLambert, , Caring, pp. 13–15; 46;Google ScholarPolanyi, Michael, Personal Knowledge (New York: Harper and Row, 1964);Google ScholarGelwick, Richard, The Way of Discovery (New York: Oxford University Press, 1977), pp. 135–36;Google ScholarLonergan, , “True Judgment and Science,” a 1929 composition, of which a copy is available at the Lonergan Research Institute.Google Scholar

19. Lonergan, , Understanding and Being, p. 148–49Google Scholar = CW 5:121–22.Google Scholar

20. Ibid., p. 149 = CWL 5:122;Google ScholarLonergan, , “Critical Realism,” pp. 21–22.Google Scholar

21. Lonergan, , Collection, p. 227Google Scholar = CWL 4: 210.Google Scholar

22. Lambert, , Caring, pp. 68, 117.Google Scholar

23. Lonergan, , Method in Theology, pp. 18–19.Google Scholar

24. Lonergan, , The Subject, p. 9.Google Scholar

25. Insight, p. xGoogle Scholar = CWL 3:3.Google Scholar

26. Ibid., p. 3 = CWL 3:27.Google Scholar

27. O'Connor, Eric, ed., Curiosity At the Center of One's Life (Montreal: Thomas More Institute, 1987), p. 374;Google ScholarInsight, pp. 5–6Google Scholar = CWL 3: 28–31.Google Scholar

28. Lonergan, , “Critical Realism,” p. 2.Google Scholar

29. Lonergan, , Second Collection, p. 269;Google Scholar“Critical Realism,” pp. 2–5;Google ScholarUnderstanding and Being, pp. 26–29Google Scholar = CWL 5: 23–26;Google ScholarMethod in Theology, p. 213 n.63.Google Scholar

30. Polanyi, , The Tacit Dimension (Garden City: Doubleday, 1967).Google Scholar

31. Lonergan, , Collection, p. 228Google Scholar = CWL 4: 211;Google ScholarThe Subject, pp. 11–12.Google Scholar

32. Lonergan, , The Subject, pp. 14–17;Google ScholarLambert, , Caring, p. 52.Google Scholar

33. Lonergan, , The Subject, p. 18. Compare Plato's Republic vii, 514a–518d.Google Scholar

34. Lonergan, , Method in Theology, p. 104.Google Scholar

35. O'Connor, , Curiosity, p. 394.Google Scholar

36. Ibid., p. 395.

37. Insight, pp. 618, 601, 599–600Google Scholar = CWL 3: 641, 624, 622–23.Google Scholar

38. O'Connor, , Curiosity, pp. 371–72.Google Scholar

39. Cushman, Robert, Therapeia:Plato's Conception of Philosophy (Westport: Greenwood Press, 1976);Google ScholarLamb, , “Political and Social Dimensions in Lonergan's Theology,” pp. 270, 277.Google Scholar

40. Going, , Dialogues, p. 310.Google Scholar

41. Crowe, F. E., “An Expansion of Lonergan's Notion of Value” in Lonergan Workshop VII, ed. Lawrence, Fred (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1988).Google Scholar

42. Insight, p. 211Google Scholar = CWL 3:236;Google ScholarLonergan, , “Critical Realism,” pp. 35–40.Google Scholar

43. Lonergan, , “Critical Realism,” pp. 45, 47.Google Scholar

44. Ibid., p. 37.

45. Feynman, Richard, What Do You Care What Other People Think? (New York: Bantam Books, 1989), pp. 116–18.Google Scholar

46. Lonergan, , A Third Collection, ed. Crowe, F. E. (New York: Paulist Press, 1985), p. 177.Google Scholar

47. Lonergan, , Philosophy of God and Theology (London: Darton: Longman and Todd, 1973), p. ix.Google Scholar

48. Going, , Dialogues, p. 288.Google Scholar

49. Lonergan, , Second Collection, p. 29.Google Scholar

50. Ibid., p. 30; Lonergan, , The Subject, pp. 2–7.Google Scholar

51. O'Connor, , Curiosity, p. 382;Google ScholarLambert, , Caring, pp. 230, 245;Google ScholarLonergan, , The Subject, pp. 9–12;Google ScholarGoing, , Dialogues, p. 288.Google Scholar

