Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-fbnjt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-04T20:18:33.054Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Communism and Lamaist Utopianism in Central Asia

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 August 2009

Emanuel Sarkisyanz
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The extension of Communist Russian domination into Outer Mongolia in 1920 and of Communist Chinese domination over Inner Mongolia as well as Tibet in 1949 and 1951 created the problem of relations between communism and Lamaism, the religion and main cultural force of these areas. Communist policies towards Lamaism provide no exception to Communist religious policies as a whole. Nevertheless, the Communist appeal seems to have found some points of departure in certain Lamaist notions. These Lamaist ideas may, therefore, have a political relevance in the penetration of Communist ideas into the areas of Lamaist culture.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Review of Politics , Volume 20 , Issue 4 , October 1958 , pp. 623 - 633
Copyright
Copyright © University of Notre Dame 1958

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 David-Neel, Alexandra, “Prophéties et Légendes thibetaines: Lefuturhéros du Nord,” La Vie des Peuples, (05, 1925), p. 160.Google Scholar

2 Combe, G. A., A Tibetan on Tibet. Being the Travels and Observations of Mr. Paul Sherap (Dorje Zödbo) of Tachienlu (London, 1926), pp. 41–42.Google Scholar

3 Cf. Shen, Tsung-Lien and Liu, Shen-Chi, Tibet and the Tibetans (Stanford, 1953), p. 61.Google Scholar

4 Kawaguchi, Ekai, Three Years in Tibet (Benares, 1909), p. 499.Google Scholar Cf. Buston, , Chos-hbyungGoogle Scholar, fol. 132a–135b; History of Buddhism in India and Tibet, translated by Obermiller, E. (Heidelberg, 1932)Google Scholar; Walleser, M., Materialien zur Kunde des Buddhismus, XIX, pp. 172–177.Google Scholar

5 Shambhalai lam vig, fol. 46b–47a; Grünwedel, , “Der Weg nach S'ambhala des dritten Gross-Lama von bKra sis lhun po,” Abhandlungen der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften. Philosophisch-philologische und historische Klasse, Vol. XXIV, iii (Munich, 1915), 78–79.Google Scholar

6 Tsibykov, G., Buddistskii palomnik u sviatyn' Tibeta (Petrograd, 1918), pp. 371–372.Google Scholar

7 Roerich, George, Trails to Inmost Asia. Five Years of exploration with the Roerich Central Asian Expedition (New Haven, 1931), p. 156.Google Scholar

8 David-Neel, Alexandra, “Le Thibet mystique,” La Revue de Paris, XXXV (02 15, 1928), 868.Google Scholar

9 Grünwedel, , op. cit., pp. 78fGoogle Scholar; Bleichsteiner, R., Die gelbe Kirche (Vienna, 1937), pp. 228–229.Google Scholar

10 Roerich, George, op. cit., p. 157.Google Scholar The expedition report of George Roerich is not to be confused with the theosophical writings of his father, Nicolas Roerich.

11 David-Neel, Alexandra, The Superhuman Life of Gesar of Ling, the legendary Tibetan Hero, as sung by the bards of his country (London, 1932), p. 46.Google Scholar The American edition has a different pagination.

12 Roerich, George, op. cit., pp. 345, 359, 360–361.Google Scholar The quotations have been abridged.

13 David-Neel, A., The Superhuman Life of Gesar, pp. 278–279.Google Scholar Similarly Lin Geser, I, fol. 4a3: Damdinsuren, Tsendiin, “Mongol'skii epos o Geser Khane,” Arkhiv Orientalni, XXIII (1955), 58.Google Scholar

14 David-Neel, , The Superhuman Life of Gesar, pp. 278f.Google Scholar

15 Ibid., pp. 35, 284–285 (quotations abridged); Cf. Haslund, H., Men and Gods in Mongolia (London, 1935), pp. 249fGoogle Scholar, and Haslund, H., Mongolian Journey (London, 1949), p. 97.Google Scholar

16 David-Neel, , The Superhuman Life of Gesar, p. 47.Google Scholar

17 Banzarov, D., Chernaia vera i drugiia stat'i (Petersburg, 1891), p. 111Google Scholar, Banzarov, D.'s letter to Bobrovnikov, dated 04 12, 1848.Google Scholar

18 Pamiatnaia kniga Irkutskoi gubernii (1881), p. 17Google Scholar, cited in Okladnikov, A. P., Ocherki iz istorii zapadnykh buriat-mongolov (Leningrad, 1937), p. 137.Google Scholar

19 Semennikov, V. P. (editor), Za kulisami tsarizma. Arkhiv tibetskogo vracha Badmaeva (Leningrad, 1925), p. 57.Google Scholar

20 Grünwedel, , op. cit., p. 4Google Scholar, footnote 1. On the Chakravartin idea cf. the Pali Buddhist scripture Digha Nikaya, xxvi, 14–25Google Scholar: Cakkavatti-Sihanada-Sutta, , and Franke, R. O. (translator), Dighanikaya. Das Buch der langen Texte des buddhistischen Kanons (Göttingen, 1913), pp. 265–270.Google Scholar

21 Dnevnik imperatora Nikolaia IIgo (Berlin, 1923), p. 125.Google Scholar

22 Tsybikov, , op. cit., p. 270Google Scholar; Papers relating to Tibet presented to Both Houses of Parliament (London, 1904), p. 115.Google Scholar

23 Kawaguchi, , op. cit., pp. 497–499Google Scholar; Bell, Charles A., Tibet Past and Present (Oxford, 1924), p. 63.Google Scholar

24 Kawaguchi, , op. cit., p. 500.Google Scholar

25 Journal de Saint Petersbourg (10 2'15, 1900Google Scholar, and Messager Officiel, Petersburg (06 25'07 8, 1901Google Scholar, cited in Papers relating to Tibet …, pp. 113, 117.Google Scholar

26 Korostovetz, P., Von Cinghiz Chan zur Sowjetrepublik (Berlin, 1926), p. 208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

27 Novyi Vostok (1923), pp. 139–156.Google Scholar

28 On Badmaev's project for Russian expansion in the Lamaist world Alexander III had written the marginal comment: “All this is so new, so unusual and fantastic, that it is difficult to believe in success.” Semennikov, , op. cit., p. 81.Google Scholar

29 Bezbozhnik, No. 1 (1929), 13.Google Scholar

30 Tong hwa lu, Chien lung, XLV, f. 46vGoogle Scholar, as cited in Courant, Maurice, L'Asie Centrale aux XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles. Empire Kalmouk ou Empire Mantchou? Annales de l'Université de Lyon. Nouvelle Série, II. Droit, lettres, No. 26 (Lyon, 1912), 108.Google Scholar

31 Kallinikov, A., “Aratskoe revolutsionne dvizhenie v doavtonomnoi Mongolii,” Revolutsionnyi Vostok, XXVIII, 53Google Scholar. Cf. Maiskii, I., Sovremennaia Mongoliia (Irkutsk, 1921), pp. 241–242Google Scholar; Roerich, George, op. cit., pp. 223–226, 229ff.Google Scholar

32 Korostovetz, , op. cit., p. 311.Google Scholar

33 Leonof, G. A. (editor), The Mongolian People's Republic on the Road to Cultural Development (Shanghai, 1948)Google Scholar, no pagination, pictures Amursena as a hero on the Communist Mongol stage.

34 Roerich, George, op. cit., p. 157, quotations abridged.Google Scholar

35 David-Neel, , “Prophéties et Légendes thibetaines: Le futur héros du Nord,” La Vie des Peuples, 05, 1925, p. 160.Google Scholar Cf. David-Neel, , Le vieux Tibet face a la Chine nouvelle (Paris, 1953), pp. 22–23.Google Scholar

36 Sarkisyanz, E., Russland und der Messianismus des Orients (Tübingen, 1955), pp. 53–63, 95–106Google Scholar; Sarkisyanz, E., “Communism and the Asian Mind,” Yale Review (Spring, 1950).Google Scholar

37 David-Neel, , Le vieux Tibet face à la Chine nouvelle, p. 24.Google Scholar

38 Reboul, Colonel in Correspondance d'Orient, 03, 1923, p. 144.Google Scholar

39 People's Law (in Mongolian) (Ulan Bator, 1924), p. 5Google Scholar, cited in Ateist, No. 17 (1927), 68–69.Google Scholar

40 Mandjigine, , “Protiv propagandy natsionalisticheskoi ideologii v Buriat Mongolii,” Revolutsionnyi Vostok, XIII (1932), 243–245.Google Scholar

41 Persian, W., “Religionspolitische Krisis des Buddhismus,” Europa Archiv (12 5, 1951), p. 4544.Google Scholar

42 Antireligioznik, No. 6 (1930), 68.Google Scholar

43 Cf. Glasenapp, H., Der Buddhismus in Indien und im Fernen Osten. Schicksale und Lebensformen einer Erlösungsreligion (Berlin, 1936), p. 352.Google Scholar

44 Oshirov, A., “O buriatskom lamaizme i bor'be s nim,” Antireligioznik, No. 6 (06, 1930), 67–68.Google Scholar

45 “Vsesoluznyi s-iezd buddistov,” in Antireligioznik, No. 3 (03, 1927), 48.Google Scholar

46 Zhamtsarano, , Osnovy buddizma, pp. 1–2Google Scholar, cited in Toglitov, B., “Lamaizm i buriatskii natsional-demokratizm,” Antireligioznik, No. 7 (07, 1930), p. 22.Google Scholar

47 Pavlovich, M., “Lenin i narody Vostoka,” in Novyi Vostok, No. 5 (1924), 13.Google Scholar

48 Vampilov, B., “Ob antireligioznoi rabote v Buriatii,” in Antireligioznik, Nos. 8–9 (08–09, 1938), 29–30Google Scholar; Philipps, G. D., Dawn over Siberia (London, 1939), p. 168.Google Scholar

49 Pomus, M. I., Bunat-Mongol'skaia A. S. S. R. (Moscow, 1937), pp. vi–vii.Google Scholar

50 “O reaktsionnoi sushchnosti eposa Geser-Khan,” Kul'tura i Zhizn', 01 11, 1951, p. 4.Google Scholar Cf. Kolarz, W., The Peoples of the Soviet Far East (New York, 1954), pp. 126f.Google Scholar

51 Indian Press Digests, I, No. 2 (Berkeley, 1953), 54.Google Scholar