52. Lonergan, , “Critical Realism,” pp. 45–46.Google Scholar

53. Ibid., pp. 40–43.

54. Lonergan, , Understanding and Being, pp. 110–111Google Scholar = CWL 5: 91.Google Scholar

55. Lonergan, , “Critical Realism,” p. 42.Google Scholar

56. O'Connor, , Curiosity, p. 382.Google Scholar

57. Jacobs, Jane, The Death and Life of Great American Cities (New York: Vintage Books, 1961).Google Scholar

58. Insight, pp. 210–11Google Scholar = CWL 3:235–36.Google Scholar

59. Ibid., p. 229 = CWL 3: 254.Google Scholar

60. Lonergan, , Third Collection, p. 105.Google Scholar

61. O'Connor, , Curiosity, p. 388.Google Scholar

62. Insight, p. 212Google Scholar = CWL 3: 238.Google Scholar

63. de Jouvenal, Bertrand, Sovereignty, trans. Huntington, J. F. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1963), pp. 17–25.Google Scholar

64. Insight, p. 209Google Scholar = CWL 3: 234.Google Scholar

65. Ibid., pp. 209–214 = CWL 3:234–39.Google Scholar

66. Ibid., p. 191 = CWL 3: 214;Google ScholarLamb, , “Political and Social Dimensions of Lonergan's Theology,” pp. 270–75.Google Scholar

67. Insight, pp. 220–21Google Scholar = CWL 3: 245–47;Google ScholarLamb, , “Political and Social Dimensions of Lonergan's Theology,” pp. 267–69.Google Scholar

68. Bergson, Henri, The Two Sources of Morality and Religion, trans. Audra, R. Ashley and Brereton, Cloudesley (New York: Holt, 1935).Google Scholar

69. Insight, p. 224Google Scholar = CWL 3: 249.Google Scholar

70. Ibid., p. 229 = CWL 3: 254.Google Scholar

71. Ibid., pp. 234, 239 = CWL 3: 259, 264.Google Scholar

72. Ibid., p. 239 = CWL 3: 264.Google Scholar

73. Ibid., pp. 240–241 = CWL 3: 265–67.Google Scholar

74. Lonergan, , Understanding and Being, pp. 328–29Google Scholar = CWL 5: 374–75.Google Scholar

75. Lonergan, , Third Collection, p. 172.Google Scholar

76. Ibid., p. 182; Braio, Frank Paul, “Lonergan's Recovery of the Notion of Natural Right,” Vera Lex 10 (1990): 4–5, 10.Google Scholar

77. Lonergan, , Third Collection, p. 176;Google ScholarInsight, p. 215Google Scholar = CWL 3: 241.Google Scholar

78. Lonergan, , Third Collection, p. 182.Google Scholar

79. Ibid., pp. 172, 174; Lonergan, , “Natural Right and Historical Mindedness” (abstract), in Program: Fifty First Annual Meeting (Washington: American Catholic Historical Society, 1977).Google Scholar

80. Lonergan, , Third Collection, p. 170.Google Scholar

81. Ibid., pp. 176–82.

82. For an interesting argument on the importance of accurate scientific knowledge in moral deliberation, see “Letter of Bernard Lonergan on contraception and the natural law,” ed. Crowe, F. E. and Doran, R. M., The Lonergan Newsletter, 11: 7–8.Google Scholar

83. Voegelin, , Anamnesis, p. 65.Google Scholar

84. Lonergan, , Third Collection, p. 104.Google Scholar

85. O'Connor, , Curiosity, p. 408.Google Scholar

86. Lonergan, , Second Collection, p. 39.Google Scholar

87. Insight, p. 236Google Scholar = CWL 3: 260–261.Google Scholar

88. See Nordquest, David A., “The Federalist on Truth and the Constitution,” Polity 23:527–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar